Vanstone: Here's what is wrong with the 2015 Riders
1. Matador defence:
Although there have been signs of a pulse lately, the Roughriders' defence remains an area of considerable concern (especially in the fourth quarter). Saskatchewan has allowed 225 points - the most in the league - after seven games. Granted, the total is skewed by two overtime games and three pick-sixes thrown by Saskatchewan quarterbacks, but the Roughriders' defence is a liability by any measure. One source of optimism is the fact that Saskatchewan has registered nine of its 15 sacks over the past two games. As a counterbalance, the Green and White has forced only two turnovers, and a Saskatchewan defensive back has yet to register an interception in 2015. Where have you gone, Ken McEachern?
2. Coaching errors:
Corey Chamblin has struggled as the head coach and de-facto defensive co-ordinator. Chamblin made a series of head-scratching coaching moves July 17 when the Roughriders coughed up a 29-18 lead in the final two minutes of regulation time and lost 35-32 in overtime to the host B.C. Lions. The Roughriders' chief strategist should have gone for a two-point convert after his team's final touchdown, and his decision to attempt a field goal on third-and-one in overtime was tantamount to waving a (green-and-) white flag. As mentioned earlier, the Chamblin-influenced defensive schemes are suspect. Is this the same guy who so adeptly guided Saskatchewan to a Grey Cup championship in 2013?
3. Lack of discipline:
Saskatchewan leads the CFL in penalties, with 109 for 924 yards. Worse yet, there isn't any sign that the problem is being eradicated. On Saturday, for example, the Roughriders were flagged 24 times - the most in franchise history - for 192 yards en route to losing 30-26 to the host Toronto Argonauts. Five Saskatchewan touchdowns have been called back this season, with Chris Getzlaf losing out on a TD catch on three occasions. A scoring grab by Weston Dressler and a pick-six by Geoff Tisdale have also been washed away. How bad is it? On Saturday, the Roughriders' bench was called for unnecessary roughness. And what can be done? How can you bench the violator when he is already on the bench?
4. Injuries:
Saskatchewan has had an inordinate amount of bad luck, as evidenced by injuries to not one, but two starting quarterbacks - namely Darian Durant and Kevin Glenn. In the first half of the regularseason opener, Durant (ruptured left Achilles tendon) and middle linebacker Shea Emry (neck) suffered significant injuries. Glenn (torn right pectoral muscle) has plenty of company on the six-game injured list. Yes, rival teams have been able to withstand injuries, but fragility cannot be discounted as a key factor behind the Roughriders' horrid start.
5. Lack of speed:
The Roughriders' defence looked slower than erosion in Saturday's fourth quarter, when the Argos' Diontae Spencer sped away from everyone while scoring what proved to be the game-winning touchdown - a 52-yard collaboration with quarterback Trevor Harris.
That game-altering play underlined one of the Roughriders' chronic deficiencies. They simply are not fast enough. Complicating matters, Chamblin has frequently accentuated the importance of "playing fast." Uh, good luck with that. On offence, the Roughriders could also use a genuine burner, such as Spencer. Where have you gone, Jeff Fairholm?
6. Diminished Canadian depth:
The core of national talent is not what it once was. Injuries have not helped, either, but the Roughriders used to boast enough starting-calibre Canadians to weather such misfortunes. The onus is on general manager Brendan Taman and director of player personnel Craig Smith to upgrade the Canadian base.
7. Advanced age:
Taman assembled a veteran-laden team with the intent of winning now. Such a formula was an unqualified success in 2013. All of the Roughriders' 30-something players enhanced their already impressive resumes during a magical season. In 2015, by contrast, veterans such as defensive tackle Tearrius George, defensive halfback Terrell Maze and safety Tyron Brackenridge have stopped making plays on a consistent (or even periodic) basis. Aging receivers Taj Smith and Jamel Richardson have already been phased out. Gainer, at 38, is apparently safe.
The Roughriders' habitual losing - they have failed to win 14 of their last 16 meaningful games, dating back to mid-September - is also getting very old.
Vanstone: Here's what is wrong with the 2015 Riders
Vanstone: Here’s what is right with the 2015 Riders
Yesterday in this cherished space, we enumerated the reasons why the Saskatchewan Roughriders are 0-7.
So now, in the interest of balance, here is another top-seven list — detailing what is right with the CFL’s only winless team:
1. Quarterbacking: Last September, a season-ending elbow injury to quarterback Darian Durant effectively signalled the conclusion of the Roughriders’ campaign. This time around, quarterbacking is an area of strength, even though Saskatchewan is now starting rookie Brett Smith *— who was third on the depth chart when the irregular season began. After Durant suffered a ruptured left Achilles tendon in the regular-season opener, veteran Kevin Glenn took over and the offence continued to purr. Now that Glenn is on the six-game injured list with a torn right pectoral muscle, Smith looks like a pivot of considerable promise. Durant, Glenn and Smith have helped Saskatchewan lead the league in touchdowns (17), first downs (160) and passing yardage (2,153).
2. Jerome Messam: The 30-year-old tailback has demonstrated an ability to run over or away from defenders while contributing on the ground and through the air. With 417 yards, Messam is the league’s second-leading rusher *— and the owner of a 7.3-yard average per carry. He is also second in yards from scrimmage, with 733. Moreover, he is first in yards after the catch (215). The only objection: Messam should be handed the ball more frequently. He has reached double digits in carries only once in seven games. Nonetheless, Saskatchewan sits atop the CFL in rushing yardage (Nine hundred and twenty-eight).
3. Special teams: Last season, the special teams — co-ordinated by Bob Dyce — were routinely and rightfully maligned. The kick coverage was comical, the punting was unremarkable and field-goal attempts were an adventure. Fast forward to 2015. The Roughriders’ kick coverage is generally airtight. Ray Early is second in the league in average yards per punt (47.6) and net average (39.7). Paul McCallum, who replaced Chris Milo after Week 1, has hit 15 of 17 field-goal attempts, including a pair of 50-yarders. Dylan Ainsworth’s eight special-teams tackles place him second in the CFL, one behind Deon Lacey of the Edmonton Eskimos.
Saskatchewan also has missed field-goal returns of 93 yards (by Nic Demski) and 55 yards (by Weston Dressler). The only sore point is a lack of production on punt and kickoff returns. The Roughriders are averaging 19.2 yards per kickoff return (with a long gain of 33) and 5.7 yards per punt return. The longest punt return is a mere 12 yards, although Steven Miller is capable of a long-gainer. Penalties washed away two impressive returns Saturday during a 30-26 loss to the host Toronto Argonauts.
4. Dan Clark: Entering the season, questions were swirling about whether Clark could fill a sizable void created by the release of veteran centre Dominic Picard (now of the Winnipeg Blue Bombers). Clark, a former standout with the Thom Trojans and Regina Thunder, has performed with aplomb in his first year as a full-time starter.
5. Jake Doughty and Jeff Knox Jr.: There haven’t been many reasons to applaud Saskatchewan’s defence, but two emerging linebackers — Doughty and Knox — are worthy of commendation. Doughty, who has a team-high four tackles for a loss along with the Roughriders’ only interception, was elevated to a primary role after middle linebacker Shea Emry suffered a neck injury in the opener.
Knox, who has been in the lineup from the outset, has 41 defensive tackles and is tied with the B.C. Lions’ Solomon Elimimian — the league’s reigning most outstanding player and top defensive player — for second in the league in that category. B.C.’s Adam Bighill leads the way with 46 tackles.
6. Chris Getzlaf: The Regina-born slotback is enjoying a bounce-back year after being hampered by injuries for most of 2014. He has four touchdown receptions and has had three other majors negated by penalties. The four touchdown catches place Getzlaf one behind the league leader, Eric Rogers of the Calgary Stampeders. The Green and White has also had strong performances from Dressler (whose 416 receiving yards place him fourth in the CFL) and Ryan Smith (372 yards; ninth overall). Dressler and Smith are in the top 10, yardage-wise, despite each missing two games due to injuries.
7. Exciting football: Win or lose, the 2014 Roughriders were not especially entertaining. The 2015 edition, by contrast, has played exciting football in all but one game (a 30-5 loss in Edmonton on July 31). Saskatchewan has lost by four or fewer points on five occasions. The nailbiters are riveting to watch. Only the 0-7 record is an eyesore.
Vanstone: Here’s what is right with the 2015 Riders
These articles were written back on August 12th so some of the stats re other teams have changed but I have to agree on balance with much of what Van has to say - though for me discipline really should be the number 1 problem considering the stats.
The Calgary Stampeders - currently tied for 1rst place in the West with the Eskimos - will be in Regina to play our Riders. I will be watching closely to see if CC has finally got a handle on discipline because if he has I think we have a good chance of making a game of it with Calgary. Bo Levi has had his struggles as had the Calgary D. Hopefully the bye-week will see our guys come back stronger, more disciplined and well able to put points on the board that will stay there. They are my CFL pick for the game - have been all season no matter who they played but it would be so sweet to actually be in the winning column. GO RIDERS, GO.