Does God exist?

s_lone

Council Member
Feb 16, 2005
2,233
30
48
44
Montreal
No, I'm not surprised, and I completely agree that there is much about the world that's rich and elegant (nice turn of phrase, BTW), but parasites and illness and so on aren't the bad designs I was thinking of. I had in mind things that in their normal operation are very bad designs from an engineering perspective: the knee joint, the temporo-mandibular joint, the eyeball, the vermiform appendix, the prostate's location, upright posture, food and air sharing the same tube... that's just a short list for humans, and it's definitely not subjective. Not to mention our reproductive system: any engineer who runs an open sewer through a recreational area deserves to be summarily fired.

Well... you certainly have a point about the reproductive system... and you gave me a good laugh!:lol:

Maybe that incompetent God will catch up in ''Humanity 2.0''... and sperm will taste like chocolate milk! ;-)
 

lone wolf

Grossly Underrated
Nov 25, 2006
32,493
210
63
In the bush near Sudbury
No. What I feel has nothing to do with any god, I have no connection to any god, my
feelings do not connect to any god, but I have a great connection to all of the other
living things on our earth, and our earth, those are real, I have lots of feeling for them,
and connection to them, but never to something I manufacture in my mind, and make
up, I'm too much of a realist to ever do that, and I would feel silly pretending I do.
Whatever you decide, by 'what you feel', is what you decide, and that is 'only' in your own
mind, has nothing to do with my mind.

Now that would be rather rude to presume I can think your thoughts wouldn't it? God, good, goode, Good Ordered Direction.... What works for me most likely does not work for you. I am very much the realist ... enough so to accept every day as something I can't give myself.
 

talloola

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 14, 2006
19,576
113
63
Vancouver Island
Now that would be rather rude to presume I can think your thoughts wouldn't it?
I don't presume you can think my thoughts, obviously we will never think each other's
thoughts.


God, good, goode, Good Ordered Direction..
I don't know what this means

.. What works for me most likely does not work for you. I am very much the realist ...

enough so to accept every day as something I can't give myself.
Again, I don't know what you're talking about.
 

lone wolf

Grossly Underrated
Nov 25, 2006
32,493
210
63
In the bush near Sudbury
Now that would be rather rude to presume I can think your thoughts wouldn't it?
I don't presume you can think my thoughts, obviously we will never think each other's
thoughts.


God, good, goode, Good Ordered Direction..
I don't know what this means

.. What works for me most likely does not work for you. I am very much the realist ...

enough so to accept every day as something I can't give myself.
Again, I don't know what you're talking about.

That's okay. It's only an abstract concept anyway. Serenity. Either you got it ... or you don't.
 

ottawabill

Electoral Member
May 27, 2005
909
8
18
Eastern Ontario
That proves nothing except that life exists on this planet. Sounds like you're edging over toward the logical fallacies of the design argument and the god of the gaps argument. Nature offers no proof that god exists, all it offers is a superficial appearance of design that people choose to interpret as meaning there's a designer. On closer inspection, the superficial appearance of design disappears. If it doesn't, and you're intellectually honest with yourself, you'd then have to conclude that the designer is an incompetent moron.

But it's all because your eyes are closed to it. As I am sure he exists you are sure he does not.

I can tell you I have had experiences that I can only put down to having God with me. I am no Bible thumper, but it made me see with no doubt that God is there, God is with me and he does amazing things. Over and over and over.

On the technical end, my piont was that if God didn't design anything and it's all so random the odds of this working as well as it does would appear to me to be much worse than any lottery we play. Trees they are alive with no brains knowing what to do, birds with may i say bird brains following stars to Mexico..doesn't appear to random to this boy.
 

Twig

Nominee Member
Sep 8, 2008
53
2
8
Ontario
I have been around for a long time and I still don't know. I just live my life as best I can, try not to hurt anyone and will wait untill this life is over to find out what and if there is another side. In the grand scheme of things it really doesn't make my life better or worse.
 

darkbeaver

the universe is electric
Jan 26, 2006
41,035
201
63
RR1 Distopia 666 Discordia
Hang in there OttawaBill, I don't think you are wrong as some of the more violently militant posters indicate but I do think we have brand recognition problems with respect to the label "God", many people jump to the judeaochristian article reflexively. My views support god but admit from the beginning there is no explanation, this of course is in tune with the state of mankinds total ignorance and insignifigance in the limitlessness of the universe.
 

ottawabill

Electoral Member
May 27, 2005
909
8
18
Eastern Ontario
Of course the problem with this discussion is the old squeaky wheel syndrome. I beleive in God. I know he is there. BUT, humanists will see it through jaded eyes, tv evangelists and islamic terrorist. The truth and the message get blurred by coruption and power then presented as "the way". This is the human flaw!
God could likely care less about how much money a church makes, if the U.S of A is victorious, whatever.

The calling is higher, some force..I call God. set forth all this energy into a focused form..creation!

It is no more silly than to say..well duh..it just happened!
 

Dexter Sinister

Unspecified Specialist
Oct 1, 2004
10,168
539
113
Regina, SK
I can tell you I have had experiences that I can only put down to having God with me.
I'm sure you can, and I'm equally sure they have mundane explanations. Every believer I've ever met makes that claim in some form. They're not evidence of anything, they're just hearsay and anecdote.

On the technical end, my piont was that if God didn't design anything and it's all so random...
That's the fallacy of the false dichotomy. God doing it or pure randomness doing it aren't the only options, as science itself makes perfectly clear. There is an element of randomness, but there's a lot more going on than that and there's no value in invoking a deity to explain any of it. Invoking a deity makes it even more mysterious, because then you have to explain the deity somehow if you really want to make sense of things. Claiming that god did it doesn't explain anything, it's the death of any further attempt to find explanations, because implicitly it means that's as far as we can go. It's not a useful hypothesis, it's a dead end.
 

Spocq

Electoral Member
Sep 8, 2008
122
1
18
But it's all because your eyes are closed to it. As I am sure he exists you are sure he does not.

Are you positive you don't have your eyes closed to the truth?

Is it possible that there is something after we die? I think its possible, there are things that if they are true would support this concept. Ghosts, physic's claiming to talk to those who have passed away, young children who claim they used to be someone else living in a different part of the world and when they check the stories out they were accurate about describing that other life and that person has passed away. But this doesn't prove to me there is a god.

I've heard many stories myself and some from people I don't believe would lie to me, for instance my mother said one night while she was sleeping a knock come to the door and she went to the door and asked, "who is it". A man said he had a flat tire and wanted to use the phone. She then heard a voice that said don't open the door. startled she said wait a minute, she then phoned the neighbor and he opened his door and asked the man if he could help him and the man ran to his car and drove off.

Both my mother and her brother said my grandfather, their dad come to them the night he died and said everything will be alright.

My mother taught me all my life not to lie and I have seen her end relationships when people have lied to her so I don't think she would lie. I myself heard a feminine voice say to me "You are the closest one ever" and I also heard the name of a city, this happened when I was reading the bible and trying to read between the lines about what really happened during the parts of the bible up to around the end of the story of Moses. I think the city the voice spoke of has the proof of what really happened (about what I'm the closest one ever to) during the days of Moses and possible other things are located there. I believe this is some of the truth that will set us free from those who believe god wants them to eradicate those who don't follow their ways.

One possibility is that maybe there are good people in this realm where we go when we die that help people who truly have good hearts and/or will have something to do with bring lots of truth/good to our world. Is it possible that The Mighty God is really The Mighty Good? The deeper I understand good the more I believe this to be true.

My father suggests that this help might come from our genetic code similar to how a child has the ability to play music very well. Perhaps the more good we become the more this genetic code is triggered, like an instinct to protect us so we can spread good. Possibly this is one way good generates good.

One other point I would like to make in this post. I seen someone mentioned that one thing that proofs god is real is that different isolated groups all believe in some kind of god. To me this proves the exact opposite. For instance the Indians of North America believe in mother earth and reincarnating into different living creatures. The god of moses branched off into several different religions. We have found primitive tribes that worship different totally different gods.

If god is communicating with people, I would think he would get them all on the same track. Now that would help prove to me that god exists.

Join the revolution, Vote Green
 
Last edited:

L Gilbert

Winterized
Nov 30, 2006
23,738
107
63
71
50 acres in Kootenays BC
the-brights.net
Demons, Mother Goose, leprachauns, gods, etc. don't exist outside the human imagination because there is no evidence or no reasonable grounds to indicate that they do. The best that believers can come up with is that gods exist just because. Logically they haven't the ground to stand on. And the Bible talks about building on sand as opposed to building on rock. lmao The faithful are mired in over their heads in this nonsensical goo.
(Sorry, that's the best I can do on short notice. Dex is a hard act to follow)
 

ottawabill

Electoral Member
May 27, 2005
909
8
18
Eastern Ontario
God usually has people on the same track..but few listen is all. I don't need to prove his existance. It was proven to me.

Let's leave it as that. I didn't start out believing, but I sure do now. To be honest anything can be explained as anything if you want it to be that way.

The general problem here is you are looking for your way to be God's way, your time frame to be his. It's the other way around.

A true belief leaves you peaceful and filled. It's letting go to allow God to take care of it. and he does!
 

Spocq

Electoral Member
Sep 8, 2008
122
1
18
God usually has people on the same track..but few listen is all. I don't need to prove his existance. It was proven to me.
I really don't think you are being honest. Religions are very much on different tracks. So much so that they have been at war in some cases from the origins of their beginning. In fact within the individual religions there are differences between the different groups. I feel that if I was to produce the precise equation that proves that god doesn't exist many would still believe God exists. Because they are closed to any possibility that God doesn't exist. Even undeniable proof will not change their mind. This would mean that they believe its just not possible that there is another explanation. Seems rather closed minded to me.

Let's leave it as that. I didn't start out believing, but I sure do now. To be honest anything can be explained as anything if you want it to be that way.
If you wish to leave it as that, you are welcome to but I feel its way to important to leave as that. You say let's leave it as that, but then you continue to express your point of view. Seems like you want me to do as you say and not as you do. Similar to God saying don't kill but then he kills or a parent saying don't smoke its bad for you while they puff on a smoke. I heard on TV the other day they figure if you smoke your child is 2 times more likely to smoke. I guess this is why people kill in the name of their religion. :(

The general problem here is you are looking for your way to be God's way, your time frame to be his. It's the other way around.
The problem is I will not just accept God's way with out question or even except my way with out question. I want to find out the way that remains after questioning it throughly.

A true belief leaves you peaceful and filled. It's letting go to allow God to take care of it. and he does!
Very understandable, of course we will feel peaceful and filled when we can leave all the problems of humanity to God to take care of. Is God really taking care of them, I certainly don't see this at all, 30 thousand people die of starvation every day and there is so much suffering all over this planet, its sickening. :( Wars are raging and looming in the distance, some would say they are religious wars.

Suffering generates Suffering

Is part of the definition of Utopia/Heaven. A place where people don't do things that make others suffer!

---------------
A vote for green is a vote for good.
The truth will set us free!