LILLEY: Scheer set to win most seats, according to polls
Brian Lilley
Published:
October 18, 2019
Updated:
October 18, 2019 8:36 AM EDT
Leader of Canada's Conservatives Andrew Scheer and his wife Jill campaign for the upcoming election in Little Harbour, Nova Scotia October 17, 2019. REUTERS/Carlos Osorio
There is a real and pressing reason that Andrew Scheer is pushing on the idea that the party winning the most seats gets to form government. There is no way that I can see the Liberals winning the most seats in this election.
Looking at all the polling available, Scheer and his Conservatives will win the most seats come Monday.
That includes the latest polling done for the Toronto Sun as part of the DART & Maru/Blue Voice Canada Poll.
Nationally, this poll puts the Conservatives ahead of the Liberals with a four-point lead. DART has Scheer’s party at 33% voter support compared to 29% for Justin Trudeau’s Liberals and 21% for Jagmeet Singh’s NDP. The Greens come in at 7% and the People’s Party at 2%.
Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau takes part in a TV interview with journalist Celine Galipeau at a Radio-Canada studio as he campaigns in Montreal on Oct. 17, 2019. (Reuters)
“The polling suggests a minority parliament for either the Conservatives or the Liberals, dependent on two major factors — voter turnout and geography,” said pollster John Wright, a partner at DART.
That’s Wright’s official stance but allow me to differ from my friend and longtime collaborator on watching politics. Based on Wright’s own numbers and looking at geography and voter turnout, I’m willing to say we are looking at Prime Minister Andrew Scheer.
That’s if the Liberals and NDP will allow it to happen.
NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh has said repeatedly that he will do anything to stop the Conservatives from taking power, a foolish move that negates his bargaining power with Scheer if the Conservatives do win the most seats. Even on Thursday, Singh was saying he wouldn’t respect the convention that the party with the most seats attempts to form government in a minority.
“We don’t respect Conservatives, no,” Singh said.
That’s a bad rookie mistake from a man who has been rising in the polls and could be using his balance of power position to get concessions from the two main parties.
LILLEY: Trudeau attacks Kenney and Ford while trolling for Quebec votes
LILLEY: Trudeau gives Quebec a pass in a way he never would for Alberta or Ontario
CBC won't sue Liberals over partisan ad using their material
For his part, Trudeau has refused to say that he will work as part of a coalition, simply saying Canada needs a “progressive government, not a progressive opposition.” Note he isn’t saying a Liberal government.
So how can I say that the Conservatives will win the most seats come Monday? Well there is more to it than the look of desperation on Trudeau’s face or his decision to spend the last two days in Quebec with a lot of time in Montreal.
He’s changed his podium sign in Quebec to read “Standing up for Quebec,” not for Canada. He’s fighting the Bloc who have come up from 23% support in Quebec at the start of the election to 33% now.
Justin Trudeau’s blindspot on Quebec and Bill 21: 10/3 podcast
The Bloc is eating away at any hope that Trudeau had for gaining seats in Quebec, he could actually lose some of the 40 seats the Liberals currently hold.
In 2015 the Liberals won 80 seats and took 45% of the vote in Ontario. The latest DART numbers have the Liberals at 32% support behind the Conservatives at 36% while the NDP sits at 22%. There is no scenario where the Liberals hold all of those seats; they could easily lose half of them if Monday goes badly for them.
Then there is the question of turnout.
The Liberals and NDP are most popular with voters between the ages of 18 and 34 while the Conservatives are the most popular party with anyone over the age of 35. Older voters are more reliable voters and while Trudeau was propelled to victory by a coalition of young voters, women and Indigenous voters in 2015 — none of those groups are as excited for the Liberals this time around.
When Scheer’s Conservatives win the most seats, but not a majority on Monday, his claim of who gets first crack at forming government goes from theoretical to a question of reality. If Scheer holds two or three seats more than Trudeau, then a coalition has a shot. But if Scheer holds a lead of 15 to 20 seats, then it becomes difficult for the Liberals to grab hold of power.
It will be late Monday or early Tuesday before we know exactly what voters will decide but I can say clearly now, the Liberals don’t have a path to victory that doesn’t include roping in the NDP or Greens.
blilley@postmedia.com
http://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/lilley-scheer-set-to-win-most-seats-according-to-polls