Attawapiskat chief goes on hunger strike

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
For those that didn't click the Taylor link:

Are those video screens in the headrests of Theresa Spence’s SUV? Is that her SUV?

The photo caption of Fred Chartrand’s photo on the National Post reads: “Attawapiskat First Nations Chief Theresa Spence leaves Victoria Island as she continues her hunger strike in Ottawa, Wednesday January 9, 2013.”

Not only this, but we’ve learned that Spence has been staying in hotels during her stay in Ottawa.

And that “hunger strike”? We all now know that it consists of fish broth, herbal tea, and whatever else Spence consumes in her teepee on Victoria Island, in the comfort of an SUV, or in her hotel room.

Other observers have fairly pointed out that she has not lost much weight for being on a hunger strike for about 30 days. I’m not for fat-shaming any person, but the hunger strike is the central news claim and it appears that this claim, and the threat to herself, are false.

The alleged hunger strike is to show that Spence is adamant about having a meeting with Prime Minister Stephen Harper. When the Prime Minister agreed to such a meeting, she backed off and moved the goal posts, asking for the Governor General to attend as well. When the Governor General re-iterated his non-administrative role in government, the #Idlenomore movement dug in their heels and threatened to call the whole meeting off. Spence even petitioned the Queen.

The Spence news event happened during the news vacuum that usually happens between mid-December through late January when the House of Commons isn’t sitting. It also comes during a time that ramps up to the release of a Deloitte audit of Attawapiskat. The audit’s last possible day of release was to be January 16th, however it was unveiled this week. It was quite damning of the administration of funds at the Attawapiskat First Nation. Over 80% of the money was unaccounted for and/or lacked supporting documentation. According to the audit, some unnamed contractor made over $300,000 for one unknown job. Who was this contractor? One named contractor is Spence’s boyfriend who is paid over $850 a day to manage the town’s expenses. He’s doing a bang-up job, isn’t he?

Since Spence must have known the quality of the Attawapiskat books, was this hunger strike a ploy to gain political capital ahead of the audit’s release?

Would we tolerate such accounting in any other municipality in Canada? In other cases such as this, the RCMP would be investigating.
Is #Idlenomore a political movement that is supposed to highlight poverty on reserves, one that calls for self-determination, self-governance, and independence from Ottawa? Why then is Theresa Spence living large on Ottawa’s dollar while her people freeze in inadequate housing?

News crews have now been evicted from Victoria Island and one from Global News was even removed from Attawapiskat.
As Canadians, we demand accountability and transparency from our elected officials. Why wouldn’t we demand the same from First Nations politicians?

Grand Chief David Harper of the Okimakanak First Nation described Theresa Spence as their very own “Mother Theresa”. I don’t remember reading reports of the Calcutta nun rolling on 20″ rims.


Theresa Spence, living it up | Stephen Taylor


A lot of supposition and innuendo with no real facts. More fear mongering.
 

Locutus

Adorable Deplorable
Jun 18, 2007
32,230
47
48
67
A lot of supposition and innuendo with no real facts. More fear mongering.

She had the audit last August.

She was/is living a pretty good life.

News crews were evicted.

She's in a Hummer2.

She ain't lost much weight.

Hunger strike my a s s.


Yep, totally made-up. :lol:


She's a farcical caricature. And that is a shame. Really.
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Theresa Spence: Attawapiskat audit’s release is a ploy to discredit me | Canadian Politics | Canada | News | National Post

A series of audit letters accountants filed annually to Attawapiskat show that in 2009, 2010 and 2011, Attawapiskat failed to provide supporting documentation for spending in many instances. The documents were released to Postmedia News under the access to information law. Audit notes from 2009, 2010 and 2011 show that when accountants asked for an explanation “often, none could be provided.”

Over the same time period, audits also found that the senior officials on the reserve failed to even set a yearly budget and that payroll cheques were being printed without proper oversight from the band council — cheques that would have covered Spence’s salary and travel expenses in 2010-2011 of more than $71,000.

The most recent audit — made public Monday — found that going back to April 1, 2005, the band council didn’t properly prepare budgets, didn’t properly keep minutes to support band council resolutions, had “incomplete, insufficient, and inaccurate bookkeeping,” made “expenditures . . . without the available funds” and added that “journal entries were made with no supporting documentation.”

The latest audit of the Attawapiskat First Nation, which covers about 80% of the more than $104 million funnelled to Attawapiskat since 2005, included numerous entries in band council books such as a May 2, 2011 donation of $10,000 and more than $1.1 million in August 2009 to buy “buildings” with no supporting documentation. There was also a $2.3 million expenses payment to an unknown vendor on March 31, 2008 with incomplete documentation to explain how or why the money was spent.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
from the above article

Adding to the problems at Attawapiskat were the oversight failures from Aboriginal Affairs. The audit found that Aboriginal Affairs’ own policies on housing were ambiguous enough that it was difficult for the department to “adequately review or challenge the information reported” by the band council. Nor were the department’s regional offices required to “explain or provide context for performance reports” to head office in the capital region.


There's enough blame to go all around. I feel that a full forensic audit should be done to see exactly what has been happening. If it turns out that Chief Spence, the band council and anyone else is responsible then they should be dealt with accordingly. This should also extend to the AANC and the government of the time.
 

55Mercury

rigid member
May 31, 2007
4,393
1,068
113
If this is true it's sure sounding like this broad ought to be strung up and made an example of... by her own people!

figuratively speaking, of course!
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
from the above article

Adding to the problems at Attawapiskat were the oversight failures from Aboriginal Affairs. The audit found that Aboriginal Affairs’ own policies on housing were ambiguous enough that it was difficult for the department to “adequately review or challenge the information reported” by the band council. Nor were the department’s regional offices required to “explain or provide context for performance reports” to head office in the capital region.


There's enough blame to go all around. I feel that a full forensic audit should be done to see exactly what has been happening. If it turns out that Chief Spence, the band council and anyone else is responsible then they should be dealt with accordingly. This should also extend to the AANC and the government of the time.

The Dept knows which Bands have problems accounting for funds - and I have also stated that all involved need to be held accountable-

But here lies just one problem- a Band elects a Chief and Council- The Chief and Council then manage the finances so poorly shall we say - money spent - no invoices- no reasons why or where the funds went -complete mismanagement-

What does the Govt do. Can you answer that one for me please.
 

Locutus

Adorable Deplorable
Jun 18, 2007
32,230
47
48
67
Some people seem to think (or are led to think by media) that if you don't swallow Theresa's charade that you are anti FN, unwilling to discuss the issues, heartless and by proxy, a war-loving neocon and all like that there.

Couldn't be further from the truth in my case man. This broad is a rounder, a possible crook and an attention whoar. Plain and simple.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
120,212
14,854
113
Low Earth Orbit
Adding to the problems at Attawapiskat were the oversight failures from Aboriginal Affairs. The audit found that Aboriginal Affairs’ own policies on housing were ambiguous enough that it was difficult for the department to “adequately review or challenge the information reported” by the band council. Nor were the department’s regional offices required to “explain or provide context for performance reports” to head office in the capital region.

That explains the $250K a house B u l l s h i t

If they were there being nosy, they'd complain of no respect and no self-governance.

So? Who is pocketing?
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
The Dept knows which Bands have problems accounting for funds - and I have also stated that all involved need to be held accountable-

But here lies just one problem- a Band elects a Chief and Council- The Chief and Council then manage the finances so poorly shall we say - money spent - no invoices- no reasons why or where the funds went -complete mismanagement-

What does the Govt do. Can you answer that one for me please.


How about training in proper accounting practices. How about offering that training right from the get go instead of waiting 7 years or more.

If I was like levant, I'd say that the government set them up to fail and prolonged the process to guarantee a fail.
 

Risus

Genius
May 24, 2006
5,373
25
38
Toronto
The Dept knows which Bands have problems accounting for funds - and I have also stated that all involved need to be held accountable-

But here lies just one problem- a Band elects a Chief and Council- The Chief and Council then manage the finances so poorly shall we say - money spent - no invoices- no reasons why or where the funds went -complete mismanagement-

What does the Govt do. Can you answer that one for me please.

What the government SHOULD do is to stop all fundings until the natives can prove they know how to handle it.
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
How about training in proper accounting practices. How about offering that training right from the get go instead of waiting 7 years or more.

If I was like levant, I'd say that the government set them up to fail and prolonged the process to guarantee a fail.

Good point- But so is asking for training- the invoices may be a mess but they can be sorted out can they not. What about no invoices- no records. The paper trail should go thru a bank should it not?
And what about after that - not all bands are free of corruption. What about those.
 

Colpy

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 5, 2005
21,887
848
113
71
Saint John, N.B.
How about training in proper accounting practices. How about offering that training right from the get go instead of waiting 7 years or more.

If I was like levant, I'd say that the government set them up to fail and prolonged the process to guarantee a fail.

Oh BALONEY.

Teaching someone to keep books showing where the money was spent should take all of 30 minutes.

Anyone that can balance a chequebook.,.......or do their own taxes.
 

Dixie Cup

Senate Member
Sep 16, 2006
6,590
4,172
113
Edmonton
Here is an example of water control that has been problematic for both sides of the story:

Agreement to replenish water level at Crooked Lake

REGINA (SNN) -- After three years of gazing at mud flats as Crooked Lake's water level dropped, cottage owners are happy to hear the water level will soon be returning to normal.

By The StarPhoenix (Saskatoon)June 14, 2006

REGINA (SNN) -- After three years of gazing at mud flats as Crooked Lake's water level dropped, cottage owners are happy to hear the water level will soon be returning to normal.

"It's a very exciting day for the Friends of the Qu'Appelle that we have a twoyear interim agreement for Crooked Lake. Now we'll be able to launch our boats and use our boat launches," said cottage owner Randy Durovick, who noted the lake level is expected to rise to 456 metres above sea level this summer, up to one metre higher than the previous three years.

On Monday, Sakimay and Cowessess First Nations signed interim agreements with the federal and provincial governments allowing the Crooked Lake watercontrol structure to operate in 2006 and 2007.

Sakimay received $340,000 and Cowessess $196,000 under the agreement -- a cost shared by the two governments.

Cottage owners, who felt they were caught in the middle of the land claim dispute, now have a better understanding of the issues that are on the table, said Durovick, the Friends of the Qu'Appelle board chair.

"Our position was that we wanted to have an interim agreement in place in 2006 so that there was no further damage to the environment, the fish and their habitat while discussions were ongoing," he said.

Chief federal negotiator Si Halyk said Tuesday the agreement will permit the water-control structure to be operated while negotiations continue toward finding workable, long-term solutions for the future operation of dams along the Qu'Appelle River.

"Before a settlement could be reached there had to be a rapport and trust established amongst the parties and that takes time," said Halyk, who brokered the deal.

In 1942, the Prairie Farm Rehabilitation Administration (PFRA) built water-control structures on Echo, Crooked and Round lakes without the consent of the Cowessess, Sakimay, Pasqua, Muscowpetung, Ochapowace and Kahkewistahaw First Nations, whose lands were flooded by the elevated lake levels.

In 1998, the Indian Claims Commission recommended the federal government either remove the structures on the lakes or negotiate -- whether by surrender or expropriation -- the interests in the land it requires for flooding purposes from all six reserves and compensate the bands for past flood damages.

In 2003, after 61 years of trying to obtain compensation, local First Nations brought the matter to a head by refusing to allow federal PFRA staff on their lands to install stop logs in the structures to maintain summer lake levels.

Ok, thank you for that. This one was news to me and its likely that a lot of the issues are "localized" thus the average Canadian is not aware of them.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
How about training in proper accounting practices. How about offering that training right from the get go instead of waiting 7 years or more.

If I was like levant, I'd say that the government set them up to fail and prolonged the process to guarantee a fail.

I think merely keeping the receipts would have done the trick, Gerry!-:)
 

DaSleeper

Trolling Hypocrites
May 27, 2007
33,676
1,666
113
Northern Ontario,
I think merely keeping the receipts would have done the trick, Gerry!-:)
Yep!


Last month I get a letter from C R A,that they wanted my medical receipts for last year... they seemed to be questioning my expenses for the year...I e-file my taxes so I don'thave to send receipts but keep all paperwork for ten years.

I realized the reason for that letter was my expenses were about four thousand more than in previous year,so I promptly mailed it to them with a note explaining the reason for the disparity with previous years was that my wife and I both had new dentures done...

Last week I got my receipts back with a letter that my expenses were accepted.

Good book keeping is just a matter ofkeeping your receipts organized......
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
I think merely keeping the receipts would have done the trick, Gerry!-:)

Yup, that would have helped a whole lot. But then again, catching the fact that they weren't keeping the proper documentation back before 2005 would have prevented all this. Or is it a matter of the government NOT wanting to prevent this. Kind of like setting up someone to fail.
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Yup, that would have helped a whole lot. But then again, catching the fact that they weren't keeping the proper documentation back before 2005 would have prevented all this. Or is it a matter of the government NOT wanting to prevent this. Kind of like setting up someone to fail.
Tell me what the reaction would be if the Govt put a person in charge of a bands finances and had to sign off on any and all agreements etc.

I can see the headlines now. I am sure you can as well.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
Tell me what the reaction would be if the Govt put a person in charge of a bands finances and had to sign off on any and all agreements etc.

I can see the headlines now. I am sure you can as well.


Who said anything about a govt employee in charge of a bands finances? I sure as hell didn't.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
120,212
14,854
113
Low Earth Orbit
Tell me what the reaction would be if the Govt put a person in charge of a bands finances and had to sign off on any and all agreements etc.

I can see the headlines now. I am sure you can as well.
Still NFG. That's another place that leaks money. It's time to have Tribal MPs, MLAs MPPs etc.