So Allah or an angel gave all this stuff to Mohammed 1400 years ago and he did not understand what he was given but he started a religion, destroyed all the existing religions and religious symbols that he could get his hands on in his lifetime and slaughtered anybody who would not join this religion that he didn't understand and Muslims have been waging holy war ever since on the infidel even though none of them know what the Quran means.... Holy Crap! That has got to be the most absurd nonsense I have ever heard.
Then some guy comes along and says he has been divinely inspired to translate the Quran into a language he doesn't even know and you come on here peddling this nonsense as if it were the word of god. You really aren't playing with a full deck.
The ayat of the Qruan are two categories:
The plain ayat: the meaning is obvious; Muslims worked according to these ayat.
The ambiguous ayat: having ambiguous meaning; Muslims left their meaning to God Who promised to inspire someone in the future to explain to them the meaning of such ambiguous ayat.
About such ayat, the hypocrites mocked and the disbelievers were tempted and misguided.
And here is the miracle which indicates the truthfulness of God's apostle; because if Mohammed had invented the Quran, then he would have told people that he knew every detail in his book. While he said about such ayat: "I don't know; I heard it as such from the angel Gabriel."
Refer to the ayat 38: 86-88 in my post #155
"There are many other ayat with the same implication, like this aya 75: 19 ثُمَّ إِنَّ عَلَيْنَا بَيَانَهُ
The explanation:
(Then [after a long time] We have to explain it [to people])
It means: the explanation of what revelations of the Quran were mysterious to them, and which they do not understand their meaning.
And the aya 6: 105
وَكَذَلِكَ نُصَرِّفُ الآيَاتِ وَلِيَقُولُواْ دَرَسْتَ وَلِنُبَيِّنَهُ لِقَوْمٍ يَعْلَمُونَ
The explanation:
(Thus do We explain the ayat by various [ways]: That they may say [to you, Mohammed,] “You have studied [the past heavenly scriptures, and invented the Quran accordingly]”, and that We may explain the [Quran in the future] to people who know [modern sciences.])
Then the late interpreter said:
"God has fulfilled what He had promised; for He never breaks His promise. So He inspired into me the interpretation of the Quran, and I explained the meaning of the ayat of the Quran that are ambiguous;
I explained them fully and clearly, so that by now there shouldn’t be any aya that one cannot understand its meaning, and …it should be clear to them that … the Quran … all of it is unchangeable. I called that book “The True Interpretation of the Revelation”
<http://www.quran-ayat.com/conflict/english3.htm#___A_The_Abrogation_>
Last edited: