Just a thought: Do we have too much freedom? is there such a thing?

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,817
471
83
well ya, but there are some people out there that are very allergic to smoke from cigarettes and they cannot be in a room that smells of smoke. or around people that smell of smoke.

True, but the severity and quantity of allergic people still doesn't necessitate the move to a ban. I'm allergic to all nuts, and even I get a bit queasy when talking to someone who just ate some peanuts or almonds. I wouldn't have them ban the legume just because of my allergy. It's up to me to find a way to keep a safe distance.

Now I'm not sure on the radius of standing from a smoker, but an easy solution is to crack the window open a bit. Make sure the smoker smokes outside and stays out for a few minutes before coming back in. Hang up your jacket in the closet or in another room that is well ventilated. There are so many solutions to a problem that doesn't need government intervention.
 

Chiliagon

Prime Minister
May 16, 2010
2,116
3
38
Spruce Grove, Alberta
True, but the severity and quantity of allergic people still doesn't necessitate the move to a ban. I'm allergic to all nuts, and even I get a bit queasy when talking to someone who just ate some peanuts or almonds. I wouldn't have them ban the legume just because of my allergy. It's up to me to find a way to keep a safe distance.

Now I'm not sure on the radius of standing from a smoker, but an easy solution is to crack the window open a bit. Make sure the smoker smokes outside and stays out for a few minutes before coming back in. Hang up your jacket in the closet or in another room that is well ventilated. There are so many solutions to a problem that doesn't need government intervention.


just so ya know, the lovely people at Commonwealth stadium in Edmonton banned all peanuts because of allergies.. sheesh
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
ironically, you can have an allergy, an actual, anaphylactic allergy, to alcohol, but not to cigarette smoke. :)
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
Chili, what it boils down to is that you think everyone should live like you do.... which is flawed. Not everyone should be leading the same lives. Different personalities, different life experience, lead us to want and need different things, and view the world in different ways.
 

Chiliagon

Prime Minister
May 16, 2010
2,116
3
38
Spruce Grove, Alberta
well, maybe I'd like to see my mom stop smoking. I try everything to get her to see why.

I think smoking is wrong and I won't stop thinking it and if I could I'd try to make laws as stiff as possible. that's just how much I despise it.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Aside from being a secnod hand risk to loved ones (which one could argue as well since alcohol tends to be largely involved in domestic disputes), alcohol does everything you just listed there too.... it's a carcinogen, and can shorten your life, damage your organs, etc.

Yep, the most sinful habit in my mind is the one I don't indulge in. :lol:
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
well, maybe I'd like to see my mom stop smoking. I try everything to get her to see why.

I think smoking is wrong and I won't stop thinking it and if I could I'd try to make laws as stiff as possible. that's just how much I despise it.

If it was only smoking I'd give you that CHili, but no, you're implying that superstores ought to be regulated because you've changed your eating habits, cars ought to be regulated to the point of controlled parts, etc., because you don't like noise, smoking ought to be regulated.... I'm sure that's just the tip of the iceburg.
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
umm jee, they have proven that smoking tobacco causes Cancer?? shortens your life? creates 2nd hand smoke that can kill loved ones?

Smoking is evil and dangerous and should be banned from everything.

So you're going to apply the same rules and restrictions on pot and other things that could possibly be inhaled, simply because one product - Tobacco - can cause possible health risks?

Second hand smoke?

You get worse second hand smoke just from walking along the side of the road, from all the vehicle exhaust...... yet nobody's complaining about that.

Sorry, but you have not won me over to your way of thinking.

yup you wanna go kill yourself from smoking go on... but remember, it's not just the smoke that turns people off.

it's how you smell, your house smells, your furniture smells, your clothes.. it all smells like smoke and it can be a turn off.

Seriously, in regards to the above.... what makes you honestly think any smoker gives a damn what you think of them?

I don't care if it's a turn off for you or you don't like the smell..... if you don't, then keep clear from me.

Do you think I like the smell of some drunk on the bus late at night?

Do you think it turns me on?

Do you think I like the smell of cherries?

There's a long list of smells I can't stand...... but again, none of it is justification to remove someone's existing freedoms, simply because you personally don't like what they're doing.

well ya, but there are some people out there that are very allergic to smoke from cigarettes and they cannot be in a room that smells of smoke. or around people that smell of smoke.

Too bad for them.... natural selection...... the weak shall perish.
 

Chiliagon

Prime Minister
May 16, 2010
2,116
3
38
Spruce Grove, Alberta
So you're going to apply the same rules and restrictions on pot and other things that could possibly be inhaled, simply because one product - Tobacco - can cause possible health risks?

Second hand smoke?

You get worse second hand smoke just from walking along the side of the road, from all the vehicle exhaust...... yet nobody's complaining about that.

Sorry, but you have not won me over to your way of thinking.



Seriously, in regards to the above.... what makes you honestly think any smoker gives a damn what you think of them?

I don't care if it's a turn off for you or you don't like the smell..... if you don't, then keep clear from me.

Do you think I like the smell of some drunk on the bus late at night?

Do you think it turns me on?

Do you think I like the smell of cherries?

There's a long list of smells I can't stand...... but again, none of it is justification to remove someone's existing freedoms, simply because you personally don't like what they're doing.



Too bad for them.... natural selection...... the weak shall perish.


maybe back in 1950.

this is 2010 where we're trying to give everyone living an equal chance to live their lives to the fullest.


the reason that people are so against smoking and there's a lot of negativity on it is because it is a choice that people take even though they realize it's harmful to their health. they use the excuse "live life to the fullest".. but yet when you really look at it, isn't smoking leading to you not being able to do that exact phrase?

yay living life to the fullest, sitting in your living room with an oxygen tank because your lungs are dying and you have emphysema (not sure how it's spelled) and you can barely breathe! that's so rockin!
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Chiliagon yay living life to the fullest said:
Let's not be too much of a drama queen. What you describe is perhaps the outcome of one or two percent of people who smoke. The main thing about smoking is the quantity- that may be the outcome for those who have smoked 50 cigarettes a day for 50 years. No amount of smoking is good, but the person who enjoys 3 or 4 cigarettes a day will likely live to an advanced age. Anyway preaching does no good at all. You come across as someone who hasn't even reached the age of legally being allowed to smoke.
 

mayety

Nominee Member
Jul 18, 2010
74
0
6
British Columbia
The question was "Do we have too much freedom?"

What makes anyone think s/he is free in the first place?

Until we can go without electricity, indoor plumbing, telephone, TV, and all the amenities of so-called progress, we are not FREE.
Until we can plough our own fields and grow our own food we are dependent upon those who do provide and sell us our food, and water, and smokes, and alcohol, and clothing.

Can we make our own clothing on an old treadle machine? Wash our clothing with a non-gas/electric washing machine. Do we own a clothesline for hanging things to dry?...with what?.... not pegs we bought in a store!

Oh the technology! then the Illuminati will bring it all down to like it was when I a poor child living on a barren farm with no niceties....well there was the wood stove, the coal-oil lamps, and the hard labour.....

The Illuminati, however, have certainly made a separate world with their own air supply, electricity, running water, and every gadget thinkable, in an underground city or 2 or 3 in countries we wouldn't even expect.

A loud truck might even end up being a pleasure when doomdsday arrives.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
The question was "Do we have too much freedom?"

What makes anyone think s/he is free in the first place?

Until we can go without electricity, indoor plumbing, telephone, TV, and all the amenities of so-called progress, we are not FREE.
Until we can plough our own fields and grow our own food we are dependent upon those who do provide and sell us our food, and water, and smokes, and alcohol, and clothing.

Can we make our own clothing on an old treadle machine? Wash our clothing with a non-gas/electric washing machine. Do we own a clothesline for hanging things to dry?...with what?.... not pegs we bought in a store!

Oh the technology! then the Illuminati will bring it all down to like it was when I a poor child living on a barren farm with no niceties....well there was the wood stove, the coal-oil lamps, and the hard labour.....

The Illuminati, however, have certainly made a separate world with their own air supply, electricity, running water, and every gadget thinkable, in an underground city or 2 or 3 in countries we wouldn't even expect.

A loud truck might even end up being a pleasure when doomdsday arrives.

So once we can do all that, what else would we be FREE to do?
 

GreenFish66

House Member
Apr 16, 2008
2,717
10
38
www.myspace.com
I just returned from a 3 month back packin' bike tour ...First week was hell but after I got into a good rountine , the Wild freedom was great! ..Loved it...Glad to be back though...There is a lot of good to be said about all the comforts and amenities of Cilvized freedom ...Ah ,Home sweet Hole..

Freedom is a matter of choice and leisure...Each to his/her own ..With courtesy and respect to others who may be affected or have different views of Freedom...(Majority rules where tollerance doesn't)

Bottom line is ..Freedom is Good/Necessary to All our well beings .

(Sometimes ...When I'm in my own Space, on my own time ...I have a cigarette and a beer, and enjoy my freedom to do so ...)

All about balance and sustainability
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
I just returned from a 3 month back packin' bike tour ...First week was hell but after I got into a good rountine , the Wild freedom was great! ..Loved it...Glad to be back though...There is a lot of good to be said about all the comforts and amenities of Cilvized freedom ...Ah ,Home sweet Hole..

Freedom is a matter of choice and leisure...Each to his/her own ..With courtesy and respect to others who may be affected or have different views of Freedom...(Majority rules where tollerance doesn't)

Bottom line is ..Freedom is Good/Necessary to All our well beings .

(Sometimes ...When I'm in my own Space, on my own time ...I have a cigarette and a beer, and enjoy my freedom to do so ...)

All about balance and sustainability

Right on- the only time "freedom" should be limited is when it infringes on someone else's freedom.
 

GreenFish66

House Member
Apr 16, 2008
2,717
10
38
www.myspace.com
Right on- the only time "freedom" should be limited is when it infringes on someone else's freedom.

Yeah , then we have an issue to be resolved through diplomacy/ Civil discussions..;)

Obey the rules , show respect towards others and everyone gets along just fine. Leaving more time to enjoy their greater Freedoms ,...

In Peace...:)
 

mayety

Nominee Member
Jul 18, 2010
74
0
6
British Columbia
JLM
"So once we can do all that, what else would we be FREE to do?"

Live a peaceful life, dependent upon no one, and that goes for the milions of families, not just one person.... no credir cards, no mortgages, no need for the Fed. let it dry up.

Make one's own fun, don't listen to /watch Illuminati garbage, no need to live in fear, help one another, love each other, neighbour helps neighbour (barter system.. my parents did it) but little did we see to what "progress" was leading......

Terrorism!
 

ironsides

Executive Branch Member
Feb 13, 2009
8,583
60
48
United States
We have as much freedom as the goverment allows us to have. plane an simple just enough to keep us happy. We don't have the right to just take another mans wife or some possession because you wanted it, Anyone who would like more must earn it.