Neil Young blasts Harper government for allowing development of Alberta oilsands

Zipperfish

House Member
Apr 12, 2013
3,688
0
36
Vancouver
Just like years ago when all the tree huggers on the west coast forgot what they used to wipe their A$$.

Yes, it does remind me of those times. I'd just moved to BC back then. There were a lot of the same kind of arguments--celebrities adn roaylty coming up to fly over the "moonscape" of Vacnouver Island. Cries of hypocricy from the industry because everyone uses wood and because the celebrities weren't thinking about the workers that had to feed their families when they danced into town.

But ultimately, the forest industry in BC had to respond and change.

I see a similar situation now. The fact is that the industry is running into a lot of resistance--not just from celebrities, but in terms of real money--trying to move their products or their projects.

And for all the criticism of Neil Young, it's not much different then the petroleum industry commercials full of green fields and bubbling voiceovers.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,209
14,249
113
Low Earth Orbit
zipper said:
And for all the criticism of Neil Young, it's not much different then the petroleum industry commercials full of green fields and bubbling voiceovers
.The ads with the greenpeace people raving about how successful the reclamation is?
 

coldstream

on dbl secret probation
Oct 19, 2005
5,160
27
48
Chillliwack, BC
I reached the same conclusion. He does have a penchant for writing (which he comes by honestly; his dad was a sportswriter for the Winnipeg Free Press), but it is definitely the work of an undisciplined mind. I did enjoy the parts about his close relationship with his severely disabled son, Ben.

However, I don't think you have to have any political or technical expertise to care about the environment.

I have no problem with anyone expressing an opinion on any topic... my problem with this was that the mere fact he was Neil Young was deemed by the media to give him credence for some special expertise on the topic, which he decidedly does not have.

My sense of matter in general that entertainers are the least reliable of all commentators on social issues. They usually parrot the most conventional and superficial and least original of views.. with an eye to conforming to a specific market franchise, and of the lowest common denominator.

My point is the being a successful artist provides no special insight, and certainly not the moral high ground on complex issues related to economic development and environmental responsibiliy. Their appeal is invariably aimed at the emotional gut rather than a critical evaluation of tradeoffs of these issues.
 
Last edited:

Zipperfish

House Member
Apr 12, 2013
3,688
0
36
Vancouver
I have no problem with anyone expressing an opinion on any topic... my problem with this was that the mere fact he was Neil Young was deemed by the media to give him credence for some special expertise on the topic, which he decidedly does not have.

My sense of matter in general that entertainers are the least reliable of all commentators on social issues. They usually parrot the most conventional and superficial and least original of views.. with an eye to conforming to a specific market franchise, and of the lowest common denominator.

My point is the being a successful artist provides no special insight, and certainly not the moral high ground on complex issues related to economic development and environmental responsibiliy. Their appeal is invariably aimed at the emotional gut rather than a critical evaluation of tradeoffs of these issues.

True enough. God doesn't necessarily hand out wisdom with talent. But in our society celebrity seems to fill the void that royalty used to, and the unwashed masses ascribe great importance to the their pronouncements. That said, I find the green fields commercials put forth by the petroleum industry to be equally as vacuous.

The question is who has the authority to speak on the oil sands. And the answer is everyone, even though most people have no clue at all about them. That's the nature of democarcy--what did Winston Churchill say--the best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter.

There is no appeal to authority anymore, no trsuted voice left. Downside of living in such a zealously egalitarian society--everybody's opinion is equal.
 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,817
471
83
Alberta to look like the moon confirmed.

Neil Young: Alberta will 'look like the moon' unless oilsands development stopped

Rock legend Neil Young continued his campaign against the Alberta oilsands Thursday, saying he hopes to use his celebrity to bring more attention to the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation community and their fight against the oil industry.

“We can preserve what we have so we can say, ‘We did the right thing.’ If we don’t it’s just going to look like the moon in Alberta,” Young said.

“It is like a war zone, a disaster area from war, what’s happened up there. It’s gone,” he added.

During the conference, which was moderated by David Suzuki, Young also criticized the proposed Keystone XL pipeline, telling reporters that he does not ”feel really good” about the project and the idea that oil produced from Canadian oilsands would be sent to China -- a country he called one of the biggest polluters in the world.

Young’s “Honour the Treaties” tour, which kicked off in Toronto on Sunday, looks to benefit the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation and their legal fight against the development of an oilsands mine near their community.

Last month, the Canadian government approved an expansion project with Shell that aimed to double oilsands production to nearly 300,000 barrels a day.

Activists and members of the First Nation community say the planned expansions will cause widespread damage to local land, water and wildlife near the Jackpine mine site and violate treaty and environmental laws.

On their website, the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nations group says it has launched “multiple legal motions” against both the Canadian government and the oil industry in order to protect Alberta’s Athabasca region.

On Sunday, Young accused the government of “trading integrity for money” when it came to Alberta’s oil sands and said the rapid expansion of mines was “killing” First Nations people.

“The blood of these people will be on modern Canada’s hands,” Young said.

“We will thank the First Nation for stopping this, if they’re able to stop it, because in 20 years from now or 30 years from now, we’ll be able to look at all of the areas we saved and they’ll still be here,” Young said Thursday.

Neil Young: Alberta will 'look like the moon' unless oilsands development stopped | CTV News
 

DaSleeper

Trolling Hypocrites
May 27, 2007
33,676
1,666
113
Northern Ontario,

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Alberta to look like the moon confirmed.

Neil Young: Alberta will 'look like the moon' unless oilsands development stopped

Rock legend Neil Young continued his campaign against the Alberta oilsands Thursday, saying he hopes to use his celebrity to bring more attention to the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation community and their fight against the oil industry.

“We can preserve what we have so we can say, ‘We did the right thing.’ If we don’t it’s just going to look like the moon in Alberta,” Young said.

“It is like a war zone, a disaster area from war, what’s happened up there. It’s gone,” he added.

During the conference, which was moderated by David Suzuki, Young also criticized the proposed Keystone XL pipeline, telling reporters that he does not ”feel really good” about the project and the idea that oil produced from Canadian oilsands would be sent to China -- a country he called one of the biggest polluters in the world.

Young’s “Honour the Treaties” tour, which kicked off in Toronto on Sunday, looks to benefit the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation and their legal fight against the development of an oilsands mine near their community.

Last month, the Canadian government approved an expansion project with Shell that aimed to double oilsands production to nearly 300,000 barrels a day.

Activists and members of the First Nation community say the planned expansions will cause widespread damage to local land, water and wildlife near the Jackpine mine site and violate treaty and environmental laws.

On their website, the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nations group says it has launched “multiple legal motions” against both the Canadian government and the oil industry in order to protect Alberta’s Athabasca region.

On Sunday, Young accused the government of “trading integrity for money” when it came to Alberta’s oil sands and said the rapid expansion of mines was “killing” First Nations people.

“The blood of these people will be on modern Canada’s hands,” Young said.

“We will thank the First Nation for stopping this, if they’re able to stop it, because in 20 years from now or 30 years from now, we’ll be able to look at all of the areas we saved and they’ll still be here,” Young said Thursday.

Neil Young: Alberta will 'look like the moon' unless oilsands development stopped | CTV News

He can afford to have his views- he can afford a number of things- meanwhile we are a country that has resources for export. And they provide jobs.
They put food on the table, pay taxes that cover a multitude of things we want.
Myself I wonder why a singer gets such news. Really a non story- from a non expert.
 

Spade

Ace Poster
Nov 18, 2008
12,822
49
48
11
Aether Island
He can afford to have his views- he can afford a number of things- meanwhile we are a country that has resources for export. And they provide jobs.
They put food on the table, pay taxes that cover a multitude of things we want.
Myself I wonder why a singer gets such news. Really a non story- from a non expert.

Because he well may be right.
Jobs before environmental stewardship, anywhere in the world including Alberta, is troubling.

The issues are not "either/or".

The problem is not oil sands/tar sands development' it is the scale and pace of development and the lack ot environmental stewardship by industry and government. The unbridled development for immediate monetary gain is shortsighted in terms of climate change, atmospheric integrity, water quality, the wilderness, native communities, and wildlife.

If there were but a fraction of Canada's race for the quick buck, we would still be driving cars, heating our homes, and buying strawberries in December. It is disingenuous in the extreme to criticise those calling for slowing the pace of development with greater envitonmental oversight as being anti wealth, economic health, or hypocritical.

As a child on the Prairies, I listened to developers call for underground nuclear explosions to release the oil from what was then simply called the Tar Sands. The analogy to Hiroshimas is not entirely an exaggeration. Because the development is tucked away in the the boreal forest kilometres from "civilisation" we seem content to cry "onward!"

Bump
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Because he well may be right.
To me he is not an expert- The resources will come out of the ground. Do we need better controls yes.

I will go with experts and asses the risk from there, as there will always be risk. But may be right Neil is in my opinion a non story. No different than an actor or sports figure.
You (Neil)can spout all you want when you do not want. And Neil is not wanting, is he?
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Because he is a celebrity does not make him wrong. Neither should this perspective be silenced nor dismissed.

True, I never stated he should be silenced. I do not have to give his opinion any weight. Old, rich and lacking in needs.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,209
14,249
113
Low Earth Orbit
Why are first nations directly across the border in SK prospering?

Reclamation laws are tight but people seem to think they don't exist.

These people don't live off the land other than being well paid by oil companies and now Neil.

Who wouldn't jump on the easy money band wagon?
 
Last edited:

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
If this is your argument, you've already lost.

Does the reality sting so badly that you have to use that comment as your perpetual backstop

Alberta to look like the moon confirmed.

Neil Young: Alberta will 'look like the moon' unless oilsands development stopped

So says the expert... Maybe in a few years when his dementia is even more severe, the hue and cry will be:



Because he is a celebrity does not make him wrong. Neither should this perspective be silenced nor dismissed.

Nor does it make him right
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,209
14,249
113
Low Earth Orbit
70% oil the oil will be insitu extraction. Mining is nearing it's end ON SCALE.

Reclamation improves the ecosystem. Fire management f-cked the boreal up. They are a mess with fuel that should have been burned decades ago. They are hard for wildlife to manuever in let alone prosper.

It's easy to criticize from thousands of kilometers away only seeing the mining and knowing nothing of the Athabasca region.

I'm greatful nobody has a clue about the world's largest nuclear industry just east of the oil sands.

All that lead and no concerns.
 

Simple Man

Electoral Member
Feb 20, 2013
132
0
16
North of ordinary
I have no problem with anyone expressing an opinion on any topic... my problem with this was that the mere fact he was Neil Young was deemed by the media to give him credence for some special expertise on the topic, which he decidedly does not have.

My sense of matter in general that entertainers are the least reliable of all commentators on social issues. They usually parrot the most conventional and superficial and least original of views.. with an eye to conforming to a specific market franchise, and of the lowest common denominator.

My point is the being a successful artist provides no special insight, and certainly not the moral high ground on complex issues related to economic development and environmental responsibiliy. Their appeal is invariably aimed at the emotional gut rather than a critical evaluation of tradeoffs of these issues.
He plainly stated in Winnipeg today that his role was to use his celebrity to highlight the issue, that he was not by any means an expert and that the other folks on stage were much more well versed on the subject.

Frankly I am surprised by the number of folks posting here along the lines of defending the industry considering what they take for what they give.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Young may be an expert in the entertainment industry! What are his credentials when it comes to oil apart from the fact he is a very active user. How do we know he doesn't have an ulterior motive in the matter? For myself I'd be willing to listen to his 30 second opinion and let it go at that.
 

Zipperfish

House Member
Apr 12, 2013
3,688
0
36
Vancouver
To me he is not an expert- The resources will come out of the ground. Do we need better controls yes.

I will go with experts and asses the risk from there, as there will always be risk. But may be right Neil is in my opinion a non story. No different than an actor or sports figure.
You (Neil)can spout all you want when you do not want. And Neil is not wanting, is he?

Who cares--even if he were an expert, it souldn't make any difference. It's esstnially a political issue, so whetehr ypu're left or right is what matters, not how much you actually know about the subject.