update
Ok, done ranting. Good luck. Hope some of this helps.
thank you so much for your advice and info! I did file my defense - on time - and noticed something odd about the trans Union statement they provided as "proof."
Their reort date at the top was an earlier date than the actual report! How can they print a report before the date of the report? Doctored, I figured. Then I noticed on my own TU report that no query had been made by PM Inc. since Oct. 2006. In fact, no querry had been made since then by anyone, except an unrelated agency I was aware of.
I called TU, they confirmed that Portfolio had not made a query, and suggested I contact the Consumer Protection Agency - even gave me the contact info to do so.
I called CPA and the guy was stunned at what I related - and I told the complete truth - no point lying - and wants to see all the documentation.
So it seems they got a CR from somewhere, without authorization, not authorized by TU, and it appears doctored.
Also, I called equifax to ask what exactly was presented to them by Portfolio to "confirm" their entry, and Equifax said they didn't have to tell me because it's an internal investigation. I don't buy that, so now I have to go to PPA over that!
CPA did agree with what you had said, that Portfolio is entirely responsible to come up with documentation - I can hardly prove the non-existence of documents.
I'll update all of you. Supposed to go for that meeting at small claims this month to see if we can resolve it without court. I won,t agree to pay even a nickel to get them off my back, because that's giving into black mail, and makes it harder for the next person.
I agree with another poster who says we should push for changes in legislation surrounding these agencies. What I'm seeing from comments is they use an approach similar to fishing - the by-catch method: cast your net (make it bigger than necessary, with a finer mesh than needed so you catch more fish including ones that aren't legal) then cash in on the legal ones, and try to cash in on the illegal by-catch as well.
thanks again! This is very reassuring for me, at least!