Texas city revives paddling in school

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
I see, so the only reason for corporal punishment, in your mind, would be to physically harm the child by inducing a welt. If no welt is induced then the punishment is ineffectual in your opinion. That's good to know.
Nope. That is your spin on what I actually said.
Do you have young children?
Young is a relative term.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
No not all, but do understand that abuse is always about power. I'm not interested in licensing more of it.
Good for you, Kreskin. Stopping abuse is a worthwhile effort when one can do it.
I was kidding about the cams. lol
 

TenPenny

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 9, 2004
17,467
139
63
Location, Location
"I know a fact relevant to the effectiveness/ineffectiveness of physical corporal punishment".
The welt is the effect. The slap is relevant to bringing up the welt. The slap is physical corporal punishment. DUH

Yes, the welt is the 'effect' of the slap.
That has nothing to do with the 'effectiveness' of the slap.

Effect = result
Effectiveness has to do with whether or not it accomplished the objective.

The objective may or may not be to leave a welt.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Yes, the welt is the 'effect' of the slap.
That has nothing to do with the 'effectiveness' of the slap.
So slaps aren't effective in bringing up welts? roflmao

Effect = result
Effectiveness has to do with whether or not it accomplished the objective.

The objective may or may not be to leave a welt.
Welt or not there is a physical reaction to a slap. Therefore, a slap is effective. It may not bring about the effect that you want, but it is effective.
A course in English comprehension may aid you with your confusion.
 

TenPenny

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 9, 2004
17,467
139
63
Location, Location
So slaps aren't effective in bringing up welts? roflmao

Welt or not there is a physical reaction to a slap. Therefore, a slap is effective. It may not bring about the effect that you want, but it is effective.
A course in English comprehension may aid you with your confusion.

I do not need to be aided with my confusion, I have none.
If I needed confusion, I certainly know where to go.

effective - producing or capable of producing an intended result

Note the use of the word 'intended'.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
I do not need to be aided with my confusion, I have none.
If I needed confusion, I certainly know where to go.

effective - producing or capable of producing an intended result

Note the use of the word 'intended'.
Whose definition is that?

Anyway, just because the slap may not have the intended result you are looking for, does not mean it isn't effective in producing a result.
You are definitely confused.
 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Gawd, and gerry said I was like SJP. I cracked a funny and he started nitpicking and now tenpenny's leaped onto the nitpicking bandwagon. roflmao Yup, somebody's like SJP and it isn't me.
We all have our fantasies, though. One of mine is that I'd like to be the female version of the Silver Surfer.
 
Last edited:

ironsides

Executive Branch Member
Feb 13, 2009
8,583
60
48
United States
Lone Star: Why Texas is doing so much better economically than the rest of the nation.



Once a separate nation, Texas has recently been behaving more like an independent economic republic than a regular state. While it hasn't been immune to the problems plaguing the nation, the Texas housing market, employment rate, and overall economic growth are relatively strong. Chalk some of this up to accidents of geology and geography. But Texan prosperity also reflects the conscious efforts of a once-parochial place to embrace globalization.


On several measures of economic stress, Texas is doing quite well. The state unemployment rate is 8.2 percent—high, but still one many states would envy. (California's is 12.5 percent; Michigan's is 14.1 percent.) It entered recession later than the rest of the country—Texas was adding jobs through August 2008—and started slowly adding jobs again last fall, thanks mostly to its great position in the largely recession-proof energy industry.



 

AnnaG

Hall of Fame Member
Jul 5, 2009
17,507
117
63
Lone Star: Why Texas is doing so much better economically than the rest of the nation.



Once a separate nation, Texas has recently been behaving more like an independent economic republic than a regular state. While it hasn't been immune to the problems plaguing the nation, the Texas housing market, employment rate, and overall economic growth are relatively strong. Chalk some of this up to accidents of geology and geography. But Texan prosperity also reflects the conscious efforts of a once-parochial place to embrace globalization.


On several measures of economic stress, Texas is doing quite well. The state unemployment rate is 8.2 percent—high, but still one many states would envy. (California's is 12.5 percent; Michigan's is 14.1 percent.) It entered recession later than the rest of the country—Texas was adding jobs through August 2008—and started slowly adding jobs again last fall, thanks mostly to its great position in the largely recession-proof energy industry.



Because of paddling?
 

Kreskin

Doctor of Thinkology
Feb 23, 2006
21,155
149
63
Where there is opportunity for abuse the abusers will be knocking down the doors to get the jobs. It happens in the church, the government... It happened in residential schools, minor hockey... I can't believe anyone would be a proponent of a system that has the potential for abuse of their own children.

The good thing is the idea is too silly to be considered in any normal community/society.