Yes, that's true. I kind of thought it was just a case of the media needing to ask something, anything, and that that was the hot topic. But I guess I didn't think it stole focus. But you may be right. Good point.
I also think that, obviously, the show was messed up because they had to work out the logistics of having all those guest judges. And I also thought that the guest judges might not necessarily be good judges of talent, or of what makes a successful AI contestant. I would rather have seen the show do the auditions with three judges, and add Ellen later, than to have all those guest judges.
Ultimately, though, the cast was really disappointing. I remember there being a week when I thought, "This week they have to bring it. And they will." Only they didn't. So I gave them one more week. And then one more. Then I realized they were never going to bring it. The show wasn't entertaining, because the contestants weren't good enough. Remember when missaddicted said there needed to be Idol moments? There really weren't any.
For this I do blame the judges. There were a lot of people, mainly guys, in the Top 100, who were good. Some seemed to be good looking and have charisma, as well as good voices. (remember several guys who said Kris inspired them? What happened to them?) Why didn't some of these people make the cut, and why did people like Paige and Lacey and Aaron make the cut?
I don't know what went on, but something seemed forced in the wrong direction this year. I swear they left behind some excellent guys and picked some mediocre guys on purpose (so the guys wouldn't be better than the girl, or girls, they hoped would win?) Hey, maybe they didn't want a guy to win because they didn't want to steal focus from their darling Adam.
Then something happened to sour them on Crystal and they seemed to grasp at Lee like drowning men.
Then there was all the Kris-Adam strangeness. The whole season was weird and it always seemed like there was more going on than met the eye. Agendas. The show is always manipulated, but it seemed so crazy this year.