Michael Mann: It's game over for the Keystone pipeline

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,817
471
83
Walt, how could you miss that lay up for the entitlement dunk?

You're slipping son.
 

Colpy

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 5, 2005
21,887
848
113
70
Saint John, N.B.
No, technically Mann is the one who sued. It's a defamation lawsuit. He's the Plaintiff. Mark Steyn submitted counterclaims after firing his lawyers. Then Mann made a motion to dismiss the counterclaims. The Court dismissed the Steyn counterclaims, and awarded Mann legal fees. Now Steyn has lawyered up again and has appealed the dismissal, perhaps realizing he's in over his head now. The first Amendment says nothing about the right to defame somebody, which is what can happen when someone asserts that someone else is a fraud.


Mann is a liar, a con artist, and a fellow scientist and lead author on the IPCC has testified before Congress that Mann's "research" is fraudulent.

Obviously, Steyn did NOT defame anyone.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
LA County and Orange County pump oil out from under residential neighbourhoods but oil sands is bad according to CA politicians.,

That's right! I was shocked to see that when I visited L.A. Oil Wells pumping away just like in Texas and right in neighborhoods.

The boom in the Dakotas must really be bothering alarmists these days.
 

Zipperfish

House Member
Apr 12, 2013
3,688
0
36
Vancouver
Breaking news from the upcoming Mann vs Steyn Salem-witch-trial of the century. Actually, it broke a couple of days ago but I dozed off reading it. So I'll come back to that in a moment. But first: Last week, Judith Curry went back to John Christy's testimony to the US House of Representatives Science, Space and Technology Committee in 2011. Here's the passage she quoted:
Regarding the Hockey Stick of IPCC 2001 evidence now indicates, in my view, that an IPCC Lead Author working with a small cohort of scientists, misrepresented the temperature record of the past 1000 years by (a) promoting his own result as the best estimate, (b) neglecting studies that contradicted his, and (c) amputating another's result so as to eliminate conflicting data and limit any serious attempt to expose the real uncertainties of these data.

The IPCC Lead Author he's talking about is the litigant in my case, Michael E Mann. That's to say, Christy is telling the United States Congress that Dr Mann "misrepresented the temperature record of the past 1000 years", by promoting his own result (a clear conflict of interest - it would be as if our DC judge were deciding his own divorce case), and not only ignoring contradictory evidence but deep-sixing it when necessary.
Who is this fellow Christy? Well, he's a professor at the University of Alabama and the guy who devised the satellite temperature record. But more to the point he's also an IPCC Lead Author. And, in fact, an IPCC Lead Author on the very same chapter of the report that Mann was an IPCC Lead Author on.
....................................................
But here's my point. I'm being sued because I referred to Mann's graph as "fraudulent". I stand by that characterization - although, were I writing my Corner post today, I would go further, having been on the receiving end of Mann's modus operandi for two years. A prudent man would not accept anything Dr Mann says about anything without independent verification, whether it be his fraudulent claim to be a Nobel Laureate or his multiple fraudulent claims to have been "exonerated" by the University of East Anglia, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the British House of Commons, etc, etc. But let us leave that aside, and stick only to the hockey stuff: Dr Mann's own colleague on the process that made the hockey stick the great iconic image of turn-of-the-century climate alarmism has testified to Congress that Mann's work is a "misrepresentation". Which is a polite word for fraud. Professor Christy again:
So, to summarize, an L.A. was given final say over a section which included as its (and the IPCC's) featured product, his very own chart, and which allowed him to leave out not only entire studies that presented contrary evidence, but even to use another strategically edited data set that had originally displayed contrary evidence.

That last is a reference to Keith Briffa's tree-ring set, which supports Mann's hockey stick except when it doesn't and therefore had to be "truncated".
"Misrepresented..." "Strategically edited..." "Amputating another's result..." Does this happen often? With the exception of the coordinator, there were only two American Lead Authors on that IPCC chapter, and the one has testified under oath that the other corrupted the process.


Life in the Expedited Lane :: SteynOnline

my emphasis

My problem is Steyn and Levant is their use of the term "alarmist." Those two practically define the word. Tune into either of them on any given subjet du jour and they will be tolling the end of civilization as we know it. Lots of heat, not much light.
 

BaalsTears

Senate Member
Jan 25, 2011
5,732
0
36
Santa Cruz, California
LA County and Orange County pump oil out from under residential neighbourhoods but oil sands is bad according to CA politicians.,

Those fields have existed for more than a century. They couldn't be developed today because of California's extreme environmentalism.

They're advertising their beaches and parks all the time. And last I looked CA was not a country.

Do you think California is still part of the United States? It doesn't even feel like America out here.
 

pgs

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 29, 2008
28,499
8,098
113
B.C.
On this one I hope he's right I am against XL not for environmental reason
for economic ones Canadian oil should be refined here and sold by our
country at inflated prices and a lower price for Canadians cause its our crude.
Not of lower than the cost of production but lower than the foreign price.
Why give it away cheap to America to buy it back refined or worse have it
shipped to foreign markets giving up jobs and profits.
Nothing but a few billion and passing environmental standards stopping you from building one grump .
But like every one else who wants to build refineries in Canada you expect others to build it .
Why not put your money where your mouth is ?
 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,817
471
83
Those fields have existed for more than a century. They couldn't be developed today because of California's extreme environmentalism.



Do you think California is still part of the United States? It doesn't even feel like America out here.

What is America supposed to feel like?
 

Tonington

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 27, 2006
15,441
150
63
Mann is a liar, a con artist, and a fellow scientist and lead author on the IPCC has testified before Congress that Mann's "research" is fraudulent.

Ever looked into the multiple revisions needed to fix Christy's UAH code? I'd bet not. You could have said the same thing about Christy's work. It was a misrepresentation of reality. It's still undergoing fixes to convert the satellite sampling of microwaves emitted from oxygen atoms into an analog of surface temperature. Christy disagrees with Mann on a lot, despite his claims of fraud, no governing body of science or society has yet to find Mann guilty of fraud.

So Steyn is going to have a hard time, I guess he figured that out when he decided it wasn't a good idea to represent himself when the court dismissed his counterclaims. Obviously Steyn called Mann a fraud, and obviously fraud does not rest on the word of a scientist like Christy with a conflicting theory.

That's kind of what the justice system is for.
 

BaalsTears

Senate Member
Jan 25, 2011
5,732
0
36
Santa Cruz, California
What is America supposed to feel like?

America is supposed to have a huge middle class. California doesn't. One third of all US welfare cases are in California. Twenty four percent of the residents here are officially classified as dirt poor. Less than half of the people here are officially middle class. California has a third world class system. California has almost the worst public school system in the country.

But California is great if you have lots of money. Does that answer your question?

michael mann sex tape is up on motherless.

just sayin'.

Wasn't Michael Mann a protege of Jerry Sandusky at Pennsylvania State University?
 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,817
471
83
Michael Mann says it's cheaper to combat climate change than pay for global warming

American climatologist Michael Mann has been at the heart of the war of words over climate change for the last 15 years.

The author of the book The Hockey Stick and the Climate Wars, in which he examines who is behind the campaigns to discredit scientists who believe in global warming, argues it is cheaper to wean ourselves from fossil fuels than to pay for the damage caused by global warming.

Known for his scientific analysis of temperature records over the last 1,000 years, his "hockey stick" graph depicting the impact of climate change and global warming became a defining symbol of man's influence on the environment.

In an interview on CBC-TV’s The Lang & O’Leary Exchange, Mann said the evidence for climate change is mounting, despite fluctuations caused by El Nino and volcanic events.

“Evidence for human influence on climate change just becomes stronger with each additional year of data that ... comes in,” he said.

“Indeed we’re seeing unprecedented warmth, we’re seeing unprecedented melt of sea ice up in the Arctic.”

Mann, who works at the Earth Systems Science Centre at Penn State University, issues a call to citizens to wake up and demand action from leaders before it’s too late.

“Will we commit to a level of dangerous interference with the climate that commits us to rapid melting of the ice sheets, to abrupt changes in drought patterns,” he said.

“The fear is that we may approach one of these climate tipping points before we approach the other tipping point – the tipping point in the public consciousness – the recognition that through the emissions we are making now, we are locking in global warming and climate change for decades to come.”

He argues that not acting to slow global warming is already costing the economy – through damage from extreme weather events, drought, wildfire and flooding.

It would be cheaper to take action, he argues, but the public debate is being poisoned by climate deniers funded by powerful private interests.

Mann is a perennial target of climate change deniers, the subject of physical threats, mocking YouTube videos, Republican politicians and chat shows accusing him of shoddy science.

His emails with researchers at the Climatic Research Unit in East Anglia were part of an international controversy when they were leaked by hackers in 2009.

Mann laments the “huge gulf” between acceptance of climate change in the scientific community and the doubt in the political sphere.

“Here in the U.S. we have a House of Representatives with a science committee led by a Republican politicians that don’t even accept that climate change is real,” he said.

Michael Mann says it's cheaper to combat climate change than pay for global warming
 

Colpy

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 5, 2005
21,887
848
113
70
Saint John, N.B.
“Here in the U.S. we have a House of Representatives with a science committee led by a Republican politicians that don’t even accept that climate change is real,” he said.

Michael Mann says it's cheaper to combat climate change than pay for global warming


Based on Michael Mann's "research", chances are it isn't real.

Meanwhile, in Newfoundland:

Mark Engstrom, the museum’s deputy director for collections and research, said the arduous process of transporting and preserving the bones is a worthwhile effort in light of a devastating blow dealt to one of Canada’s most endangered marine species this past winter.
The two blue whales Engstrom’s team is recovering were among nine killed by unusually thick sea ice, Engstrom said, adding that number represented about five per cent of the population in the North Atlantic.
The chance to preserve some record of a highly endangered species, he said, marks one of the more bittersweet moments in his 30-year career.

The multi-year Newfoundland whale relocation gets underway | Metro