The death of personal responsibility

Kreskin

Doctor of Thinkology
Feb 23, 2006
21,155
149
63
I'm of two minds about this law. Who is to say the article bought at a garage sale is going to be used in the way it was originally intended? Let's say for instance it's a door but the buyer likes the wood and is going to sand it down and varnish it for use as a table.
Maybe an old baby's crib is sold and bought cheap for a source of dowells. I think the law is presumtuous to say the least. More work for bureaucrats I guess!
Or selling beer to minors. Who says they are going to drink it? Could be used to wash cars :).

F!ck health Canada and the nannystatism that infests it.
It's just legal liability. It has nothing to do with a Nannystate.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Of course there have been deaths connected with every type of activity and probably every type of article from a garden hose to a pair of roller skates and when it is a child involved it is particularly sad. But it is a fact of life and the main prevention is going to be from the individual him/herself. We are becoming too sanitized. All of us who are still around in the latter stages of our lives have survived all kinds of things without very much being banned. Remember getting our pant leg caught up in the chain on our bike and going for a spill and scraping our knees and elbows or the soapbox without brakes speeding down a hill out of control amongst traffic. Were these things banned? We used to chew on pencils painted with lead paint..................who gave it a second thought? How many died from it? Car seats are a modern invention. My dad had on old Dodge sedan in which the back seat was long gone..............my seat was a round block of wood about 16" in diameter and about 18" long sitting on the floorboards, not secured to anything. I'm still here. No one ever gave a thought to what a missile this could be in an accident. One of the shortcuts to a lot of places when we were kids were the railway tracks, no one died. Of course the one big difference between then and now is the media. I guess things are much better now for 1% of the population and a lot worse for 99%.

Or selling beer to minors. Who says they are going to drink it? Could be used to wash cars :).


.

That too is a distinct possibility ..........................drink more than they can handle then puke all over the car! :lol:
 

WLDB

Senate Member
Jun 24, 2011
6,182
0
36
Ottawa
I'm of two minds about this law. Who is to say the article bought at a garage sale is going to be used in the way it was originally intended? Let's say for instance it's a door but the buyer likes the wood and is going to sand it down and varnish it for use as a table.
Maybe an old baby's crib is sold and bought cheap for a source of dowells. I think the law is presumtuous to say the least. More work for bureaucrats I guess!


Thats pretty much my position. I guess it sort of has its place but not for everything. Given that there are no receipts and everything at garage sales are paid in cash I imagine it'd be difficult to prove you got something from a particular garage sale.
 

Goober

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 23, 2009
24,691
116
63
Moving
Thats pretty much my position. I guess it sort of has its place but not for everything. Given that there are no receipts and everything at garage sales are paid in cash I imagine it'd be difficult to prove you got something from a particular garage sale.

Lots of people make a decent dollar- tax free - checking garage sales for good bargains then they have their own and resell - and unknown to many - Farmers Markets - people have been nabbed selling organic vegetables that they bought wholesale from a dealer. Good markup on that.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
Of course there have been deaths connected with every type of activity and probably every type of article from a garden hose to a pair of roller skates and when it is a child involved it is particularly sad. But it is a fact of life and the main prevention is going to be from the individual him/herself. We are becoming too sanitized. All of us who are still around in the latter stages of our lives have survived all kinds of things without very much being banned. Remember getting our pant leg caught up in the chain on our bike and going for a spill and scraping our knees and elbows or the soapbox without brakes speeding down a hill out of control amongst traffic. Were these things banned? We used to chew on pencils painted with lead paint..................who gave it a second thought? How many died from it? Car seats are a modern invention. My dad had on old Dodge sedan in which the back seat was long gone..............my seat was a round block of wood about 16" in diameter and about 18" long sitting on the floorboards, not secured to anything. I'm still here. No one ever gave a thought to what a missile this could be in an accident. One of the shortcuts to a lot of places when we were kids were the railway tracks, no one died. Of course the one big difference between then and now is the media. I guess things are much better now for 1% of the population and a lot
worse for 99%

I gather you didn't get into an accident when your old man was driving and you were sitting on that block of wood. How about you take the rear seat out of your car, throw your grandkid in on a block of wood, and then rear end someone doing 30kmph and we'll see what happens to the kid. Should be fine though, right? You survived. :roll:
 
Last edited:

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
I gather you didn't get into an accident when your old man was driving and you were sitting on that block of wood. How about you take the rear seat out of your car, throw your grandkid in on a block of wood, and then rear end someone doing 30kmph and we'll see what happens to the kid. Should be fine though, right? You survived. :roll:

Any person with a room temperature I.Q. could tell from what I wrote that I recognize the potential hazards. Of course with traffic conditions and higher speeds today, I wouldn't consider it. We weren't like your mainstream family of today, we lived in the sticks and had no money. :lol:
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
Any person with a room temperature I.Q. could tell from what I wrote that I recognize the potential hazards. Of course with traffic conditions and higher speeds today, I wouldn't consider it. We weren't like your mainstream family of today, we lived in the sticks and had no money. :lol:


What higher speeds? I suggested a mere 30 kmph. The point is, just because we didn't have the safety measures in years gone by, doesn't mean that the safety measures we have now are a waste. The fact is they save lives. Car seats save lives, seatbelts save lives, helmets save lives. These are indisputable facts. Just because we didn't use them in the past and didn't get hurt doesn't mean someone else didn't. Some one that may be alive today if they had had the safety equipment then that we have now. Your continued "when I was growing up" straw man argument is just so much bullshyte.

This legislation is obviously needed as there are far too many idiots out there that come up with the "when I was growing up" argument and will sell unsafe equipment because "when they were growing up".
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
What higher speeds? I suggested a mere 30 kmph. The point is, just because we didn't have the safety measures in years gone by, doesn't mean that the safety measures we have now are a waste. The fact is they save lives. Car seats save lives, seatbelts save lives, helmets save lives. These are indisputable facts. Just because we didn't use them in the past and didn't get hurt doesn't mean someone else didn't. Some one that may be alive today if they had had the safety equipment then that we have now. Your continued "when I was growing up" straw man argument is just so much bullshyte.

This legislation is obviously needed as there are far too many idiots out there that come up with the "when I was growing up" argument and will sell unsafe equipment because "when they were growing up".

You won't get any argument from me and I don't know why you think you would. I just stated that we are "over sanitized" today and the majority of us survived through "less safe" conditions. Of course you are safer wearing a helmet while cycling (I went over the handle bars at age 5 "doubling" and was knocked out for an hour) Not a pleasant experience.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
You won't get any argument from me and I don't know why you think you would. I just stated that we are "over sanitized" today and the majority of us survived through "less safe" conditions. Of course you are safer wearing a helmet while cycling (I went over the handle bars at age 5 "doubling" and was knocked out for an hour) Not a pleasant experience.


You're contradicting yourself. Are we safer, or are we "over sanitized"? Your use of "over sanitized" implies that we have too many safety devices since we "survived" in the past. If so, then what should we do without?
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
You're contradicting yourself. Are we safer, or are we "over sanitized"? Your use of "over sanitized" implies that we have too many safety devices since we "survived" in the past. If so, then what should we do without?

I don't think so.............gadgets only contribute so much in keeping people safe, far less than things like being aware of the dangers and paying attention to what you are doing. Sure buy a car seat and use it properly, but you don't need to run out once a week to buy a so called better one. Getting back to the original discussion of yard sales, one wise poster pointed out that a car seat purchased at a yard sale may well be for a very different purpose than its original use.
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
I don't think so.............gadgets only contribute so much in keeping people safe, far less than things like being aware of the dangers and paying attention to what you are doing. Sure buy a car seat and use it properly, but you don't need to run out once a week to buy a so called better one. Getting back to the original discussion of yard sales, one wise poster pointed out that a car seat purchased at a yard sale may well be for a very different purpose than its original use.


Nobody, including this legislation is stating OR implying that one needs to go out and buy a new carseat every week. The legislation is to protect people in the same way other consumer protection legislation is used. All it is doing is extending the legal liability to EVERYONE that sells or gives away a car seat or other product that has safety attached to it.. Not just the retail store.
 

PoliticalNick

The Troll Bashing Troll
Mar 8, 2011
7,940
0
36
Edson, AB
Garage sale sellers responsible for product safety, Health Canada says

Garage sales face the same responsibilities as legitimate retailers when it comes to screening for banned or unsafe products, Health Canada reminded Canadians in a Tuesday advisory.
“Everyone holding a garage sale in Canada is legally responsible for ensuring that products sold or even given away, whether new or used, are safe and meet current safety standards,” says an instructional video released this week by Health Canada.
The new rule stems from the revised Canada Consumer Product Safety Act, which came into force last June, although similar regulations existed under the previous Hazardous Products Act. The “sweeping” changes, first proposed in 2008, were meant to combat sellers “who care more about the almighty dollar than the safety of their customers,” Prime Minister Stephen Harper said at the time.
“They cut corners and play fast and loose with safety. To these outfits I say: Be warned. You will soon face severe punishment if you willfully expose Canadians to danger,” Mr. Harper told an annual meeting of the Canadian Consumer Specialty Products Association.
‘Be warned. You will soon face severe punishment if you willfully expose Canadians to danger’
As well as allowing Health Canada to impose mandatory product recalls, the act extends vendor responsibility to thrift stores, independent sellers and even people listing free items in online classifieds. Depending on the severity of consumer injury that results, the act allows Health Canada to prosecute anyone who has sold or given away a potentially unsafe item.
According to the Health Canada website, a garage sale is effectively breaking the law if it includes lawn darts, corded blinds, broken toys, toys with powerful magnets, hockey helmets, tiki torches or any product that has been the subject of a recall. Regulations also call for garage sale electronics to be bundled with “instructions for safe use.”


Garage sale sellers responsible for product safety, Health Canada says | News | National Post

Has nobody in the brain-dead asylum on parliament hill ever heard the adage "BUYER BEWARE"
You know this is the kind of stupidity from a govt that makes me want to go to Ottawa and just start shooting. I suppose next will be a law that if we don't rat out our neighbor for selling junk on a Saturday morning we will be prosecuted too. I would be quite willing to up the ante to multiple murder of numerous dumb-f*ck, ignorant, Orwellian politicians if the govt wants to prosecute me under this law.

I'm sorry but if somebody is dumb enough to buy a 15 year old half busted car seat and strap their child into it then it should be them prosecuted and not the one who sold it off their lawn. We are not talking about selling snake-oil to the mentally handicapped here we are talking about reasonably intelligent people buying used crap out of a carport.

The better course of action from the govt would have been an ad campaign with a simple statement 'use care and caution when buying second hand products'.

I can only imagine the amount of costs enforcing and administering this most f*cking stupid of policies will absorb. Think about the current backlog in courtrooms and toss in a couple of million law-suits and crown prosecutions just because someone bought an old matchbox car with lead paint at a flea market.

Seriously folks, this is the kind of bullsh*t that makes people go postal. On the brighter side it should also lead to the en-mass revolt needed to tear down this abhorration we call a democracy of the people.

WELCOME TO 1984....BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU!!!!
 

LiesOfTheIntell

Time Out
Feb 19, 2012
66
0
6
London, Ontario
Health Canada is putting out instructional videos (that no one will see) to help educate vendors of used goods. Hopefully they'll spend a few million on a marketing blitz so that this "instructional video" will actually be seen.
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
The long and short of it is, there is no point in having a government body trying to keep our kids alive if we bind and gag them from doing their job. Kids die because of crap passed off to save a buck. Expired car seats, car seats that have been in accidents, cribs that no longer meet code...products people have deemed unfit for their own children but have no qualms about selling to someone else's. Buyer beware only goes so far when it comes to children.

There are, btw, simple ways of dealing with selling things that the gov. has deemed are unsafe (car seats do not apply, those are illegal to sell or trade no matter what)

"For doll use only, deemed unsafe for children by Health Canada" is one of the simplest. Feel free to buy it, I've made you aware it's unsafe.
 

CDNBear

Custom Troll
Sep 24, 2006
43,839
207
63
Ontario
Expired car seats, car seats that have been in accidents, cribs that no longer meet code...products people have deemed unfit for their own children but have no qualms about selling to someone else's. Buyer beware only goes so far when it comes to children.
Or their children have out grown.