Not the best way to handle overbooking

Ocean Breeze

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 5, 2005
18,396
94
48
Overbooking is the issue. AKA greed. They should never have to ask passengers to give up their light in this way. Plain incompetence. why do they think that passengers can be bribed into giving up their seats?? That is assuming that passengers have no scruples.

This does nothing but contribute to a bad image for air travel companies.This action gives the impression that passengers are expendable. not THE MOST SOPHISTICATED PR action.

Mexico will pay for it.
LOL. Spot on ;-)
 

Highball

Council Member
Jan 28, 2010
1,170
1
38
Over booking is a frequent practice by United. In this case someone could have avoided this whole incident had prior planning been done to accommodate the United employees destined for Louisville ahead of boarding any passengers. I avoid flying with United or any of its affiliates.
 

tay

Hall of Fame Member
May 20, 2012
11,548
1
36
 

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
59,998
9,369
113
Washington DC
Man this guy is going kick azz in the lawsuit. United better settle as this case is a slam dunk for any lawyer whose is even remotely competent.
Not gonna happen. Your legal expertise notwithstanding.

He was biligerent.
At least he wasn't illiterate.

He was assaulted. He had every legal right to be where he was, had paid his fare, was there originally by the invitation of the airline (thus not tresspassing) was minding his own business and he was attacked by some truly moronic "security" people. Not only should he sue United for the value of their airplane, the "security" guard (maybe all of them) should be charged with assault. He should file a complaint with the local police to press charges.
You do understand that aviation law varies considerably from the common law of trespass, right?

"Security" was the Chicago PD. Their shield, or "star" as they call it, is quite distinctive. It's in the pictures.
 

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
8
36
Not gonna happen. Your legal expertise notwithstanding.


At least he wasn't illiterate.


You do understand that aviation law varies considerably from the common law of trespass, right?

"Security" was the Chicago PD. Their shield, or "star" as they call it, is quite distinctive. It's in the pictures.

I guess that the police can assault anyone they want with impunity, any old time they want to.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
59,998
9,369
113
Washington DC
Sorry T-Bones looks like you need to have a Law School refresher.

Are Airlines Allowed to Force/Drag Passengers Off Flight? | Law News

Professor John Banzhaf, from the George Washington University Law School, believes that the passenger has a very good case and that the force used to remove the doctor may even be considered excessive in this scenario.
I like John. He's a fun guy to drink with. And I find the Banzhaf Theory of Torts quite elegant and well considered. Too bad it has about as much to do with what happens in courts in the U.S. as Melania's wardrobe has to do with Trump's foreign policy.

But I got a charge out of you quoting a liberal law professor. Sure they won't take away your Southie card?
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
Now now T-Bones... no need to get all touchy because a guy who isn't even a lawyer was correct that the United passenger has a case and you were incorrect. Being a liberal law professor has nothing to do with the subject at hand.

Personal injury attorney David Eisbrouch told LawNewz.com, “These are some questions I would be asking if I represented the passenger. At a minimum United personnel should be reaching out to the good doctor asap in order to resolve this matter before it goes any further.”

This lawyer agrees with me too!
 

Scooby

Electoral Member
Mar 22, 2012
403
0
16
Alberta
" Rights" for a consumer are simply this: " Don't like it, don't buy it "

Looking to the legal system or government for justice in this case is a lost cause. Just remember to boycott this and every other company that is completely unethical at every chance.
 

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
59,998
9,369
113
Washington DC
Now now T-Bones... no need to get all touchy because a guy who isn't even a lawyer was correct that the United passenger has a case and you were incorrect. Being a liberal law professor has nothing to do with the subject at hand.

Personal injury attorney David Eisbrouch told LawNewz.com, “These are some questions I would be asking if I represented the passenger. At a minimum United personnel should be reaching out to the good doctor asap in order to resolve this matter before it goes any further.”

This lawyer agrees with me too!
You think Eisbrouch is saying that he could win a legal action on this?

Heh-heh. That's so cute.

" Rights" for a consumer are simply this: " Don't like it, don't buy it "

Looking to the legal system or government for justice in this case is a lost cause. Just remember to boycott this and every other company that is completely unethical at every chance.
Better figure on not flying, then. I don't know of a single airline that doesn't do the overbook-and-bump thing. It's in their contracts of carriage.
 

Scooby

Electoral Member
Mar 22, 2012
403
0
16
Alberta
You think Eisbrouch is saying that he could win a legal action on this?

Heh-heh. That's so cute.


Better figure on not flying, then. I don't know of a single airline that doesn't do the overbook-and-bump thing. It's in their contracts of carriage.
They may all overbook, but some certainly handle better than others.
 

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
59,998
9,369
113
Washington DC
Cleveland Browns lineman Joe Thomas's take on "re-accommodating"

He tweeted "I had to re-accommodate someone once," and this picture:



They may all overbook, but some certainly handle better than others.
Here's part of your (well, my) problem. Most major cities in the U.S. you got your choice of Delta, American, or United.

All three have shocking stories of discrimination, indifference, and ill-treatment of passengers.

Internationally, if you book your ticket with BA, Lufthansa, or any of the Star Alliance carriers, you're likely to end up on a flight "operated by United." Even though it has a Lufthansa flight number.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
You think Eisbrouch is saying that he could win a legal action on this?

Heh-heh. That's so cute.

LOL... you are just fuming right now aren't you? You got bested on a law debate by someone who isn't even a lawyer. I said he has a case and you said he didn't. I was right and you were wrong... admit it.