Canadian Idol Fans Watching American Idol

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
You know, as far as international exposure goes, Idols are not often publicized outside the U.S. (and maybe a bit in Canada). It happened for Kelly because she had huge hits and they pushed Adam like their lived depended on it, but otherwise, it didn't really happen for anybody else. I'm sure Daughtry is still mostly unknown to a lot of people outside North America and so is Carrie. They sent Archie do some shows in England, but they never actively pushed his career there. Same thing for Jordin I believe. David Cook didn't get that treatment either. Also, a lot of American acts are unknown in Europe, same goes for super popular European acts that are unknown in American. The music scenes are actually quite different. So I guess I'm not that surprised they're concentrating their efforts in the U.S. right now. Touring internationally can be really really expensive.
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
Not going to lie - love Red Dwarf -- especially the early years. Although, it's more than a little rude and gross at times. :)

Adam's promotion outside US borders really was out of the ordinary.

Someone just posted Heartless from Alabama. with good sound!

YouTube - Kris Allen at Alabama Adventure july 17, 2010

Kate Voegle (can't spell her last name) Nothing has come of it so far. I guess we'll find out later.

And regarding the BNL fan scorn. He's never going to make fans out of all of them.. but he will get some of them.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
And regarding the BNL fan scorn. He's never going to make fans out of all of them.. but he will get some of them.

Yeah, he'll probably win some over. But does it really have to be like this? I think he could be opening for bands where there wouldn't be much (or any) scorn from fans. Remember that Fray concert in Virginia, last year, where he was cheered like he was "a Beatle" just for showing up in the audience? Fans like that have no scorn. Or the radio concert with Boys Like Girls? Why should he have to play for tough crowds? It makes no sense to me. He just played in San Francisco and was very well received.

(ETA: Not that the crowd is bad. I have no idea! Probably great. But I stilll need to be convinced that opening for BNL is good.)
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
All bands have to play for tough crowds. Or they do if they want to make new fans out of them. I love the headling concerts too, they're kind of special - and I'd love to see one, and the tour with GRO has actually been my favourite line-up so far. But, this is a good thing for Kris and the band. Tough crowd but they are loyal music lovers. They will make new fans out of this. Sure some won't be impressed but those people are never going to be impressed. That Idol bias will hold them back from enjoying anything from Idol. It's their loss quite frankly. There's still a huge bias towards Idol out there. One of my favourite music hosts has stated quite emphatically that he will never play anything from Idol. I love the guy but it's a total blind spot of his, and it's his loss.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
I think we're making two different points. Unless you're saying Kris should deliberately be booked in front of tough crowds most of the time.

revskip Is watching kris allen (that one) cover kanye's "heartless." shoot me in the head with a cannonball!

All bands have to play for tough crowds. Or they do if they want to make new fans out of them.

I think accidentally being in front of a tough crowd is one thing. But it's obviously not something musicians seek out. I think the idea is to find recepetive audiences. Isn't the idea usually to find a band to open for that has a similar sound, or vibe, or one whose fans will probably appreciate the artist?

Anyhow, maybe the fans will like Kris. A few tweets don't mean much.

----------------------------------

ETA: Some interesting stuff.

hermits_united Now awaiting BNL. Wonder if some portion of the crowd will leave since they were here for Kris Allen.

hermits_united Didn't know Kris Allen at all and now I've seen him twice in a month. Starting to sound familiar cause I think he did the same set.

NatalieJumper So Kris Allen doing Come Together by the Beatles? Double Rainbow.

amara_m Kris Allen was pretty good. No complaints.

NatalieJumper Kris Allen :) Pretty good show! http://twitpic.com/27gtfl

Some "pretty good" (lol) comments from the non-fans. I think there were a lot of Kris fans there tonight. Also, the same 4 or 5 girls seem to be following him around the country, which is bizarre. Don't they have jobs?

Thanks for the Heartless video. That was a great crowd. I need to listen to Kris and the band every now and then because they literally get better all the time.
 
Last edited:

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
I don't actually think the crowd is that tough - no fruit remember? Some disgruntled tweeters sure, but I bet they sat in their seats or went to the bar not exactly rioting or heckling. I have yet to hear of any heckling or booing happening at these opening dates.

I like the comment about them starting to sound familiar because they did the same set. LOL - Kris has one album out. He's not working with 20 years of material here folks.

and clearly those fans have have better jobs than us... or a money printer in the basement :) They're also in Cali where Kris and the band have played a bazillion shows.

The Grass Heat (Torres's band) is opening for Kris at the San Diego show..

They just tweeted.
@thegrassheat Trying to rent a Pope Mobile for Latin Jesus-big coming home parade this Saturday-we need bags of glitter

kinda cracks me up that they've started calling Chris Torres latin Jesus too. LOL
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Okay, I'll shut up after making the point this time. Haha. Here it is. Kris has a hit on the radio and he has a chance at pop stardom right now. Is the way to market a fresh, potentially hot young pop star to have him open for BNL? Why does he even need to win over those fans? He should be marketed to a completely different type of audience.

Here are some better situations (than he's been in), in my opinion: He's the opener, with a couple of young bands who are new, not big yet, but creating some buzz. Or maybe he's one of several new acts touring together. Or he opens for a current, hot band that draws mainly a younger crowd, and I could name a lot of them.

The people who hear his songs on the radio should be hearing him live. He doesn't need to go outside his demographic, yet - he still needs to win over that demographic as a concert artist. I don't feel he's gaining those young fans on this tour, except when he plays theme parks, maybe.

I think his management is intentionally marketing him to a thirtysomething demographic with HAC or AC tastes. And I don't get it. He's young and his music appeals most to young audiences.

[BTW, Adam has two openers who are both young, and one (Orianthi) has a hit single. It certainly makes him look more current than Kris. Yet, to me, his style is more old-fashioned. And he has a lot of older fans, obviously. So that's ironic.]
 
Last edited:

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Meanwhile, there is still American Idol. Or as I like to refer to that product:

"American Idol - now with 15 year olds!"
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
missaddicted, just saw your post on international audiences for Idols. Not wanting to contradict you but Daughtry played arena shows in England and Scotland just this past winter. I remember reading about it. They opened for Nickleback. I think they're pretty well known there.

Also, I looked up Carrie and she's had the #2 country album in Canada, #2 in the UK, and #3 in Australia (in 2009).

BTW, I hope the 15 year old who wins Idol next year will also be a country artist. That would be my dream come true. Don't you guys agree? Can't wait.
 
Last edited:

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
BTW, I hope the 15 year old who wins Idol next year will also be a country artist. That would be my dream come true. Don't you guys agree? Can't wait.

Please can that happen? Please.

David is at Kris's show tonight :)
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
David Cook is at Kris's concert at the Greek Theatre tonight.

[You beat me to it.]

Tweet: Paranoid Android: They flipped a coin and it said not to play this song but they’re playing it anyway.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38





This reminds me of a story. When Judy Garland played the Greek, she said a moth flew into her mouth in the middle of a song. She didn't think it would be too classy to spit out the moth onstage, so she said she parked it in her cheek like a piece of gum and finished the song.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Moth story at 2:10.

YouTube - Judy's Stories 2/2

Anyhow, just one of the many legends who've played the Greek Theatre and it's pretty awesome that Kris is walking in their footsteps tonight. Which he wouldn't be doing if he wasn't opening for BNL. So I take back all I said. Most of what I said. Some of what I said.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
SleepinIn -- Sorry, I didn't know what you meant by this, can you explain?

Last edited by SleepinIn; 9 hours ago at 10:38 PM..Reason: reconsidering.. who doesn't know David???? Who are these people...? LOL
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
Last edited by SleepinIn; 9 hours ago at 10:38 PM..Reason: reconsidering.. who doesn't know David???? Who are these people...? LOL
LOL - I wrote a whole paragraph about BNL fans not knowing David Cook. Who doesn't know David cook??? Then I erased it and left a cryptic explanation. That's about it.

You were looking for a young crowd.. tonight's benefit show performers are YOUNG - capital Y-O-U-N-G.

Cannery Ballroom

I'm gonna imagine lots and lots of screaming.

It's funny though, Kris fits in with both crowds.