What could possibly go wrong?

grainfedpraiboy

Electoral Member
Mar 15, 2009
715
1
18
Alberta The Last Best West
Back in the 90s the LIberal government looked at the numbers in the military and decided the Military were woefully short of women and not a very inclusive bunch. Sure there were lots of females in the support trades such as clerks, transport and medics. Hell, there were even Intelligence Operators, Engineers and Mechanics but in the combat arms of Infantry, Armoured and Artillery there were virtually none particularly in the non commissioned ranks (non officers) .

The government as some of you might recall, began an ambitious recruiting drive targeting women specifically for combat arms. They spent 24 million over three years and recruited a total of 23 females. I do not know the exact figure but I believe only three girls remained in the military when their terms of service expired after three years.

To find these girls the military spent more than a million per gal and in the end it didn't work out like the military and government WOGs thought it would. You see, it is hard enough to find and retain old fashioned tough guys to perform such awful work in such terrible conditions let alone women. I wonder if the RCMP lifestyle of moving from town to town or dealing with bad guys everyday doesn't appeal to women the way it might to men?
 

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
61,496
10,162
113
Washington DC
You never understood how strength and speed is/was a qualification for soldiers or Marines?
I spent twelve years in service, Eagle. Never, ever in that time did I see a situation where anybody's job, life, or safety depended on doing a pushup.

Back in the 90s the LIberal government looked at the numbers in the military and decided the Military were woefully short of women and not a very inclusive bunch. Sure there were lots of females in the support trades such as clerks, transport and medics. Hell, there were even Intelligence Operators, Engineers and Mechanics but in the combat arms of Infantry, Armoured and Artillery there were virtually none particularly in the non commissioned ranks (non officers) .

The government as some of you might recall, began an ambitious recruiting drive targeting women specifically for combat arms. They spent 24 million over three years and recruited a total of 23 females. I do not know the exact figure but I believe only three girls remained in the military when their terms of service expired after three years.

To find these girls the military spent more than a million per gal and in the end it didn't work out like the military and government WOGs thought it would. You see, it is hard enough to find and retain old fashioned tough guys to perform such awful work in such terrible conditions let alone women. I wonder if the RCMP lifestyle of moving from town to town or dealing with bad guys everyday doesn't appeal to women the way it might to men?
All valid points. But equally valid is attempting to deal with whatever causes an organisation to be a boys' club (or a club of any other sort). That increases the pool of quality candidates.
 

Twila

Nanah Potato
Mar 26, 2003
14,698
73
48
I spent twelve years in service, Eagle. Never, ever in that time did I see a situation where anybody's job, life, or safety depended on doing a pushup.

It's not the push up that's essential. It's the upper body strength it gives that's needed. To bad yoga and pilates weren't used...or maybe it is now.

Sort of like how you may not ever use algebra in real life, but you will use the skill needed for algebra in other facets of life.
 

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
61,496
10,162
113
Washington DC
It's not the push up that's essential. It's the upper body strength it gives that's needed. To bad yoga and pilates weren't used...or maybe it is now.

Sort of like how you may not ever use algebra in real life, but you will use the skill needed for algebra in other facets of life.
Contrary to what Eagle seems to think, I'm not saying physical performance standards are wrong, or irrelevant. I'm saying pushups are irrelevant.

For example, my local fire department's physical fitness test is humping a 150-lb. (69kg) hose up five floors five times. That is what I call realistic testing.
 

Twila

Nanah Potato
Mar 26, 2003
14,698
73
48
Contrary to what Eagle seems to think, I'm not saying physical performance standards are wrong, or irrelevant. I'm saying pushups are irrelevant.

For example, my local fire department's physical fitness test is humping a 150-lb. (69kg) hose up five floors five times. That is what I call realistic testing.

well I guess that depends. For fireman, I'd want them to be able to do a push up with me sitting on their back AND be able to lug a 150lb hose up a ladder with no shirt on. Those are important physical activities...to me at least.

I think it might also be important to be able to take pictures...for posterity...of course.
 

Cannuck

Time Out
Feb 2, 2006
30,245
99
48
Alberta
All valid points. But equally valid is attempting to deal with whatever causes an organisation to be a boys' club (or a club of any other sort). That increases the pool of quality candidates.


The LPGA requires one to have a vag in order to get in. My Gawd!! The inhumanity we inflict on each other.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
It's not the push up that's essential. It's the upper body strength it gives that's needed. To bad yoga and pilates weren't used...or maybe it is now.

Sort of like how you may not ever use algebra in real life, but you will use the skill needed for algebra in other facets of life.


Yep, motion helps build strength and stamina both of which could come in handy when you're dodging bullets in the trenches! :)

Contrary to what Eagle seems to think, I'm not saying physical performance standards are wrong, or irrelevant. I'm saying pushups are irrelevant.

For example, my local fire department's physical fitness test is humping a 150-lb. (69kg) hose up five floors five times. That is what I call realistic testing.


For the guy who's still "green" wouldn't push ups give him a head start for these other feats?
 

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
61,496
10,162
113
Washington DC
The LPGA requires one to have a vag in order to get in. My Gawd!! The inhumanity we inflict on each other.
You're so oppressed. I can't imagine how you find the strength to endure.

Yep, motion helps build strength and stamina both of which could come in handy when you're dodging bullets in the trenches! :)




For the guy who's still "green" wouldn't push ups give him a head start for these other feats?
Yup. So would weight lifting, core strength training, and aerobics. Doesn't change the fact that firefighters don't need to do pushups to fight fires. But they do need to hump hoses up stairs.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
You're so oppressed. I can't imagine how you find the strength to endure.


Yup. So would weight lifting, core strength training, and aerobics. Doesn't change the fact that firefighters don't need to do pushups to fight fires. But they do need to hump hoses up stairs.


Good, we're on the same "page" :)
 

Sal

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 29, 2007
17,135
33
48
You're so oppressed. I can't imagine how you find the strength to endure.


Yup. So would weight lifting, core strength training, and aerobics. Doesn't change the fact that firefighters don't need to do pushups to fight fires. But they do need to hump hoses up stairs.

with Twila around I don't think using hump and firefighters in the same sentence is a kind thing to do....just saying
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,342
113
Vancouver Island
Typical of our government to set quotas based on anything other than ability. When I worked for DND they were more interested in my non status native identification than mechanical abilities. Somehow that made me more qualified to fix firetrucks and fueltrucks than all the training and experience I have.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Typical of our government to set quotas based on anything other than ability. When I worked for DND they were more interested in my non status native identification than mechanical abilities. Somehow that made me more qualified to fix firetrucks and fueltrucks than all the training and experience I have.


That mentality was running rampant in B.C. in the 1990s under the N.D.P. Gov't. of the day. I was sent to a seminar in Qualicum Beach to be indoctrinated into the current thinking. White, healthy, intelligent people weren't qualified for any jobs. They didn't like me too much because I kind of "pissed on their parade". I think that nonsense was finally dropped a few years later. Those dippers sure had some f**king retards in their midst.