Tory ridings big winners with enriched child-care benefits
- Thread starter mentalfloss
- Start date
Justin Trudeau says he’s giving his $3,400 Universal Child Care Benefit payments to charity
National Post | Canadian News, Financial News and Opinion
OTTAWA — Justin Trudeau is putting his money where his mouth is when it comes to the Conservative government’s newly enhanced universal child care benefit.
The Liberal leader maintains it’s wrong to give the benefit to wealthy families that don’t need help raising their kids. And to underscore that point, he’s going to give his own family’s windfall to charity.
With three young children, one under the age of six, Trudeau is entitled to collect annual UCCB payments of about $3,400.
In an interview Tuesday, he said he’ll give that money to La Maison Bleue, a charitable group in his Montreal riding devoted to helping vulnerable women during pregnancy and the early days of motherhood.
Child care benefits should go to families who need the help, “not families like mine or Mr. (Prime Minister Stephen) Harper’s,” Trudeau told The Canadian Press.
Darryl Dyck / The Canadian Press
Darryl Dyck / The Canadian PressLiberal Leader Justin Trudeau holds his then-5-month-old son Hadrien while attending the B.C. Day Liberal barbeque in Vancouver, B.C., on Monday August 4, 2014. With three young children, one under the age of six, Trudeau is entitled to collect annual UCCB payments of about $3,400. He is giving his benefit to charity.
“When it comes to child benefits, fair doesn’t mean giving everyone the same thing, it means giving people what they need.”
On the same principle, Trudeau has previously promised that he and his wife won’t take advantage of the Conservatives’ newly introduced parental income splitting scheme — forgoing some $2,000 in potential savings on his family’s annual income taxes.
Should the Liberals win this fall’s election, Trudeau is vowing to scrap income splitting for couples with children, a measure worth more than $2 billion which many experts have said would benefit primarily the top 15 per cent of income earners.
He’s promising to plow that money, and more, into a single, new, tax-free child benefit. It would replace the UCCB and two other existing child benefits with what Liberals say would be more generous payments for most parents than what they currently receive from the Conservative government.
We’re choosing to do more for the people who need it by doing less for the people who don’t. Our plan is progressive
Trudeau said he actually agrees with the Conservatives that boosting child benefits will help stimulate the sluggish economy but he fundamentally disagrees with their insistence that all families, regardless of income, should get the same amount.
Under the Liberal proposal, benefits would be gradually reduced for families with incomes of more than $150,000, and cut off entirely for those with incomes over $200,000.
“We’re choosing to do more for the people who need it by doing less for the people who don’t,” Trudeau said. “Our plan is progressive.”
He stressed that the Liberal benefit would also be tax-free, not clawed back through income taxes like the UCCB.
One more sleep until Christmas in July for Moms and Dads! #UCCB #YourKidsYourWay http://t.co/lVGwdQF07P
—
Pierre Poilievre (@PierrePoilievre) July 19, 2015
The government is delivering the enhanced UCCB payments, retroactive to January, in lump sum payments to parents this week. Employment Minister Pierre Poilievre sported a shirt emblazoned with the Conservative party logo at a government event Monday to tout the payments — calling them “Christmas in July.”
“Everybody knows that Christmas is followed by a month or two in which you’re going to get the credit card bills,” Trudeau said, accusing the Conservatives of shamelessly trying to buy the votes of parents.
“Come tax time, an awful lot of families are going to have to be paying back a chunk of that child care money that’s just announced.”
Trudeau also had tough words for NDP Leader Tom Mulcair, who has promised to keep the current UCCB and introduce a program to create one million $15-a-day child spaces, which would be available to parents regardless of income.
“In both of the NDP positionings, they are continuing to give benefits and advantages to wealthy Canadians, which, quite frankly, I don’t get,” he said.
“The NDP is supposed to be the party, I mean everyone thinks of it as a party that actually helps the people who need it and doesn’t help the wealthy.”
On that score, Trudeau said he’s equally mystified that the NDP has panned his proposal to hike income taxes for the wealthiest one per cent of Canadians.
Justin Trudeau says he’s giving his $3,400 Universal Child Care Benefit payments to charity
National Post | Canadian News, Financial News and Opinion
OTTAWA — Justin Trudeau is putting his money where his mouth is when it comes to the Conservative government’s newly enhanced universal child care benefit.
The Liberal leader maintains it’s wrong to give the benefit to wealthy families that don’t need help raising their kids. And to underscore that point, he’s going to give his own family’s windfall to charity.
With three young children, one under the age of six, Trudeau is entitled to collect annual UCCB payments of about $3,400.
In an interview Tuesday, he said he’ll give that money to La Maison Bleue, a charitable group in his Montreal riding devoted to helping vulnerable women during pregnancy and the early days of motherhood.
Child care benefits should go to families who need the help, “not families like mine or Mr. (Prime Minister Stephen) Harper’s,” Trudeau told The Canadian Press.
Darryl Dyck / The Canadian Press
Darryl Dyck / The Canadian PressLiberal Leader Justin Trudeau holds his then-5-month-old son Hadrien while attending the B.C. Day Liberal barbeque in Vancouver, B.C., on Monday August 4, 2014. With three young children, one under the age of six, Trudeau is entitled to collect annual UCCB payments of about $3,400. He is giving his benefit to charity.
“When it comes to child benefits, fair doesn’t mean giving everyone the same thing, it means giving people what they need.”
On the same principle, Trudeau has previously promised that he and his wife won’t take advantage of the Conservatives’ newly introduced parental income splitting scheme — forgoing some $2,000 in potential savings on his family’s annual income taxes.
Should the Liberals win this fall’s election, Trudeau is vowing to scrap income splitting for couples with children, a measure worth more than $2 billion which many experts have said would benefit primarily the top 15 per cent of income earners.
He’s promising to plow that money, and more, into a single, new, tax-free child benefit. It would replace the UCCB and two other existing child benefits with what Liberals say would be more generous payments for most parents than what they currently receive from the Conservative government.
We’re choosing to do more for the people who need it by doing less for the people who don’t. Our plan is progressive
Trudeau said he actually agrees with the Conservatives that boosting child benefits will help stimulate the sluggish economy but he fundamentally disagrees with their insistence that all families, regardless of income, should get the same amount.
Under the Liberal proposal, benefits would be gradually reduced for families with incomes of more than $150,000, and cut off entirely for those with incomes over $200,000.
“We’re choosing to do more for the people who need it by doing less for the people who don’t,” Trudeau said. “Our plan is progressive.”
He stressed that the Liberal benefit would also be tax-free, not clawed back through income taxes like the UCCB.
One more sleep until Christmas in July for Moms and Dads! #UCCB #YourKidsYourWay http://t.co/lVGwdQF07P
—
Pierre Poilievre (@PierrePoilievre) July 19, 2015
The government is delivering the enhanced UCCB payments, retroactive to January, in lump sum payments to parents this week. Employment Minister Pierre Poilievre sported a shirt emblazoned with the Conservative party logo at a government event Monday to tout the payments — calling them “Christmas in July.”
“Everybody knows that Christmas is followed by a month or two in which you’re going to get the credit card bills,” Trudeau said, accusing the Conservatives of shamelessly trying to buy the votes of parents.
“Come tax time, an awful lot of families are going to have to be paying back a chunk of that child care money that’s just announced.”
Trudeau also had tough words for NDP Leader Tom Mulcair, who has promised to keep the current UCCB and introduce a program to create one million $15-a-day child spaces, which would be available to parents regardless of income.
“In both of the NDP positionings, they are continuing to give benefits and advantages to wealthy Canadians, which, quite frankly, I don’t get,” he said.
“The NDP is supposed to be the party, I mean everyone thinks of it as a party that actually helps the people who need it and doesn’t help the wealthy.”
On that score, Trudeau said he’s equally mystified that the NDP has panned his proposal to hike income taxes for the wealthiest one per cent of Canadians.
Justin Trudeau says he’s giving his $3,400 Universal Child Care Benefit payments to charity
So he is still earning from it. Those who need the UCCB don't have the cash to give to charity nor would the tax credit be of any use.
Not at all. You want daycare because the UBBC doesn't come close to covering what you pay for your kid's daycare.
That is greed.
Not everyone needs daycare do they?
That is greed.
Not everyone needs daycare do they?
That doesn't even make sense because under your philosophy, I could still put this benefit money toward daycare if I really wanted to.
But it is so pitifully small it's not worth implementing in my budget so I'll just buy some cap'n Morgan with it instead.
This is just a political stunt that's obviously not paying off lol
But it is so pitifully small it's not worth implementing in my budget so I'll just buy some cap'n Morgan with it instead.
This is just a political stunt that's obviously not paying off lol
That's right you could put it towards daycare even though it's your wife and kid's money and she should spend it on her kids. She doesn't need you blowing it on rum.
Just like UBBC, it self adjusts. Anyone needing the supplement is probably not in a taxable bracket so in the end they get the full nut without owing.
A couple can make 41,000. without paying taxes???
Old Age Security benefits Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) amounts for individuals receiving a full Old Age Security (OAS) pension.
If you are a single, widowed or divorced pensioner $765.93 $17,136 (individual income)
If your spouse/common-law partner receives the full OAS pension $507.87 $22,608 (combined income)
If your spouse/common-law partner does not receive an OAS pension $765.93 $41,088 (combined income)
If your spouse/common-law partner receives the Allowance $507.87 $41,088 (combined income)
Source: Old Age Security payment amounts - Service Canada
Kids are future taxpayers, thus it makes a certain amount of sense to help them reach the point where they can pay taxes...
