How best to help the poor?

What is the best way to help the poor?

  • Give them enough money to help them get on their feet again.

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Give them the education and basic essentials they need, reardles of cost, but no money.

    Votes: 3 25.0%
  • Other answer.

    Votes: 8 66.7%

  • Total voters
    12

Said1

Hubba Hubba
Apr 18, 2005
5,338
70
48
53
Das Kapital
Lots of homeless and poor people have concurrent mental health problems. Hiring them to pass a mop sounds like the final solutaion, just keep the number for the guys with the white van and straight jacket near by.
 

darkbeaver

the universe is electric
Jan 26, 2006
41,035
201
63
RR1 Distopia 666 Discordia
There is much truth in what you say whereby some can make money out of their inheritance while others are plagued by bad luck no matter how hard they work.

And yes it's also true that various forms of systemic or systematic discrimination in the system itself can lead to money flowing from poor to rich.

This does not mean however that we need to demonize the rich. It's not necessarily the rich who'd creted this system. Instead of focusing on blame, why not focus on restructuring the system to make it more fair so that less money will flow from poor to rich in the first place rather than just depend on the rich always giivng their money to the poor.

yes, the por will always be with us, and yes the rich should always carry their fair share of the burden. But the trooth is, some rich are carrying their fair share of the burden and are payig taxes already. Unfortunately, government bureaucracy uses that money too inefficiently. Let those rich have more say in where that charitable money goes.



I have it on very good advice that the rich certainly did create the system, and they created it to serve them the rest of us on a platter. You cannot restructure anything without being focused on the problem. You can rename it you can study it you can consult with experts for decades you can lecture at length but you cannot restructure something with cosmetics especially a system that is definately serveing it's intended purpose if not the expressed. They won't let you. The rich always and still blame government bureaucracy for low efficiency as if the present crisis of private corporations greed and corruption has not revealed that to be the bull**** joke it always was.
Let the rich have more say where that charitable money goes and it'll go to the rich, where else? Of course this is only my opinion of the miserable parrasites.
 

mit

Electoral Member
Nov 26, 2008
273
5
18
SouthWestern Ontario
There was a time when people down on their luck could go to the city/town and ask for work - they might have to cut grass - sweep the sidewalks or paint some fences. These tasks are all sewn up by public works departments now. Time was also when a person in need of work could knock on a few doors and find work gardening etc. from homeowners or a couple days at a factory - Sometimes women would open up their home to look after others children - now it is regulated in to a business not a service. We create public housing projects where if a person finds a good paying job they are kicked out because they make too much money but if you run a crack house or ***** house then it is accepted if not expected by those stalwart taxpayers that are just glad they don't live in the same neighbourhood.
We will never get to a point where we wish to help our neighbour until we get over the fear of our neighbours.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
There was a time when people down on their luck could go to the city/town and ask for work - they might have to cut grass - sweep the sidewalks or paint some fences. These tasks are all sewn up by public works departments now. Time was also when a person in need of work could knock on a few doors and find work gardening etc. from homeowners or a couple days at a factory - Sometimes women would open up their home to look after others children - now it is regulated in to a business not a service. We create public housing projects where if a person finds a good paying job they are kicked out because they make too much money but if you run a crack house or ***** house then it is accepted if not expected by those stalwart taxpayers that are just glad they don't live in the same neighbourhood.
We will never get to a point where we wish to help our neighbour until we get over the fear of our neighbours.

And more often than not if you did start baking cookies to sell in the neighbourhood, you'd have some Union mucky mucky at your door telling you,you can't be doing it as you are depriving a Union baker of work or you yourself would have to join the baker's Union.
 

Unforgiven

Force majeure
May 28, 2007
6,770
137
63
First off I would have to say that you must accept that there will always be poor people. Some people choose that and there is no stopping their will, so accept it and move on to what you can help with.

Provide the basics needed to live and make that accessible to anyone who wants it.

Once stable, bring in education and training for specifics in the market place. Partner business with government initiative and provide supplemental training once a permanent position has been developed.

Workfare is the right direction if not the right vehicle.

Further, a return to technical instruction and streaming in middle and high school in a meaningful way to rebuild the service and manufacturing sector providing those areas with a larger pool of educated workers.

There will always be plenty of lawyers and doctors, but we should provide the wages to compensate doctors and nurses for opening practice outside highly populated centres to some degree to make that more attractive.

Not the whole answer but we mostly have that already in place and with a little better management, especially where working poor are concerned to transition from government aid to self support.

Other aspects such as mental health should be dealt with by medical interaction rather than Corrections Canada and the Emergency department.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
First off I would have to say that you must accept that there will always be poor people. Some people choose that and there is no stopping their will, so accept it and move on to what you can help with.

Provide the basics needed to live and make that accessible to anyone who wants it.

Once stable, bring in education and training for specifics in the market place. Partner business with government initiative and provide supplemental training once a permanent position has been developed.

Workfare is the right direction if not the right vehicle.

Further, a return to technical instruction and streaming in middle and high school in a meaningful way to rebuild the service and manufacturing sector providing those areas with a larger pool of educated workers.

There will always be plenty of lawyers and doctors, but we should provide the wages to compensate doctors and nurses for opening practice outside highly populated centres to some degree to make that more attractive.

Not the whole answer but we mostly have that already in place and with a little better management, especially where working poor are concerned to transition from government aid to self support.

Other aspects such as mental health should be dealt with by medical interaction rather than Corrections Canada and the Emergency department.

I agree 99%, and there would be enough doctors too if all people took their health seriously and relied on themselves more. We have to simply get rid of that "drugstore mentality" in our society.
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
I agree 99%, and there would be enough doctors too if all people took their health seriously and relied on themselves more. We have to simply get rid of that "drugstore mentality" in our society.

Take it one step further and work to eliminate the mentality that 'free' healthcare is not a right... Far too many people bitch about the lack-luster care they receive when they have no clue about the actual cost of that care. I think that if the individual were in required to pay for one tenth of the cost of the basic stuff and 1/100th of the major stuff, they'd shut-up quick enough and start making healthier choices.
 

Liberalman

Senate Member
Mar 18, 2007
5,623
36
48
Toronto
The drunk men who sleep on sewer grates from Bay Street to Main Street Canada should be rounded up by the military and sent off to Afghanistan when this happens this will give the rest of the drunks motivation to sober up and get a job.

People that lose their jobs are covered by unemployment insurance to help them get retrained to find another jobs.

People that are on welfare who don’t have jobs should be shipped off to provinces that need workers.

A good example of this is that we are in a middle of a depression where tens of thousands of people are losing their jobs but in the province of Saskatchewan they need workers.

For the people that don’t want to leave their families then let the families support them.

For the mentaly ill put them back into the institutions.

There is always simple solutions, the only problem is that government do not want to act on it.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Take it one step further and work to eliminate the mentality that 'free' healthcare is not a right... Far too many people bitch about the lack-luster care they receive when they have no clue about the actual cost of that care. I think that if the individual were in required to pay for one tenth of the cost of the basic stuff and 1/100th of the major stuff, they'd shut-up quick enough and start making healthier choices.

Health care so far is basically very cheap in CAnada, like $110 a month for a family. Health IMHO is about the most important asset you have (next to family and a good credit rating) and yet people are willing to spend 3 or 4 times the amount trying to destroy it than they are willing to pay to protect it. I think any family earning over $50 thousand should pay $150 a month and that would put the system back on it's feet, the other alternative being demand less service (don't run to the E.R. with a sniffy nose)
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
The drunk men who sleep on sewer grates from Bay Street to Main Street Canada should be rounded up by the military and sent off to Afghanistan when this happens this will give the rest of the drunks motivation to sober up and get a job.

People that lose their jobs are covered by unemployment insurance to help them get retrained to find another jobs.

People that are on welfare who don’t have jobs should be shipped off to provinces that need workers.

A good example of this is that we are in a middle of a depression where tens of thousands of people are losing their jobs but in the province of Saskatchewan they need workers.

For the people that don’t want to leave their families then let the families support them.

For the mentaly ill put them back into the institutions.

There is always simple solutions, the only problem is that government do not want to act on it.


Do we really want to lose the war in Afghanistan? :lol::lol: Otherwise you are right on.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
! 8O TY ;-) (with a typo)

Means thank you. I edited when I realized you posted between....

You gotta have patience with us old codgers, took me damn near 60 years to learn English and now it looks like I have to spend another 60 learning computerese. Not going to have time for many more languages. :lol::lol:
 

Unforgiven

Force majeure
May 28, 2007
6,770
137
63
The drunk men who sleep on sewer grates from Bay Street to Main Street Canada should be rounded up by the military and sent off to Afghanistan when this happens this will give the rest of the drunks motivation to sober up and get a job.


Do you even know who it is that is fighting on your behalf over in Afghanistan? Trust me, a homeless person with whatever problems they are suffering at the moment, wouldn't last ten minutes in Afghanistan. It takes nearly a year to train someone to go fight in the war over there, and those are healthy both physically and mentally, men and women working at the top of their game.

I find you attempt here at a solution is doomed to failure long before it starts.

People that lose their jobs are covered by unemployment insurance to help them get retrained to find another jobs.

Yeah once it kicks in. Then it's not all that long before it runs out. The majority manage to move from one job through the system and into their next job without too much trouble, but it's not really those people that need help.

People that are on welfare who don’t have jobs should be shipped off to provinces that need workers.

Except that Charter thingy gets in the way. I think your solutions would have more traction if only we were the Nazis. But wait, we fought and died and eventually rebuked their ideals and final solution. So where does that leave you?

A good example of this is that we are in a middle of a depression where tens of thousands of people are losing their jobs but in the province of Saskatchewan they need workers.

Yes workers not slaves. Migration will happen as needs and means dictate for the most part.

For the people that don’t want to leave their families then let the families support them.

Sure those that can should, I'm all for that. Some people need various amounts of help and we should supply that help so that they can again return to making a livable wage as soon as possible.

For the mentaly ill put them back into the institutions.

What institutions? They were closed and the mentally ill sent home to their families so they can support them. Now that you're painted into the corner, what do you think you should do to get out?

There is always simple solutions, the only problem is that government do not want to act on it.

It can be said that there are also stupid ideas that won't work no matter what. It's a good thing that the government doesn't implement every dumb idea that comes down the pike.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Yep, shipping the unemployed over to Afghanistan, would just be transporting the problem for someone else to contend with. A lot of these guys have their own demons to fight, without getting in other's way and probably end up being more of a threat than the enemy.
 

YukonJack

Time Out
Dec 26, 2008
7,026
73
48
Winnipeg
I have been waitig in vain for anyone to say what they ACTUALLY HAVE DONE for the poor.

Theorize, but do not act. In other words just be a Canadian.