Veteran battles Hydro One over meter

#juan

Hall of Fame Member
Aug 30, 2005
18,326
119
63
With a smart meter they can keep just his bathroom light, furnace and fridge running and say that he's in no danger, unless boredom is harmful?

As far as I know the "smart meter", has no idea which circuits do what. The bathroom light could run off a completely unrelated circuit. In our house the master bedrom lights are on the same breaker as the kitchen lights. I am not an electrician but house wiring has always seemed arcane.
 

tober

Time Out
Aug 6, 2013
752
0
16
I'd love to but it's a long drive from AB to ON.

Wrong! They do not get approval from the cabinet or any other governmental committee or official. There is a regulatory body called the BC Utilities Commission made up of a Chairman and 10 commissioners hired from a cross-section of utilities and businesses within BC.

Welcome to the British Columbia Utilities Commission

"Wrong?" Oh dear, what an emotion-filled reply.

The point is, for those of us who do not feel compelled to call others wrong and nit-pick meaningless differences, that our system of government has checks and balances. Various committees or commissions make recommendations but our elected representatives have the final say. Cabinet has to approve and pass regulations. The regulations do not have to follow recommendations.
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
And how would you define those alternatives? Solar panels? An expensive lock in contractor?
CM, for me to go off my gas meter, the alt charge is 5.89 / /gigajoule on a '
lock in contract, monthly admn fees not cancellable if I move.

Not my problem.

If buddy doesn't like the company or policies, that's his tough sh*t... He can always look at solar or get a portable generator.

The bottom line is this, the company is a service provider - IF you wish to consume their product/service, then understand that they make the rules

There is no alternative in BC.

Pretty much the same thing here; but even if their were alternatives, chances are that there would be policies in those companies that won't appease all the people all the time.

Maybe what the producer should offer to those that don't want a smart meter is tp pay the additional cost of having an employee go out to their home and take the reading... I'm guessing that the same people that don't want the smart meter will piss and moan about having to cover-off on the additional costs of doing business.
 

hunboldt

Time Out
May 5, 2013
2,427
0
36
at my keyboard
Not my problem.

If buddy doesn't like the company or policies, that's his tough sh*t... He can always look at solar or get a portable generator.

The bottom line is this, the company is a service provider - IF you wish to consume their product/service, then understand that they make the rules



Pretty much the same thing here; but even if their were alternatives, chances are that there would be policies in those companies that won't appease all the people all the time.

Maybe what the producer should offer to those that don't want a smart meter is tp pay the additional cost of having an employee go out to their home and take the reading... I'm guessing that the same people that don't want the smart meter will piss and moan about having to cover-off on the additional costs of doing business.

That isn't an answer, CM- that is a 'cop out'. A utility is exactly that- a service provider to the citizens, publically owned unless you live in the F__U--- called Alberta, where the ancient playbook got thrown out the window. and prices Doubled.

Man oh man, do you need a course in basic citizenship.


Not my problem.

If buddy doesn't like the company or policies, that's his tough sh*t... He can always look at solar or get a portable generator.

The bottom line is this, the company is a service provider - IF you wish to consume their product/service, then understand that they make the rules



Pretty much the same thing here; but even if their were alternatives, chances are that there would be policies in those companies that won't appease all the people all the time.

Maybe what the producer should offer to those that don't want a smart meter is tp pay the additional cost of having an employee go out to their home and take the reading... I'm guessing that the same people that don't want the smart meter will piss and moan about having to cover-off on the additional costs of doing business.

So,in your example, if the tycoon owning the 'essential utility' only agrees to provide you with electricity only if you surrender your nine year old daughter to his possession, that is OK - as he who has the gold makes the rules?

Ohhh CM...hath harper and Mackay so corrupted you?
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,994
14,442
113
Low Earth Orbit
As far as I know the "smart meter", has no idea which circuits do what. The bathroom light could run off a completely unrelated circuit. In our house the master bedrom lights are on the same breaker as the kitchen lights. I am not an electrician but house wiring has always seemed arcane.
As far as you know...

Did you bother investigating?

From a "Power company":
The person living in the house or apartment will have the choice whether to use these features or not.
The utility will only provide the current price of electricity via the smart meter. It is up to the person whether to set the thermostat to use the information, and save money.

Equipment that should not be turned off, such as medical equipment, will not be affected.

The use of dynamic pricing will require the purchase of new thermostats and other devices. Some new appliances will have the electronics built in, while older ones can possibly be retrofitted. The use of them will most likely be voluntary, as it would be impossible to force people to program their thermostats, and probably unlawful as well. Instead, lower prices on electricity will make people convert over time.

The new appliances will likely have these features turned on by default, and many people may not even know they are active.

A more controversial issue with the smart meters is that they could be used to turn off certain equipment in people’s homes.

If a utility company finds itself short on power, because a power plant had a sudden failure or the wind stopped blowing at several large wind farms, they will have to shed consumption or they will have brownouts or blackouts. What they may do today is rolling blackouts, where they disconnect whole neighborhoods or areas for awhil, then disconnect another area for awhile, while the first area gets their power back.

The idea with the smart meters is that instead of causing total blackouts, they only turn off some things that are not essential. It is much less disruptive to have heating/cooling, hot water, etc., turned off for an hour or two, than having a total blackout for that period.

The meters will not be able to turn off individual appliances if they are not modified for it, so the owner of a home or business will have the choice.

The shedding of loads may be done by setting the price of electricity so high anyone’s smart meter-enabled appliances will turn themselves off. But then there is the ethical issue of what price should people pay for electricity used by light bulbs and medical equipment during such an emergency.
 

PoliticalNick

The Troll Bashing Troll
Mar 8, 2011
7,940
0
36
Edson, AB
"Wrong?" Oh dear, what an emotion-filled reply.

The point is, for those of us who do not feel compelled to call others wrong and nit-pick meaningless differences, that our system of government has checks and balances. Various committees or commissions make recommendations but our elected representatives have the final say. Cabinet has to approve and pass regulations. The regulations do not have to follow recommendations.

You should maybe take a course or do some studying on the subject before you make these ridiculous remarks. The govt has absolutely nothing to do with BC Hydro other than being the majority shareholder. They are legally bound by legislation to NOT interfere or affect the operation of the corporation. This is done because it would be too easy for it to be used for political gain by whatever party held sway over the legislature at any given time.

So just to bring you up to speed. The CEO of BCH and the rest of the board decide how to run the company. If they want to increase rates or make any major changes to the service they have to apply to the commission for permission. The commission can either accept or reject the proposal or send it back for revision. Nowhere does it ever cross the desk of an MLA or cabinet Minister and it doesn't go to the floor of the legislature for a vote.

No run along and learn about the things you wish to speak on before you look any sillier. :roll:
 

hunboldt

Time Out
May 5, 2013
2,427
0
36
at my keyboard
You should maybe take a course or do some studying on the subject before you make these ridiculous remarks. The govt has absolutely nothing to do with BC Hydro other than being the majority shareholder. They are legally bound by legislation to NOT interfere or affect the operation of the corporation. This is done because it would be too easy for it to be used for political gain by whatever party held sway over the legislature at any given time.

So just to bring you up to speed. The CEO of BCH and the rest of the board decide how to run the company. If they want to increase rates or make any major changes to the service they have to apply to the commission for permission. The commission can either accept or reject the proposal or send it back for revision. Nowhere does it ever cross the desk of an MLA or cabinet Minister and it doesn't go to the floor of the legislature for a vote.

No run along and learn about the things you wish to speak on before you look any sillier. :roll:

Very well written,NIck
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
That isn't an answer, CM- that is a 'cop out'. A utility is exactly that- a service provider to the citizens, publically owned unless you live in the F__U--- called Alberta, where the ancient playbook got thrown out the window. and prices Doubled.

Too funny... The most realistic of all answers that conforms neatly with your (likely) ideals of rights and freedoms is a cop-out.

Man oh man, do you need a course in basic citizenship.

Is there any part of this citizenship course that details that folks have individual responsibilities to themselves as well as to the community in which they live?

Thanks Comrade, I think that I'll take a pass on that


So,in your example, if the tycoon owning the 'essential utility' only agrees to provide you with electricity only if you surrender your nine year old daughter to his possession, that is OK - as he who has the gold makes the rules?

Wow, that was fast... I never imagined that it would take you so little time to invoke the theater and drama to make a point.... The eevviiiiillll 'tycoon' vs the poor share-cropper that is forced to sell his one and only child into servitude.

Tell ya what, the solution is basically simple... You need to scrape together the money to buy out your local/provincial energy supplier and then you'll be free to operate it any way you see fit.

Ohhh CM...hath harper and Mackay so corrupted you?

Nothing of the sort - I just haven't been infected with the brand of Marxist syphilis that you contracted low these many years ago
 

PoliticalNick

The Troll Bashing Troll
Mar 8, 2011
7,940
0
36
Edson, AB
Tell ya what, the solution is basically simple... You need to scrape together the money to buy out your local/provincial energy supplier and then you'll be free to operate it any way you see fit.

Tell ya what CM....If it is a crown corporation then the citizens DO own it and it should be operated the way we dictate. That should be in a manner that is not based on increasing the bottom line but with rates that will sustain maintenance and upgrades. Anything like smart-meters should be put forth to the public for a referendum, not decided by some super-rich a$$hole who wants a bigger bonus and a few more 'fact-finding'trips to 5-star hotels in warm sunny places in January.
 

hunboldt

Time Out
May 5, 2013
2,427
0
36
at my keyboard
Too funny... The most realistic of all answers that conforms neatly with your (likely) ideals of rights and freedoms is a cop-out.



Is there any part of this citizenship course that details that folks have individual responsibilities to themselves as well as to the community in which they live?

Thanks Comrade, I think that I'll take a pass on that




Wow, that was fast... I never imagined that it would take you so little time to invoke the theater and drama to make a point.... The eevviiiiillll 'tycoon' vs the poor share-cropper that is forced to sell his one and only child into servitude.

Tell ya what, the solution is basically simple... You need to scrape together the money to buy out your local/provincial energy supplier and then you'll be free to operate it any way you see fit.



Nothing of the sort - I just haven't been infected with the brand of Marxist syphilis that you contracted low these many years ago


Interesting "branding' what you define as Marxist syphilis actually comes form the encyclicals of John Paul the second.
I was under the impression,. from somewhere that both of us were Catholics.

Sorry if I misinterpreted your faith, which seems to come form 'a different source'.
However, if you are interested in the Catholic view on this , you can find the encyclicals at :

Pope John Paul II
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,994
14,442
113
Low Earth Orbit
LABOREM EXERCENS

THROUGH WORK man must earn his daily bread1 and contribute to the continual advance of science and technology and, above all, to elevating unceasingly the cultural and moral level of the society within which he lives in community with those who belong to the same family. And work means any activity by man, whether manual or intellectual, whatever its nature or circumstances; it means any human activity that can and must be recognized as work, in the midst of all the many activities of which man is capable and to which he is predisposed by his very nature, by virtue of humanity itself. Man is made to be in the visible universe an image and likeness of God himself2, and he is placed in it in order to subdue the earth3. From the beginning therefore he is called to work. Work is one of the characteristics that distinguish man from the rest of creatures, whose activity for sustaining their lives cannot be called work. Only man is capable of work, and only man works, at the same time by work occupying his existence on earth. Thus work bears a particular mark of man and of humanity, the mark of a person operating within a community of persons. And this mark decides its interior characteristics; in a sense it constitutes its very nature.
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
Tell ya what CM....If it is a crown corporation then the citizens DO own it and it should be operated the way we dictate. That should be in a manner that is not based on increasing the bottom line but with rates that will sustain maintenance and upgrades. Anything like smart-meters should be put forth to the public for a referendum, not decided by some super-rich a$$hole who wants a bigger bonus and a few more 'fact-finding'trips to 5-star hotels in warm sunny places in January.

Since when does this one yahoo speak for everyone and therefore is able to unilaterally dictate to the utility how they operate?

As far as the speculation on the 'super rich azzhole' - you gotta link? A name? Any proof?

I didn't think so - just a whole lot of whining about how tough you have it.

Don't like it? Install a solar panel or wind turbine... That'll show him! No more fact finding missions or 5 star hotels!

Interesting "branding' what you define as Marxist syphilis actually comes form the encyclicals of John Paul the second.
I was under the impression,. from somewhere that both of us were Catholics.

Sorry if I misinterpreted your faith, which seems to come form 'a different source'.
However, if you are interested in the Catholic view on this , you can find the encyclicals at :

Pope John Paul II

Nope... I used Marx for a reason.

Nice try at a deflection though... I take it from your inability to respond to the actual points that you don't have any tangible points to support your position?
 

hunboldt

Time Out
May 5, 2013
2,427
0
36
at my keyboard
LABOREM EXERCENS

THROUGH WORK man must earn his daily bread1 and contribute to the continual advance of science and technology and, above all, to elevating unceasingly the cultural and moral level of the society within which he lives in community with those who belong to the same family. And work means any activity by man, whether manual or intellectual, whatever its nature or circumstances; it means any human activity that can and must be recognized as work, in the midst of all the many activities of which man is capable and to which he is predisposed by his very nature, by virtue of humanity itself. Man is made to be in the visible universe an image and likeness of God himself2, and he is placed in it in order to subdue the earth3. From the beginning therefore he is called to work. Work is one of the characteristics that distinguish man from the rest of creatures, whose activity for sustaining their lives cannot be called work. Only man is capable of work, and only man works, at the same time by work occupying his existence on earth. Thus work bears a particular mark of man and of humanity, the mark of a person operating within a community of persons. And this mark decides its interior characteristics; in a sense it constitutes its very nature.



Aye , and the Red Gospel Gets Worse:

98. In a word, we can say that the cultural change which we are calling for demands from everyone the courage to adopt a new life-style, consisting in making practical choices-at the personal, family, social and international level-on the basis of a correct scale of values: the primacy of being over having, 130 of the person over things. 131 This renewed life-style involves a passing from indifference to concern for others, from rejection to acceptance of them. Other people are not rivals from whom we must defend ourselves, but brothers and sisters to be supported. They are to be loved for their own sakes, and they enrich us by their very presence.
In this mobilization for a new culture of life no one must feel excluded: everyone has an important role to play. Together with the family, teachers and educators have a particularly valuable contribution to make. Much will depend on them if young people, trained in true freedom, are to be able to preserve for themselves and make known to others new, authentic ideals of life, and if they are to grow in respect for and service to every other person, in the family and in society.
Evangelium vitae: text - IntraText SC

Worse than Lenin, CM. CAN you IMAGINE?
 

#juan

Hall of Fame Member
Aug 30, 2005
18,326
119
63
As far as you know...

Did you bother investigating?

From a "Power company":

What I do know is that one day a new smart was installed. Nothing was done to anything inside the house. I'm sure that by adding a few nik naks, and doing a bit of wiring, we can do all sorts of things. Just adding a so-called smart meter by it'self is not going to be that exciting.
 

petros

The Central Scrutinizer
Nov 21, 2008
117,994
14,442
113
Low Earth Orbit
Do BC hydro have tiered rates yet?

Nothing has to be done inside the house. The meter database already knows which appliances run at which frequencies.
 

hunboldt

Time Out
May 5, 2013
2,427
0
36
at my keyboard
As far as I know the "smart meter", has no idea which circuits do what. The bathroom light could run off a completely unrelated circuit. In our house the master bedrom lights are on the same breaker as the kitchen lights. I am not an electrician but house wiring has always seemed arcane.

The idea behind the smart meters is that your appliances will eventually come with Transponders that can be activated to cycle off, reducing load on the system.