Opinion
Opinion | Israelis Would Rather Be Lied to Than Face the Painful Truth
Yossi Klein
Feb 14, 2024
Get email notification for articles from Yossi Klein
Follow
Share in Twitter
Gift this article
Save article to reading list
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Open gallery view
A protester wears a shirt depicting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during a demonstration to demand the release of the hostages taken by Hamas, in Tel Aviv, in January.Credit: Leo Correa /AP
The government is against everyone. Against Hamas, against Hezbollah, against the army and against the public. Hamas doesn't care what happens to the Gazans; does the government care what happens to us? Like sailors abandoning a sinking ship they care for themselves. Looting, taking everything they can. Passing funds to friends, helping the ultra-Orthodox, ignoring the fighters.
The soldiers also understand by now that today the government is fighting on their backs. They are its cannon fodder. They are neither out of touch nor idiots. They see where the money goes, they see the extension of reserve duty, the incompetence to deal with the displaced Israelis, the apathy toward the hostages. They are astounded to see how every week the war's goal changes. From "toppling Hamas" in the past to "absolute victory" now. Who knows what this "absolute victory" is, for which they're sacrificing their lives?
'If we don't offer an alternative to chaos in Gaza, we'll end up with Hamas rule again'
The media knows. Journalists who can analyze every second in Sinwar's mind know what happens in Netanyahu's. They know that "absolute victory" means preserving Netanyahu's rule. They know and keep silent. They know there are no other goals, no plans. No "day after." No toppling and no releasing. They all serve the same purpose, the fighters who will fall and the hostages who will be released. That's the goal, and from that everything derives. This is what must be mentioned in every report.
Journalists know, but they're not reporting what the public must know, only what the public wants to know. What doesn't it want to know? That its sons are fighting for Netanyahu. A survey conducted by Nimrod Nir and Nimrod Zeldin of Hebrew University found that most of the public think Channel 1 is the most reliable. It is also the least watched. Conclusion: Reliability doesn't count. The public prefers being lied to than being tormented with the painful truth.
Commentators don't recite the painful truth to the cameras like hostages with a gun to their head. They practice psychological terrorism, present a false spectacle of reservists who are willing to serve two to three more years as long as the goal is achieved. They cover up the fact that the goal is deliberately vague.
Self-defense and human shields: How should Israel wage war in Gaza?
Israel's future is tied to the hostages' fate - and Netanyahu doesn't get it
With the 'perfect' rescue operation, Israel's dehumanization of Gazans reached a new low
But the government doesn't appreciate their submissive devotion and treats the commentators like reserve soldiers. Who does it approach to report on 30 dead hostages, Alon Ben David? To whom does it send Brig-Gen. Barak Hiram to explain shelling a community center with hostages in it, Nir Dvori? No. It goes to the New York Times.
The media accepts the humiliation with its head bowed. It abandons the stage to the worthless speeches of politicians with nothing to say. Instead of information, it floods us with hostage stories to mournful harp sounds. It doesn't want to spoil the joy over releasing two hostages with the alarming number of killed Gazans.
The television studios think we're morons, that it's easy to feed us nonsense but not bad news. Bad news that is "cleared for publication" cannot be concealed with "impressive achievements" and "successes." They won't tell the truth: that from now on the war is a whim of one dangerous cynic. It would hurt the "united nation" narrative they're fostering. They don't want us to think that anyone who is killed from now won't be falling in defense of the country, but in defense of the government. They don't query, they hide. Instead of information there's a snowjob. A blizzard of unimportant information. This and that division moved from here to there and from there to here.
That's not relevant. That's not interesting. What is interesting? The hostages, the displaced Israelis and the attack in Rafah.
How do we win without eliminating thousands of refugees? How do we get rid of them? We "transport" them. Sure, the brilliant minds who don't even know how to take care of 100,000 Israeli refugees "will know" how to "transport" 1.4 million Gazan refugees? Like sheep, like oranges? On the face of it, it's easy. You shower them with leaflets telling them to transport themselves. And whoever remains? May Allah have mercy on him.
I have a suggestion for the pollster Dr. Camil Fuchs: Check whether the public supports or opposes an act in Rafah during which, say, 5,000 old people, women and children will be killed. My guess: The public will support it, providing they don't have to see it.
***
www.haaretz.com