HEALTH CARE - User fees

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
So what are you saying, if you have to get emergency treatment in USA, Canada pays the full cost of the treatment? I seriously doubt that. Travel agents strongly recommend that travelers to USA buy medical insurance.

If we are traveling to USA more than a weekend, we always buy medical insurance.

That's exactly what I said.
 

Nuggler

kind and gentle
Feb 27, 2006
11,596
141
63
Backwater, Ontario.
Sorry for the off-topic bit here but I can understand why people would pay more to travel to the States for a hip replacement (or something) and get it done immediately rather than stay and wait months, in pain and getting hooked on analgesics, for the procedure here.

Yeah, well...................We (yup, both of us) didn't have to wait at all for knee and hip replacements. (Ont.)

Both of us got referred to an orthapedic surgeon and the wait was something like two weeks.

Walk into the local ER with your hand on your chest, and you'll be in the Ottawa Heart Institute within an hour. Helicopter if needed.

??????????????????? I hear the horror stories, but can't think of any local.

Thank Whosisname!!:idea:
 

YukonJack

Time Out
Dec 26, 2008
7,026
73
48
Winnipeg
The Canadian Health Care System is funded by PUBLIC, TAXPAYERS' MONEY.

As such it should strive to deliver the best service to ALL.

So, if one should find a service in the States that can deliver relief in two weeks, rather than eight months in Canada, the Canadian Health Care System should cover the expenses. After all, it would enable another Canadian to get one step ahead in the cue.

Of course, the Canadian Health Care System is NOT about helping patients. I is about padding the coffers of the Government.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
The Canadian Health Care System is funded by PUBLIC, TAXPAYERS' MONEY.

As such it should strive to deliver the best service to ALL.

So, if one should find a service in the States that can deliver relief in two weeks, rather than eight months in Canada, the Canadian Health Care System should cover the expenses. After all, it would enable another Canadian to get one step ahead in the cue.

Of course, the Canadian Health Care System is NOT about helping patients. I is about padding the coffers of the Government.

Yep, I think there are a few things wrong with the system contrary to the opinion of some. For one thing I don't really thing all Canadians are willing to fund the system to cover the true costs. Our health is our most important asset and we have to decide what it's worth to use. Surely equal to the amount some spend on booze and cigarettes. Of course abuse to the system is at fault for a lot of the problem (which user fees up front would solve (much to the chagrin of the resident expert). I'd just as soon they drop me from the system refund my money and I'll take my chances with a private insurance policy (which I bet would be quite reasonable with $1000 deductable)
 

YukonJack

Time Out
Dec 26, 2008
7,026
73
48
Winnipeg
User fees will not happen because of so-called "SOCIAL JUSTICE".

There are those who made something of their lives can afford them and there are the slugs who never did anything, but waiting for and receiving hand-outs, who can't.

In our politically correct system the slugs are favoured, in the name of social justice.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
User fees will not happen because of so-called "SOCIAL JUSTICE".

There are those who made something of their lives can afford them and there are the slugs who never did anything, but waiting for and receiving hand-outs, who can't.

In our politically correct system the slugs are favoured, in the name of social justice.

YOu speak a lot of truth, but I like to think a lot of "slugs" are salvagable through education and patience. At the same time there is the old axiom "survival of the fittest" which can't be ignored. If people are self destructive, there's just no saving them until they can see for themselves - trying amounts to dumping money into a big ravine.
 

Machjo

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 19, 2004
17,878
61
48
Ottawa, ON
User fees will not happen because of so-called "SOCIAL JUSTICE".

There are those who made something of their lives can afford them and there are the slugs who never did anything, but waiting for and receiving hand-outs, who can't.

In our politically correct system the slugs are favoured, in the name of social justice.

I think you're simplifying things a bit here. There are also the successful crooks and the unlucky ones who'd worked hard but have fallen hard on their luck. Luck always plays at least a small role in life. Add to that that education and access to education, local, family and other environment, etc. play a role too, along with racial and other discrimination which could also make it harder for a person to land a job or find a place to live.

So while there is some truth to what you say, you are grossly oversimplifying it.
 

ironsides

Executive Branch Member
Feb 13, 2009
8,583
60
48
United States
Of course, the Canadian Health Care System is NOT about helping patients. I is about padding the coffers of the Government.

And that is exactly what would happen here in the U.S. (again) Every goverment organization must have a BIG bureaucracy to run it, no savings there.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
I guess it would be good as long as we are prepared to pay four times the rate when we go down there for procedures.
Actually a hip replacement here at the most costs about $18,000 and in the States it is about $24,000, not 4 times as much.
But this sounds like the attitude Campbull and Co. would take; take advantage of someone's health problem and gouge his pocketbook.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Yeah, well...................We (yup, both of us) didn't have to wait at all for knee and hip replacements. (Ont.)

Both of us got referred to an orthapedic surgeon and the wait was something like two weeks.

Walk into the local ER with your hand on your chest, and you'll be in the Ottawa Heart Institute within an hour. Helicopter if needed.

??????????????????? I hear the horror stories, but can't think of any local.

Thank Whosisname!!:idea:
One of our neighbors waited almost a year and got fed up. Went to Arizona and got hip replacement and had a holiday on top of it.
Oh, you mean Martin? Yeah balancing the budget for a couple years was sure worth screwing the provinces and crippling healthcare for a decade.
 
Last edited:

Machjo

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 19, 2004
17,878
61
48
Ottawa, ON
And that is exactly what would happen here in the U.S. (again) Every goverment organization must have a BIG bureaucracy to run it, no savings there.

Another option to consider though is to have a private system that is simply regulated by the government.Through granted that might need a bureaucracy too. But then again, if we take this to its extreme, all government organizations need a bureaucracy, so do we go ahead and privatize the military and police, and what about highway construction, etc. They all need administrations, etc. So while your point is valid, we have to be careful not to demonize bureaucracy completely.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
The Canadian Health Care System is funded by PUBLIC, TAXPAYERS' MONEY.

As such it should strive to deliver the best service to ALL.

So, if one should find a service in the States that can deliver relief in two weeks, rather than eight months in Canada, the Canadian Health Care System should cover the expenses. After all, it would enable another Canadian to get one step ahead in the cue.

Of course, the Canadian Health Care System is NOT about helping patients. I is about padding the coffers of the Government.
... and playing god with people's health.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Yep, no use knocking on the door when there is no one home...........:lol::lol::lol::lol:
There's someone home but he is the only one with valid points, you know. Everyone else hasn't a clue.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Another option to consider though is to have a private system that is simply regulated by the government.Through granted that might need a bureaucracy too. But then again, if we take this to its extreme, all government organizations need a bureaucracy, so do we go ahead and privatize the military and police, and what about highway construction, etc. They all need administrations, etc. So while your point is valid, we have to be careful not to demonize bureaucracy completely.
The best person I've ever read about for determining what gov't should run, what it should regulate, and what it should stay out of was WAC Bennett. BC ran like a clock when he was premiere from what I've read. I haven't seen anyone since then that's even come close to his savvy.
 

ironsides

Executive Branch Member
Feb 13, 2009
8,583
60
48
United States
Another option to consider though is to have a private system that is simply regulated by the government.Through granted that might need a bureaucracy too. But then again, if we take this to its extreme, all government organizations need a bureaucracy, so do we go ahead and privatize the military and police, and what about highway construction, etc. They all need administrations, etc. So while your point is valid, we have to be careful not to demonize bureaucracy completely.

I am not sure something like price controls would work thru regulation, but it is better than running up the bills like we are doing. If were going to have a goverment run health care system, why not just add it to one of the other systems we already have like "Medicare". The system is already there, however good or bad it maybe. I would like to hear how they plan on either lowering the cost of health insurance or limiting how much it can increase. Our postal system (was gov. run) is on the verge of bankruptcy, because of competition by the Internet, FedEx, UPS etc. just doing the job cheaper.
 

VanIsle

Always thinking
Nov 12, 2008
7,046
43
48
Yeah, well...................We (yup, both of us) didn't have to wait at all for knee and hip replacements. (Ont.)

Both of us got referred to an orthapedic surgeon and the wait was something like two weeks.

Walk into the local ER with your hand on your chest, and you'll be in the Ottawa Heart Institute within an hour. Helicopter if needed.

??????????????????? I hear the horror stories, but can't think of any local.

Thank Whosisname!!:idea:
Well then I guess BC people should be heading for Ontario because you wait a very long time for such things both here and Alberta.
 

VanIsle

Always thinking
Nov 12, 2008
7,046
43
48
The best person I've ever read about for determining what gov't should run, what it should regulate, and what it should stay out of was WAC Bennett. BC ran like a clock when he was premiere from what I've read. I haven't seen anyone since then that's even come close to his savvy.
Yah and not even his son had the smarts to follow in his footsteps!