Yukon Jack, you remarks,"The basic difference between a Canadian and an American is that an American NEVER feels that he/she needs to be compared to a Canadian.
Whereas the essence of being a Canadian is exactly the opposite.
Another, and perhaps even more telling, is that an American IS an American, from Maine to California, from Seattle to Miami, on the coasts, or in the Heartland"
EXCUSE ME? I've lived in the deep south and in Colorado, and I've spent a fair bit of time in the Boston States. Yes, they may have thought of themselves as American, but trust me, while they may have been connected to the idea of the United States of America, they were more connected to their regional roots. The myth of the 'melting pot' is just that - a myth. Every place i lived, most of the people thought themselves as American, but more importantly, they defined themselves by their region. Their 'America' had more to do with their region than the country as a whole, in fact, they knew usually knew very little about the rest of the country. Having said that, Canadians should not feel very smug when it comes to national knowledge. We profess love for our country and mock the fact that Americans know little about their own country but in reality we are no better when it comes to our own.
I'm a proud Canadian. I don't come that way by comparing myself to the USA. I like the USA - I recognize what they have achieved but i live my life as a Canadian. do I have regional loyalties? Of course I do, it would be disingenuous for me to say otherwise but as far as my nationality? I don't define it by what I am not, I define it by what i am.