Show me where Colpy made that particular statement- word for ffn word - If not retract it.
Jewish MP: Israel acting like Nazis in Gaza
- Thread starter gore0bsessed
- Start date
Show me where Colpy made that particular statement- word for ffn word - If not retract it.
Not going to happen Goob's. EAO as moved up from ideological troll, to garden variety troll.
I don't think even he's as daft as his silly logic would indicate.
But I could be wrong.
Ya know I can be pretty dumb at times- but what is it like being dumb all the time. To make claims that are utter BS- to have your claims torn to shreds- you have no creditability on this issue.
Click on link:
http://forums.canadiancontent.net/n...oportionate-response-hamas-3.html#post1047510
direct copy and paste from the above link:
....1000 dead civilians after 21 days of warfare in the most densely packed population centre on earth shows amazing restraint and care taken by Israelis.
Here's the entire post in context:
Colpy wrote on Feb 4th, 2009
Yep.
The Israelis fought in the most densely populated area on earth for 21 days, using the most sophisticated conventional air, sea, and land power known.
They killed 1300 people. Somewhere between 25 and 50 % of those were militants.
they were carefully avoiding civilian casualties as much as possible while achieving their strategic ends.
In comparison, Allied Bomber command, using only air power, killed 80,000 people in the city of Dresden in a single night.........65 years ago.
THAT is targeting civilians.
The Americans killed considerably more than 100,000 in a single night raid on Tokyo.
THAT is targeting civilians.
At the very outside, 1000 dead civilians after 21 days of warfare in the most densely packed population centre on earth shows amazing restraint and care taken by Israelis.
Despite several incidents such as those above. Start tossing tons of explosives around, and Shyte happens.
Stop embarrassing yourself already.
Your posts are just getting more and more pathetic.
Did you read your own link Bucky- Link and copy and paste it- you can do that for us that have a problem with mah and English-
Goob's, he's stuck in a loop. He likely knows he's made a grave error, but will not admit it at all costs.
Just look at the flotilla thread. His claims have been thoroughly proven false, and absurd.
That has upset him greatly. Hence the angst and anger in this thread.
As long as his feelings are hurt, this will continue. But have hope, he usually cools off over night.
Oh I know - When he started retracting and apologizing I had hoped for a change. Guess i was wrong.
Maybe if I post it in bold and bigger letters you guys will get it.
Colpy claims that only killing a 1000 innocent civilians over a three week period demonstrated an "amazing restraint and care taken by Israelis".
Therefore it would reasonable to assume that Colpy would describe only killing 17,000 innocent civilians (more likely less than 10,000) over a 70 week period as an even greater level of restraint and care taken by the Syrians.
If the Syrians had exercised the same level of amazing restraint and care as the Israelis they would have killed 23,333 Syrians by now, not 17,000.
Colpy claims that only killing a 1000 innocent civilians over a three week period demonstrated an "amazing restraint and care taken by Israelis".
Therefore it would reasonable to assume that Colpy would describe only killing 17,000 innocent civilians (more likely less than 10,000) over a 70 week period as an even greater level of restraint and care taken by the Syrians.
If the Syrians had exercised the same level of amazing restraint and care as the Israelis they would have killed 23,333 Syrians by now, not 17,000.
Nope again- Do you know what the average ratio is for soldiers - civilians killed during combat. Well do you.
There's nothing to get.
The argument is...
Colpy never said that, lol. I don't care about the rest of your original post, lol.
You can do mathmatic back flips, till the cows come home.
You're still a liar, lol.
The fact that you keep going back to that is incredibly funny though.
Last edited:
Colpy's post to prove that the Israeli's used "amazing restraint and care" referenced a ratio because it gave two numbers. Because the ratio referenced time, that makes it a special kind of ratio known as a "rate".
The rate at which Israelis killed innocent civilians was 1000 civilians over 3 weeks . Clearly a rate, not a total as you two imply. If Colpy's value was a total, he just would have said 1000 civilians without a reference to time. But as soon as he includes time as a second number, then it becomes a rate, not a total.
He also mentioned the Dresden bombing... 80,000 of dead in one night... that statement references a rate, not a total.
He also mentioned the Tokyo bombing... 100,000 in a single night raid. Also a rate.
According to Colpy, these death "rates" proved deliberate targeting of civilians. Killing civilians at a much lower "rate" by Israelis "shows amazing restraint and care"
Since the Syrian "rate" of killing civilians is much lower than the "rate" at which Israelis killed civilians, then it would be logical to assume that Colpy would agree that the Syrians have demonstrated a greater level of restraint and care.
BTW, Take any three weeks of the Syrian uprising and you won't find any period where the Syrians killed innocent civilians at a greater rate than the Israelis did during Cast Lead.
Take any Israeli incursion into Gaza in the last 10 years and you won't find a rate of killing innocent civilians less than the rate Syrian rate of killing innocent civilians.
Let me know when you guys understand the difference between total and rate.
The rate at which Israelis killed innocent civilians was 1000 civilians over 3 weeks . Clearly a rate, not a total as you two imply. If Colpy's value was a total, he just would have said 1000 civilians without a reference to time. But as soon as he includes time as a second number, then it becomes a rate, not a total.
He also mentioned the Dresden bombing... 80,000 of dead in one night... that statement references a rate, not a total.
He also mentioned the Tokyo bombing... 100,000 in a single night raid. Also a rate.
According to Colpy, these death "rates" proved deliberate targeting of civilians. Killing civilians at a much lower "rate" by Israelis "shows amazing restraint and care"
Since the Syrian "rate" of killing civilians is much lower than the "rate" at which Israelis killed civilians, then it would be logical to assume that Colpy would agree that the Syrians have demonstrated a greater level of restraint and care.
BTW, Take any three weeks of the Syrian uprising and you won't find any period where the Syrians killed innocent civilians at a greater rate than the Israelis did during Cast Lead.
Take any Israeli incursion into Gaza in the last 10 years and you won't find a rate of killing innocent civilians less than the rate Syrian rate of killing innocent civilians.
Let me know when you guys understand the difference between total and rate.
Last edited:
You still misrepresented what Colpy said...
Let me know when you're done embarrassing yourself...
BTW, please respect forum rules and do not attack people. I could have
called CB a liar for portraying three weeks of mass slaughter as a
single event. Yet I restrained myself. You two should try to do like
wise. Despite your insults and taunts, the worst I did was call you an
idiot and I just retracted that term
Have a nice day....
called CB a liar for portraying three weeks of mass slaughter as a
single event. Yet I restrained myself. You two should try to do like
wise. Despite your insults and taunts, the worst I did was call you an
idiot and I just retracted that term
Have a nice day....
Why do you hold us to standards you don't hold yourself to?
You could have, but it would be a lie like the one where you misrepresented what Colpy posted.
A short while after you were warned.
I haven't attacked you.
Just because you retract it, doesn't mean you didn't say it, lol.
Thanks to the idiocy contained in your posts, I will...