Palestinian "Unilateral Declaration of Independence"

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Obama's speech in support of continued Palestinian injustice and oppression while praising Arabs everywhere else for fighting against oppression and injustice didn't go over well with Palestinians, the Arab world and most of the international community. Obama is openly being called a hypocrite today.

Peter Goodspeed: ‘Right of return’ could fall victim to Palestinian statehood | Full Comment | National Post

I think that Abbas will table his request, and wait for new peace talks. But you along with many others ignore the consequences of a Palestinian State, Observer status only.


Another unintended consequence may be a self-inflicted wound for the Palestinians. By unilaterally declaring statehood and having that endorsed by much of the rest of the world, the Palestinian Authority could terminate the legal status of the Palestinian Liberation Organization as the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinians (a claim already vehemently rejected by Hamas and its supporters). But, at the same time, the creation of a new Palestinian state will immediately cast doubt on the future of hundreds of thousands of Palestinian refugees who live outside the West Bank and Gaza.

They risk becoming truly stateless and will lack any representation in international institutions.

Guy Goodwin-Gill, an Oxford University law professor who has been hired to give the Palestinian Authority legal advice, drew Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas’s attention to this possibility but he has been ignored.

More than half the world’s Palestinian population lives outside the West Bank and Gaza, Mr. Goodwin-Gill reminded Mr. Abbas.
 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
Palestinians have nothing to loose by seeking UN recognition. They've already got the 2/3 majority support they need at the UN general assembly to get Enhanced UN Observer Status. They will force the US to veto their demand for freedom and justice.

Hundreds of thousands of stateless refugees (millions actually) aren't represented by international institutions now. If the UN recognizes the Palestinian state, then Palestinians will determine who has Palestinian citizenship. With enhanced UN observer status recognition at the UN General Assembly, Palestinians will be able to represent themselves at international institutions like the International Court of Justice, establish official diplomatic relations with other nations and so on...

Regarding the legitimacy of the Palestinian government, Hamas won a majority over Fatah in the last Palestinian election. Dictator Abbas of Fatah (the PLO) lost his mandate to lead Palestinians in that election. He was supposed to transfer power to Hamas as per the Palestinian constitution,. Instead Abbas ignored election results and blocked Hamas from fulfilling their election mandate to lead Palestinians. Thanks to arms from the US and Israel, Abbas was able to remain in control of the West Bank. In Gaza, Hamas intercepted Israeli and American arms shipments to Fatah and used those weapons to seize control of Gaza.
The Gaza Bombshell | Politics | Vanity Fair

The only losers here are Israel, the US and other countries like Canada that support the continued injustice and oppression suffered by Palestinians. Israel's ongoing cruelty against the Palestinian people is on display for the entire world to see. The US and Canada have exposed themselves as hypocrites for stating that everyone has a right to freedom and justice.... with the sole exception of Palestinians.
 

CDNBear

Custom Troll
Sep 24, 2006
43,839
207
63
Ontario
What happened in Nazi occupied Europe, in Rwanda, in Armenia.... could happen anywhere given the right conditions... even Canada. The slippery path starts with demonizing propaganda promoting irrational hate and fear.
You would be the resident expert here, for spreading demonizing propaganda, for the purposes of promoting hate and fear.

That's about all you post here.
 
Last edited:

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
The US and Canada have exposed themselves as hypocrites for stating that everyone has a right to freedom and justice.... with the sole exception of Palestinians.

Well I believe that you have the freedom of thought. But that does not mean you make any sense with your thoughts. Thought I might mention that as I thought it was the right thought and thoughtful as well on my part I thought, but that is just a thought. Do you have any thoughts on what I thought?
 

Colpy

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 5, 2005
21,887
848
113
70
Saint John, N.B.
Palestinians have nothing to loose by seeking UN recognition. They've already got the 2/3 majority support they need at the UN general assembly to get Enhanced UN Observer Status. They will force the US to veto their demand for freedom and justice.

Hundreds of thousands of stateless refugees (millions actually) aren't represented by international institutions now. If the UN recognizes the Palestinian state, then Palestinians will determine who has Palestinian citizenship. With enhanced UN observer status recognition at the UN General Assembly, Palestinians will be able to represent themselves at international institutions like the International Court of Justice, establish official diplomatic relations with other nations and so on...

Regarding the legitimacy of the Palestinian government, Hamas won a majority over Fatah in the last Palestinian election. Dictator Abbas of Fatah (the PLO) lost his mandate to lead Palestinians in that election. He was supposed to transfer power to Hamas as per the Palestinian constitution,. Instead Abbas ignored election results and blocked Hamas from fulfilling their election mandate to lead Palestinians. Thanks to arms from the US and Israel, Abbas was able to remain in control of the West Bank. In Gaza, Hamas intercepted Israeli and American arms shipments to Fatah and used those weapons to seize control of Gaza.
The Gaza Bombshell | Politics | Vanity Fair

The only losers here are Israel, the US and other countries like Canada that support the continued injustice and oppression suffered by Palestinians. Israel's ongoing cruelty against the Palestinian people is on display for the entire world to see. The US and Canada have exposed themselves as hypocrites for stating that everyone has a right to freedom and justice.... with the sole exception of Palestinians.

Who cares???

No one.

Your obsession is becoming offensive once again: you realize of course, that Syria has murdered more innocent Arabs in the past 6 months than Israel has killed in the past 20 years?

Oh sorry, you don't give a crap.

Or that your heroes in China have executed more people in the last year that have died in clashes with Israel since 1974???

Oh sorry, you don't give a crap.

How about that Israel is the ONLY self-made democracy with minority rights in the ME??

Oh, sorry, you don't give a crap.
 

Retired_Can_Soldier

The End of the Dog is Coming!
Mar 19, 2006
12,399
1,369
113
60
Alberta
Correction, I think your proper classification for someone like me is a "self hating Jew".

Since I'm probably of Jewish descent on my mother's side, I'm going to embrace all people who share my mitochondrial DNA as "my people". That would be my choice not yours. This isn't really a change, since I always believed all human beings are related by blood, I consider the entire human race including Jews as "my people".
.

If your so Jewish let's see your Jew card.
 

CDNBear

Custom Troll
Sep 24, 2006
43,839
207
63
Ontario
If your so Jewish let's see your Jew card.


 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
You would be the resident expert here, for spreading demonizing propaganda, for the purposes of promoting hate and fear.

That's about all you post here.

You would be the resident expert here for insults, name calling and taunts. That's about all you post here.

Do you actually have anything on topic to add, or was your post just a lame attempt to troll?
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
You would be the resident expert here for insults, name calling and taunts. Do you actually have anything on topic to add, or was your post just a lame attempt to troll?

I wonder what your parents / uncles etc opinions are on Israel?
 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
Who cares???

No one.

Your obsession is becoming offensive once again: you realize of course, that Syria has murdered more innocent Arabs in the past 6 months than Israel has killed in the past 20 years?

Oh sorry, you don't give a crap.

Or that your heroes in China have executed more people in the last year that have died in clashes with Israel since 1974???

Oh sorry, you don't give a crap.

How about that Israel is the ONLY self-made democracy with minority rights in the ME??

Oh, sorry, you don't give a crap.

If you recall I posted the very first thread regarding Syria's uprising. I have followed events in Syria closely. The Canadian government in this case has sided with freedom and justice against oppression and injustice. I have little complaints about Canada's policies regarding Syria. I'd post more on that subject if the Canadian government unshakably supported the Syrian government's oppression and injustice, the same way the Canadian government support's the Israeli government's oppression and injustice.
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
If you recall I posted the very first thread regarding Syria's uprising. I have followed events in Syria closely. The Canadian government in this case has sided with freedom and justice against oppression and injustice. I have little complaints about Canada's policies regarding Syria. I'd post more on that subject if the Canadian government unshakably supported the Syrian government's oppression and injustice, the same way the Canadian government support's the Israeli government's oppression and injustice.

You only complain when someone does not do as you see fit.
 

CDNBear

Custom Troll
Sep 24, 2006
43,839
207
63
Ontario
You would be the resident expert here for insults, name calling and taunts.
For contemptable Jew hating spammers.

That's about all you post here.
To you and anyone like you.

Do you actually have anything on topic to add, or was your post just a lame attempt to troll?
What's to add? You won't hear anything other than "Israel is bad".

You continuously ignore questions, you know the answer to will force you to admit you're wrong.

You continuously anything that you can't refute.

You dismiss material because of the source, without ever actually refuting the material.

You've made it quite clear that anyone that doesn't believe Israel is as you think they are, is an apologist.

Proving unequivocally, you are NOT here to discuss.

So I ask again, What's to add?

The day you stop trying to demonize Israel, stop dismissing things you can't refute, admit when you're wrong.

Is the day I stop treating you like the thing that eats the thing that eats the thing that eats snail sh!t.
 

DaSleeper

Trolling Hypocrites
May 27, 2007
33,676
1,666
113
Northern Ontario,
Correction, I think your proper classification for someone like me is a "self hating Jew".

Yup......and you join the list of some infamous ones like.....


1. Max Blumenthal

2. Moishe Ayre Friedman

3. Ian Lustick

4. Richard Goldstone

5. Gideon Levy

6. Roseanne Barr

7. Mike Wallace

8. Andrea Dworkin

9. Noam Chomsky

10. Karl Marx

11. Vladimir Zhirinovsky

12. Bobby Fischer

13. George Soros
 

BruSan

Electoral Member
Jul 5, 2011
416
0
16
The U.N. while having been created with the best of intentions has been subject to manipulation for many years now and this is just one more of those examples that bring to question it's continued relevance since adopting a policy of inclusion to all those it was origionally created to protect against.

****-can the whole U.N. org. and let the mid-east revert to tribal warfare driven by ancient religious zealotry and stand back to observe the outcome. My opinion only but in that particular scenario the very word Palestine would cease to exist through their own Arab brethren finally being able to practice the genocide they had already been using for centuries against the so called palestinians. they were relegated to a wasteland for a reason.
Another prediction would be the Isrealites would have the chains of restraint removed and the region would have no more worries of Hamas or Fatah lobbing stones, rockets, shoes or anything else at anyone because the Arab nations and their current borders would ALL be changed dramaticly to reflect the new Israel's vastly larger country. They would be too busy scavenging to find enough camel dung to heat their hovels with to waste time shaking their fists at Israel.
Iran would be reduced to a smoking hole in the ground with residual radioactivity making that retarded cesspool uninhabitable for the next 100 years or so.
The whole region has been nothing but a boil on a pig's ass for so long we've all become inured at the reasons for the problem being one of religious and cultural idiocy spanning centuries. There isn't one of them that can get along with the other and it ain't gonna change with statehood for Palestine, the Arabs themselves will ignore them again.
I say let them go at it and who gives a rat's patoot what the totally disfuntional U.N. has to say about Palestinian statehood.
 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
Other than their dignity
When did Palestinians get that? They haven't had any dignity for 60+ years. Can they be proud of their nationless refugee status rather than being citizens of a country like you and I? Can they be proud of having to live on a limited amount of international food and medical rations, based on the occupying country's mood?
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
When did Palestinians get that? They haven't had any dignity for 60+ years. Can they be proud of their nationless refugee status rather than being citizens of a country like you and I? Can they be proud of having to live on a limited amount of international food and medical rations, based on the occupying country's mood?

Can they be proud of wanting to commit genocide - can they - Can they be proud when they celebrate children having their throats cut, or in one case a baby shot thru the head when the terrorist was cornered on the beach.
 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
More irrational fear and hate mongering...

Meanwhile:

23 Sep 2011
Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas has handed over a historic request to UN chief Ban Ki-moon asking the United Nations to admit the state of Palestine as a full member.
The Palestinian leader won huge applause and a standing ovation on Friday from some of the assembly as he entered the hall before beginning his speech.
Palestinians across the West Bank have set in motion plans to celebrate the formal submission of their bid to become a United Nations member state, despite opposition from the United States and Israel.
In city centres, giant television screens were set up so residents could watch Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president, deliver a historic address to the 193 member states of the UN General Assembly.
"Today the Palestinian president will ask that Resolution 181 be applied to the Palestinian state as well,"....
Abbas submits Palestine statehood bid to UN - Middle East - Al Jazeera English