Canadian Idol Fans Watching American Idol

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Just thought of a possible MJ song for Kris. He was good doing I Want You Back, in the White Chocolate group number; I could see him singing that. It'd be good if he can do a song he can move to. I bet he can dance.

This website about him has some good videos; his AI performances, plus some "home town news" stuff, which I always think is fun.

I'm guessing Jackson Five songs would be included in the Michael Jackson theme.
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
Just thought of a possible MJ song for Kris. He was good doing I Want You Back, in the White Chocolate group number; I could see him singing that. It'd be good if he can do a song he can move to. I bet he can dance.

It's funny, I don't think we want the same thing from Kris for his performance tomorrow. I Want You Back would be an ok song choice for me, but I already feel that he showed me that he could let loose and dance. Now, I want him to bring out the guitar. And he said that he wanted to use it as soon as possible, so unless he didn't find a song he could use it with, I think we could expect him to come out with his guitar. I really hope that he does since I believe he'll get the "you're so much better with the guitar" kind of critics once again if he doesn't. Also, in a lot of the comments I've read in a few places, people mention wanting him to play the guitar since he could stand out more if he does and I don't think a lot of other guys are really guitar players, if any are. It's interesting to note that the 5 who played instruments last season ended up as the final 5, so I think it could be an advantage for the contestants if they play.

But I don't deny that the boy seems to be a pretty good dancer, but for this week, I hope he keeps it for the group number!
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
ross, do you read Michael Slezak's recaps on the EW website? Slezak is Mr. Idol Extraordinaire in my mind, his recaps are the best. I don't always agree with him (and his favorites are always girls, while mine are always guys!), but his comments are interesting, witty and funny. And he's aware of the manipulation and calls it out and I like to see that on a mainstream site like EW. The Idolatry videos are often hilarious. I didn't really watch them last year, but I've been watching them this year and they're great. They're already depicting Kara as a monkey, which is hilarious. Here's the link to the EW American Idol site.
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
Oh no, the judges are so going to meddle with the voting and I'm already hating it. In fact, they know that "America" is going to hate it, but they're doing it anyway, because it'll bring the ratings (or not!) and get people to talk about the show.

Well, at least tonight wasn't that bad, it wasn't the trainwreck that many expected. Here I go with my recap:

Lil: Come on judges! She wasn't THAT good. She was good, but nothing out of the ordinary in my mind. And no Kara, she wouldn't stand out on the radio, her sound is not original. I mean, I don't want to hate on her, but the tongue bath wasn't warranted in my opinion. And the outfit and the hair were horrid.

Scott: Good to see him on the piano and I knew that song, Simon, thank you very much. The vocals weren't all that though, he's still strugling. At least the piano distracted me from that a bit. I still find it a bit uncomfortable to watch him perform though.

Danny: Thank you Danny. Seriously. No preaching, no inspirational crap, no boring ballad. I seriously questioned the fact that I liked him so much in the early rounds these last few weeks, but I think I might be back on the train right now. I prefer him when he does something upbeat like that. The dancing was a bit ridiculous, but at least, it was funny!

Michael: Seriously, why did the judges pimp him? He was mediocre at best and the second most boring of the night. I was meh on him, but if the judges want to pimp him even if he isn't better than that, I might come out with the hate soon.

Jasmine: She was better than I was expecting, but it doesn't mean much. Her voice isn't really pleasant or original and she still seems like an out of place pageant contestant.

Kris: Ah Kris, I'm scared for you. I loved you and your guitar and your contagious enthusiasm and your beautiful voice, but I fear it's not going to be enough. I want to see more of him and hear more from him! Him and his wife make the cutest couple!

Allison: OMG, she 16!!! Why didn't anybody tell me? I'm shocked! Ok, in all seriousness, I guess she was good, but I didn't like her that much tonight. Some of her vocal affectations were bothering me. I don't know, I guess I wasn't that interested.

Anoop: When Ryan said "Beat It", I said what? I didn't think he was that horrible, but that song didn't fit him at all. I think his fanbase will save him, but he'll have to get it together sooner than later.

Jorge: The worst of the night for me. I agreed with Simon, I couldn't wait for his song to be over. He's so cheesy that I find it uncomfortable to watch. And the arrangement was elevator music at it's best. I'm bored. Bye Jorge.

Megan: Wow, Simon, you didn't realize that she was awkward and that her dancing was horrible before tonight? Where were you? I actually thought that it wasn't as bad as before, at least, she didn't stay behind the microphone stand. The vocals are still not pleasant though.

Adam: It's weird, what happened with Danny actually happened in reverse with Adam tonight. I was starting to like him more and more in the last few weeks, but tonight destroyed a lot of that. I found him over the top and cheesy tonight (contrary to over the top but entertaining in the semis). It felt a bit ridiculous watching him strutting on stage. I wasn't a big fan of the voice in the first place, but I was counting on being entertained and I wasn't. After the tongue bath, I even watched his performance again to see if I had missed something, but I didn't find any redeeming element the second time around.

Matt: It's funny, before he even started, I felt like I wanted him to do well. He was good at the piano, but I'm not blown away yet. His vocal control needs work.

Alexis: I liked her better than the judges. She's my favorite girl. I almost couldn't believe that Paula and Simon told her to watch her oversinging after kneeling at the alter of Adam a few minutes before. She didn't look to be thrilled by her number 36 though!

My favorites: Danny, Kris and Alexis, with a special mention for Matt.
My least favorites: Jorge, Michael and Megan.

Who goes home: Jorge I hope. Other than that it's hard to call. I just hope it's not Kris!
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
First, missaddicted, thanks for the link! I never saw the site, and I really liked the Idolatry videos -- I agreed with a lot of what they said and I'll be visiting that site often! Seriously enjoyed it.

I don't think I'm going to like the "surprise" tomorrow. I have heard various rumblings -- do you think you know what it is, missaddicted?

I don't see why they seem to want to give the judges more say, and the voters less (wild card, e. g.). The viewers choosing who stays or goes is, in my opinion, what the show is all about. It's really the whole concept. There's something fair and also something irrefutable when millions of people vote. It is what it is. The decisions of four people are not what the show is about.

Okay. My recaps, with my actual notes written during the show in italics. Heh.

"Pedantic ross" also graded everyone tonight.

Lil. The Way You Make Me Feel. Sorry, but the first thing I noticed was the unflattering outfit. Last week, she looked good in a retro-style dress. The white pants were not good. The top wasn't good, either, actually. She needs to sing something where she shows some vulnerability. But she does come out there with a lot of energy and sings well. Not a great song choice. B+ to A-

Scott. It was good to see him at the piano, he seemed more comfortable. He seems like a sweet guy. I like him. Wish I liked his singing more. I did like it a bit more than usual; he was far less pitchy and a few notes were beautiful. Very dull song choice, though. B

Danny. Whoa, he can sing! I liked his excess energy. I didn't mind his dancing, as I took it to be just improvised moves like a singer might do in a concert setting, not choreography. I would go to see this guy in concert. I love his voice. I liked that he kicked it. He proved he's not just a "church singer." Nice family; his parents maybe should have gotten him braces, though. A

Michael. You're Not Alone. It was likeable and warm, involving, well-done. Nothing really special, but enough to keep him around. Sort of a thinnish tone, but mostly nice. B+

Jasmine. I'm not sure why they want her there, but now they have to defend putting her there, and they seemed to be doing that tonight. (Kara: "You did it, you sold it, great stage presence." :?: ) My notes on her performance: Flat, sharp, whatever, painful. I want her gone, I can't take it every week. Poor kid is way out of her depth. C

Kris. Remember The Time. He had a lot of charm and sounded great. I smiled all the way through. Though there was a little something awkward, as I think Simon accurately said. I don't actually think he needed a guitar for this song, and it seemed to anchor him to one spot and to the mike stand. (And like Drew Wright, his voice disappeared when he moved away from the mike.) Other than that, I love his voice, and he's got presence. Liked how he brought more energy this time, too. I want to hear him do a song where he shows off his vocal ability a bit more, though. Wife is shooting daggers at Simon. lol A

Allison. I find her pitchy. And I think she might turn out to be a one-trick pony. She really isn't my style. I don't always like rocker-chick singing, but for what it was, it was professional, and for her age, kind of great. B+ to A-

Anoop. He got a pre-song interview, for some reason. :?: :?: Mediocre. Not much energy. The performance never took off. I haven't thought a lot of his singing since Hollywood week. He's a slightly better performer than a singer, but not tonight. Amateur night in Dixie. C-

Jorge. His explanation for why he chose the song made sense to me; he had to find somthing that suited his voice. Unfortunately, he set himself up for a funny line from Simon. Jorge: "I couldn't sing Bad, by Michael Jackson." Simon: "I think you just did." Very '80's. Sounded like the theme from the Love Boat. B or B-

Megan. Rockin' Robin. I can't see her as the American Idol. She's Simon's idea of "current?" Awkward. C

Adam. Great song choice. He sang it like a personal statement. I don't really love the tone of his voice (yet?) but I'm amazed at the power and range of it -- and his performance skills are awesome. I couldn't believe his face when they were praising him. He was almost in tears. Go, Adam. A

Matt. Pitchy, to me, but at least he has soul, a sense of rhythm. He's obviously musical. I don't know what to make of him yet. At times he sounded like a sick cat. Don't really get the love, but I have some like. B

Alexis. Not as good as I hoped. I didn't like her outfit, and the whole thing was overblown. I'm not sure she understands who she is as an artist, as cliche as that sounds at this point. B+
 
Last edited:

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Dialidol results. I don't know if this counts as a spoiler, but I'll put it in white lettering and it can be scrolled over to see it. Keep in mind Megan Joy is the VFTW pick.
25.836 Danny Gokey
22.572 Adam Lambert
18.128 Lil Rounds
15.140 Alexis Grace
15.044 Anoop Desai
13.501 Scott MacIntyre
12.643 Matt Giraud
12.638 Michael Sarver
12.535 Megan Joy
12.490 Kris Allen
12.357 Jasmine Murray
11.488 Allison Iraheta
10.440 Jorge Nunez


12.490 Kris Allen
12.357 Jasmine Murray
11.488 Allison Iraheta
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
Yeah, I was following Dialidol last night, but apart from the first 4, it could be anybody. They're all within the margin of error so it's too close to call.

For the "surprise", I don't really want to try to guess, but MJ posted what it might actually be. I guess we'll know soon enough, the show is in a little more than 2 hours.

I came home early today and I actually rewatched all the performances, fast-forwarding everything else. So here are my second opinions:

Lil: My opinion didn't change. She was good enough, but not amazing, and the outfit was horrible.

Scott: He was ok, but so very boring.

Danny: Still liked him a lot, except for the ugly jacket, and I'm looking forward to buying the studio version from iTunes tonight!

Michael: His singing was ok, but apart from the last glory note, I noted that he had trouble staying on a note for more than a second. His voice is always wobbling between notes and I think that's what I didn't like. I still found him incredibly boring though. I differ from you ross here, I want him gone as soon as possible, he's just not interesting to me.

Jasmine: I had trouble getting through her performance a second time. I didn't think she sang that badly, it's just her tone that is not really pleasant to me.

Kris: Still loved it of course. One of the last "fell" of his song, he sounded exactly like Jason Mraz, he did it exactly like Mraz would do it. Which is a big plus since Mraz is my favorite singer, he's got amazing vocal chops. I still loved seeing him with his guitar, he seemed more comfortable and it sets him apart from the others. He still had a lot of energy though even with the guitar. I'll also be buying his song tonight.

Michael Slezak also really liked Kris last night and put him as the second best of the night I think. I don't know why, but it made me happy that he liked him too.

Allison: A lot of people really really liked her, but while I like her attitude and that she's not boring like Jasmine, I wasn't that impressed with her vocals. And her pronunciation wasn't very good, she sounded like she was saying "Hive in to me".

Anoop: His vocals were ok, but he didn't have the attitude to pull off that song. Better luck next time Anoop.

Jorge: I couldn't get through his performance a second time. I hope he leaves tonight.

Megan: I just watched her again to catch her "caw, caw" at the end, since I had missed it last night. Other than that, no interest watsoever.

Adam: I liked him slightly better today. I did liked that he did the song as a personal statement and I liked the beginning of the song. When he went right in front of the judges, that's when he lost me, that part was too OTT for me.

Matt: Again, I liked the beginning of the song, but the falsetto part at the end was just really weird. He's a bit JT-light at the moment, so I hope he gets better.

Alexis: I kind of agree with you that she might not know who she is as an artist just yet (and I'm not sure that's even the type of artist that I would buy an album from), but I still really liked her performance.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Wow, missaddicted, I admire your dedication! I really enjoyed your recaps of your recaps! I never have re-watched a whole show's worth of performances, but I've got 40 minutes before the show, I'm doing laundry, have a few minutes to kill, so I'm going to quickly give another look to some of the performances, at least.

LIL. She has a big voice I can see being thrilled by in a church, but it didn't suit song and she just did what she always does, and it's getting boring.

SCOTT. For some reason I actually liked it better.

DANNY. He needs a makeover (and when did he gain weight?), but he is a really awesome singer; he's totally in control of "his instrument," wow, I loved it vocally. Performance itself was really no better than your brother-in-law after a few beers at a wedding. CooCooTheBirdGirl said the voice is distinctive, but, to me it isn't, I wouldn't recognize it at this point. Not that I consider something like that a drawback, especially -- I just don't agree with her on it.

MICHAEL. Yeah, he's just okay. Well, he's better than okay, he has a voice, but he seriously needs lessons and coaching. He does a lot wrong. I like the guy and I suppose I want to cut him some slack. But he wasn't great.

JASMINE. Why is she there?

KRIS. His vocal was more ragged on second listen, but in a concert it would be like that, I didn't have a problem with it. I think you (and, who? Paula?) had a good observation re Jason Mraz. I also think he is about the closest to a CI6 vibe that there is in this AI season. I hope he stays.

ALLISON: Same opinion of it as before. Maybe I wouldn't grade her so high, though.

ANOOP: Not an epic fail, but far from good.

Okay, nine minutes to showtime...gotta stop now


 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
So, the twist isn't so bad I guess. At least they'll only be able to use it once. I guess it'll depend on which contestant they decide to save! But sometimes, it's better to go out as the shock boot than to overstay your welcome.

Goodbye Jasmine and Jorge, you won't be missed, by me anyway. I'm really glad that Kris is still there and that he'll hopefully get to sing something else than a Michael Jackson song!

Wow, the group number was cheesetastic. And they were doing lipsync, in no way was that live, they were barely singing in their microphones.

I've been a fan of Kelly Clarkson since her second album and I love her new CD, I've been listening to it non-stop for two days, but I've rarely seen her live. I was a bit disappointed tonight. I thought she sounded a bit rough and I was a bit perplexed by her apparent lack of energy. I mean, I can barely stay seated when I hear her song, but she just sang it like it was another boring ballad. She wasn't the most charismatic pop star tonight. Am I too harsh?

I just bought Kris' and Danny's songs from iTunes and I'm a bit underwhelmed, both are heavy on the cheesy keyboards.

We don't what the theme is next week, do we?
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
I confess the group number had already slipped my mind, missaddicted. The main thing I noticed was how well Scott did in it. And how Jorge and Kris moved better than the others.

Re the twist: I don't especially like the idea of the judges' rejection, following on the heels of the person having learned they didn't get enough votes to advance. A bit too much rejection for comfort. Besides, not getting enough votes -- yet still knowing you did get thousands of votes -- isn't so bad. Having to sing for your salvation, and then having to listen to the four people sitting there saying "no, sorry" in front of a huge audience -- yuch. One thing I liked most about this kind of show is that once the "Top" group has been chosen -- e. g., the Top 24 of last season's Canadian Idol -- the judges were through deciding who stayed or went. It was completely up to the voters. Oh, well.

Wow, the group number was cheesetastic. And they were doing lipsync, in no way was that live, they were barely singing in their microphones.

The only thing I was noticing was how well Scott was doing in the choreography.
I wish they would let him sit at the piano for one of these numbers. Maybe they could all sit, a la the Top 24 group sings, on CI6. They're not dancers, anyway. Well, except Kris. Heh. And Jorge. Who is no more.

I've been a fan of Kelly Clarkson since her second album and I love her new CD, I've been listening to it non-stop for two days, but I've rarely seen her live. I was a bit disappointed tonight. I thought she sounded a bit rough and I was a bit perplexed by her apparent lack of energy. I mean, I can barely stay seated when I hear her song, but she just sang it like it was another boring ballad. She wasn't the most charismatic pop star tonight. Am I too harsh?

I never heard Kelly Clarkson more than a couple of times in my life, so I'm probably not a good judge. Personally I didn't like the song. Is it common on this show to make contestants (and audience) wait through the guest artist's song in order to hear the verdict?

Kanye made no big impression, but I think he's overrated, anyway. Not sure why he was there.

We don't what the theme is next week, do we?

Funny they didn't announce it. Is it on the AI website, I wonder?

I just bought Kris' and Danny's songs from iTunes and I'm a bit underwhelmed, both are heavy on the cheesy keyboards.

Whose stuff did you like better (itunes), Danny or Kris? Do they do their own songs?
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
I agree with you about the "twist". I would prefer if the judges didn't have any say at all. But I prefer this scenario over a sing-off between the bottom 2 and then the judges deciding who goes home, for example. At least it doesn't give them too much power. I almost wish that the one who will be saved will be booted again the week after just to show the judges that the viewers don't care about their veto. And, yes, two rejections in a few minutes is a bit much.

Is it common on this show to make contestants (and audience) wait through the guest artist's song in order to hear the verdict?

Well, it's different each week I would say. But there were two people going home this week though so it was even more different than usual. Usually, it's just a commercial break.

I didn't say anything about Kanye because I've already made myself forget about him. I hate hip hop music in general (except M.I.A's Paper Planes), and Kanye is definitely overrated.

We'll probably hear about next week's theme in the media in the next few days. I'm pretty sure David Cook is going to be there singing his new single. Well, he'll release two singles at the same time (Come Back to Me for top40/HAC radio and Bar-ba-sol for rock radio), but he'll probably sing Come Back to Me, which isn't my favorite on the album and I wonder if he'll be able to make it more exciting live or not. It's still going to be great to see him there on the stage where I first discovered him! Did you get a chance to listen to his album? You didn't like it and you don't want to tell me?

On iTunes, you can find studio versions of the songs they did on the show, the whole song. I have to say that I'm really unsure about both Danny's and Kris' songs. I also wanted to listen to Adam's and Matt's song (well the 30 seconds snippet), but iTunes is not letting me right now. I want to see how Adam sounds on a recording. Not to go back too much on David Cook, but last year, I bought all the studio versions of his songs (and the videos) and I still listen to a good number of them (the studio version of Billie Jean is still killing me every time I hear it). They really seemed to be of better quality than the two I bought tonight. We'll see, maybe I'll get used to the cheesy keybords.

ETA: Well, I just saw the theme for next week: Grand Ole Opry. Ugh, country music, I almost hate it more than hip hop music. Could make or break certain contestants though.
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
Apparently, I was completely wrong Cook is not going to be on AI next week at all. Carrie Underwood, Randy Travis and Brad Paisley will be there. Which fits with the theme for the week. Bleh, country music.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Apparently, I was completely wrong Cook is not going to be on AI next week at all. Carrie Underwood, Randy Travis and Brad Paisley will be there. Which fits with the theme for the week. Bleh, country music.

Get out your cowboy hats, folks. The first person I think about re country week is Adam. He will probably do just great. Being in theatre has probably helped him be adaptable to different genres. But I'm wondering what he's going to sing. Stand By Your Man? lol His usual look won't cut it, either. Yet anything too cowboy and you're talking Village People.

So you have never heard one of Adam's recordings? Or do you just mean his iTunes/Idol stuff? This is one of his recordings, Pop Goes the Camera.

I don't have any love for country music. I can't believe a lot of AI viewers are country fans, though I may be totally wrong. I actually like a lot of hip-hop, but I'm only in the mood for it when I'm in the mood for it. Kanye, though: uh-uh. What a poseur.

David Cook:

Did you get a chance to listen to his album? You didn't like it and you don't want to tell me?

I haven't listened to it yet! But I did hear it in a record store. There was a store near where I live, and the manager was a big Idol fan and especially a Cook fan. (The store was a casualty of the bad economy, unfortunately.) I heard parts of the album two different times I was in the store (incl. the bonus track of Eleanor Rigby. Don't know if this was on the disc, or a download). I mostly really liked it, though as I think you said it sounds a bit...well, you didn't say "generic rock album," but that is how I would put it, myself. Just a bit, though. Still, for an "Idol" album, it's really very good. But I have yet to actually get the chance to give it a good listen. He's a great singer.

I'm a bit worried the save could be used for Anoop or another wild card contestant, which would really be a case of the judges forcing somebody on the populace, methinks.

I've smiled as Kris gets a bit more popular on the forums. He may even end up being the "safe" choice between Adam and Danny, at some point.
He's definitely a dark horse -- hope he can hang on. What is this "404 Server Not Found" joke at his expense? Grrr...
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
Thanks for the link. I listened to it for a second time since I actually listened to it last weekend and it's ok I guess, the chorus is catchy. Dance music is really hit or miss with me though. For example, I really like "Just Dance" by Lady Gaga, but I can't stand any of her other stuff.

What I especially wanted to know was if I could enjoy the studio version of his song this week or if it was as OTT as the live performance. I went on a shopping spree this morning and you know what, I really like his song. His vocals are mostly enjoyable and he really makes the song work (and I can actually understand the words, contrary to MJ's version).

I also bought Alexis' and Matt's songs. I like them both. I really like the energy that Alexis brought to the song. Matt's song is a bit on the cheesy side and there's still a bit too much falsetto, but it's good. And I have to admit that I got used to the cheesy keyboards on Kris' and Danny's songs. I just try to concentrate on their voices and it works. I love both their voices. You know, if you had told me a few weeks ago that I would buy 5 of the 13 songs from this week, I wouldn't have believed you, so I guess it's a good sign for the rest of the season!

I mostly really liked it, though as I think you said it sounds a bit...well, you didn't say "generic rock album," but that is how I would put it, myself. Just a bit, though. Still, for an "Idol" album, it's really very good. But I have yet to actually get the chance to give it a good listen. He's a great singer.

Oh, I think I did use the term generic when describing his album, because that's exactly what I think. Not as generic as Nickelback let's say, but still. It's weird because when I first bought it, I wasn't as enthusiastic about it as most of his fans. But now, most of the songs really grew on me and I can't get tired of his voice. A lot of his fans (well, the ones I "see" on the forums) treat his music (and him) as if it was the best thing since sliced bread, but I'm more realistic. I think it's a solid album and I just hope that he has the chance to make several more to really show what he his capable of.

Get out your cowboy hats, folks. The first person I think about re country week is Adam. He will probably do just great. Being in theatre has probably helped him be adaptable to different genres. But I'm wondering what he's going to sing. Stand By Your Man? lol His usual look won't cut it, either. Yet anything too cowboy and you're talking Village People.

I think what will be interesting will be to see if some of them can make the song their own, as cliché as that sounds. I don't want them to come out with the cowboy boots and the hat, I want them to take a country song and do it in their respective style. I'm asking for a lot, am I? I hope I'll be surprised.

I'm a bit worried the save could be used for Anoop or another wild card contestant, which would really be a case of the judges forcing somebody on the populace, methinks.

I'm not sure the judges like Anoop that much. They just know that he's really popular for some reason. But I could totally be wrong. The most valid prediction that I saw would be that they could use it on Lil. I guess it would be a possibility for people to get tired of her (since she doesn't bring anything new, in my opinion of course, but it seems to be a popular opinion) before the top 5, so that they could use the "save" to save her. We'll see.

I've smiled as Kris gets a bit more popular on the forums. He may even end up being the "safe" choice between Adam and Danny, at some point.
He's definitely a dark horse -- hope he can hang on. What is this "404 Server Not Found" joke at his expense? Grrr...

Yeah, I didn't read that many opinions about the show, only a couple of pages from the episode thread on TWoP (and Slezak's favorable opinion of course), but I got that people seemed to like him. I still think it's because he brings something a bit different than a lot of the others. Not to mention that he's a very likeable guy and he brings the pretty. Should he have kept his wife a secret? I hope not, but I was a teenage girl not that long ago... Was it on TWoP that you saw that he was gaining in popularity or elsewhere? I also hope he can hang on for a while because he's the one from that bunch that I would most see myself buying music from.

On the TV Guide website today, they had a poll asking people who their favorite from the top 11 is and you know, with all the Danny "hate" that I've read on TWoP, I was almost surprised to see that he was leading with 33% of the 2000 votes that had been casted when I checked. Adam was second with 24%. The others were all left in the dust way behind (I think Lil was third with 9%). The fact is, I can't imagine Danny winning. It would probably be like Taylor Hicks 2.0, because he's not really marketable I think. As much as I like his voice, I don't really see where he would fit in the music business. Anyway, it's still really early in the competition and David Archuleta was probably leading these kind of polls at this point last season.

(Well, after writing that post, I went back to check on the poll, which has now 4500 votes and now Adam is in the lead with 30%, then Anoop with 26% and Danny at 22%. Lil is down at 5% and the others are at 1% or 3%. Anoop really? He's not even really good. Likeable, yes, but I need more than that, he hasn't been that impressive yet. Well, I think it's the kind of poll that people can vote for many times, so it might not mean anything at all!)
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
I think what will be interesting will be to see if some of them can make the song their own, as cliché as that sounds. I don't want them to come out with the cowboy boots and the hat, I want them to take a country song and do it in their respective style. I'm asking for a lot, am I? I hope I'll be surprised.

You may be -- this may even turn out to be one of the better episodes; when people have to go outside their comfort zones, it can sometimes work. I think the genres are fun for what they show you about the singers -- as singers and personalities.

On the TV Guide website today, they had a poll asking people who their favorite from the top 11 is and you know, with all the Danny "hate" that I've read on TWoP, I was almost surprised to see that he was leading with 33% of the 2000 votes that had been casted when I checked. Adam was second with 24%. The others were all left in the dust way behind (I think Lil was third with 9%). The fact is, I can't imagine Danny winning. It would probably be like Taylor Hicks 2.0, because he's not really marketable I think. As much as I like his voice, I don't really see where he would fit in the music business. Anyway, it's still really early in the competition and David Archuleta was probably leading these kind of polls at this point last season.

(Well, after writing that post, I went back to check on the poll, which has now 4500 votes and now Adam is in the lead with 30%, then Anoop with 26% and Danny at 22%. Lil is down at 5% and the others are at 1% or 3%. Anoop really? He's not even really good. Likeable, yes, but I need more than that, he hasn't been that impressive yet. Well, I think it's the kind of poll that people can vote for many times, so it might not mean anything at all!)

Thanks for sharing this. I wouldn't find a lot of this stuff on my own!

The show is so schizoid. People are hoping to get recording contracts, so they compete for votes by being more like TV stars or performers than recording artists. How many actual recording artists would be any good at it? The show is all about discovering the next recording star, yet it's TV, so it creates TV stars. Anoop, for example. If there were still TV variety shows, a lot of these people could get their own shows and work for years. Instead they get 15 minutes.

About Kris:

Was it on TWoP that you saw that he was gaining in popularity or elsewhere? I also hope he can hang on for a while because he's the one from that bunch that I would most see myself buying music from.

I saw a lot of positive remarks about him on TWoP, yeah. And not really any negative ones I can recall.

Hey, I'm thinking he may do well next week. He already has the twang, right? And the guitar.

I really enjoy the stuff you uncover and your opinions so keep 'em coming!
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
I thought it was another pretty good show tonight, even though I dislike country music very much. But I have some complaints about the performance order. I mean I know I shouldn't expect fairness from the AI TPTB, but Kris went again in the first hour of the show and Matt and Megan went towards the end once again, especially Matt, who had the pimp spot tonight and was second to last last week. Also, I'm maybe the only one who thought about that but Kris and Allison, since the semis, have always performed in the same segment, one after the other. Do I spend too much time reading the Grassy Knoll?

My recap of the performances:

Michael: Well, he wasn't as boring as last week, but I think I would still vote for the harmonica player before voting for him. The song he did is exactly the type of country song I really dislike.

Allison: She's getting a lot of hype I guess, but she leaves me rather cold. Actually she reminds me a bit of Mookie. What I mean is, they're both young, they're both cool, but I don't feel any emotional connection at all. I think that's what Allison is lacking for me. She's still young though.

Kris: Ah, I just love his tone. And with him, I did feel the emotional connection, I was pretty much captivated. I was a bit worried that I would find him boring without his guitar and sitting on a stool like that, but I loved him. Did I mention that I loved his tone? Love it, even with the slight vocal imperfections. I also really liked his reaction to Simon's comments, he was just genuinely happy to get his approval. Please be safe once again Kris!

By the way, ross, did you listen to his original songs? I was wondering when they were going to come out. MJ posted them on her blog. They're not the best songs ever, but I really really like them. Definitely one type of music that I enjoy.

Lil: I didn't like this at all. I thought her style was horrible again and her voice was really shaky. Not to mention that the song didn't fit her at all. So contrary to what she said, she didn't show me at all that she could change things up and still make it work. Oh, and I just wanted to tell her to shut up when the judges were giving their comments. And I can't believe Randy told her she should have done IWALY. That would have been even worse, in my opinion.

Adam: Adam is driving me crazy. Seriously. I can't decide if I want to be on the love train or off (definitely not on the hate train though, I really like him, if not his OTT style sometimes). I'm very much on the love train tonight. His performance was so weird, but I just loved it... except for the faces, they're still a bit much. I loved his vocals like that. Randy Travis's reaction to him was priceless, but I still cringed a little. So what if he wears nail polish?

I have to admit that it was a slow day yesterday and I watched a lot of his videos, most of them I hadn't watched yet. I must admit I'm kinda smitten with him. If that's even possible. I guess I just enjoy that there's a contestants like him on a show like AI. He took a big drop tonight it seems if I look at the "results" from Dialidol.

OK, getting back to my recap:

Scott: He has to go, seriously. There's boring and there's BORING. He chooses the most boring songs and his vocals are not up to par.

Alexis: I liked her vocals and didn't really find her off-pitch, but her mannerisms bothered me a bit tonight. Too many unnecessary hand and head movements for the song.

Danny: I stay as far as possible from Carrie's songs. Jesus, Take the Wheel? Not a song I would want on my iPod. He was ok I guess, but he does start to grate a little, maybe the hate is getting a bit to me. And Jesus, Take the Wheel, really? I like you when you're fun Danny, not when you sing about Jesus. At least, the wedding ring didn't make a comeback.

Anoop: It was nice and a very good comeback from him. In the "tender and honest" department, I prefer Kris though.

Megan "I dropped my last name" Joy: Well, she was sick, which almost makes me want to be kind to her. But I can't really. I disliked the arrangement and her vocals are still very unpleasant to my ears.

Matt: I still haven't really made up my mind about his performance. The vocals were ok, but I didn't find them outstanding. I'll probably like the recording though. The thing is, he made the song sound a bit like what a coronation song would sound like and I found the arrangement a bit lite-FM. I'm not sure that's really a compliment. I still want to see more from him, because right now, I can't say that he's "piercing my heart" (tm Paula) with his singing.

Who's going home? Scott or Michael hopefully. Or Megan, but I don't think so. I want to see more from the others.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
To me, Kris had the night's best performance. Along with vocal ability, he has taste, the song was beautifully realized; his judgement as a performer is right on, and he comes across as sincere, real, and very professional. Plus I totally love his voice. I thought it was beautiful. Way to go.

Our local Fox newscast had a segment on the show, and led off with Kris's vocal because it was the anchorman's favorite of the night (good taste, man.) (His partner liked Anoop.)

I agree with the judges that Scott's song/performance was really similar to last week's, but he did say he's "lost a lot of hat picks." He didn't overawe me but he's growing on me for some reason. I love him personally, he's an awesome guy; but I'm also beginning to realize he really is a touching singer and performer; I wish his voice was stronger, but he does bring a lot of feeling to what he sings and I appreciate that side of him.

Michael's was the one believable country performance of the night, so it gets some points just for that. At least he could perform the genre. Not exactly brilliant, but it did come across as authentic. Allison adapted to country surprisingly easily, singing with a country-rock sound that worked for the song. Nice vocal quality. Sweet personality, interacting with the judges and Ryan.

I have to give Lil credit for trying to be true to the genre, also. Her voice often sounded beautiful. Unfortunately, the performance lacked energy, and maybe conviction. It was somewhat dull. This week and last week seem to prove she really can't sing very far out of her own genre/style. There's really nothing wrong with that, but it doesn't work too well with the show's concept.

Uh...who else sang? Oh, yeah. Danny. I thought perhaps he oversang. I love the sound of his voice, but tonight something about it seemed forced, and it wasn't involving. Actually he seemed somewhat nervous, to me. Anoop sang pretty well; I think his voice is good, but ordinary. His delivery lacked originality. Still, this was by far the best thing he's done that I've seen. He held my attention without really blowing me away. Alexis was pitchy but that didn't bother me as much as her emotionless, flat delivery. To me, it was like she wasn't thinking about what she was singing. Still, she was better than Megan, who was sick with the flu. Lucky for her, because I think the sympathy vote will save her this week. The judges' overpimping of her is weird; I think she's terrible.

Adam was ridiculous. I think that version would have been okay in a club, where most of the people in the audience were fans or friends. For this show it was too esoteric and arty. And I'm beginning to wonder if he can sing anything without trying to sex it up. I'm not feeling the love tonight. Matt just somehow never makes any impression on me. I have to practically force myself to pay attention when he comes on my tv screen. I don't know why. So I guess if you like what he does, it was good.

ETA: missaddicted, thanks for the heads-up re Kris's songs. I haven't been over to mj's blog today. I'll have to wait till tomorrow to check out his music. Yeah, now that you mention it, I've noticed Kris never gets on later in the show, and Matt is always on near or at the end. This stuff annoys me! I hadn't noticed how Kris and Allison are always paired up, though. Strange!
 
Last edited:

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
Well, I guess we're not always in agreement ross! I mean we agree about Kris and some others, but our opinions on Scott and Adam are very very different. It's funny because Scott doesn't make me feel anything. At all. He feels very robotic to me. At this point, I really can't see anything redeeming about him.

About Adam, I mean, yes his performance was a bit ridiculous, but I enjoyed the fact that it was just different. He's extremely polarizing for sure. Anyway, I don't think any contestant ever left me feeling so ambivalent about them. I also just appreciate the fact that he's so much more interesting than most of the contestants left. He's more exciting.

About Matt, I agree with you that he doesn't make an impression. Maybe that's why I'm having trouble making my mind about him. He comes off as a bit bland too, not really likeable but you can't really hate him either (even though it seems that a lot of people seem to think he's a douche).

At least, we agree about Megan. I can't wait until she's out of there!
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
I liked Adam's previous two performances. He now seems narrower to me as an artist. I felt his attitude was "I don't do country," so he didn't try. Had he tried (as Anoop did) to meet the genre halfway he might have given a great performance. If he had taken it seriously. I don't mean he had to do a serious song. I mean he should have respected the genre. I don't feel he did.

There are many great country songs, as I think the evening's choices proved. "Ring Of Fire" is a good song. The offbeat sitar arrangement was fine, but what does the song have to do with that male Britney/Madonna act he's been doing every time he sings? The last two times, I didn't mind; it even fit Satisfaction, but this time the weird seductiveness was just embarrassing, and I wonder if the guy is just all about camping everything up.
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
*popping back in for a moment*

I really liked Adam last night. It was a bit odd to watch on AI but it was interesting and he sounded good.

but this is a really good point.

I felt his attitude was "I don't do country," so he didn't try.

At what point does making a song your own mean that you don't sing in the musical style of the "genre week" ? That's a good point. He did change the genres.. 'cause it really wasn't country music he was singing, although I liked it a lot.

I also liked Anoop a lot, and he did sing within the genre.

I missed a few singers last night, but I saw Adam, Scott and Anoop and Alexis. (hopefully I'm getting the names right - hee)

I loved Adam and Anoop, Scott bored me (although he does have a pleasing voice) and I thought Alexis didn't give Jolene enough angst.