Normally, I am a free-trader and don't want government meddling in an activity that should be left to the individuals or companies involved. However, in this case, I am opposed to the decision to import Chinese miners; the import of these mine workers should have been blocked. Our economy is still not at the point it was before the 2009 recession, so I am sure there are many Canadians who would have taken the work. If not, the company could have considered American miners: America is still suffering from high unemployment, America has miners, and America is part of the NAFTA agreement . Perhaps some unemployed miners from West Virginia or Pennsylvania would have been interested in those jobs. And they would have contributed a lot more to the local community. If Americans could not be found, the search should have been expanded to other NAFTA partners. And so on. But the employer did not do that; the Chinese company went straight to importing their own people. Their initial job posting even listed Mandarin as a requirement of the job:
Mandarin required in worker permits for B.C. mine project
Yet now when they are in the public eye, they plead innocence, or claim it was a mistake. Yeah, right!
Usually, when a new business starts up in a community, that community enjoys some positive results from the growth: more money flowing around, more people, more support for local businesses, etc. For example, perhaps the community was formerly too small to support a children's hockey team, or a community swimming pool, etc. When the economy and population grows, a point is reached where the community
can support one or more children's hockey teams. Or there become enough consumers for it to be feasible for somebody to open a local sporting goods store (instead of having to drive two hours to a bigger town that
does have a sporting goods store). Or the local churches gain some members filling the pews, perhaps reaching the point that a choir can be formed. etc.
You get the point:
usually when there is economic growth, it leads to population growth and positive effects in the community. However, when the Chinese come to town, I do not believe those benefits are as many or as large as they are when another group comes to town. Instead, they stick to themselves. They eat Chinese food, buying from other Chinese instead of supporting local supermarkets. They buy their clothes from China instead of supporting the local stores. I am almost certain they will even bring their own work boots with them, so not even the local Mark's Work Wearhouse will get any additional business from the presence of these new workers (I hope somebody is checking to make sure their boots have the little green triangle on the side to indicate CSA-approved) . The local hockey teams do not get more potential sign-ups, or a bigger audience. At Christmas, they won't be out caroling or participating in other community activities. They stick to themselves. The Chinese will come to
take what they can and give back as little as possible.
Don't believe me? Spend time in any large city in Canada. The Chinese have created their own enclave in most of them. Chinese companies use Chinese travel agents, Chinese bankers, Chinese bakers, Chinese plumbers, Chinese electricians, etc. If you offer a Chinese company, say, carpentry services, and are not Chinese, they will decline because one of their employees has a nephew or uncle who happens to do part-time carpentry. There are even many who think they can live here for decades but learning to speak English is beneath them.
The Chinese are too much about their own people; in fact, they are
all about their own people. This is another case of the Chinese being all about the Chinese. No surprise there. I doubt this project will ultimately have much net benefit to Canada. Besides the royalties and taxes, which will be squandered quickly, the Chinese workers will stick to themselves and their money will be sent back to China. The local communities will not benefit much. The Chinese do not augment a community; they
displace.