How do we solve the Middle East problem.

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
As it's been pointed out, this "conflict" has been going on for over 60 years now. It is past the time, in my opinion, for the 2 sides and the world to get their act together. The 2000 Camp David talks came damn close to an agreement. I would propose that the same agreement be put forward to both sides, the Isreali's and the Palistinians. I propose that the PEOPLE be allowed to vote on that agreement, both the Isreali's and the Palistinians, without their respective governments interfereing with that vote. U.N. observers could ensure that it is fair and legal, with U.N. troops backing them up to ensure no one is intimidated. If the people from both sides vote to go forward with the Camp David agreement, then both sides will sit down and hammer out the logistics. Failure would NOT be an option.

Iranian President Ahmadinejad made a similar proprosal.

NPR: Do you accept the label of the man who wants to wipe Israel off the map? You're not?

Ahmadinejad: Please pay attention to the fact that there are two issues that go side by side in this discussion. The first part is the proposal we have given to resolve the problem of Palestine. For 60 years, wars and killings have been going on over there.

Every peace proposal that has been put on the table so far has failed to give results. Why? Because it neglects the rights of the Palestinian people. Our proposal has been to offer the Palestinian people a free referendum. Everyone who lives in Palestine [should be able] to participate in a referendum to decide the future and the nature of its government.

Let me create an analogy here — where exactly is the Soviet Union today? It did disappear — but exactly how? It was through the vote of its own people. So therefore in Palestine too we must allow the people, the Palestinians, to determine their own future.

And then the second side of this same issue, and I'd really like to invite you to pay attention to it. Especially you — you must, because you are always being subjected to [the] unilateral sort of information that is coming from the administration here.

Let's ask ourselves, where exactly did the Zionist regime come from? Palestine has existed historically with people who live there for thousands of years. Then at gunpoint several million of the indigenous people there were forced out of their homes and became displaced. And it didn't stop there; others were brought from elsewhere in the world to replace them. How can you accept this regime?...

Ahmadinejad: 'Who Exactly Is The Provocateur?' : NPR

Also by Palestinians, he means Jews and non-Jews. Iran recognizes that Jewish Palestinians haved lived in this area for millenia, just as they lived in Iran (and continue to do so) since before Islam.

He does not recognize the immigrants as Palestinians, but everyone born in Israel/Palestine and those displaced by Israel would probably qualify as eligible to vote.

Your efforts to find a peaceful solution are admirable gerryh, but unfortunately this area is not ruled by peaceful people willing to compromise. I'm sure you are well aware of the violent intentions of some Palestinians. But how aware are you of the violent intentions of most of Israel's leadership?

Does this sound like Israel's leaders seek a peaceful solution?

Today's News
Israel rebuffs US call for total settlement freeze
By MATTI FRIEDMAN – 15 minutes ago

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel defied a surprisingly blunt U.S. demand that it freeze all building in West Bank Jewish settlements, saying Thursday it will press ahead with construction.

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said Wednesday that President Barack Obama wants Israel to halt to all settlement construction — including "natural growth." She was referring to Israel's insistence that new construction is necessary to accommodate the expansion of families already living in existing settlements.

Government spokesman Mark Regev responded by saying "normal life in those communities must be allowed to continue." He confirmed that this meant some construction will continue in existing settlements...

The Associated Press: Israel rebuffs US call for total settlement freeze

What that means is Israel's ethnic cleansing and rolling annexations will continue unabated.

Compare the situation of Israeli settlers to Palestinians:
U.N. Seeks End to Razing of Homes in East Jerusalem
Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times
May 1, 2009

Samia al-Hdaidun with three of her children in the site of their East Jerusalem home, which Israel demolished last week.

JERUSALEM — The United Nations is calling on Israel to freeze all pending demolition orders against Palestinian homes in East Jerusalem in a new report that reflects growing international concern over developments in the contested city. The report also urges Israel to provide solutions to the housing crisis there.

Scores of Palestinian-owned structures are demolished every year by the Israeli authorities on the grounds that they were built without the required permits. But many Palestinians say Israel limits construction to push them out of East Jerusalem...

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/01/world/middleeast/01jerusalem.html

Does that sound like Israel treats everyone the same way? The Palestinians above are Israeli citizens, but they can't live in their homes and they can't build new ones. Imagine how Israel treats their non-citizens....

Israel intends to continue demolishing Palestinian homes and building Israeli homes. This is the root cause of the conflict and its been going on for over 60 years. Until the ethnic cleansing issue and the issue of nearly 5 million displaced people has been resolved in a fair and just manner, this area will not have peace.

Israel's leaders have no interest in peace. They won't come out and say so openly, because they depend on the sympathy of people like yourself and billions in US military and economic aid to continue taking more and more land. But Israel's leaders understand good PR and that if they take Palestine a home a time, most people outside of the area won't notice even when all that's left of Palestine is a collection of open air prisons, which is where we are today, more or less.
 
Last edited:

darkbeaver

the universe is electric
Jan 26, 2006
41,035
201
63
RR1 Distopia 666 Discordia
Israel’s “Existential Threats”

By Dina Jadallah

Global Research, May 28, 2009



The last few days have witnessed an inflection point in the history of Israel. It has effectively shed its democratic veneer and blatantly embraced its racist, fascist and colonialist ideology. I am referring to the passage of three bills in the Knesset. One would require loyalty oaths to maintain citizenship. A second states that citizens must recognize Israel as a Jewish state or else face up to one year in prison. And the third makes commemoration of the Nakba (Catastrophe – referring to the creation of Israel in 1948) a crime. (1) These come on the heels of PM Netanyahu’s demands that the Palestinians must recognize Israel as a State for the Jewish People in return for “economic development.” These steps were all taken ostensibly to counteract Israel’s “existential threats,” which include the “demographic time bomb,” being “surrounded by enemies,” “anti-Semitism,” and so forth. The “threat” to Israel is real. But not because of its proclaimed reasons. The central and unacknowledged “threat” is that it is natural and inevitable that there will be Resistance from the victims of Zionist praxis. Israel’s “existential” dilemma can only be resolved within universal ethical parameters.
And yet, as outrageous and revolting as the above developments are, there is an underlying silver lining. Namely, the quality of Israel’s conduct has now reached a new low from which it will be hard to emerge. These developments cap a demonstrated weakening of its overwhelming regional military power, both in terms of deterrence capacity and execution, which has resulted in its growing inability to use aggression in order to achieve political goals.
There is an irony in being unjust, racist, colonialist, expansionist, murderously brutal, and unapologetic and still expecting an “existential” free-ride. Adding insult to irony is that the above statement would be a moral and ethical given, but is frequently qualified or denied when applied to Israel. It is, after all, the only state to claim a “right to exist.” There are two main reasons for this. First is Israel’s self-designated status as the sine qua non Victim -- historically, presently, existentially, and perpetually – placing it outside of moral equivalence. And second is the international balance of power (BOP) which accepts and encourages its actions because they often serve larger strategic goals.
Denying Palestinian Dispossession While Pursuing “Peace”-ful Solutions To “Existential Threats”
Israel and its sponsors have relied on a BOP approach to “peace” in order to address these “existential threats.” Ever since its establishment in 1948, Israel has dominated the region militarily. This dominance made them useful to international powers – first England, then United States. Whatever “solution” the Israelis proposed served as the basis of a “peace” formula that was to be implemented. The most significant result has been the categorical denial of the Nakba and of Israel’s responsibility for dispossessing and uprooting the Palestinians.
From the outset, a solution was impossible because Israel made sure that, institutionally, the refugees do not exist. Fearing their repatriation, Israel insisted that the UN’s International Refugee
 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
Great link IS! More from the same site:

WELCOME TO OUR WEBSITE! We’re a “down and dirty” website of World Citizens Exposing Islam, an organization devoted 110% towards exposing the evil idiocy of Islam. Non-Muslims, with even a small measure of intellectual curiosity, are sincerely welcome!


UNWELCOME VISITORS TO THIS WEBSITE ARE:

* Muslims!

* Stupid, and evidently desperate, non-Muslim women who hook up with Muslims.

* University Professors, betraying their own country, by hanging on the tit of Saudi Arabia for their 100-150k salaries.

* Members of Congress and of the Judiciary, that, by ignorance or personal interest, turn a blind eye and deaf ear to the subversion of our Country.

* School officials that allow the teaching of a sanitized version of Islam in public and private schools.

* Members of the Media, from the highest executive, to the lowliest intern, that consistently show a bias towards Islam.

* Pseudo-intellectual Liberals, recently converted to Islam from Communism.

* Persons whose milk of human kindness has curdled their brains and especially those Christian leaders who think Allah is God.

* Silly graduates or undergraduates of Islamic or Middle-Eastern Studies, who have wasted, or are presently wasting, their parent’s hard-earned money.

Home


Sounds like your kind of website. Full of hate and prejudice, just like you.

The fact is, nearly a million people were ethnically cleansed from this area during Israel's creation. These people and their descendents have no rights or citizenship. They live in extreme poverty under a constant state of attack. The minority who managed to stay in Israel after the 1947-49 ethnic cleansing war are second class citizens in the Zionist State of Israel. They face persecution, home demolitions, restrictions on where they can travel, live, work... They have less access to education and other social services. They face a growing movement within Israel to be forcefully removed in order to make Israel a pure Jewish state.

I could rebut the crap you post, but instead I'll just post a summary of the situation by Nobel Peace Prize Laureate Amnesty International which is a far more objective and informative than "All about Muhammad"


Amnesty International 2009 Annual Report regarding Israel and the Occupied Territories:

Israeli forces launched a military offensive on an unprecedented scale – code-named “Operation Cast Lead” – on 27 December in the Gaza Strip, killing many civilians and destroying homes and other civilian property. Earlier in the year there had been a marked upsurge in killings of civilians and others by both Israeli forces and Palestinian armed groups in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT) before a ceasefire was agreed in June (see Palestinian Authority entry). Some 70 children were among the 425 Palestinians killed in the first half of the year. In addition to the large-scale destruction of homes and property in the Gaza Strip, Israeli forces also destroyed scores of Palestinian homes in the West Bank and in Bedouin villages in the south of Israel. Throughout the year, the Israeli army maintained stringent restrictions on the movement of Palestinians in the OPT, including a blockade on the Gaza Strip, which caused an unprecedented level of humanitarian hardship and virtually imprisoned the entire population of 1.5 million. This was further exacerbated by the Israeli offensive launched on 27 December. Hundreds of patients with serious medical conditions requiring treatment not available in local hospitals were refused passage out of Gaza; several died. Hundreds of students could not travel to their universities abroad because they could not leave Gaza, where many fields of study are not available. Most of Gaza’s inhabitants depended on international aid, but the Israeli blockade hampered the ability of UN agencies to provide assistance and services. In the West Bank the movement of Palestinians was severely curtailed by some 600 Israeli checkpoints and barriers, and by the 700km fence/wall which the Israeli army continued to build mostly inside the West Bank. The expansion of illegal Israeli settlements on seized Palestinian land increased to a level not seen since 2001. Israeli soldiers and settlers who committed serious abuses against Palestinians, including unlawful killings, assaults and attacks against property, enjoyed impunity in most cases. Hundreds of Palestinians were arrested by Israeli forces; reports of torture and other ill-treatment were frequent, but investigations were rare. Some 8,000 Palestinians remained in Israeli prisons, many after unfair military trials.

Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories | Amnesty International Report 2009

The first step to solving a problem is to recognize the problem.

The problem is that Palestinians suffer oppression and injustice at the hands of Zionists for over 60 years. While the Zionist State of Israel continues to practice ethnic cleansing and deny Palestinians fundamental human rights, this area will continue to be a war zone.

27/02/2009
Israel planning mass expansion of West Bank settlement bloc

By Akiva Eldar

Despite the state's formal commitment not to expand West Bank settlements, a government agency has been promoting plans over the past two years to construct thousands of housing units east of the Green Line, Haaretz has learned...

Israel planning mass expansion of West Bank settlement bloc - Haaretz - Israel News

I also recommend this OpEd:
MJ Rosenberg: Another West Bank Settlement Expansion: Silence = Death

To summarize it points out how Israeli scientists have made a breakthrough in cancer detection. This discovery is an example of the potential of Israelis to improve the world. Unfortunately most of Israel's resources are wasted on waging war with their neighbors and ethnic cleansing. As a result, everyone including Israelis are worse off. Eventually settlement expansion (aka ethnic cleansing) will lead to Israel's destruction.

From the Israel Human Rights group B'Tselem regarding Israeli settlements on land ethnically cleansed of non-Jews:

...Israel has stolen thousands of dunams of land from the Palestinians. On this land, Israel has established dozens of settlements in which hundreds of thousands of Israeli civilians now live. Israel forbids Palestinians to enter and use these lands and uses the settlements to justify numerous violations of Palestinian rights, such as the right to housing, to earn a living, and freedom of movement. The sharp changes Israel made to the map of the West Bank make a viable Palestinian state impossible as part of the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination.

The settlers, on the other hand, benefit from all rights given to citizens of Israel who live inside the Green Line, and in some instances, even additional rights. The great effort Israel has expended in the settlement enterprise – financially, legally, and bureaucratically – has turned the settlements into civilian enclaves within an area under military rule and has given the settlers a preferred status. To perpetuate this unlawful situation, Israel has continuously violated the Palestinians’ human rights.

B'Tselem - Land Expropriation and Settlements
 
Last edited:

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
More and more people are begining to realize the truth about what's going on in Israel and the occupied territories. Israel's war crimes and crimes against humanity are becoming well known. Zionists may control the news media, but they don't control the internet.

People looking for answers to IS's misinformation and hate propaganda should check out this Jewish Website:

Jewish Voice for Peace:
Israeli Palestinian Conflict 101http://www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org/publish/101conflict.shtml#1
 
Last edited:

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
I see you guys just can't help laying blame on one side over the other rather than coming up with solutions amiable to both sides. Very limited and narrow minds.
 

karrie

OogedyBoogedy
Jan 6, 2007
27,780
285
83
bliss
I see you guys just can't help laying blame on one side over the other rather than coming up with solutions amiable to both sides. Very limited and narrow minds.

It's exactly what's stopped any progression of peace.

Right and wrong have to be thrown out the window for the sake of life sometimes.
 

earth_as_one

Time Out
Jan 5, 2006
7,933
53
48
I see you guys just can't help laying blame on one side over the other rather than coming up with solutions amiable to both sides. Very limited and narrow minds.

In order to solve a problem, you first have to recognize the problem.

The root cause of this areas problems are Israel's injustice and oppression. Everything else is a chain reaction.

How would it be possible to end Apratheid without recognizing that racism and white supremecy is the root cause?

How do you stop the Rwandan genocide without recognizing that armed Hutus were slaughtering Tutsis?