Keeyask dam cost could reach $10.5 billion

tay

Hall of Fame Member
May 20, 2012
11,548
1
36
An independent review of Manitoba Hydro's capital expenditure program warns the Keeyask hydroelectric dam could cost the province billions more to complete than expected. It also blames the Crown corporation's lack of construction management experience and skills for failing to keep the multibillion-dollar project on track.

The report, written by Calgary consulting firm MGF Project Services, was commissioned by the Manitoba Public Utilities Board as part of the PUB hearings into Hydro's proposed rate increase. It found the Keeyask dam could cost as much as $10.5 billion due to the "contractor's poor productivity and increased indirect costs" associated with the project.

The 695-megawatt generating station — approximately 725 kilometres north of Winnipeg on the Nelson River — was originally estimated to cost $6.5 billion and expected to be in service by November 2019. In September 2016, Hydro raised its cost estimate to $7.8 billion.

Then in March, it went up to $8.7 billion. At the time, Hydro blamed rising expenses for foundation work for the additional increase.

Hydro wants to charge 7.9 per cent more per year until 2023-24, and raise rates an additional 4.54 per cent the following year. If allowed, that would mean a $1,000 Hydro bill would reach almost $1,600 in 2023-24, and it would hit $1,650 the following year.

more

Keeyask dam cost could reach $10.5 billion, report warns - Manitoba - CBC News
 

Decapoda

Council Member
Mar 4, 2016
1,682
801
113
So much for cheap hydro in Manitoba. After 17 years of NDP rule, the last thing the province needs is to give people and business one more reason to leave.
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
oh just wait for it.

mega project = mega cost over run. Site C already $3 billion over and it's barely started?

should add its blown past the $10 billion mark and it looking at that $20 billion finish line.
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,340
113
Vancouver Island
oh just wait for it.

mega project = mega cost over run. Site C already $3 billion over and it's barely started?

Site C was on time and on budget when the dippers took over the government. Do tell how did the dippers squander that much money on one little project in 4 short months?
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
Site C was on time and on budget when the dippers took over the government. Do tell how did the dippers squander that much money on one little project in 4 short months?
it has never been on time or on budget,

the previous government ran up that $3 billion or so over run prior to getting permission to go ahead with the project.
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,340
113
Vancouver Island
it has never been on time or on budget,

the previous government ran up that $3 billion or so over run prior to getting permission to go ahead with the project.

There was no overrun until 4 months after the dippers took over. The provincial government gives permission, not askes for it.
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
the provincial government has spent billions of dollars on this project.

the provincial government approved the project last week.

anywhere outside of BC this would be considered odd.
 

bob the dog

Council Member
Aug 14, 2020
1,768
1,253
113
So much for cheap hydro in Manitoba. After 17 years of NDP rule, the last thing the province needs is to give people and business one more reason to leave.
Premier Wab Kinew recently mentioned Manitoba Hydro owed $25 billion which is ridiculous for a utility company with no competition.

Keeyask was easily twice the $10.5 billion they claim.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,183
14,241
113
Low Earth Orbit
Premier Wab Kinew recently mentioned Manitoba Hydro owed $25 billion which is ridiculous for a utility company with no competition.

Keeyask was easily twice the $10.5 billion they claim.
They'd best pay that off before Amazon starts selling power to Winnipeg residents.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Taxslave2

bob the dog

Council Member
Aug 14, 2020
1,768
1,253
113
They'd best pay that off before Amazon starts selling power to Winnipeg residents.
Pensions rule the day at institutions like Manitoba Hydro. Nothing else matters unless it is a buyout. It's like they think they will all live forever and be healthy enough to spend their money. A fine example of corporate narcissism. Hire your brother goes a long way as well.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,183
14,241
113
Low Earth Orbit
Pensions rule the day at institutions like Manitoba Hydro. Nothing else matters unless it is a buyout. It's like they think they will all live forever and be healthy enough to spend their money. A fine example of corporate narcissism. Hire your brother goes a long way as well.
They could charge more.

Sask is pricy but we recently invested heavily into the grid infrastructure including DOPL.

Here is the average total cost of electricity by province, based on a monthly consumption of 1,000kWh:

Alberta25.8¢/kWh
British Columbia11.4¢/kWh
Manitoba10.2¢/kWh
New Brunswick13.9¢/kWh
Newfoundland & Labrador14.8¢/kWh
Nova Scotia18.3¢/kWh
Northwest Territories41.0¢/kWh
Nunavut35.4¢/kWh
Ontario14.1¢/kWh
Prince Edward Island18.4¢/kWh
Quebec7.8¢/kWh
Saskatchewan19.9¢/kWh
Yukon Territory18.7¢/kWh
Canada Average19.2¢/kWh

That's was with carbon taxes in 2023
 

Taxslave2

Senate Member
Aug 13, 2022
5,010
2,827
113
They could charge more.

Sask is pricy but we recently invested heavily into the grid infrastructure including DOPL.

Here is the average total cost of electricity by province, based on a monthly consumption of 1,000kWh:

Alberta25.8¢/kWh
British Columbia11.4¢/kWh
Manitoba10.2¢/kWh
New Brunswick13.9¢/kWh
Newfoundland & Labrador14.8¢/kWh
Nova Scotia18.3¢/kWh
Northwest Territories41.0¢/kWh
Nunavut35.4¢/kWh
Ontario14.1¢/kWh
Prince Edward Island18.4¢/kWh
Quebec7.8¢/kWh
Saskatchewan19.9¢/kWh
Yukon Territory18.7¢/kWh
Canada Average19.2¢/kWh

That's was with carbon taxes in 2023
SO if Quebec raised their power rate to even BC level, they could do away with transfer payments.