It was a bad idea to illegally occupy West Bank for 58 years through State spsored terrorism. It spurred a fuck tonne of retaliation has it not?
Do you know of any other society who would protest in opposition of soldiers being detained for butt fucking prisoners?
Far-right lawmaker Zvi Sukkot appeared to be among those rioting after at least nine soldiers were detained on suspicion of “severe abuse of a detainee.”
www.nbcnews.com
Meanwhile...
Overview of Allegations and Investigations
The query refers to allegations of rapes and sexual violence during the October 7, 2023, Hamas-led attack on southern Israel, which killed about 1,200 people and took over 240 hostages. These claims emerged immediately after the attack, amplified by Israeli officials, media, and some international outlets.
However, investigations have revealed a complex picture: credible evidence of some instances of sexual violence exists, but many specific high-profile claims have been debunked or lack substantiation.
No comprehensive forensic or survivor-led prosecutions have resulted, largely due to the chaos of the attack, rapid burials for religious reasons, and the death of most alleged victims.
Below, I summarize key findings from diverse sources, including UN reports, Israeli investigations, and critical analyses, representing Israeli, Palestinian, and neutral perspectives.
Key Evidence Supporting Sexual Violence
Multiple independent investigations have identified "reasonable grounds" for believing some rapes and sexual assaults occurred, based on witness testimonies, forensic patterns, and confessions. However, these do not confirm "mass" or "systematic" rapes as initially claimed.
UN Mission Report (Pramila Patten, March 2024): The UN Special Representative on Sexual Violence in Conflict visited Israel and found "reasonable grounds" to believe rape and gang rape occurred at multiple sites, including the Nova music festival, kibbutzim (e.g., Re'im, Nir Oz), and the Nahal Oz base.
Evidence included:
Eyewitness accounts of gang rapes and mutilations (e.g., a festival witness describing a woman being raped and shot).
Forensic patterns: Bodies (mostly women) found naked from the waist down, bound, shot in the head/genitals, with signs of genital trauma or semen.
Confessions from two interrogated militants admitting to rapes.
Released hostages reported sexual assaults in captivity (e.g., threats, forced nudity, at least one confirmed rape). The report stressed this was not a full investigation and called for one, noting no direct survivor interviews from October 7 itself due to trauma or death.
Association of Rape Crisis Centers in Israel (ARCCI) Report (February 2024): Analyzed 1,500 testimonies and visual evidence, concluding "systematic, targeted sexual abuse" of women. It cited:
At least seven sites with assaults/mutilations.
Hamas videos showing naked, bloodied women.
First-responder accounts of broken pelvises, bruises, and cuts indicating assault.
New York Times Investigation (December 2023): Verified video evidence and interviews with 150+ people, documenting a "pattern" of rape and mutilation at the festival and kibbutzim.
Examples:
Gal Abdush's body (festival victim) showed signs of rape per police analysis.
Eyewitness "Witness S" described a gang rape and execution.
Israeli Police (Lahav 433 Unit): Collected 50,000+ images and 1,500 testimonies by December 2023, stating sexual crimes were "part of the planning" to terrorize.
Interrogations of seven militants yielded confessions of assaults.
International Criminal Court (ICC, May 2024): Prosecutor Karim Khan sought warrants for Hamas leaders (e.g., Mohammed Deif), citing "reasonable grounds" for rape as a crime against humanity, based on hostage accounts and attack-site evidence.
Recent Reports (2025): The Dinah Project (Israeli gender experts) reviewed 17 incidents, including survivor testimony of an attempted rape and 15 ex-hostage accounts, calling it a "genocidal strategy." A UN Secretary-General report (April 2024) listed Hamas for verified sexual violence in at least six locations.
These findings align with patterns in other conflicts (e.g., Bosnia), where rape is used for humiliation, but quantifying exact numbers is impossible without full autopsies.
Debunked or Unsubstantiated Claims
Many early sensational stories, often from ZAKA (Israeli volunteer body handlers lacking forensic training), were later retracted or disproven.
Critics (e.g., Al Jazeera's I-Unit, Electronic Intifada) argue these fueled propaganda to justify Israel's Gaza response. Hamas denies all allegations.
Claim
Details
Status
Source
Widespread/systematic mass rape
Initial reports of "dozens" or "hundreds" of rapes, including orders to Hamas fighters.
Insufficient evidence for scale; isolated incidents possible, but not proven systematic.
No prosecutions filed as of 2025. Israeli prosecutor Moran Gaz (Team 710) stated no identifiable victims or cases in January 2025.
Al Jazeera I-Unit (March 2024); Haaretz (April 2024); AP (May 2024)da1f3e705664df224d
Pregnant woman mutilated (baby cut out)
ZAKA volunteer Yossi Landau claimed a fetus was beheaded.
Debunked; video was from a 2021 Mexican cartel killing.
AP (May 2024); The Intercept (February 2024)2b537abd3450
Teen girl raped in Kibbutz Be'eri
ZAKA's Chaim Otmazgin described a body with pants down as rape evidence.
Retracted; family confirmed no assault—pants down from fleeing.
PBS/AP (May 2024); Haaretz (December 2023)cfb4d0529d8b
Festival witness "Esther" gang rape account
Described hiding and seeing a rape.
Partially walked back; witness later said she "assumed" details and regretted fueling doubt.
Wikipedia (citing Le Parisien/BBC); AP (May 2024)f5ddfd
Genital mutilation pattern
Claims of soldiers/babies shot in genitals.
No discernible pattern found; some injuries verified but not systematic.
UN Patten Report (March 2024)282380
Broader Context on Debunking: An AP/PBS investigation (May 2024) traced two ZAKA stories to chaos, not malice, but noted they eroded trust. Physicians for Human Rights Israel (May 2024) retracted parts of its November 2023 paper for "unverifiable" testimonies. Haaretz (April 2024) compiled all evidence: 15 witnesses, three confessions, but no living named rape victims from the day itself (one hostage case stands). Al Jazeera (March 2024) concluded "isolated rapes may have taken place" but not widespread.
Challenges and Broader Implications
Why Limited Proof? Most victims died; bodies were buried quickly (halachic reasons), limiting forensics. Trauma silences survivors. The UN noted the "true prevalence may never be fully known."
Political Weaponization: Israel has accused the UN/media of bias for not emphasizing claims enough; critics say exaggerations justified Gaza operations (57,000+ Palestinian deaths as of 2025). Hamas's denial and lack of internal probes add opacity.
Ongoing Risks: UN/ICC reports highlight continued sexual violence against hostages (e.g., "sexualized torture"). Conversely, a UN Commission (June 2024) documented Israeli sexual violence against Palestinians since October 7, including in detentions.
In summary, while some sexual violence is substantiated by patterns and testimonies, no "proven" rapes have led to convictions, and exaggerated claims have been discredited.
Full accountability requires independent probes, as urged by the UN. For deeper reading, see the UN Patten Report or Haaretz's April 2024 compilation.
www.youtube.com
www.youtube.com
www.youtube.com
en.wikipedia.org
View attachment 31110www.memri.org
