Legalized Cat Killing

talloola

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 14, 2006
19,576
113
63
Vancouver Island
BTW, I'm glad you're an ornithologist talloola. Do you even know what kinds of burds your cat is eating? And for the most part in urban areas, the bird thing isn't as big a problem, since most of the birds are common pest species anyway. But I watched a friends cat come back with a rather rare woodpecker in it's mouth once, and I can guarantee you that one killing had a significant impact in the local bird population.

By using the logic that there are plenty of birds, so it's ok, especially since I feed them, I can go out and shoot cats (or allow my big dog to kill cats) because there are plenty of them, they aren't going extinct, and I have a cat that I feed at home. Nice. I'll tell the SPCA that when I get arrested for animal cruelty.

You mention the word 'kill' far too often, and seem to be finding excuses to
kill something, how about looking in the mirror, and think about that species,
they are the ones who kill far too often for no apparant reason.
 
Last edited:

Unforgiven

Force majeure
May 28, 2007
6,770
137
63
Can any cat lover tell me why it should be my job to keep other peoples pets out of my yard? And why I have so few recourses to do so?

Because it's your yard and you are charged with it's care. No one has the right to have their pet use anything you own. But it's up to you to catch the cat and turn it over to the pound. If that results in the cat being put down, "thems the breaks".
If that bothers the owner, pity they choose to allow their beloved pet to be killed.

There is a method to it but it works when used properly.

I have three cats who have no problem living indoors for over ten years now. All happy, all healthy. There is no reason that a person should allow a cat or dog loose in any city.

As for damages, webcams are pretty cheap and about all you need is to show that the pet has entered your property and caused damages along with the identity of the pet which is evident in a good clear picture or video of the pet on your property doing the deed. Show your damages and the cost to have them professionally repaired and you should win your case plus costs.

No need to shoot anything or anyone.
 

DaSleeper

Trolling Hypocrites
May 27, 2007
33,676
1,666
113
Northern Ontario,
Seriously though......when I purchased my house 22 years ago....there was a neighbor's cat that kept spraying the back door..(what a smell)....and I had a crow problem on garbage day.....
Since there was no house across the street at the time....one .22 BBcap solved both problems.....I didn't let the garbage men pick up the crow that morning.....left it on the lawn all day as a warning to the other crows...(they are smart birds)
I have rarely had crows in my garbage since.....And I guess the cat owner must have got the word because I never had to wash the back door for that reason again.....
 

wallybipster

New Member
May 5, 2009
20
1
3
You mention the word 'kill' far too often, and seem to be finding excuses to
kill something, how about looking in the mirror, and think about that species,
they are the ones who kill far too often for no apparant reason.



You have done nothing to make a logical argument, only accuse me of using the word kill too much. Bravo. It is clear that you value the freedom of your cat above the death of wildlife, yet the word kill bothers you. Do I kill cats? No. Do I like it when cats OR wildlife die needlessly? No. But for the sake of this argument death must be considered. If you can't wrap your head around that, then I am sorry you are so sensitive. You used the word kill to describe what your cat does to birds, and then justified it by saying that it fulfils a need for your cat. So, you are ok with needless death, as long as you are passively allowing it, and not actively doing the killing. That hypocrisy is very plain to me. When it comes down to it, you don't care about all the suffering your cat inflicts, only that it is happy and fulfilled, and given liberties that no other carnivorous pet would enjoy. Thank you for making your apathy toward the plight of wild animals clear.

I hope you only eat pre-packaged meat then so you don't have to think of all the killing that takes place to support you. I'd hate for you to ever feel guilt. That would be inhumane.
 

wallybipster

New Member
May 5, 2009
20
1
3
FYI, It's not that I want to kill cats, but I think feral cats should be removed when possible. TNR is horrible, because it denies the ecological impacts of an introduced predator, by allowing cats to continue the slaughter. If you think TNR is the only way to do it, then you are saying that a wild cats life is more valuable than the life of any wild animal. So killing (lethal removing, does that sound cuter to you?) is the only answer in that scenario, unless you really believe that wild cats are somehow on a higher plane than the animals they are exterminating. If you would rather live in a homogenized world where the only birds around are house sparrows, pigeons, and starlings, and don't care that your kids will never know the beauty of a meadowlark bravely singing on the prairie, then I guess that is sad, and just another example of how we destroy the world around us, even with good intentions. That is where this irrational cat love will take us at some point.

I'm glad your cat is happy. The next time you see it with a bird in mouth, imagine the babies in a nest somewhere starving to death because their mom will never return. It is absolutely disgusting to think that is merely a price to pay for allowing your cat to roam.
 

talloola

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 14, 2006
19,576
113
63
Vancouver Island
that, then I am sorry you are so sensitive. You used the word kill to describe what your cat does to birds, and then justified it by saying that it fulfils a need for your cat. So, you are ok with needless death, as long as you are passively allowing it, and not actively doing the killing. That hypocrisy is very plain to me. When it comes down to it, you don't care about all the suffering your cat inflicts, only that it is happy and fulfilled, and given liberties that no other carnivorous pet wouldnt enjoy. Thank you for making your apathy toward the plight of wild animals clear.

You are deciding what I think, but you don't have a 'clue'. It is very very easy
to get on your soapbox and call me 'whatever' you want, and I suppose that
satisfies 'whatever' you want to satisfy about 'yourself.' Most people don't feed
the birds all winter, and in your eyes I suppose that would be cruel, because they are knowingly allowing all those birds to die from starvation, but do nothing about it, and one could go on and on in that direction to no end, but it does
nothing but make oneself look so 'holier than thou'.
I am not sensitive at
all, I just accept the way of wildlife, and the habits of animals, as they have
been for thousands of years. I did not say that I am happy with my cat killing
birds, because it fulfills a need for the cat,' don't make up things', and then say
that I said them. I saved the lives of hundreds of birds through the cold winter, and I am happy for that, my cat kills a few birds during the summer season,
which hasn't started yet, and the birds aren't adults, they are mostly half
grown birds, which I imagine have just started to fly, and I also accept that.
I only have one cat, spayed, clean and home most of the time, birds are killed
from many different predators, but because a cat isn't a wild animal, then for
you it isn't allowed. Peoples children take eggs out of nests often, then throw
them around, or step on them to see what's inside, where are the parents.

I do agree with the concept that ferral cats are a big problem, and I do agree
that something must be done about it.
It isn't a cat problem, it's a people problem, and with some effort, laws could
be enforced to make spaying and neutering mandatory, and yes, ferral cats
should be picked up and euthanized, as they are usually not fit to be a pet any
longer, as they become mostly wild. People are cruel and irresponsible, and
the loosey goosey way that many people behave concerning, having cats, and
dogs is unnacceptable. It's not someone like me with one cat, it's the number
of groups of ferral cats, or people with many cats, and also people who have
not spayed or neutered their animals. They are the culprits.

That goofy concept that having pets is cruel, is a 'joke,' people and their pets
are an important part of society, animals bring joy to so many, especially the
elderly. We have trained dogs for years, and bred them for hunting etc., and
we have had a lifetime of happiness with our animals. We have responsibly
cared for them, made sure they had good homes to go to, and sold 'every'
puppy with a written promise to spay or neuter, then followed up on that
promise.

You are consumed with hate and criticizm, it seems to be eating away at you.
Go out and have some fun, take a walk, have a massage, 'pet a cat'.
Have a good day.
 

wallybipster

New Member
May 5, 2009
20
1
3
Thank you for judging me and telling me what I think

Being passionate about something does not make you full of hate. I'm sorry you feel that way, just because I am passionate about something that you are not. Just because I think you are being hypocritical doesn't mean I think you are living a sad life, so I wonder why you seem to think I am.

Just because you do good things for animals sometimes, like feeding birds, does not make it a good thing that you let your cat maim and kill wildlife, or justify it in any way.

Thank you for suggesting that I take a hike. I am actually planning a birding excursion today. Beats writing more nonsense to people who will always consider the supposed needs of their pet over the struggle of wildlife to survive.
 

wallybipster

New Member
May 5, 2009
20
1
3
Actually, I suppose the best way to get all that hate and criticism out of my system would be a rifle, and some kitty plunking. That must be the only way for me to carry on with my sad, hateful life.

I
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
I live in a city with cat by-laws. I think they're brilliant. We rarely see cats roaming, and I can go dig in my dirt without coming across cat gifts. The reasoning is sound... cats are destructive, they kill off wildlife, they wreck property (as even neutered cats sometimes spray other people's places, lawn furniture, etc).

Although, I will admit that my cat does roam from time to time. It's been next to impossible to break him of his mousing habits that he developed before we rescued him. But, I feel no need to apologize for his meager kills when compared to mousetraps, poison, cars, etc. I live in a city, I have no delusions about there being a natural environment here for wildlife.

In my opinion a balanced view is a wonderful thing, and while I'm not going to stress over the cat I have right now getting out hunting the odd night, I'm also not likely to replace him once he passes away.
 

talloola

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 14, 2006
19,576
113
63
Vancouver Island
Once my cat passes away, I will immediately go to the spca and buy another one, or
possibly two, it is more enjoyable having two cats. I will save a life or two, and nurture our lives.
They will be spayed/neutered at a very young age, never have kittens,( and you
know somelthing,) there are people out there who think that is cruel, doesn't
matter which way you turn, someone will disagree with something you agree with,
that's life, just find your balance. When I had my registered kennel, (and I only
sold puppies with signed 'non breeding contracts,) there was one man who went
up one side me and down the other, preaching that I had no right to take away
the breeding ability of a purebred dog, as he/she should be allowed to reproduce
it's own. Well it took a while, but he finally left my house, without a puppy.

When the winters are harsh, I will save the birds, they seem to appreciate that,
and my cat is entertained watching them out on the patio, sometimes 40 of
them at a time, filling their tummys, so they will get through the cold night
stuck in some tree somewhere, freezing temperatures. Most of our winters
here on the island aren't harsh, but this last one was, and the birds aren't
prepared for that much snow, and cold.

Life isn't perfect, and we could drive ourselves crazy trying to make it that way,
just find your balance, as best as you can, and live your own life, and answer
to yourself, not others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron in Regina

Ron in Regina

"Voice of the West" Party
Apr 9, 2008
28,988
10,958
113
Regina, Saskatchewan

______________________________________
_____________________________:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:
 

shadowshiv

Dark Overlord
May 29, 2007
17,545
120
63
52

______________________________________
_____________________________:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

You'd think that whoever was operating the camera would warn them away!8O I guess they thought it would be funnier letting them catch hold of them.;-):lol: