B.C. judge rules father guilty of “family violence” for calling trans son “she”

[Colpy]

Except Trans men that don't have GRS can still get pregnant unless taking blockers/HRT. For some, that's fine and for others, that's a huge dysphoric thing, hence the surgery and HRT.


Doesn't make them less men because physically their body doesn't match the gender they are.

Oh Bullshit.


I've tried to stay out of this, but it just gets so ridiculous.


Every single cell in the body has an XX or an XY chromosone, that is what makes you male or female, whether you are talking about sex or gender. And cutting up your genitals doesn't change that.


If your head doesn't agree, then your head needs some work.


What other mental illness is treated by cutting off body parts?


In 200 years the way we treat trans will be viewed in the same way we today view bleeding to treat various diseases.....idiotic, seriously counter-productive, and ignorant.


Now, that said, I have no faith in psychiatry either. And if you want to indulge in some body mutilation upon yourself as an adult, be my guest. If you are a person that wants to dress and live as the opposite sex, feel free......none of my business.



But if anyone tried to do hormone/surgical alterations to my child, it would be over my dead body.


It would be my absolute duty as a father.


And the father in the case that set this thread off should ignore the court order, speak to his daughter, publicize what has been done to him, and continue his resistance in every way possible.


And when they haul him into court and charge him with contempt of court, he could honestly tell them "Well, that is the first thing you've gotten right so far".

 

[White_Unifier]

Except Trans men that don't have GRS can still get pregnant unless taking blockers/HRT. For some, that's fine and for others, that's a huge dysphoric thing, hence the surgery and HRT.
Doesn't make them less men because physically their body doesn't match the gender they are.

And some coyote-rabbits can surf the web and vote too.

 

[JLM]

Just because you want to interfere in the kid's life, doesn't change what he's going through.


If the kid is Trans, then the 'daughter' was never a 'girl' to begin with.


The mother actually gives a shit, meanwhile the father wants a dead kid.


The 'mental disorder' is that mentally the kid is a he, while biologically, things got ****ed up and he's got a female body.



Just cause you wish it was otherwise, doesn't mean it'll happen the way you want.

You need to see a shrink, sweetheart! Penis = boy, Vagina = girl. Any problem with that?

 

[White_Unifier]

You need to see a shrink, sweetheart! Penis = boy, Vagina = girl. Any problem with that?

Next he'll ask how to define a penis and a vagina. Who says that a penis must protrude and that a vagina must be concave? Who says that a vagina can't ejaculate semen and a penis can't produce vaginal fluids? That's what I mean when I say English is becoming way too complicated and fast:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzNGkwGYE4E&t=37s

 

[JLM]

Next he'll ask how to define a penis and a vagina. Who says that a penis must protrude and that a vagina must be concave? Who says that a vagina can't ejaculate semen and a penis can't produce vaginal fluids? That's what I mean when I say English is becoming way too complicated and fast:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzNGkwGYE4E&t=37s

I guess we are finding out in fact it does take all kinds to make a world. The question now is what kind of a world?

 

[Serryah]

Oh Bullshit.


I've tried to stay out of this, but it just gets so ridiculous.


Every single cell in the body has an XX or an XY chromosone, that is what makes you male or female, whether you are talking about sex or gender. And cutting up your genitals doesn't change that.


If your head doesn't agree, then your head needs some work.


What other mental illness is treated by cutting off body parts?


In 200 years the way we treat trans will be viewed in the same way we today view bleeding to treat various diseases.....idiotic, seriously counter-productive, and ignorant.


Now, that said, I have no faith in psychiatry either. And if you want to indulge in some body mutilation upon yourself as an adult, be my guest. If you are a person that wants to dress and live as the opposite sex, feel free......none of my business.



But if anyone tried to do hormone/surgical alterations to my child, it would be over my dead body.


It would be my absolute duty as a father.


And the father in the case that set this thread off should ignore the court order, speak to his daughter, publicize what has been done to him, and continue his resistance in every way possible.


And when they haul him into court and charge him with contempt of court, he could honestly tell them "Well, that is the first thing you've gotten right so far".

As you said, oh bullshit.


No one is cutting up the genitals of children.


Anyone under 18 CANNOT get GRS. Under what kind of ****ed up illusion are you operating? One of the points of taking blockers is to keep Trans people from developing the characteristics that would make the dysphoria worse when they get older that cannot be really corrected by surgery.



Also, as I said, there is more than XX and XY.


But as you also said, you have your view - wrong and ignorant as it is - and nothing will change your mind.


Your bliss is amazing; keep being special, you special, special person you.

 

[Serryah]

You are trying to talk sense to a bunch of brick walls. Must be frustrating.

Getting there, yes.

 

[Serryah]

And some coyote-rabbits can surf the web and vote too.

Yep, and has nothing to do with me.

 

[Serryah]

You need to see a shrink, sweetheart! Penis = boy, Vagina = girl. Any problem with that?

Nope.


But also penis = woman and vagina = man when the physical body gets screwed up in utero.

 

[JLM]

Nope.


But also penis = woman and vagina = man when the physical body gets screwed up in utero.

Straighten the head out, leave the rest of the anatomy alone. When the engine is screwed you don't tinker with the transmission! Savvy?

 

[Serryah]

I guess we are finding out in fact it does take all kinds to make a world. The question now is what kind of a world?

A world that's the way it's always been, since Trans people have been part of it for thousands of years.

 

[Serryah]

Straighten the head out, leave the rest of the anatomy alone. When the engine is screwed you don't tinker with the transmission! Savvy?

But how do you know the head is in the wrong?



What's wrong with the idea the body is in the wrong?


Fixing the mental isn't as easy as fixing the physical sometimes and that's the way it is in this case.

 

[Hoid]

But how do you know the head is in the wrong?



What's wrong with the idea the body is in the wrong?


Fixing the mental isn't as easy as fixing the physical sometimes and that's the way it is in this case.

Why are you encouraging this moron?

 

[MHz]

Best just to ignore them! There is no law that says you have to have a brain before you open your trap!

But that would just leave you to talk to.
There should be if you are billing somebody for 'your time and wisdom'.
Who dreamed up the one about donations to put a new roof on an old church? Why would fire insurance not cover all that and more??
Why ignore them, when they say something stupid and/or immoral an opinion should be allowed if it is said once. If you are right they may hesitate the next time and adjust the way they say it to about falling into some hidden pit.

 

[B00Mer]

But that would just leave you to talk to.
There should be if you are billing somebody for 'your time and wisdom'.
Who dreamed up the one about donations to put a new roof on an old church? Why would fire insurance not cover all that and more??
Why ignore them, when they say something stupid and/or immoral an opinion should be allowed if it is said once. If you are right they may hesitate the next time and adjust the way they say it to about falling into some hidden pit.

MHz you're a hermaphrodite off it's meds..

 

[JLM]

MHz you're a hermaphrodite off it's meds..

I have no idea what his problem is but there's something not quite right about that boy!

 

[JLM]

Why are you encouraging this moron?

What moron are you referring to?

 

[Colpy]

But how do you know the head is in the wrong?



What's wrong with the idea the body is in the wrong?


Fixing the mental isn't as easy as fixing the physical sometimes and that's the way it is in this case.

Because every cell in the body has a DNA marker for the gender/sex of the individual. The body can not be wrong......that leaves only one alternative. Process of elimination.

 

[JLM]

You are trying to talk sense to a bunch of brick walls. Must be frustrating.

You're old enough to know better than this bull shit, but anyway have fun, I have bigger and SANER fish to fry!

 

[White_Unifier]