Abortion demonstration just doesn't sound right.

DaSleeper

Trolling Hypocrites
May 27, 2007
33,676
1,666
113
Northern Ontario,
your arm is part of your body....right?

Just for laughs and giggles....try to find a surgeon that will cut of a good arm for you.

You'll get thrown in the loony bin...

Yet a woman is allowed and even encouraged in some cases to remove a viable part of her body

Her body. Should you be allowed to do what you want with your body or not?

Try to do that with an arm or a leg instead of a fetus and see how far you'll get;-)
 

damngrumpy

Executive Branch Member
Mar 16, 2005
9,949
21
38
kelowna bc
In a civilized society a solution is found when a compromise is found. Therefore we will
likely never find a solution as both sides of the argument believe they are totally right and
therefore there is no compromise. For decades I have listened to this thing go round and
round without an inch being given. Sometimes I also think we should allow abortion to be
applied retroactively in the case of some people but that won't work either.
The law is what it is, and as of now we should be concentrating on creating a better world
for the children who are already here. If we lead by example and raise children to be the
investment in the future we profess them to be instead of an expense, we would have more
success in seeing the abortion numbers go down. The abortion rates are a reflection of
how bad our society has progressed and it demonstrates just how dysfunctional we are.
I think it is a sad state of affairs when people can do this without a second thought or because
a child is inconvenient
 

PoliticalNick

The Troll Bashing Troll
Mar 8, 2011
7,940
0
36
Edson, AB
your arm is part of your body....right?

Just for laughs and giggles....try to find a surgeon that will cut of a good arm for you.

You'll get thrown in the loony bin...

Yet a woman is allowed and even encouraged in some cases to remove a viable part of her body
Actually a fetus is a parasite living in symbiosis with another human, not a part of the host's body. So if you want to start making nonsensical comparisons we could compare the fetus to an unwanted tapeworm. I actually think your comparison makes the case for pro-choicers though in the fact that we are granted inalienable human rights to have control over our bodies so if it is part of her body it is hers to do as she pleases. If your standard is about it being a viable part of your body them where does that put such things as kidney donation? Should we stop that too?

Pretty much typical of your idiotic comments (that you have every right to post) :lol: And what about young couples who can't have children who would give their eye teeth to adopt. This subject is much bigger than one selfish mother. :smile:
Wrong, the subject is very individual and personal. Unless you want to promote a 'big-brother' state where YOU have no control over YOUR body or life at all. Don't ever kid yourself that this is some broad spectrum issue. This comes down to an individual having the right to make choices about their life and body. We have laws that prevent having unwanted medical treatments forced upon us because we value the right to choose as individuals.

As previously stated before you spout about removing anothers right to make choices about themselves consider having choices you value removed from you. Where does the whole pro-life issue stop? Do we outlaw vasectomy and tubal ligation to appease the religious right? It is, as DaS puts it,'removing a viable part of the body'.
 

DaSleeper

Trolling Hypocrites
May 27, 2007
33,676
1,666
113
Northern Ontario,
Actually a fetus is a parasite living in symbiosis with another human, not a part of the host's body. So if you want to start making nonsensical comparisons we could compare the fetus to an unwanted tapeworm. I actually think your comparison makes the case for pro-choicers though in the fact that we are granted inalienable human rights to have control over our bodies so if it is part of her body it is hers to do as she pleases. If your standard is about it being a viable part of your body them where does that put such things as kidney donation? Should we stop that too?


Wrong, the subject is very individual and personal. Unless you want to promote a 'big-brother' state where YOU have no control over YOUR body or life at all. Don't ever kid yourself that this is some broad spectrum issue. This comes down to an individual having the right to make choices about their life and body. We have laws that prevent having unwanted medical treatments forced upon us because we value the right to choose as individuals.

As previously stated before you spout about removing anothers right to make choices about themselves consider having choices you value removed from you. Where does the whole pro-life issue stop? Do we outlaw vasectomy and tubal ligation to appease the religious right? It is, as DaS puts it,'removing a viable part of the body'.
Sorry for your loss......

Of common sense
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
In a civilized society a solution is found when a compromise is found. Therefore we will
likely never find a solution as both sides of the argument believe they are totally right and
therefore there is no compromise. For decades I have listened to this thing go round and
round without an inch being given. Sometimes I also think we should allow abortion to be
applied retroactively in the case of some people but that won't work either.
The law is what it is, and as of now we should be concentrating on creating a better world
for the children who are already here. If we lead by example and raise children to be the
investment in the future we profess them to be instead of an expense, we would have more
success in seeing the abortion numbers go down. The abortion rates are a reflection of
how bad our society has progressed and it demonstrates just how dysfunctional we are.
I think it is a sad state of affairs when people can do this without a second thought or because
a child is inconvenient

The problem I have Grumpy is the pros is everything to do with the mother and nothing to do with the child.
 

YukonJack

Time Out
Dec 26, 2008
7,026
73
48
Winnipeg
Arguing with idiots is something I leave to others:lol:

DaSleeper, am I the only one to think that PoliticalNick and CUBert are identical twins, separated at birth, or 'they' are the same 'person'?

And, of course, let us not forget those who are candidates for the quadruplet and the quintuplet status.
 

DaSleeper

Trolling Hypocrites
May 27, 2007
33,676
1,666
113
Northern Ontario,
DaSleeper, am I the only one to think that PoliticalNick and CUBert are identical twins, separated at birth, or 'they' are the same 'person'?

And, of course, let us not forget those who are candidates for the quadruplet and the quintuplet status.
Naaahh...they are not the same person....It's an illusion caused by the "Progressives'" herd mentality
 

Unforgiven

Force majeure
May 28, 2007
6,770
137
63
Try to do that with an arm or a leg instead of a fetus and see how far you'll get;-)

Well for a while there were preop transgender men that would cut off their own penis and then the hospital would complete the operation until they stopped preventing transgender operations.

I expect that if you cut of your hand and tossed it into the garburator you would get the operations you need to live without the hand, rehab and prosthetic while never having a charge leveled against you.

As it was before the prochoice law was enacted, women still had abortions. Unregulated, some ending in death of the woman and the fetus.

Prohibition doesn't work.

Arguing with idiots is something I leave to others:lol:

Come on we argue all the time! :blackeye: heh heh

Poor baby! Do you need a Kleenex?

Was the question too hard for you? Should I sue smaller words maybe one or two syllables?
I could use two kleenex though, this honker is too much for just one. :p
 

YukonJack

Time Out
Dec 26, 2008
7,026
73
48
Winnipeg
Of course prohibition does not work.

Murder is prohibited, yet, there are murders.
Robbery is prohibited, yet, there are robberies.
Rape is prohibited, yet, there are rapes.

Shall I go on?

However, none of them sanctioned and encouraged by law and paid for by taxpayers' money, except, of course the murder and butchering of an innocent human life, a 'medical' procedure commonly known as abortion.
 

Unforgiven

Force majeure
May 28, 2007
6,770
137
63
In a civilized society a solution is found when a compromise is found. Therefore we will
likely never find a solution as both sides of the argument believe they are totally right and
therefore there is no compromise. For decades I have listened to this thing go round and
round without an inch being given. Sometimes I also think we should allow abortion to be
applied retroactively in the case of some people but that won't work either.
The law is what it is, and as of now we should be concentrating on creating a better world
for the children who are already here. If we lead by example and raise children to be the
investment in the future we profess them to be instead of an expense, we would have more
success in seeing the abortion numbers go down. The abortion rates are a reflection of
how bad our society has progressed and it demonstrates just how dysfunctional we are.
I think it is a sad state of affairs when people can do this without a second thought or because
a child is inconvenient

I say you do what you want with your body and I'll take care of mine. Simple and inline with our cultural of freedom.
 

CDNBear

Custom Troll
Sep 24, 2006
43,839
207
63
Ontario
I'm not religious, I don't believe in God. There are no fundamental principles in the spirituality I do believe. I am for the most part, Pro choice and I believe life begins at conception. No matter what anybody says, abortion is the act of killing life, full stop.

I also recognize a need for some changes to the system, abortion has become a form of birth control.

Arguing with idiots is something I leave to others:lol:
It's tiring, but entertaining...

I say you do what you want with your body and I'll take care of mine. Simple and inline with our cultural of freedom.
How many abortions have you had?
 

Unforgiven

Force majeure
May 28, 2007
6,770
137
63
Of course prohibition does not work.

So why bother with prohibition if it doesn't work?

Murder is prohibited, yet, there are murders.
Robbery is prohibited, yet, there are robberies.
Rape is prohibited, yet, there are rapes.

All inflicted on those with rights.

Shall I go on?

Your point is moot so going on, which is something you have a tendency to do regardless of whether you should or not, it is entirely your decision.

However, none of them sanctioned and encouraged by law and paid for by taxpayers' money, except, of course the murder and butchering of an innocent human life, a 'medical' procedure commonly known as abortion.

Except that isn't what an abortion is at all. It's the removal of cells from a womans body that are unwanted. It's not an innocent human life, it's an unaware group of cells. Chances are it will if allowed to, develop into a human baby once it is born and free of the woman's body.

Ratcheting up the rhetoric isn't going to win you any arguments. You have a chance to make a real point here and perhaps change someone's mind so why don't you work at building a reasonable argument refuting the points raised from the pro choice position if that is your desire?
 

PoliticalNick

The Troll Bashing Troll
Mar 8, 2011
7,940
0
36
Edson, AB
However, none of them sanctioned and encouraged by law and paid for by taxpayers' money, except, of course the murder and butchering of an innocent human life, a 'medical' procedure commonly known as abortion.

Please do show us this law that encourages abortion. Also show us the legal rulings where a fetus is determined to be a human life and where abortion is equivalant to murder.

Of course you can't do that because none of it exists and you are just running off your pig-headed mouth trying to impose your morality and view of the world upon others.
 

Unforgiven

Force majeure
May 28, 2007
6,770
137
63
I'm not religious, I don't believe in God. There are no fundamental principles in the spirituality I do believe. I am for the most part, Pro choice and I believe life begins at conception. No matter what anybody says, abortion is the act of killing life, full stop.

Life is the act of dying over time. I don't know when life begins. I'm not even sure everyone I meet is alive. I am like you in that I believe in choice. While I would like to have the conversation about when abortion is no longer appropriate, so far there hasn't been a discussion on this topic that can get past pro/anti positions.

I also recognize a need for some changes to the system, abortion has become a form of birth control.

Ah yes but that can of worms is one no one is eager to open

It's tiring, but entertaining...

People are passionate about this subject without question.

How many abortions have you had?

It's a good question and I think you for asking it.

When I met my wife, I knew right away that she was my soul mate. You've heard that word tossed around before I am sure but in my case, it is very accurate in describing our relationship. Three days after I met her we moved in together. Very young, she just finishing her last year of high school.

Not an easy go of it but hardship build character.

Within a couple of months, my wife became pregnant. She was scared, we talked about it and I told her that it's fine, kids are great and it's nothing we can't manage together. Granted not the way I would have wished for, but life happens at it's own pace.

Under threat of death, violence, shunning, logic, reason compassion, good advice and wisdom, I defended our relationship and the life of my unborn son against all comers. While I accepted advice on the ways and means, I would brook no nonsense about our abilities or lifestyle. In time all fell away like chaff in the wind.

We had our first kid with all the joy and terror that comes with the first one. All was fine, healthy wee chap and healthy happy wife. No clue as to what we were doing but we learned through experience and gained advice from others who had been through it. Made mistakes but none too big they couldn't be fixed.

I made that happen through sheer will and the trust and support of my wife.

That trust is what put the onus on me to make things right. My wife had the option to have an abortion, give the baby up, split up with me and keep the baby and she chose to put her trust in me to make a life for us and our family.

We were very young, and of the sort to rise to the challenge. You have kids, you know what that means.
There was little faith for us by those who should and eventually did support our decision. No matter, if you are parenting material, there are no barriers that can stand against your will.

That is the key, "Parenting Material". Not everyone is made for it. While some kids will grow up in a pretty good home with parents that try hard to raise their kids right, some won't. You've seen it in all likelihood in some friend of your kids or a kid at the school they went to at some point. Some kids are so abused, they kill themselves before they can get to any of the good stuff. They suffer so much and some succumb to that vile abuse and die at the hands of those very people charged with being the loving supportive people in their lives.

How much suffering is justified?

If someone knows they are going to make a life a terrible thing, they shouldn't be bringing kids into this world. But sh!t happens. People use it as birth control and that shouldn't happen but it's accepted because we can't bring ourselves to have that rational discussion about this subject without those very passionate about their position polarizing the discussion and ending the calm point based exchange.

So it's all on and don't talk about it. Both sides sit seething and outraged waiting for the time when someone does open that can of worms and things get out of hand.

Thanks for asking that question mate.

Our two kids, a boy and a girl have both managed to make it to the age of majority intact inspite of our parenting skills. heh heh Neither have kids of their own yet. Though with the older one, we're starting to nag about it as he's been married for a couple of years now and this old man is in need of a ready excuse for my childish behaviour. ;-)
 

gerryh

Time Out
Nov 21, 2004
25,756
295
83
"Pro-choice", "pro-abortion" is not about choice. It's about responsibility, or rather, the lack there of. A male and a female have a choice as to whether or not they have sex. If they choose to have sex, they are doing so knowing full well that thier "precautions" are not 100% effective. Therefore when they decide to engage in a little playtime, they are doing so with the full knowledge that it is possible that they may be starting a new life. Killing an innocent is NOT the responsible thing to do.


As an aside, it has always blown me away how a great many of those that scream about the innocent lives lost because of war have no problem with and fully support abortion. It is the same way on the right, many of those that cry out against abortion can always seem to justify "collateral damage". To me, a life is a life. One is not more precious or important than another.

"Pro-choice", "pro-abortion" is not about choice. It's about responsibility, or rather, the lack there of. A male and a female have a choice as to whether or not they have sex. If they choose to have sex, they are doing so knowing full well that thier "precautions" are not 100% effective. Therefore when they decide to engage in a little playtime, they are doing so with the full knowledge that it is possible that they may be starting a new life. Killing an innocent is NOT the responsible thing to do.


As an aside, it has always blown me away how a great many of those that scream about the innocent lives lost because of war have no problem with and fully support abortion. It is the same way on the right, many of those that cry out against abortion can always seem to justify "collateral damage". To me, a life is a life. One is not more precious or important than another.


Politicalnick, you do realize that you were one of the ones I was referring to with the part in red......don't you?