Woman Files False Rape Claim Because She "Didn’t Enjoy It”

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
What risk do these women pose to society aftre such a thing, that locking them up would do any good? And weigh that against what risk society faces by making it hardr for them to tell the truth.

This is something that pops up in here from time to time. What risk do they pose to society after committing a crime. Unless they are violent criminals the risk is probably minimal to none. But what about Crime & Punishment? For example white collar crime, they are not a threat to society. Should they be let go? Bernie Maddoff is hardly a threat to anyone... should he not have been sent to jail.

When a rape charge or abuse charge is levied that carries a hefty social penalty even if they are falsely accused. The falsely accused are the real victims... and the ones that levies the charge is the real criminals. They should be punished.
 

SLM

The Velvet Hammer
Mar 5, 2011
29,151
5
36
London, Ontario
This is something that pops up in here from time to time. What risk do they pose to society after committing a crime. Unless they are violent criminals the risk is probably minimal to none. But what about Crime & Punishment? For example white collar crime, they are not a threat to society. Should they be let go? Bernie Maddoff is hardly a threat to anyone... should he not have been sent to jail.

My thoughts on that are that we should be restricting imprisonment to the violent criminals and we should come up with other methods of "punishment" for the Bernie Madoff's of the world to pay back society for their crimes.

When a rape charge or abuse charge is levied that carries a hefty social penalty even if they are falsely accused. The falsely accused are the real victims... and the ones that levies the charge is the real criminals. They should be punished.

Absolutely they should be punished but how is the question.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
My thoughts on that are that we should be restricting imprisonment to the violent criminals and we should come up with other methods of "punishment" for the Bernie Madoff's of the world to pay back society for their crimes.



Absolutely they should be punished but how is the question.

Well then what is the punishment? What can you do with a Bernie Maddoff? His family is hardly destitute. He'd be living a comfortable life if he was released today. Much more comfortable than you and I.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
I think its likely happened in almost every home town. Its part of why people need to remember the old idiom of innocent until proven guilty.

But that reinforces my view that if you slammed these girls with charges, it wouldnt stop a defective brain from concocting the initial lie, all it would dois mean they have to stick to said lie.

What risk do these women pose to society aftre such a thing, that locking them up would do any good? And weigh that against what risk society faces by making it hardr for them to tell the truth.

I think one of the main concerns here is the fact that our courts across the country are jammed, some of it by trivial cases, so (I'm not necessarily advocating prison) there has to be a level of punishment in place to put a stop to this bullsh*t.

Absolutely they should be punished but how is the question.

For Bernie, 14 hours a day, 7 days a week on a treadmill, being supervised by his victims armed with whips, should he happen to reduce the pace
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
For Bernie, 14 hours a day, 7 days a week on a treadmill, being supervised by his victims armed with whips, should he happen to reduce the pace

Those are all fun things to say and I know you are kidding but the fact of the matter is the Maddof's are still living the high life and living a life of luxury. They are worth over 100 Million. They are so lawyered up and their money is so protected that their victim's will spend their lives trying to recoup what they lost.

Let him leave jail because he is not a threat and he'll be sipping wine in the Hamptons tomorrow.
 

SLM

The Velvet Hammer
Mar 5, 2011
29,151
5
36
London, Ontario
Well then what is the punishment? What can you do with a Bernie Maddoff? His family is hardly destitute. He'd be living a comfortable life if he was released today. Much more comfortable than you and I.

The way things work right now, you're absolutely right. I'm speaking of an almost 'ideal' situation here. If the justice system can restrict someone's freedom, like a Bernie Maddoff, by putting them in prison, then they should conceivably be able to impose other restrictions. Would it be inconceivable for something like Ricoh to apply to someone like him for instance? That could compensate the victims and on top of which we could impose house arrest or make him work exclusively in a community service capacity for set number of years. Something. It's not anything that's going to happen tomorrow of course, but as much as we hear about overcrowded prisons and still having really dangerous violent offenders on the street, is it not time to start thinking outside the box a little?

Obviously this woman doesn't have the resources of a Bernie Maddoff. If, mind you I'm saying if, we are going to look at reforming the correctional system would it not be best to start with a person like this? I think she needs to pay a debt to society in general and the falsely accused in particular. All I'm saying is why is imprisonment the only way we can come up with for her to do it?
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
This is something that pops up in here from time to time. What risk do they pose to society after committing a crime. Unless they are violent criminals the risk is probably minimal to none. But what about Crime & Punishment? For example white collar crime, they are not a threat to society. Should they be let go? Bernie Maddoff is hardly a threat to anyone... should he not have been sent to jail.

When a rape charge or abuse charge is levied that carries a hefty social penalty even if they are falsely accused. The falsely accused are the real victims... and the ones that levies the charge is the real criminals. They should be punished.

I never said they shouldn't, I just questioned the mentality that she should face worse than she is.