Israel 'attacks' Gaza aid fleet

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
"At close range" is pretty much normal on a ship.

Very good. I agree. As a US Marine assigned to a ship for a time everything was close in fighting when training. Small passageways, tight compartments, etc.

"At close range'... well yeah
 

MHz

Time Out
Mar 16, 2007
41,030
43
48
Red Deer AB
Mhz, you already capitulated and conceded, that the blockade is legal, the boarding was legal, and the deaths, the tragic result of the Israeli's being forced to defend themselves. Why do you continue to flail around like a fish out of water?.
That is what you wish to have understood and I obviously would agree with the article I posted. In the same post I also stated the reason given for the blockade/state of armed conflict is based on a 'presumed right'. Things change sometimes.

They were looking for missiles mhz. They're kind of conspicuous. .
And Israel has a list of prohibited items, that would have to be checked against what the UN lists as prohibited. I can understand why some are on the list, no use sending them because thieves make off with them before they can be delivered to the UN inside Gaza and the West Bank. Nobody seems to interfere with the delivery of goods to Israel despite their tendency to use their war machines against civilians.

You and your conspiracy theories. .
Like I said the names and bios aren't out yet.

That's Turkey's choice, though I highly doubt they'll go to war with Israel over this..
They gave the last convoy the go-ahead because the Mavi Marmara was a from Turkey, as far as I know the Irish don't even have canoes.

You already proved it was legal, thanx by the way.
Look at the reactions so far. Do you think there is such a thing as an independent body now? Don't answer, that was rhetorical..
What a twit, yes the article I posted does point to the rules of blockades, it is about weapons, specifically rockets and lets throw in the spare parts just for the hell of it. Wheelchair batteries were on a pre-existing list or they have thieves in their ports.

Yes, full stop. The article you posted, said straight out, legal blockade, legal boarding, legal defence. FULL STOP..
All under false pretenses, Hamas is an elected government, UN181 gave the country status by Nov of 1948 no matter what. The UN was to hear any disputes. The 33 countries said they Government was allowed to form a protective force. Start from there and work forward, those right were never taken away by the body that gave them, Jews and Arabs had rights and responsibilities or satasfaction through the UN Courts, of which none have been allowed to proceed because of US vetoes. Perhaps that can help at the security council but I doubt it.

You can try and spin it any way you want mhz, your own post kills your position. Israel and Hamas are in a state of conflict, full stop..
No kidding, try that the conflict is older than 70 years when you evn glance at any summation of events.

It isn't, because it was lawful, as you have already pointed out..
Spin it all you want, only in some cases is a blocade legal, in other cases it is gunboat diplomacy.

Thank you for posting that awesome article, links and conceding to fact..
NP, facts are facts.

Irrelevant, a blockade does not need UN approval.
When it includes items meant for civilians it does need it.

You need to read up on NATO.
It might be in crash and burn mode anyway.
 

#juan

Hall of Fame Member
Aug 30, 2005
18,326
119
63
Re: WHY can Americans be Murdered by the Israeli Government With Impunity?

It doesn't take a lot of reading to figure out what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians in Gaza. Almost two million Palestinians are trapped in Gaza, which is no better than any other refugee camp. The attack on the ship and the killing of innocent civilians by the Israelis was piracy. Israel has no special rights to attack ships in international waters, except the apparent condoning of these actions by the U.S.. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is really the U.S.-Palestinian conflict.
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
When you want to inspect cargo you send experts in that field, when you want to kill people you send in Commandos.


No... The hate mongers on the flotilla attacked the Israelis immediately. Had there been customs agents sent, they would have been battered and butchered by the lawless mob that were clearly prepared to do harm to anyone that came by.


It isn't me putting those things forward, somewhat like you having a god-like worship of the Jews who would prefer all Gentiles would burn in an instant.


Holy cow... You really have a deep hatred for the Jews don't you.

GET HELP IMMEDIATELY!


A blockade is an act of war


So is launching thousands of missiles into a sovereign nation... Funny how that works, eh?


Imagine the items if they had brought 'the farm'.


.. But, they didn't bring the farm, did they? Just a few specific items for a particular purpose.

They weren't tools MHz, they were weapons inventoried specifically to cause harm to others.


They will be facing a warship before they will be able to board anything in the civilian category.

I wonder how that warship will stand-up to the Israeli airforce?

Probably not too well.


Do you really want photos's of children being held in dangerous positions by the IDF or the way people are treated at the few crossings there are. They go hand-in-hand with the 'donkey-fuker' vid created bu some US soldier while talking to some children in Iraq. Somebody should go and do an in-depth interview with his parents, get their view first.


Well, since you put it that way, I suppose that it does fully excuse the Palestinians frequent habit of pushing women and children in front of the Hamas soldiers (real brave SOB's at that) to take the brunt of the violence.



You mean people who got stressed out after 20 years of brutal military occupation and seeing their children/parents made victims.


Just 20 years? The Israelis have been attacked, threatened and subjected to teh most vile racial pressures since their inception.

20 years?... pppfffffttt


Prpbably more false-flag operation, why send in an innocent when there are men who would gladly deliver a huidden bomb.


Probably?

This is tin-foil-hat talk MHz. Put up or shut up via real evidence and not your biased gut feeling.


Dry up the funding and see how fast the fighting stops.


Are you serious?... What a joke, Hamas wouldn't have enough cash to scrape together a bowl of rice on their own. Their are entirely dependent on everyone else for everything.

They can't afford real medical food or education, but get arms and explosives by the boat-load.

That said, that's why they are so pissed about this blockade. israel is turned-off the tap for their arms supplies.

Staying on course for Gaza City meant delivering wheelchairs with batteries, letting Israel deliver the good meant no batteries and wobbly wheels.


Yeah, sure... There's a big need for electric wheel chairs in a nation that can't even feed itself.

Think about MHz... It doesn't make any sense.



Take a look at their track record, Lebanon was pounded the same way, take out the civilian facilities.

That's smart strategy.. That's all.


Are you saying Turkey doesn't know how to fight battles with machines of war?


When was the last time that Turkey fought independently in a war? And I'm not talking about a nominal role with the UN.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
Re: WHY can Americans be Murdered by the Israeli Government With Impunity?

It doesn't take a lot of reading to figure out what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians in Gaza. Almost two million Palestinians are trapped in Gaza, which is no better than any other refugee camp. The attack on the ship and the killing of innocent civilians by the Israelis was piracy. Israel has no special rights to attack ships in international waters, except the apparent condoning of these actions by the U.S.. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is really the U.S.-Palestinian conflict.

With all due respect Juan, what is your own country doing? I think the US response is wishy washy at best but certainly not condoning it.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Re: WHY can Americans be Murdered by the Israeli Government With Impunity?

Jeez. Another redundant thread from someone too lazy to add to an existing thread.
 

ironsides

Executive Branch Member
Feb 13, 2009
8,583
60
48
United States
Stop using logic, reason, critical thought and deductive reasoning Ironsides. How can you ever be expected to hate Israel with the rest of the mentally challenged when you actually think?

Come come now Ironsides, drink your koolaid and join the masses!!! Then you can leave rep like this for people who prove your position asinine and unfounded...
Ok :)
 

Colpy

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 5, 2005
21,887
848
113
70
Saint John, N.B.
Who's controlling the message on this?

I have yet to see any footage from the people on board the ship.

While everyone is patting each other on the back about how many people they killed should we not wait for the whole story and demand we get it?

A clearer picture emerges of bloodshed aboard Gaza-bound ship

Two interesting quotes from your link:

None of the passengers interviewed by AP have said lethal force was used by the Israelis before they boarded the ship.

I don’t deny that in the fighting some of them were using some of the weapons they’ve been showing on TV now, like the slingshot or the hatchets,” he said. “But don’t forget that the Israelis attacked us in international waters. According to international law, you’re allowed to defend yourself when you get attacked.”

So, when one considers the fact that both the blockade and the boarding were perfectly legal........

the Israelis are slowly emerging as completely justified......
 

Avro

Time Out
Feb 12, 2007
7,815
65
48
55
Oshawa
Two interesting quotes from your link:





So, when one considers the fact that both the blockade and the boarding were perfectly legal........

the Israelis are slowly emerging as completely justified......

I was being fair from the beginning and never assumed anything....how about you?

I'd still like to see the video's.

Why haven't we?

Why just video released by the Israeli military?

Ah who cares....Israel is always right anyways.
 

Colpy

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 5, 2005
21,887
848
113
70
Saint John, N.B.
I was being fair from the beginning and never assumed anything....how about you?

No, I confess.

I usually assume Islamo-fascist lunatics are in the wrong.

I've occassionally been wrong in that assumption.....but not often......

and not this time.
 

Avro

Time Out
Feb 12, 2007
7,815
65
48
55
Oshawa
No, I confess.

I usually assume Islamo-fascist lunatics are in the wrong.

I've occassionally been wrong in that assumption.....but not often......

and not this time.

Even though the message has been controlled by the Israeli military?
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Wow, even the activists ar now saying that other activists were "hardcore", "violent", "Had taken sidearms from the captured Israeli's".

The story just gets worse and worse for the activist crowed and their moronic defenders.

Staff Sergeant S, well deserves that medal, if it's awarded.

He defended and saved his Brothers, are you actually going to say that that is not a commendable act?

This has long ago turned into a PR War - Note AAH Week - Boycotts etc - All against Israel but nothing about Hamas - Hezbollah - Israel should lift the blockade in my
opinion

Their is another War coming and Israel will have to take the first missile showers - suffer casualties then people may understand what these Terrorists are all about. Israel cannot be seen to do a pre emptive strike like 67 - They are going to have to take pain, dead civilians and children and show restraint - and then there will be more attacks - and then some more.

Then and only then can they attack and do it right this time - do not destroy infrastructure - hospitals - bridges - and it will most likely include Syria.

That is what I see occurring within the next year or so at the most. Major War is on the horizon.

I also noted that I am a " worthless retard" for posting Mr. Clements Cartoons - worth 10,000 words they were. The person that disagrees should find another term because he/she is insulting persons with disabilities - But I guess that would fit into the Master Plan. 1st the Jews then>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>


And they should also note that persons with mental disabilities are the ones that demonstrate compassion and kindness on a daily basis - day after day- They are an example to all of us that helps us understand what we have and to count our blessings and be thankful. So I do not find be called that offensive I take it as a compliment. Thank you
 

MHz

Time Out
Mar 16, 2007
41,030
43
48
Red Deer AB
No... The hate mongers on the flotilla attacked the Israelis immediately. Had there been customs agents sent, they would have been battered and butchered by the lawless mob that were clearly prepared to do harm to anyone that came by.
I guess we'll never know.

Holy cow... You really have a deep hatred for the Jews don't you.
GET HELP IMMEDIATELY!
Did you just think it was Muslims?

So is launching thousands of missiles into a sovereign nation... Funny how that works, eh?
The not so funny part is signing a cease-fire and then unloading a lot more tonnage in 1 day than those rockets from Gaza carried collectively.

.. But, they didn't bring the farm, did they? Just a few specific items for a particular purpose.
They weren't tools MHz, they were weapons inventoried specifically to cause harm to others.
600 people and 60 weapons



I wonder how that warship will stand-up to the Israeli airforce?

Probably not too well.
Israel must have improved it's targeting since the Liberty then. Why do you assume that would be the end of it. Given their position at the UN perhaps they can put a group together


Well, since you put it that way, I suppose that it does fully excuse the Palestinians frequent habit of pushing women and children in front of the Hamas soldiers (real brave SOB's at that) to take the brunt of the violence.
They are on the same side twit.


Just 20 years? The Israelis have been attacked, threatened and subjected to teh most vile racial pressures since their inception.

20 years?... pppfffffttt
That was just going back to '87, when Hamas came on the scene. Making 700,000 people refugees contrary to all signed agreements even before May of 1948 is their normal tactic. What do they have to give the Rothschild in exchange for this 'gift' from then. Wait, first they have to claim the territory originally demanded. Perpetual slavery to follow that. Theu should have stuck with God, at least He was true to His word.

Probably?
This is tin-foil-hat talk MHz. Put up or shut up via real evidence and not your biased gut feeling.
That false-flag operations exist? Gulf of Tonkin ring a bell.

Are you serious?... What a joke, Hamas wouldn't have enough cash to scrape together a bowl of rice on their own. Their are entirely dependent on everyone else for everything.
Another gift from the pages of UN181, Oh, wait we bailed along with 33 other Nations and didn't demand anybody follow it except the Arabs. Just as two-faced as we were in daeling with out Indian problem.

They can't afford real medical food or education, but get arms and explosives by the boat-load.
You must agree by now that Israel was the onlt one to bring fire-arms aboard.

That said, that's why they are so pissed about this blockade. israel is turned-off the tap for their arms supplies.
There were none, aren't you paying attention.

Yeah, sure... There's a big need for electric wheel chairs in a nation that can't even feed itself.
Think about MHz... It doesn't make any sense.
By design, Israel sets how much aid come in and then steals the rest for themselves or lets it sit until it is spoiled and on no use to antbody, all by design.

That's smart strategy.. That's all.
Don't bet on it, there only has tp be a collective will to short the oil supplies and stop using the US dollar. America will be out of business and Israel will be out of fuel, all perfectly legal.

When was the last time that Turkey fought independently in a war? And I'm not talking about a nominal role with the UN.
I don't keep stats like that, ask Colpy he likes to keep track of kill ratios and things like that.

Flotilla Choir presents: We Con the World .

(LatmaTV) "We'll make the world, abandon reason. We'll make them all believe that the Hamas is Momma Theresa"
Pretty funny vid from the killers of the people on the Mavi Marmara

You can send them a thank you note if you like.

% This is the RIPE Database query service.
% The objects are in RPSL format.
%
% The RIPE Database is subject to Terms and Conditions.
% See http://www.ripe.net/db/support/db-terms-conditions.pdf

% Note: This output has been filtered.
% To receive output for a database update, use the "-B" flag.

% Information related to '212.143.17.160 - 212.143.17.191'

inetnum: 212.143.17.160 - 212.143.17.191
netname: NV-Katom
descr: NV-Katom
country: IL
admin-c: NI118-RIPE
tech-c: NN105-RIPE
status: ASSIGNED PA
mnt-by: NV-MNT-RIPE
mnt-lower: NV-MNT-RIPE
source: RIPE # Filtered

role: Netvision NOC team
address: Omega Building
address: MATAM industrial park
address: Haifa 31905
address: Israel
phone: +972 4 8560 600
fax-no: +972 4 8551 132
e-mail: abuse@013netvision.co.il
remarks: trouble: Send Spam and Abuse complains ONLY to the above address!
e-mail: ripetech@013netvision.co.il
admin-c: NVAC-RIPE
tech-c: NVTC-RIPE
nic-hdl: NN105-RIPE
mnt-by: NV-MNT-RIPE
source: RIPE # Filtered

person: Noam Ilovich
address: Minicy Catom
address: Matam , Haifa 31905, Israel
phone: +972-4-8500661
fax-no: +972-4-8500662
e-mail: noam@catom.com
nic-hdl: NI118-RIPE
source: RIPE # Filtered

% Information related to '212.143.0.0/16AS1680'

route: 212.143.0.0/16
descr: 013 Netvision Network
origin: AS1680
mnt-by: NV-MNT-RIPE
source: RIPE # Filtered
 

Ron in Regina

"Voice of the West" Party
Apr 9, 2008
29,065
10,993
113
Regina, Saskatchewan
A "New York Times" Headline: Second Set of Activists Steams Toward Gaza
Link: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/05/world/middleeast/05flotilla.html?src=mv

JERUSALEM — Days after a deadly confrontation at sea when Israeli commandos raided a
flotilla trying to challenge the naval blockade of Gaza, an Irish-owned vessel carrying
humanitarian supplies and a small group of pro-Palestinian activists was on the way,
scheduled to arrive early on Saturday.

On Friday, the Israeli and Irish governments reached an agreement to unload the vessel’s
cargo at the port in Ashdod, in southern Israel, and transport it to Gaza — essentially the
same deal Israel offered to the activists in the aid convoy that was attacked on Monday.

But Greta Berlin, a spokeswoman for the Free Gaza Movement, the principal organizer of
the earlier flotilla, said that those on board had rejected that approach. “The whole point is
to try to break the blockade,” Ms. Berlin said, speaking by telephone from Cyprus.

The rejection left open the possibility of another confrontation, though with only 11 passengers
on board, 4 of them over 60 years old, and a crew of 8, there seemed to be less potential for
violence. The passengers have said that any resistance will be peaceful.

The rest of that story can be read at the above Link...