Obama will seek to close Guantanamo swiftly: advisers

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
So you think he is just an innocent kid. You would not make a good juror anymore than I would at his trial. He is already innocent.

I don't care to be on any jury in the first place.

What does the landmine agreement have to do with it? Just because we use them doesn't mean he gets a pass with using them too. They are weapons of war. Your point is so flawed. Him laying out landmines makes him a combatant. Plain and simple. That is one of the reasons why he is sitting in Cuba.

Oh so you get to pick and choose at your own will who can and can not use them, based on your own laws and rules you guys made up yourselves for your own country....... to then apply them in a forign country where you technically have no jurisdiction in the first place..... why? Because it's not fair that those you wish to fight are not supposed to fight back?

And him (may or may not be) laying out mines... once again, doesn't matter, because once again..... that would classify him as a child soldier..... which once again, you completely ignored and avoided.

Which means he is being held in Cuba under illegal reasongs and actions..... oh yeah, that's right, Bush invented up a new classification of someone you might stumble apon on the battlefield..... what is it again? Enemy Non-Combatant? Enemy Combatant? :roll:

He either didn't throw the grenade and thereby innocent of the charges and thus should charge your soldier's sorry asses for shooting him twice in the back and sue your government for what they put him through..... Or he's guilty of tossing the grenade and perhaps being a Terr'ist..... and thus, classified once again as a child soldier and have the proper treatments for such a case.

And sue your asses.



No, it would look like you are tinkering with Commodore electronics. If you had a stack of anti-vehicle mines behind you like Omar had it would look like you are working on landmines...like he was.

In a court, that'd be nothing but assumptions.... for all I know, he could be making cakes or curling stones in the desert.... but his hands are not on any of them nor does it actually look like he's doing anything other then picking the crud from his finger nails.

There is no proof in that shot that he made those or has ever worked on them. For all you and I know, those could have all been made by his father at their home his father took him to..... if in fact they are mines/bombs.

It'd be no different then myself accidentally stumbling into a drug factory and then walking back out..... if someone took a picture of me standing in there, gee.... I guess I'm guilty of working in that drug factory, I might be the ring leader..... you have no evidence of me actually putting my hands on any of it, you have no proof of any of my involvement except standing there being a witness to the scene.

As mentioned before in regards to those photos, they prove nothing, they do nothing for the case, none of them relate to the grenade charges, and are nothing but poor attempts to sway emotional influence based on nothing but items being behind him in the photos..... which can and already have been explained very easily.

And besides, you keep acting like this 14 year old kid (at the time) would be some super bomb wizard and the next best thing to Osama himself...... your country is grasping at straws to attempt to prove your actions have been justified..... and it's failing. This isn't even a kid who's had the opportunity to head to college or get a full education, and you keep talking about him as being some evil-doer who was in charge of the whole operation and should be locked away in Cuba until he goes insane and kills himself somehow.

Afterall, them terr'ists are lower then human, which is why afterall, you guys stripped them of all their human rights in the first place isn't it?

Funny how many Americans forget how they were treated by the British not too long ago.

Evidence? You seem to need photos and I have yet to see him getting shot in the back while cowering.

http://writechic.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/omar_khadr_wounded.jpg

^ Warning, Graphic Content. (Allegedly the Photo was taken shortly after he was shot, if indeed it is him)

As for the rest of the information, it's all within your troops' reports. Even the medical records state two exit wounds in the chest, which obviously means he was shot in the back. I have supplied all of this information continually within these forums since I came here..... do a search.

Many reports talk about how infected his wounds became and how very little treatment he was given to help the infection, to the point of almost being intentional.

The difference here is that I supply images that relate to the actual case, and you supply crappy propaganda images that have nothing to do with the case.

Here, I'll even provide you with some more information on the matter:

Khadr shot by U.S. forces before capture: witness
CTV.ca | Khadr shot by U.S. forces before capture: witness=

"U.S. forces shot Omar Khadr twice in the back before the young Canadian terror suspect allegedly killed one of their commandos during a 2002 firefight in Afghanistan, according to one witness.


The unidentified U.S. fighter said Khadr was hit by shrapnel and was facing away from the firefight when he was shot inside an al Qaeda compound......"

^ Seems to match with the original reports the troops made prior to them being edited.

".....The eyewitness also said a second enemy fighter was alive inside the compound when he entered. Khadr's defence lawyers said this casts doubt on the U.S. government's conclusion that Khadr threw the grenade....."

^ Hmmm.... this information has been around for almost a year now.... and you wonder why I already came to a conclusion? Probably because I have been following this stuff for a while now.

No... different troops saw it differently. You chose the one that suits your belief in his innocence.

Yeah, of course the troop who shot him would see it differently from the guy who didn't shoot him..... oh and their commanding officer would also see it differently too since his ass would be in the sling along with this guy..... so we'll just make him guilty and make up some story.

Soldier's report casts doubt on Khadr guilt - Dec 12, 2008
TheStar.com | Omar Khadr | Soldier's report casts doubt on Khadr guilt

"A U.S. soldier reported that he accidentally stepped on Omar Khadr following a firefight in Afghanistan because Khadr was covered in rubble, casting doubt on whether the 15-year-old Canadian could have thrown the grenade that fatally wounded Delta Force soldier Christopher Speer.

Identified only as "Soldier # 2," it's expected he will testify that he "inadvertently stood on top of (Khadr) and thought he was standing on a 'trap door' because the ground did not seem solid," a motion submitted to the court states.

The soldier then "bent down to move the brush away to see what was beneath him and discovered that he was standing on a person; and that Mr. Khadr appeared to be 'acting dead,' " the motion continued........."

Interesting, another reasonable doubt situation.

"..... Yet another theory offered by the defence suggests that Speer may have been fatally wounded by a "friendly grenade" — meaning one thrown by a member of his own forces. Khadr's military-appointed lawyer, Rebecca Snyder, told the military commission that there was evidence the grenade wounds suffered by Speer were those from a U.S. military M67 grenade — not from a Russian F1 grenade, as the prosecution has asserted......."

^ Well that would line up with the level of stupidity of this whole situation and would explain even better why the US would try to pin the blame on Omar with so many holes in the story.

So now there's three different stories which differ from the official claims (which were edited don't forget) on what could have happened..... and the majority of the other differing claims all seem to have one thing in common...... that Omar didn't have a chance to throw the grenade.

Reasonable doubt.

Sure they can. They can even travel to war torn countries and fight against other Canadians. But if they get caught...quite trying to baby them and whine about them.

I have no sympathy for his father, his actions and who he sided with.... he got what was coming to him...... his child however, is exactly that..... a child.... and even if he was fighting, once again, Child Soldier.....

Ahhh...the old myth made by Canadians for Canadians to make other Canadians feel better about themselves.

It's not really a myth if you come accross one of these situations and you decide to talk it up with them to see where they come from in Canada, and they either claim to be from the US, or they try and make up some BS story that only an American could think up...... yes, a Myth.

So much of a myth in fact, I remember seeing some American Travel information claiming that it would be wise to do this. Our own travel information companies have been telling us to wear them for decades now to wear a flag on a backpack or something like that, because most overseas considered us "Neutral" .... or used to.....

But here's some information:

Why Americans pretend to be Canadian
Why Americans pretend to be Canadian - Times Online

"FOR some Americans, to be mistaken for a Canadian is the ultimate humiliation, yet hundreds of US citizens travelling abroad have willingly acquired a disguise of a T-shirt with a Canadian flag.

Traditionally, Americans have looked down on their northern neighbours and Canadians are the butt of a thousand American jokes. But faced with hostility on their foreign holidays, some Americans are going to great lengths to conceal their nationality.

Those prepared to make the switch can now buy maple leaf stickers for their luggage. The truly adventurous can even learn the dialect and replenish their knowledge of the adopted homeland with the help of the quick reference guide How to Speak Canadian, Eh?......."

Or how about:

Americans offered "Canadian disguise kit" for travelling
http://www.travelmole.com/stories/102430.php

"Many American travellers are reportedly going to great lengths to pretend they are Canadian – and they can now take advantage of a reference guide to help with the deception. According to a report in The Times newspaper, an American company is selling a "disguise package" including a T-shirt and lapel pin bearing the traditional Canadian maple leaf motif – and the reference guide, entitled "How to Speak Canadian, Eh?" The owner of the company reportedly sensed a business opportunity after anecdotal evidence that US citizens have faced "hostility" while abroad, and reports of a "flood of inquiries" on the Canadian immigration website following George Bush's recent election win........"

Myth indeed.

Common sense is what you are lacking in this. Saying their is nothing wrong with him in those pictures, where he was at the time, who he was with... all innocent.

No, all irrelevant..... and I'll say it again, since I'm almost to the end of another of your responses and have yet to see any response to it...... CHILD SOLDIER

If I'm lacking common sense, then what does that say about you?

Nope... I bet his dad had A LOT to do with it.

So then you feel the son should be punished for the actions of the father?

You never brought them up as thus far you have been saying he is pretty much innocent. And it isn't like he is 9... he was 15. If they are old enough to pick up a gun and fight... then they are old enough for Guantanamo.

I never brought it up thus far?

Are you mad?? :-? I've been saying it continually since this whole situation became public. And it doesn't matter if I think for the most part that he is innocent..... If by the remote chance he is guilty of the crimes put against him..... he is a child soldier in that situation.

And you don't make up the international rules on human rights or war, and neither do I. You can't just pick and choose at what age you think you can throw a teenager into adult courts, prisons and punishments..... I was old enough to pick up my dad's Bren gun when I was 7..... it was heavy as hell, but I could do it..... so I guess I should be tossed into Cuba as well based on that mentality.

Oh yeah, that mentality means squat in "Real" law cases.

Nothing to admit to. You fail to use any common sense in this issue.

I have provided a plithora of magical common sense thus far, you have yet to connect to much of it however and revolve yourself around the same excuses and flawed emotional reasonings that the Bush Administration wanted you to get sucked into.

Dismissal of all evidence as you want him free. All those pictures and evidence are dismissed by you as irrelevant because you are emotionally attached to the boy.

Yes, because I have been so know for being emotional over these types of things. I know nothing about this kids likes, hates, wants or desires anymore then the next person, and whatever happens to him has very little affect on my own life...... what I do know is the situation he has been placed in. He could have been any race, any gender, following any religious belief you can think of..... what he has been placed through.... what all of those prisoners in Git have been put through is barbaric and a true view of what US Freedom and Opportunity is all about..... which is the freedom to take other people's freedom away.
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
Intoxicants were forbidden in the Qur'an through several separate verses revealed
at different times over a period of years. At first, it was forbidden for Muslims to
attend to prayers while intoxicated (4:43). Then a later verse was revealed which
said that alcohol contains some good and some evil, but the evil is greater than the
good (2:219). This was the next step in turning people away from consumption of it.8O

Finally, "intoxicants and games of chance" were called "abominations of Satan's
handiwork," intended to turn people away from God and forget about prayer, and
Muslims were ordered to abstain (5:90-91). (Note - the Qur'an is not arranged
chronologically, so later verses of the book were not necessarily revealed after
earlier verses.)8O

In the first verse cited above, the word for "intoxicated" is sukara which is derived
from the word "sugar" and means drunk or intoxicated. That verse doesn't mention
the drink which makes one so. In the next verses cited, the word which is often
translated as "wine" or "intoxicants" is al-khamr, which is related to the verb "to
ferment." This word could be used to describe other intoxicants such as beer,
although wine is the most common understanding of the word.8O

Muslims interpret these verses in total to forbid any intoxicating substance -- whether
it be wine, beer, gin, whiskey, or whatever. The result is the same, and the Qur'an
outlines that it is the intoxication, which makes one forgetful of God and prayer,
which is harmful. Over the years, the list of intoxicating substances has come to
include more modern street drugs and the like.8O

The Prophet Muhammad also instructed his followers, at the time, to avoid any
intoxicating substances -- (paraphrased) "if it intoxicates in a large amount, it is
forbidden even in a small amount." For this reason, most observant Muslims avoid
alcohol in any form, even small amounts that are sometimes used in cooking. 8O
Maybe Omar doesn't swing that way though. :lol::lol::lol:

After going through all of this, I'm sure he has a different perspective on life.

I used to be Christian.... things change. :p
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
Americans as Canadians... from your article...

“It was not meant as a slight against the US or Canada,” Bill Broadbent, president of T-shirtKing.com, said. “Some people might not mind, but others just want to be on vacation. So we were joking that they could just go as Canadians, and that just kind of evolved.”
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
Oh so you get to pick and choose at your own will who can and can not use them, based on your own laws and rules you guys made up yourselves for your own country....... to then apply them in a forign country where you technically have no jurisdiction in the first place..... why? Because it's not fair that those you wish to fight are not supposed to fight back?

Again... who said we are picking and choosing. The US did not sign the agreement but we did not say...

"You can't use landmines...but we can."

If you get caught using landmines, grenades, weapons, etc...prepare for the consequences.

It's all fair...but don't whine if you end up in Cuba.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
"Many American travellers are reportedly going to great lengths to pretend they are Canadian – and they can now take advantage of a reference guide to help with the deception. According to a report in The Times newspaper, an American company is selling a "disguise package" including a T-shirt and lapel pin bearing the traditional Canadian maple leaf motif – and the reference guide, entitled "How to Speak Canadian, Eh?" The owner of the company reportedly sensed a business opportunity after anecdotal evidence that US citizens have faced "hostility" while abroad, and reports of a "flood of inquiries" on the Canadian immigration website following George Bush's recent election win........"


Seems like a gag... a joke as they have said. You guys just eat that stuff up.

Myth indeed.

Indeed and thanks for proving my point.
 

Ron in Regina

"Voice of the West" Party
Apr 9, 2008
29,392
11,077
113
Regina, Saskatchewan
This is only antidotal, and a personal observation from something that happened
to me. I was going on vacation a little over a year ago and wanted a camera bag
(designed like a fanny pack from days gone by) so I wouldn't have to carry it or
have it hanging off my shoulder like a purse.

I hunted around and just couldn't find one. A relative found one for me though &
purchased it for me. It even had a Canadian flag embroidered onto it. She found
this in a luggage shop in Minot, ND. This doesn't prove anything, and may not
even be relevant....but it is interesting.

 

Tyr

Council Member
Nov 27, 2008
2,152
14
38
Sitting at my laptop
Why Americans pretend to be Canadian
Why Americans pretend to be Canadian - Times Online

"FOR some Americans, to be mistaken for a Canadian is the ultimate humiliation, yet hundreds of US citizens travelling abroad have willingly acquired a disguise of a T-shirt with a Canadian flag.

Traditionally, Americans have looked down on their northern neighbours and Canadians are the butt of a thousand American jokes. But faced with hostility on their foreign holidays, some Americans are going to great lengths to conceal their nationality.

Those prepared to make the switch can now buy maple leaf stickers for their luggage. The truly adventurous can even learn the dialect and replenish their knowledge of the adopted homeland with the help of the quick reference guide How to Speak Canadian, Eh?......."

Or how about:

Americans offered "Canadian disguise kit" for travelling
http://www.travelmole.com/stories/102430.php

"Many American travellers are reportedly going to great lengths to pretend they are Canadian – and they can now take advantage of a reference guide to help with the deception. According to a report in The Times newspaper, an American company is selling a "disguise package" including a T-shirt and lapel pin bearing the traditional Canadian maple leaf motif – and the reference guide, entitled "How to Speak Canadian, Eh?" The owner of the company reportedly sensed a business opportunity after anecdotal evidence that US citizens have faced "hostility" while abroad, and reports of a "flood of inquiries" on the Canadian immigration website following George Bush's recent election win........"


...at least you won't have a bunch of American tourists "gettin' a beatin'"when they travel internationally.

The problem exists when so many American's are walking around with Canadian flagss stitched to their belongings, that "real" Canadians are starting to get viewed with a "jaded" eye and mistaken as "american's"

We should get a residual for saving American lives overseas
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
My parents took a tour in Germany last summer... no Canadian flags and no beatings... imagine that.

We should get residuals for being the country next door to you!

OOOOOOOOOH!
 

Tyr

Council Member
Nov 27, 2008
2,152
14
38
Sitting at my laptop
My parents took a tour in Germany last summer... no Canadian flags and no beatings... imagine that.

If they would have lied and claimed they were Canadian, this would have never happened

ANTI-American sentiment is being blamed for an attack on two of Ireland's
top basketball players.

The two American players, Mike Speranza and Jared Harding, who are
currently playing for an Irish team, were attacked in a fast food
restaurant in Castlebar, Co. Mayo in the early hours of Saturday morning.

One player suffered a broken jaw, while the second had his hand broken.
They were attacked by a number of youths.

Witnesses claim that one of those who assaulted the players shouted,
"Americans think they rule the world"

Speranza and Harding play for the Castlebar Westaro. Both will be out of
the game for some time as a result of their injuries
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
If they would have lied and claimed they were Canadian, this would have never happened

ANTI-American sentiment is being blamed for an attack on two of Ireland's
top basketball players.

The two American players, Mike Speranza and Jared Harding, who are
currently playing for an Irish team, were attacked in a fast food
restaurant in Castlebar, Co. Mayo in the early hours of Saturday morning.

One player suffered a broken jaw, while the second had his hand broken.
They were attacked by a number of youths.

Witnesses claim that one of those who assaulted the players shouted,
"Americans think they rule the world"

Speranza and Harding play for the Castlebar Westaro. Both will be out of
the game for some time as a result of their injuries

Yeah you don't hear too many of these stories in the US Media for some odd reason.

Wonder if it has any relation with Bush's comments that the US's status hasn't deminished any under his presidency? :roll: (Perhaps trying to maintain some illusion to the rest of the US internally)
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
If they would have lied and claimed they were Canadian, this would have never happened

ANTI-American sentiment is being blamed for an attack on two of Ireland's
top basketball players.

The two American players, Mike Speranza and Jared Harding, who are
currently playing for an Irish team, were attacked in a fast food
restaurant in Castlebar, Co. Mayo in the early hours of Saturday morning.

One player suffered a broken jaw, while the second had his hand broken.
They were attacked by a number of youths.

Witnesses claim that one of those who assaulted the players shouted,
"Americans think they rule the world"

Speranza and Harding play for the Castlebar Westaro. Both will be out of
the game for some time as a result of their injuries

As you can see from Blackleafs post a girl got bashed for being English. I read a news report of an Iranian reporter getting bashed by Iraqi's because he was from Iran. There was a fight here in Mass not too long ago between a Pakistani and an Indian store owner. Both owned gas stations across the street from each other and accused the other of stealing customers.

But hey...Tyr...if it makes you feel better about yourself then go ahead and believe it.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
Yeah you don't hear too many of these stories in the US Media for some odd reason.

Wonder if it has any relation with Bush's comments that the US's status hasn't deminished any under his presidency? :roll: (Perhaps trying to maintain some illusion to the rest of the US internally)

Right...because up until Bush not one American was attacked anywhere in the world because of being American.
 

Tyr

Council Member
Nov 27, 2008
2,152
14
38
Sitting at my laptop
Yeah you don't hear too many of these stories in the US Media for some odd reason.

Wonder if it has any relation with Bush's comments that the US's status hasn't deminished any under his presidency? :roll: (Perhaps trying to maintain some illusion to the rest of the US internally)


Actually Praxius. American status abroad has been steadily declining since the Nixon criminal administration. Intervention in other countries internal affiars, blatant expansionism and invasions. It's hardly surprising that the US is in the twilight of it's influence

Can Obama do something about it? Hopefully.
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
Well it can happen to anybody anywhere based on where they come from. Canadians get attacked too, esspecially in Mexico for some reason.

I just have noticed a bit of a trend where the attacks on US Citizens abroad have increased a lot compared to what I knew occured in the 90's.

Since I wasn't born in the 60's and I was a child in the 80's, I can't really say much between those decades.
 

EagleSmack

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 16, 2005
44,168
96
48
USA
I personally think if each and every person in the world wears a Canadian flag on their sleeves, a patch, a Canadian T-Shirt, anywhere visible...anywhere... at all times...in every country...

NOBODY and I mean NOBODY...

Would ever hit, beat, smack, cajole, another person ever again!
 

Tyr

Council Member
Nov 27, 2008
2,152
14
38
Sitting at my laptop
I personally think if each and every person in the world wears a Canadian flag on their sleeves, a patch, a Canadian T-Shirt, anywhere visible...anywhere... at all times...in every country...

NOBODY and I mean NOBODY...

Would ever hit, beat, smack, cajole, another person ever again!

True