Stubborn Father

Ron in Regina

"Voice of the West" Party
Apr 9, 2008
29,191
11,032
113
Regina, Saskatchewan
I am 32

well ya, we're just not comfortable with having two more people in the car. it's a room factor and privacy factor.

I too would feel uncomfortable with the situation of not being able to talk about whatever you want because you have a parent in the car..


I lost my Mom to Cancer when I was 19yrs old, and I lost my Dad to a series
of 10 massive heart attacks in 7 days when I was 13yrs old. I dealt with it.

I'd kill to trade you places, to be able to have even 8hrs with one of my parents,
even packed in with two other people in a car. Even to just say, "Hey, this is
me, & I turned out just fine.....& thank you!"

Buddy, you don't know what you have 'till it's gone.
 

Nuggler

kind and gentle
Feb 27, 2006
11,596
141
63
Backwater, Ontario.
I lost my Mom to Cancer when I was 19yrs old, and I lost my Dad to a series
of 10 massive heart attacks in 7 days when I was 13yrs old. I dealt with it.

I'd kill to trade you places, to be able to have even 8hrs with one of my parents,
even packed in with two other people in a car. Even to just say, "Hey, this is
me, & I turned out just fine.....& thank you!"

Buddy, you don't know what you have 'till it's gone.


Second that:............:(
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
i lost my mom to cancer when i was 19yrs old, and i lost my dad to a series
of 10 massive heart attacks in 7 days when i was 13yrs old. I dealt with it.

i'd kill to trade you places, to be able to have even 8hrs with one of my parents,
even packed in with two other people in a car. Even to just say, "hey, this is
me, & i turned out just fine.....& thank you!"

buddy, you don't know what you have 'till it's gone.

((((hugs))))
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
the problem is that it was arranged to be the way it is.. we were going down in separate vehicles, there were no issues there. I immediately made the point back when we first talked about it all that we were going down ourselves. she and I just want to have this to ourselves that's all.
Like Ron has stated quite well. And I agree - i lost my mother when i was 25 - she was 55 - My father at 27 - he was 61 -

I think that you have made a mountain out of a molehill and should mature a little bit - Is it your father who is being stubborn or you. You have not mentioned anything other than this single disagreement - so how is a person to understand if he is being stubborn or not.

Also your Father knows full well that your Mother would like to spend more time with you. There is something about a Mother loves that transcends what we know of today. She carried you, gave birth and suckled you, were there when you came home with your cuts and scrapes. And that does not in any way lessen the love you Father has for you.

I am betting that you do not see your parents as often as they would like. You are grown and left the roost - They realize that time for them is getting shorter by the day.

So is this a hill you wish to die on as we say in the Army.

So man up, call and apologize and tell your mother that you would like to have her come with you so that you can spend more time together.

Just my opinion.
 

lone wolf

Grossly Underrated
Nov 25, 2006
32,493
212
63
In the bush near Sudbury
I'm 53, have a full set of parents, and I'm glad my Dad is stubborn. Through prostate cancer - and the results of treatment - to two knee replacements (one was faulty) and the end of being a very active Mister Fixit type guy, stubborn (and some bitchy too) keeps him going and in good spirits.

Chili, I really think you should stop and see there is a world outside you.
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
I'm 53, have a full set of parents, and I'm glad my Dad is stubborn. Through prostate cancer - and the results of treatment - to two knee replacements (one was faulty) and the end of being a very active Mister Fixit type guy, stubborn (and some bitchy too) keeps him going and in good spirits.

Chili, I really think you should stop and see there is a world outside you.

I am 53 as well and not a day gfoes by where i do not wish for my Parents to see what I have done, what i have become because of their help, guidance and love. And I was one bad SOB growing up. Mostly - not all
 

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
I think you should drive down sharing a car. You'll realize soon enough that as time goes by, family matters more than anything. If you're going to marry this woman, then you'll have plenty of time in the future to take long drives. If you're not going to marry this woman, then you should put your family first. If you're looking at this as an opportunity to deepen the relationship with this woman, there are many ways to do that without telling your mom to drive herself.

If this woman is crazy about you, then she's crazy about all of you ... including your family ... and should step up and insist that you do the right thing for your family. I suggest you sit down with her and let her know that you have responsibilities to your family, and you hope she doesn't mind if you travel in one car with some of your family. If she says no, then you know the relationship is going no where. It will be a good test of her character.
 

Chiliagon

Prime Minister
May 16, 2010
2,116
3
38
Spruce Grove, Alberta
If you're 32, then you should have moved out 7 years ago, and grown a set of balls 15 years ago.

If you're 32, living at home, and doing what your father says, you are never going to grow up.


ya it would have been the most realistic and likely thing to do .. but today when the cost of living is higher than what you can afford today, it's awful damn difficult to JUST move out!

I have been looking and working out a way to see if it's possible. and today it's NOT possible. I've had a job for almost a year, I make enough money to live on my own but I am paying off a loan that takes a good chunk of that money.

I have a time line.

you shouldn't just say what you said without knowing everything first.
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
the problem is that it was arranged to be the way it is.. we were going down in separate vehicles, there were no issues there. I immediately made the point back when we first talked about it all that we were going down ourselves. she and I just want to have this to ourselves that's all.

The only reason why I and backing Chili's position is the fact (based on the information) that this was the original plan made a month ago and nothing was said or argued about and then suddenly when hotel rooms are booked, plans have already been made and so on..... now there's a problem.

To me, that's a case of being d*cked around.... it's a minor and small issue overall, but it doesn't make any sense to complain about already set plans a month after they were set.

I lost my Mom to Cancer when I was 19yrs old, and I lost my Dad to a series
of 10 massive heart attacks in 7 days when I was 13yrs old. I dealt with it.

I'd kill to trade you places, to be able to have even 8hrs with one of my parents,
even packed in with two other people in a car. Even to just say, "Hey, this is
me, & I turned out just fine.....& thank you!"

Buddy, you don't know what you have 'till it's gone.

I understand your position Ron, but this is not your life but his..... his parents are still around, he sees them basically every single day because he lives with them, and every so often..... a couple of hours alone with someone you're in a relationship without having your parents over your shoulders is a nice thing to have.

I know what it's like to still be living with a parent, in a relationship and being extremely limited on what you can do or say around the house or in your room because of what they may hear or how they may react because you're their little baby who should still be a child in their eyes.

It's pretty difficult to find time for yourself and your girlfriend/wife in that kind of environment, and I think asking for 8 hours alone on a drive wouldn't be asking too much.

Usually you have to leave the house, go find some place to be alone, maybe even find some hotel room or motel room..... but if you're living with your parents, chances are you don't always have the money to do that on a regular basis in the first place, so you're back to square one.

Because if you're doing the nasty in your parent's house with your significant other, from my personal experience, chances are they heard and you're going to have a guilt trip tossed on you, especially if they're the old skool kind who try and put out the argument that you should be married before you do such things, blah blah blah....... even though in my case, that argument was pretty hypocritical considering my parent's own past and why they got married.

The other problem is if they do take one car and all go up there together, when someone wants to go somewhere for whatever reason, either everybody has to go, or they take the car and everybody else is stuck in one spot until they return with that car.

With two cars, he and his girlfriend can go somewhere, his brother can go somewhere or his mother can go somewhere...... I personally don't see the big deal.

Added:

And to be honest I think it's everybody else in this thread who's making a mountain out of a molehill..... he's asking for a couple of hours alone on a drive with his significant other, not banishing his parents to some friggin island until they die so he never has to see them again..... and everybody in here seems to be acting as though if they all don't take the car together and spend time with his parents (who he sees everyday because he lives with them) that suddenly they're both going to die and he'll be sorry for making one minor selfish decision...... which his brother and mother both feel is perfectly fine and said they'd have no problem taking another car.

As far as I know, his mother doesn't have some terminal illness, was not crying and sobbing that she couldn't go in the car with him and the only argument being used to take one car is gas money (which was dealt with) and them possibly getting lost (which I am sure both his mother and brother have driven a car before at least once or twice in their lives)

Way to put on the unfounded guilt trip people.

Yeah sure..... some of you have had your parents die and can no longer spend time with them and that makes you feel bad sometimes...... and some day, his parents will die...... my parents will die...... my wife's father died almost a year ago from cancer and her mom is being treated for cancer as well but is treatable...... all our parents will die eventually, just as our grand parents died and our parents had to deal with it..... it affects you...... I've had a number of people die in my life whom I'll never see again...... but does that mean I should cling onto every single person I know 24 hours a day, 7 days a week and try and spend every waking moment with them because they might die someday or feel guilty that I didn't spend more time with them?

We all have lives, including our parents.... and sometimes that means spending some time away from them in order to live our lives...... Should you feel guilty for not spending every waking moment clinging to your parents..... or should your parents feel guilty for cling to you every waking moment and not allowing you to actually live your own life as you should..... as they should have raised you to?

Frig, they'd probably want to get in a car and drive for 8 hours without me tagging along too..... just for the peace and quiet and so they don't have to hear my voice going on and on and on about everything under the sun like what you guys are suffering through right now in these forums.

Oh but you best not try and spend time away from me, because I might die tomorrow and then you'll all miss me, wished you spent more time with me and fill your life full of regret that you weren't as close to Praxius as you think you should have.

Don't worry, I won't hold it against you.......

And in a couple of months, I'll be in Australia with limited opportunities to head back here to visit my parents, friends and the rest of my family..... there's a real good chance that one of my parents or someone else in my family will die while I'm over there...... that's what happened to my wife when her father passed away last year.

Should we just divorce so she can be with her mother until she passes away, or so I can remain here in my low paying job, living pay cheque to pay cheque until both my parents die?

The reason why she was here when her father died was because he specifically told her to stay here and not come back home because of him..... he wanted her to live her life...... and when her mother got cancer a few months later, she told her the exact same thing, that she didn't want her to come back home without me....... and both my mother and father want me to head to Australia because both of us will have better opportunities there, both of us can finally afford to start a family, pay off my damn student loans..... start a life, which I hoped to have started 10 damn years ago.

He's asking for 8 hours in a car and a hotel room for the two of them for a couple of days...... based on what I'm about to do, what he's asking for is pretty damn trivial and I don't see why he has to be trashed on for asking for a simple request he already planned out a month ago.

And while I predict some of you will respond to me saying that since I never lost a parent yet, I don't know what it's like.... you're right..... I haven't and no I don't know exactly what it's like..... but I've been spending the last year at my wife's side as she's dealing with her loss and I know it's a factual reality that it will happen soon for me.

But I'm not going to halt my life because of it, nor should I or anybody else feel guilty in indulging in a tiny bit of selfishness once in a while because of it, because I know damn well my parents have done so in their lives..... and I don't hold it against them...... and I know they'd feel guilty for stopping me from living my life just because of what they may want..... because they told me so..... and actually, what we're going to be doing is what they want anyways.
 
Last edited:

Chiliagon

Prime Minister
May 16, 2010
2,116
3
38
Spruce Grove, Alberta
there, he's made a good point, which I didn't really think about till now.

I see them pretty much all the time and I wouldn't mind having some time on my own on the trip.
 

Curiosity

Senate Member
Jul 30, 2005
7,326
138
63
California
Chiliagon

You are getting some excellent advice from the writers here about a son/father relationship - I was surprised you are thirty-two - not that it matters but that you seem to react to things as if you were of a younger age. Perhaps you have been protected living with your family.

As Ron and Praxius and others have written, I would give my arms to have my parents with me even for an afternoon of sitting together just being near and going over old memories and laughs at what a dunce I could be to them.

Parents often feel the sadness of losing children to adulthood too - we have to be adult enough to appreciate where they are coming from - even if their wishes seem a bit over the top - what's the hurt in just keeping the peace.

Don't build a later life of regret by missing some really landmark moments you can still make with your parents - in honoring them, showing them your love and desire to a good life for yourself, and keep the
Archie Bunker kinda "who's on first" in the background. You can come here and vent but show your love as often as you can - those who have been there are the best advice you can receive.

It often hurts to be a parent too knowing your children need you no longer. Keep that honor going as
long and often as you can in love and sincerity.
 

Chiliagon

Prime Minister
May 16, 2010
2,116
3
38
Spruce Grove, Alberta
well cur, I dont' want to give the impression that I dont' need them anymore, or that I don't want to be around them.. because that is not the case at all.

I guess being stuck where I am and having to be around them all the time you begin to wish that you could have more independence and not always have them around. isn't that why people get their own place to live? to have their freedom and ability to do what they like?

there are a lot of things that I cannot do at home that I would love to do and it's all because I am not the one in charge.

I love them both as much as you can possibly love parents, I just feel that a road trip is one of the chances I get to get away from them for a bit.

I'll see them when I arrive and we'll all be there together having fun and enjoying the wedding.. I just need a few hours on my own.
 

Curiosity

Senate Member
Jul 30, 2005
7,326
138
63
California
Chiliagon

I wish you could tell that to your father - does he know how much you love him? Sometimes with men it's tough.
 

Chiliagon

Prime Minister
May 16, 2010
2,116
3
38
Spruce Grove, Alberta
ya, between the times I tell him he's crazy for wishing harmful things on Edmonton Eskimos players and his thinking..

and then when he's obsessed with stuff.. it can be difficult.

I haven't told anyone that in years.
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
...... As Ron and Praxius and others have written, I would give my arms to have my parents with me even for an afternoon of sitting together just being near and going over old memories and laughs at what a dunce I could be to them.

:-? ...... you really didn't read what I wrote did you? lol

It often hurts to be a parent too knowing your children need you no longer. Keep that honor going as long and often as you can in love and sincerity.

See that's something I never got..... certainly not when it comes to my own parents..... I would have thought you no longer needing your parents to help you out in life and finally gaining your own independence would prove that you, as a parent, did exactly what you needed to do and you raised a good kid who can now fend for themselves.

Sure that aspect of raising them is over, but from my parents own words, they were glad that we're out on our own and living our own lives..... more so because now they can finally live their lives again and do what they wanted to do with their lives...... but also because they know they did well.

Once in a while we still ask for help with this or that, but for me personally, I don't do that unless I have no other choice..... then again, our family, extended and close, were always people who liked to be a little independent..... but we still spend time with one another.... just not every waking day.
 

TenPenny

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 9, 2004
17,467
139
63
Location, Location
See that's something I never got..... certainly not when it comes to my own parents..... I would have thought you no longer needing your parents to help you out in life and finally gaining your own independence would prove that you, as a parent, did exactly what you needed to do and you raised a good kid who can now fend for themselves.

Exactly; the goal of being a parent is to get your children to the point where they don't NEED you anymore.
Wanting to spend time with you, and have a relationship is one thing, but fully grown adults shouldn't NEED their parents, it won't be long before the parents NEED the children. That's how life works.
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
well cur, I dont' want to give the impression that I dont' need them anymore, or that I don't want to be around them.. because that is not the case at all.

I guess being stuck where I am and having to be around them all the time you begin to wish that you could have more independence and not always have them around. isn't that why people get their own place to live? to have their freedom and ability to do what they like?

there are a lot of things that I cannot do at home that I would love to do and it's all because I am not the one in charge.

I love them both as much as you can possibly love parents, I just feel that a road trip is one of the chances I get to get away from them for a bit.

I'll see them when I arrive and we'll all be there together having fun and enjoying the wedding.. I just need a few hours on my own.

Well I understand where you're coming from..... but at the same time, I'd strongly recommend you look upon this situation and come to the conclusion that while it is difficult to get out there and live on your own due to loans and high costs of living (was the reason why I went back for a year)...... believe me, the struggle is worth your own independence.

If both of you are working, then both of you should have enough money to get your own place, even if it's just a one bedroom apartment and not the most ritzy..... it'd still be your place where you both have the say in what happens and where you both can do what you please, when you want to and how you want to.

I had to start in a bach. apartment where my bed was in my living room and a dumpster was just below the only window that could open......

Student loans are a pain in the ass and they eventually screwed me over with my payments by claiming they didn't receive certain forms (which I sent in several times) and they eventually tossed me into collections.

I freaked out and thought I'd lose everything...... but all they really can do is screw your credit up...... and what I've learned over the years is that in my situation, that means squat. I'm still living decently, I am still working, I am still paying my other more important bills and since they're the ones who d*cked me over, they can damn well wait until I have the money to pay it off.

I am paying off one loan at the moment, and I have already paid off the loan from the bank which my father had to help with while I was in school to get and I paid him off.... eventually I'll just have one loan left....... which with any luck when I head to Australia, I'll have paid off soon too.

They can not take all your money from you because they can not leave you in complete destitution..... you still need to have a roof over your head, a job, pay your every day bills and eat...... if they attempt to suck you completely dry, then in their view, you'll eventually be on the streets bumming for change..... and then they get nothing...... so they'll take whatever the hell they can get from you after realizing the tough talk and threats don't work anymore.

I was stressed out at the first.... had to deal with the constant phone calls and letters..... then when I realized the letters looped back to the very first letter they sent me and then eventually passed me off to another collection agency who just did the exact same thing...... I realized they're full of crap.

They got my GST and income tax money and they toasted my credit rating.... big whoop..... You can still get a 2nd hand car if you really need a vehicle without credit..... Otherwise, that's what transit systems and taxis are for........ you can still rent or eventually pay to own for a house you can call your own (Pretty much the same as a mortgage)....... and everything else I ever needed in my life I have been able to get one way or another without needing credit...... and once I head to Australia, I have no credit rating there anyways, thus them screwing me over with my student loans has little to no affect on my life and I'll still be able to pay them off eventually, while still living my own life with my own place.

Either way, you can work something out with the S.Loans..... tell them that you're being kicked out of your parents place and have to begin living on your own, thus you can only afford "this much" of a payment per month..... which will probably extend the time it will take to pay it all off, but it's either that or they try and screw you over and risk losing that payment coming in every month..... which will hurt them more then it will hurt you.

You'd be surprised how many people they deal with who don't pay their loans off at all...... and that mostly has to due with, yet again, coming straight out of college and not getting a job in their field because they don't have "Experience" and by the time they actually do find something..... they're already sent to collections.

-------------------------------

Something else you can use to help you get out on your own in regards to dealing with the Loans is filling out an "Interest Relief Application" which basically tells them that you are not making enough money to sustain yourself and forces them to hold off payments for a couple of months:

Interest Relief for Canada Student Loans

^ This is probably your best tool to use to get out on your own and have a place to call your own, because it takes that burden off your shoulders for a while until you're situated.

Unfortunately, this is also the forms they screwed me around with (RBC Bank that is) claiming they never received them when I know in fact that they did because I personally dropped them into their hands at one of their branches that dealt directly with student loans...... but I did get a little over half a year where I didn't have to worry about loans and try to get on my own feet.

Reading the above link it seems as though they actually improved the Interest Relief to 6 months and up to 30 months.

Take a chance man..... get out there and get your own place..... there's always risks and it will get stressful sometimes...... but in my opinion, it's worth it.
 

Ariadne

Council Member
Aug 7, 2006
2,432
8
38
there, he's made a good point, which I didn't really think about till now.

I see them pretty much all the time and I wouldn't mind having some time on my own on the trip.

If we live under our parents roof, we live by their rules. That's pretty much a no brainer. If we want our independence, and to live by our rules, we establish independent living. I completed a degree 8 years ago using provincial and federal student loans. You say that because of loans you live with your parents. If you have an income, it should be manageable to live independently and pay student loans ... after all ... the gov't calculates load repayment such that you will pay very little for a very long time. As a single parent, I repaid my entire loans in 2 years while living independently. I ensured that my expenses remained the same as when I was a student, which made it easy to get rid of the debt quickly. The mistake people make is to overspend when they have an income, and then carry the loan for many years. If a single parent can pull it off, a single employed guy can pull it off.

ETA: I see this is a loan to your parents, which means you have even more flexibility in repayment than with institutional loans.

I think you would feel better about everything in life if you found a cheap apt, stopped spending, repaid the loan, and visited with your parents when it suits all parties. I don't agree with adults living with their parents, cramping their parents lifestyles, and then stomping their feet when they can't have their way.

I think the deeper issue may be that your father wants you to establish independent living, and is using this as an opportunity to demonstrate that if you want to continue living as a dependent child, then there are responsibilities that, for you, take on the appearance of unpleasant consequences

Did I mention the guy I met at University in 1986 who was living with his mom to reduce costs? Did I mention that he had a student loan? He graduated, and continued living with his mom to reduce costs. He's a 55 year old basement dweller ... still living with mom, still paying off student loans ... no life, no relationship, no family. That is not a life that anyone should settle for.

ETA: alternatively, since you say this is something that you have no control over, it's possible that your parents are unable to cut the apron strings. I suggest you cut them anyway ... for your sake.