Was Patrick Brown Rejected by the PCs? Could he get the Liberals re-elected?

Murphy

Executive Branch Member
Apr 12, 2013
8,181
0
36
Ontario
I have never believed that Patrick Brown was the best choice as leader of the PCs, but he carried the day in 2015. In the three years since, it's apparent that the core of the party didn't care for the direction he was trying to take them. Some PC party members believe that his departure will help them win in June.

The Liberals are saying Brown's bad press is an example of why the PCs should not form the government.
The allegations of sexual misconduct must have been manna from heaven.

So, was it the PCs or the Liberals who torpedoed Patrick Brown? Or was it simply bad timing?


It is rare in politics for things to "just happen". Here are a few things to consider about Brown's alleged indiscretions: No charges were ever laid. The two women who made the accusations were never named. The story was published by CTV, a national media outlet. The mere suggestion of sexual indiscretion and Brown's career was over!

Several
things stand out.

The accusations of sexual misconduct were leveled five months before the provincial elections. Not too much has been made of this yet, but it raises several interesting questions.


Did these women simply come forward on their own, or were they encouraged to speak out? If so, who encouraged them? Did it come from the Liberals or the PCs?

It is easy to point fingers at the Liberals. Their popularity and polling numbers are very low. Wynne and McGuinty have made a mess of the province.Their irresponsible spending, the hydro fiasco, and the "cap and trade" pricing - another name for a carbon tax - were all vote killers. The Liberals really need something to help their re-election campaign.

Did they have something to do with the two women coming forward? We'll have to wait and see. Brown has instructed his lawyers to file a lawsuit against CTV. Any dirty laundry should come out at trial, but that won't happen until the fall at the earliest.


But what about the PCs? The party was increasingly unhappy with his leadership. Evidence can be seen as late as yesterday, in an article published in the National Post, before Brown delivered the papers to run as leader (again).

None of the four other candidates wanted a carbon tax, but Brown was good with it. Red flag! Voters don't like more taxes.

Brown has been continually accused of pointing out Wynne's failures, but never proposing any solutions.

It is also said that his short time with the provincial conservatives make him unfit to be leader in the first place.

Brown wants to run again for the top job, but it is likely his petition will be rejected. Regardless of how PCs felt prior to January, Brown is not the person to lead the party now. He's carrying too much baggage. There simply isn't enough time to reconcile Brown's lawsuit and the press that will result. The Liberals and NDP will pounce on his situation like a pack of hungry wolves.

If Brown really cared about his party getting elected, he'd take himself out of the picture. The trouble is, his ego won't let him.
---

In first debate, Ontario PC leadership hopefuls signal intention to steer party to the right

The four candidates rejected to varying degrees the legacy of ex-leader Patrick Brown, whose centre-right platform included a carbon tax

- Tom Blackwell, February 15, 2018 - 4:01 AM EST

The four contenders to be Ontario’s next Conservative leader made clear their intentions to steer their party to the right Thursday, vowing to battle Prime Minister Justin Trudeau over a possible carbon tax and blasting the provincial Liberals’ controversial sex-education program.

In the first debate of a hastily called, truncated leadership race, the candidates rejected to varying degrees the legacy of Patrick Brown, who resigned as leader last month over sexual-misconduct allegations he calls lies.

Brown had left behind a centre-right platform that promised tax cuts and other conservative red meat, but that also promised significant new spending and a tax on carbon emissions to help pay for it all.

On Thursday all the candidates reiterated their opposition to the tax — two of them vowing to take the Trudeau government to court if it imposes a levy. Three of the four said they would revisit or tear up the Kathleen Wynne administration’s sex ed curriculum, an issue Brown had carefully avoided.

The rest here.

In first debate, Ontario PC leadership hopefuls signal intention to steer party to the right | National Post

It seems that all the candidates are leaning the same way.
 
Last edited:

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
8
36
They're leaning that way because they are in a Conservative Party convention. The winner then has to do a double axel followed by a backwards flip in a matter of days and move the party (however temporarily) to the electable center.
 

Murphy

Executive Branch Member
Apr 12, 2013
8,181
0
36
Ontario
I don' know about Walter, but I think Brown will be cut from this round. The ebb and flow of politics.
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,340
113
Vancouver Island
I don't follow Onscario politics all that closely but it seems to me that this may be a golden opportunity for the party with two capable women contenders. As for who pulled the trigger I think Wynn most likely because it is too close to election time for party insiders to take a chance on what should be a shoe in election.
 

Murphy

Executive Branch Member
Apr 12, 2013
8,181
0
36
Ontario
The Liberals have been suggested as being the ones who encouraged the women to come forward, but I believe that it's too early to know. If it was the Liberals, they aren't going to say anything. With a lawsuit filed, an investigation will start, and a search for the truth will get underway.

It might be entertaining television.
 

Murphy

Executive Branch Member
Apr 12, 2013
8,181
0
36
Ontario
That's why the results of an investigation will be interesting to watch. taxslave raises a good point.

...As for who pulled the trigger I think Wynn most likely because it is too close to election time for party insiders to take a chance on what should be a shoe in election.

Why would the PCs risk a leadership race so close to the election? Brown's bad press is going to weigh heavily on the result. Then there's the cost. Money runs like water for both events. I don't think they can afford it.
 

WLDB

Senate Member
Jun 24, 2011
6,182
0
36
Ottawa
I get them not liking the carbon tax but it didn’t just appear out of nowhere. Brown didn’t dictate it, the members passed it in their policy convention.
 

Murphy

Executive Branch Member
Apr 12, 2013
8,181
0
36
Ontario
We'll have to hear what each says about the tax. Voters won't like the idea of paying out more in taxes.
 

Danbones

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 23, 2015
24,505
2,198
113
Especially when the heating bills start coming in as the interest rates go up and the cardboard boxes they now live in start to freeze up in the ditches on the side of the road...