Why do some Jews and Christians insist that Muslims worship another God?

Torch light

Torch light

House Member
Dec 4, 2017
3,584
170
63
Muslims worship the Creator; they call Him Allah in Arabic; some Muslims who are not Arab may call Him Khodah, although all Muslims call Him Allah as it is in the Quran which was revealed in Arabic.

Now, all Jews, Christians and Muslims essentially worship the Creator ... but because not all people speak English, they call the Creator with words different according to their different languages:

So God in English is the Creator, while in Arabic the synonymous word is Al-Khaliq ... in other languages He is certainly called by other names indicating this attribute that He is the Creator.

But [O believers,] dispute not [concerning the religion] with the People of the Scripture [or the Bible] unless it be in [a way] that is better [than theirs], except such of them as do wrong.

And say [to those among them who are not wrong-doers]: "We believe in [the Quran] that has been revealed to us and [the Torah] revealed to you, our God and your God is One, and to Him we have resigned."

The above in blue is the meaning of the aya of the Quran 29: 46

It means: Our God and your God is the same One .. that is the Creator, the Most Gracious, the Almighty.
But of course, it can't be called God in Arabic, because the word 'God' is an English word, and the word 'Allah' is an Arabic word which means "The God".

=========================================================

The reason why some leaders and followers among Jews and Christians insist that Muslims worship another god is:

Because if they admit that Muslims worship the same God as it is cited in the Quran .. then they will acknowledge that the Islam is similar to their original religions ... and by so doing all bounds, limitations and restrictions will be broken .. and then all people may come to the Islam religion and will convert.
 
Last edited:
petros

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
118,217
14,488
113
Low Earth Orbit
Mohammad was born into a family of traders that had contact with Jewish and Christian traders.

He was jealous of their prosperity, intelligence and the unity they had while his people were savages and had no commonality.

He was a wannabe.
 
Torch light

Torch light

House Member
Dec 4, 2017
3,584
170
63
But devils suggested to the leaders of these Jews, Christians (and Muslims) that there is the god of Jews, the god of Christians and the god of Muslims.
So God tells them that He is the same One, while devils tell them: No, He is not the same one!

God tells them that He is the same One Who sent Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Mohammed (and the Mahdi), but devils say to them: No, to each of these sects is their own god!

petros said:
Mohammad was born into a family of traders that had contact with Jewish and Christian traders.

He was jealous of their prosperity, intelligence and the unity they had while his people were savages and had no commonality.

He was a wannabe.
Click to expand...

You know this is not correct; but you tell yourself this suggestion, which is wrong, and I surprise how can you be any science following!?

If you are Jew or Christian, and say: he had contact with Jewish and Christian traders:
.. Who can be without contact with people whether Jews or Christians? Moses was in contact with his people: the Children of Israel, and Jesus was in contact with his people who originally were Jews. And all prophets and messengers were in such contact.

While the rest of your post is only the assertion without proof.

Therefore, I tell you (and others) here two points:
Will God leave people ignorant and savage without sending them a messenger to teach them? And why would He do so, only to confine the religion to Jews for example?

The other point: if truly you know God and love Him, you will not utter such words; because if you are wrong, you will be punished and will be a loser when you deny His messenger who called to God alone without associate or son or daughters.

Moreover, was he alone with contact with Jews and Christians, why not all people who were in contact, and they should have done similar to him?

And how can he alone find the true and correct way, while all others were misguided: so that he invited to God alone, not like the Jews who worshiped the Baalim, Astaroth, the calf statues and the sky stars, nor like Christians who fell in the idolatry of worshiping Jesus Christ himself, his mother and the saints besides God Almighty.

==============================================================

I surprise also of some people that are educated and qualified: some of them study and teach philosophy, and he asked the atheist leader in an interview (which was politically directed), and he said to him: Do you believe in 'the Muslim god' !?

So this is an example of one being a scientist and qualified, but he is misguided in spite of his knowledge and qualification .. because he is a wrong-doer in some way or another, while God does not guide the wrong-doer.

http://quran-ayat.com/pret/45.htm#a45_23
quran-ayat.com/pret/45.htm#a45_23

========================================================

In addition, don't these Jews, Christians and others contemplate:

If Mohammed invented the religion quoting it from Jews and Christians, how could he bring it in the correct way without the mistakes and the distortions that afflicted the Torah and the Gospel which led to their misguidance and error away from the true and exclusive monotheism and submission to God alone!?

So if he acquired it from Jews and Christians, he would follow the same faults and errors of the people of the Bible.

While the outline of the Quran is the same outline of the Ten Commandments without the distortions and alterations of the Torah and the Gospel.

========================================================

So the aya of the Quran 29: 46, the meaning of which I wrote in blue in the first post:
But [O believers,] dispute not [concerning the religion] with the People of the Scripture [or the Bible] unless it be in [a way] that is better [than theirs], except such of them as do wrong.

And say [to those among them who are not wrong-doers]: "We believe in [the Quran] that has been revealed to us and [the Torah] revealed to you, our God and your God is One, and to Him we have resigned."

It implies:
The dispute with the wrong-doers among the people of the Bible (Jews and Christians) is useless.
To those that are not wrong-doers, we say: We believe in the Torah and the Gospel revealed to them.
We worship the same One God: the Creator, the Most Gracious and Almighty.

And in another aya: if they turn away, tell them we submit ourselves to God alone without associate.

http://quran-ayat.com/pret/3.htm#a3_64
quran-ayat.com/pret/3.htm#a3_64
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom