Mel Hurtig’s wake-up call for Canada’s democracy

tay

Hall of Fame Member
May 20, 2012
11,548
1
36
Mel Hurtig, one of Canada’s most-celebrated economic nationalists, has fought the good fight for this country for more than 60 years.


Over the years, Hurtig has raged about foreign control of our economy, the threats of free trade and the grumbling foundations of our democracy. He also was a successful businessman, operating a book company that was best known for publishing the Canadian Encyclopedia.



For his efforts, Hurtig received honorary degrees from six universities and was awarded the prestigious Order of Canada.



Now, at an age when most of his contemporaries have either withdrawn to the political sidelines or died, Hurtig, 82, is still going strong. To prove it, he has just released his eighth book, which he calls the most important one he has ever written.



Titled The Arrogant Autocrat: Stephen Harper’s Takeover of Canada, the book takes direct aim at Harper’s actions since becoming prime minister in 2006 that are systematically and deliberately in Hurtig’s view destroying our democratic institutions and values.



“My major purpose in writing the book was to reveal the extent to which Harper has damaged our democracy,” Hurtig said in an interview from his home in Vancouver. Harper “doesn’t understand what democracy is all about or care about it,” he added, saying he is “terrified by the idea that the man could be re-elected.”


In recent decades, nationalists like Hurtig have been largely ignored by Canada’s political and media elite.


But for years, especially from about 1960 to 1990, nationalists such as Hurtig, Walter Gordon, Keith Davey, Maude Barlow, Jack McClelland and Claude Ryan were dominant forces in Canadian life. They formed influential groups such as the Committee for an Independent Canada and later the Council of Canadians and fought against free trade and foreign ownership of key industries.



Today, even Hurtig concedes he is slowing down, but says he decided to write his new book because he was increasingly worried about what Harper, who he calls a “control freak,” was doing to our democracy.



Using extensive research and public statistics, Hurtig presents a powerful argument showing that Harper has indeed weakened Canadian democratic institutions and traditions.


Hurtig examines actions that Harper has taken that have affected our democracy, such as muzzling cabinet ministers, federal scientists and top bureaucrats, introducing omnibus bills, withholding information, gutting the Parliamentary Budget Office, distaining parliamentary committees, and overseeing a party rife with questionable campaign spending and robocalls. The list goes on.


Most of the information has been published elsewhere over the years. What Hurtig has done, though, is package it all in a short, 140-page book that is easy to read and understand.



“Through decades of sounding the alarm on (foreign) takeovers,” he says in the book’s introduction, “I never imagined that the greatest threat would come from the takeover of our democratic institutions by one politician determined to remake our nation according to his own values and priorities.”



Hurtig writes that “not only does Stephen Harper demonstrate a lack of respect for the democratic foundations of our nation, all indications are that he is determined to undermine or destroy them. Information is withheld, dissent is stifled and the checks and balances on government power are eroded or eliminated.”



As Hurtig sees it, the only way to stop Harper is for the Liberals and NDP to form a coalition “for the sake of restoring our democracy and indeed, our civil society” if there is a minority Conservative government after the Oct. 19 federal election.



Longer term, Hurtig recommends Canada hold a national referendum on whether to adopt a proportional representation electoral system, which he argues would prevent future “autocrats” from hijacking our democracy.



As much as Hurtig wishes it to happen, it’s highly unlikely Canadians will see a revised voting system for years to come. However, Hurtig’s dream of a Liberal-NDP coalition could come true if Harper wins the October election, but fails to achieve a majority government.




Mel Hurtig’s wake-up call for Canada’s democracy: Hepburn | Toronto Star
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
Just another disgruntled ideologue that believes that all the ails of the world are to be placed at the feet of one person rather than the masses that are the major participants in the equation.

Quite laughable really
 

Cliffy

Standing Member
Nov 19, 2008
44,850
193
63
Nakusp, BC
What is laughable is conservative ideologues who are blinded by Harper simply because he wears a blue Con icon. He is not a conservative but a repackaged Reformer with a right wing religious ideology. He has sullied Canada's international reputation and hitched his wagon to the war mongers at our expense. He has proven that he cannot be trusted to anybody who is half awake which leads one to wonder in what state of mind his fanboys are.
 

Cliffy

Standing Member
Nov 19, 2008
44,850
193
63
Nakusp, BC
Reading your Post it makes one wonder about your state of mind.

You really need to get some help eh !!
Coming from the biggest Con fruit loop on the boards, I take that as a compliment. Well, sorry, Walter is the biggest Con fruit loop but you are riding his shirt tails.
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
What is laughable is conservative ideologues who are blinded by Harper simply because he wears a blue Con icon. He is not a conservative but a repackaged Reformer with a right wing religious ideology. He has sullied Canada's international reputation and hitched his wagon to the war mongers at our expense. He has proven that he cannot be trusted to anybody who is half awake which leads one to wonder in what state of mind his fanboys are.

I really love the over exaggeration of Harper's gvt being right wing with a religious flavor. Only an ideologue without any real argument (or basis for such) would twist themselves silly to incorporate that into their argument.

PS - Your Messiah Justine has done more to crater Canada's reputation on the national stage, but of course, as you are purely, ideologically driven and blind to anything resembling reality, you assessment is that it's someone else's fault
 

damngrumpy

Executive Branch Member
Mar 16, 2005
9,949
21
38
kelowna bc
Cliffy has a point actually Harper is a leftover from the Reform era and is still out there
trying to solve 1980\s problems. Mel is not silly the corporate world having too much
power is as dangerous and having ISIS. ISIS has regional implications the Multinationals
like a legal version of the mob have uncontrolled outreach into the halls of power until
they become the power.
If we are not careful the new communism will in fact be capitalism. A dictatorship that is
a bigger scourge than anything we've known. The reason is not that these companies
are bad its because there are no disciplinary controls on them like there is for the rest
of society. Mel is right allow unbridled capitalism or communism or fascism to take
hold and you end up with a different problem that goes from providing peoples desires
to dictating their desires to the people and we are seeing signs of that already.
 

Cliffy

Standing Member
Nov 19, 2008
44,850
193
63
Nakusp, BC
I really love the over exaggeration of Harper's gvt being right wing with a religious flavor. Only an ideologue without any real argument (or basis for such) would twist themselves silly to incorporate that into their argument.

PS - Your Messiah Justine has done more to crater Canada's reputation on the national stage, but of course, as you are purely, ideologically driven and blind to anything resembling reality, you assessment is that it's someone else's fault
Justine is certainly no messiah and definitely not mine. That you can't see Haper's right wing religious bent in many of his actions, like cow towing to Israel, and hitching his wagon to the war mongers (Armageddon tired of waiting) is surely blinded by their ideology.

Justine and Stevo are cut from the same cloth:

 

Walter

Hall of Fame Member
Jan 28, 2007
34,892
129
63
What is laughable is conservative ideologues who are blinded by Harper simply because he wears a blue Con icon. He is not a conservative but a repackaged Reformer with a right wing religious ideology. He has sullied Canada's international reputation and hitched his wagon to the war mongers at our expense. He has proven that he cannot be trusted to anybody who is half awake which leads one to wonder in what state of mind his fanboys are.
Lots o' hate in that post.

Coming from the biggest Con fruit loop on the boards, I take that as a compliment. Well, sorry, Walter is the biggest Con fruit loop but you are riding his shirt tails.
And more hate.
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,342
113
Vancouver Island
Justine is certainly no messiah and definitely not mine. That you can't see Harper's right wing religious bent in many of his actions, like cow towing to Israel, and hitching his wagon to the war mongers (Armageddon tired of waiting) is surely blinded by their ideology.

Justine and Stevo are cut from the same cloth:


For the most part Harper is doing exactly what we elected him to do. Fix the problems created by extreme left ideologues. It is a time consuming process.
 

pgs

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 29, 2008
29,048
8,461
113
B.C.
What is laughable is conservative ideologues who are blinded by Harper simply because he wears a blue Con icon. He is not a conservative but a repackaged Reformer with a right wing religious ideology. He has sullied Canada's international reputation and hitched his wagon to the war mongers at our expense. He has proven that he cannot be trusted to anybody who is half awake which leads one to wonder in what state of mind his fanboys are.
We want more reformers in parliament . The bureaucracy needs reform now more then ever .
 

mentalfloss

Prickly Curmudgeon Smiter
Jun 28, 2010
39,817
471
83
Just another disgruntled ideologue that believes that all the ails of the world are to be placed at the feet of one person rather than the masses that are the major participants in the equation.

Quite laughable really

Do you actually say 'quite laughable really' in real life?

With a monocle?
 
Last edited: