Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about Liberals

bluealberta

Council Member
Apr 19, 2005
2,004
0
36
Proud to be in Alberta
Re: RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about

Cosmo said:
Travis said:
Seem to have hit another nerve
What's wrong free speech bothering everbody!

Free speech doesn't bother me in the least, Travis. You have a right to your opinion and are free to express it. I'm free to "blah" it if I think it's deserving. :)

You will find, Travis, that freedom of expression only applies to the left thinkers on this forum, everyone who disagrees with them is a bigot, dinosaur, neanderthal, prejudiced, out of touch, neo-con, bush lover, homophobe, white supremacist, religious whacko, US lover, anti-Canadian, ............I don't think I missed any, but you all have called us right wingers so many stupid names it is hard to keep track of them all. And they are all incorrect, you just don't know it because we don't fit your little intolerant circle, even though you all claim to be inclusive and tolerant, when in fact you exclusive of anyone with another opinion, and intolerant of anyone with another viewpoint. For shame.
 

Jay

Executive Branch Member
Jan 7, 2005
8,366
3
38
Re: RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about

Jay said:
Even the Quebec justice system is catching on....


Thanks Toro...

Toro said:
A patient died on a gurney in a Montreal hospital a year or so ago while suffering from cardiac arrest. In the subsequent investigation, it was determined that the man had been waiting in the hallway for 37 minutes, 7 minutes over the prescribed time limit.

Oh, look. See! Socialism causes death! Medicare, because it cannot allocate resources efficiently, caused that man to die. Thousands others like him because of insufficient resources in the system have also died. That's the policies of socialism. Death and destruction are left in its wake. The faceless bureaucrats who are only interested in one thing - keeping their jobs - did not fund that hospital properly. Because they can't. Tell that to the man's family! Tell him how wonderful socialism is! Tell all the other thousands who have died at the hands of Medicare how wonderful it is! Death! Chaos! The policies of the NDP. All the socialists want to do is expand the power of the state because they hate freedom! And they don't care how many people die, because they hate freedom! They may say they don't, but they really do! They hate you! They hate liberty! The only thing they care about is expanding the power of the state and wiping out freedom so the white wine socialists can keep their high-paying, 35-hour work week jobs.
 

bluealberta

Council Member
Apr 19, 2005
2,004
0
36
Proud to be in Alberta
Re: RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about

Jay said:
I hear what you’re saying, and I'm not going to argue with you over the technicalities anymore, but from my perspective things like "no two-tier health care" is an extremist point of view (and it is current policy)...and is not centralist. In fact I believe it is stupid and stifling and surely smacks of communism....

However, to be fair, we would have to get rid of about three tiers to get DOWN to a two tier system. This single tier system is the biggest myth ever produced in Canada. Look for it under the fiction category in your local library, it is not a truth at all.
 

Numure

Council Member
Apr 30, 2004
1,063
0
36
Montréal, Québec
Re: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about Libe

Jay said:
Communism

N

1: a form of socialism that abolishes private ownership.

2: a political theory favoring collectivism in a classless society.

Nice and simple...you call it equal access...I call it communism...means the same in this discussion.


Any system that tells GPs they can't open up private clinics and all the clinics are government owned, and the increasingly normal fashion is walk-in clinics, is communism....

Don't try to pretend that our system in healthcare isn't leftist extremism; your not fooling me anyways.

Doctors are allowed to run privatly owned clinics in Québec, btw.
 

bluealberta

Council Member
Apr 19, 2005
2,004
0
36
Proud to be in Alberta
Re: RE: Why you hate the Cons

Numure said:
Alberta's GDP: $172.0 Billion
Québec's GDP: $267.0 Billion (21% Of national)
Ontario's GDP: $470.40 Billion
British Columbia's GDP : $156,48 Billion

That's nice, now compare populations, or as Jean says, poopulations. Why are you even arguing anything? Albertans put more per capita into Canada than any other province. That is a fact, no argument necessary. Of course Ontarios GDP is higher, they have a larger population. Geez, get over it already.
 

I think not

Hall of Fame Member
Apr 12, 2005
10,506
33
48
The Evil Empire
Re: RE: Why you hate the Cons

manda said:
Toro said:
I look forward to the day Old Glory is flying over the legislature in Edmonton!

The old glory hangs in Canada, is the day the last true Canadian dies. Sorry, Toro, nothing personal, but I am a very proud Canadian, and I DESPISE Bush

Everyone despises Bush, what on earth are you sorry about?
 

manda

Council Member
Jul 3, 2005
2,007
0
36
swirling in the abyss of nowhere la
RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about Libe

Sorry that I attacked her personal quote. i don't understand how Bush got elected to a second term...I'd love to know how that vote rigging worked, I could become Prime Minister really easily if I got a hold of that system...Look out world!!!!
 

I think not

Hall of Fame Member
Apr 12, 2005
10,506
33
48
The Evil Empire
Re: RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about

manda said:
Sorry that I attacked her personal quote. i don't understand how Bush got elected to a second term...I'd love to know how that vote rigging worked, I could become Prime Minister really easily if I got a hold of that system...Look out world!!!!

For the same reason Blair and Howard got elected.
 

LeftCoast

Electoral Member
Jun 16, 2005
111
0
16
Vancouver
RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about Libe

Any system that tells GPs they can't open up private clinics and all the clinics are government owned, and the increasingly normal fashion is walk-in clinics, is communism....

God! You don't even know how the Canadian healthcare system works.

Virtually all clinical practices in Canada are private practices, owned and operated by the physicians themselves - not by the government.

Under the Canada Health Act doctors must accept Medical Services Plan (in BC - not sure what it is called in Alberta) insurance and are prevented from direct billing patients.

Doctors, through their professional association (BCMA in BC) provide their own malpractice insurance, hire nurses, administrative staff, janitors, etc. They own or lease their own facilities, purchase their exam room equipment (and write it off as a business expense) etc. They send specimines out to private labs and refer patients to specialists who are also in private practice. With the exception of community health (at least in BC) most physicians are in private practice. They must pay the hospitals for admitting rights.

Walk-in clinics are generally community health or primary care (I can't speak for Alberta). Since primary/community healthcare is for the most part preventative in outlook, it is very difficult to provide such a service through a private system.

The only thing not private about it is that there is a single health insurance plan and most (but not all) hospitals - that is acute care facilities (at least in BC) are run by the provinces 6 Health Authorities. All medical procedures that require an overnight stay (i believe) are performed in public hospitals.

It's called a single payer system - not a single provider system.

So far you have demonstrated that you don't really understand the basic differences between communism, socialism and capitalism and can't seem to grasp that most countrys operate under some sort of hybrid form.

You make sweeping claims about the Canadian healthcare system, but hold to some misguided beleive that doctors in Canada are not permitted to be in private practice.

BTW - the same situation happens in the US. Physicians who are part of a Health Management Organization (HMO) are not permitted to direct bill their patients and patients who are part of the HMO must use HMO hospitals and physicians.
 

Jay

Executive Branch Member
Jan 7, 2005
8,366
3
38
Re: RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about

LeftCoast said:
Any system that tells GPs they can't open up private clinics and all the clinics are government owned, and the increasingly normal fashion is walk-in clinics, is communism....

God! You don't even know how the Canadian healthcare system works.

Virtually all clinical practices in Canada are private practices, owned and operated by the physicians themselves - not by the government.

Under the Canada Health Act doctors must accept Medical Services Plan (in BC - not sure what it is called in Alberta) insurance and are prevented from direct billing patients.

Doctors, through their professional association (BCMA in BC) provide their own malpractice insurance, hire nurses, administrative staff, janitors, etc. They own or lease their own facilities, purchase their exam room equipment (and write it off as a business expense) etc. They send specimines out to private labs and refer patients to specialists who are also in private practice. With the exception of community health (at least in BC) most physicians are in private practice. They must pay the hospitals for admitting rights.

Walk-in clinics are generally community health or primary care (I can't speak for Alberta). Since primary/community healthcare is for the most part preventative in outlook, it is very difficult to provide such a service through a private system.

The only thing not private about it is that there is a single health insurance plan and most (but not all) hospitals - that is acute care facilities (at least in BC) are run by the provinces 6 Health Authorities. All medical procedures that require an overnight stay (i believe) are performed in public hospitals.

It's called a single payer system - not a single provider system.

So far you have demonstrated that you don't really understand the basic differences between communism, socialism and capitalism and can't seem to grasp that most countrys operate under some sort of hybrid form.

You make sweeping claims about the Canadian healthcare system, but hold to some misguided beleive that doctors in Canada are not permitted to be in private practice.

BTW - the same situation happens in the US. Physicians who are part of a Health Management Organization (HMO) are not permitted to direct bill their patients and patients who are part of the HMO must use HMO hospitals and physicians.


I suppose I could have saved you all that if I was a little less general. They can't be paid for by the customer...they can't open up a private practice and charge the customer money...sorry.

But I did forget to mention that the Feds have nothing to do with health care...the provinces signed away constitutional rights...we have government run (paid for) health care under a centralist federal government....
 

Said1

Hubba Hubba
Apr 18, 2005
5,338
70
48
52
Das Kapital
Re: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about Libe

Numure said:
Jay said:
Communism

N

1: a form of socialism that abolishes private ownership.

2: a political theory favoring collectivism in a classless society.

Nice and simple...you call it equal access...I call it communism...means the same in this discussion.


Any system that tells GPs they can't open up private clinics and all the clinics are government owned, and the increasingly normal fashion is walk-in clinics, is communism....

Don't try to pretend that our system in healthcare isn't leftist extremism; your not fooling me anyways.

Doctors are allowed to run privatly owned clinics in Québec, btw.

Are these public-private (P3 Projects)? P3s are when a private company is given licencing to build a hospital, or other facility, manage maintenance and infrastructure services. All health services are paid for and by our public system.
 

Numure

Council Member
Apr 30, 2004
1,063
0
36
Montréal, Québec
Re: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about Libe

Said1 said:
Numure said:
Jay said:
Communism

N

1: a form of socialism that abolishes private ownership.

2: a political theory favoring collectivism in a classless society.

Nice and simple...you call it equal access...I call it communism...means the same in this discussion.


Any system that tells GPs they can't open up private clinics and all the clinics are government owned, and the increasingly normal fashion is walk-in clinics, is communism....

Don't try to pretend that our system in healthcare isn't leftist extremism; your not fooling me anyways.

Doctors are allowed to run privatly owned clinics in Québec, btw.

Are these public-private (P3 Projects)? P3s are when a private company is given licencing to build a hospital, or other facility, manage maintenance and infrastructure services. All health services are paid for and by our public system.

Only one is in Gatineau. I think its the only one in this country. But yes, all bills are paid by the Provincial Goverment, as it should be. If you want private healthcare, head to the south. They will make it their plaisure to accept your money.
 

Vanni Fucci

Senate Member
Dec 26, 2004
5,239
17
38
8th Circle, 7th Bolgia
the-brights.net
Re: RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about

Jay said:
But I did forget to mention that the Feds have nothing to do with health care...the provinces signed away constitutional rights...we have government run (paid for) health care under a centralist federal government....

Alright...enough with the lies Jay...

Since the Canada Health Act was passed, provinces NEVER had that right...so stop whining about signing away rights that the provinces never had in the first place...
 

Jay

Executive Branch Member
Jan 7, 2005
8,366
3
38
RE: Why you hate the Conservatives and what is it about Libe

Health is a provincial matter.