Pro-independence SNP unlikely to get overall majority in Scottish Parliament
Professor Sir John Curtice
Polling expert
There is still a chance the SNP could get an overall majority but in truth it’s a remote chance.
It rests on whether or not the SNP can pick up Galloway and Aberdeenshire West – two Conservative-held marginal seats.
Those do look like more of a long shot.
And it also depends whether or not they can pick up a couple of list seats – one in the Highlands and one in the south of Scotland.
Bu they would need to get at least three of those four seats, and on the evidence of what we’ve seen so far they will be lucky to make it.
So we’re probably not looking at an SNP overall majority.
But there will be a majority of pro-independence MSPs – the SNP and the Greens in combination.
One of the ironies of the result is that perhaps one of the reasons the SNP are not going to get an overall majority is because - despite the claims from unionist parties that voters were much more concerned about the pandemic - actually these results reveal the extent to which voters were concerned about the constitutional question.
One way that was realised was the extent of tactical voting, particularly in those seats that both Conservative and Labour were defending.
There is pretty clear evidence that where the Conservatives have been lying third they switched to Labour, and equally, where Labour was lying third they switched to the Conservatives.
This is also going to be a record high turnout for a Scottish Parliament election.
So I think we can take away first, that Scotland’s voters on both sides of the argument really are concerned about the constitutional question.
And secondly, probably when all the votes are counted it’s going to underline that this country is pretty much evenly divided between supporters of independence and supporters of the union.
Crunching the numbers: What does the data tell us?
Professor Sir John Curtice
Polling expert
The BBC has been collecting data in 1,000 key wards.
This gives us something known as the projected national share.
It gives us an estimate of the share of the vote the parties may have won in a nationwide general election - if voters had behaved in the same way as those who actually voted in the local elections.
So on the basis of those 1,000 key wards, the BBC projects that if a general election was taking place, the parties would have the following percentage shares:
Conservative 36
Labour 29
Lib Dem 17
Other 18
The projected Conservative lead of 7 points is similar to the average Conservative lead of 6 points in the most recent Britain-wide polls.
The election results thus appear to confirm the apparent vaccine boost to the Conservatives' popularity.
But in contrast to
the result in Hartlepool, there is a projected nationwide net swing from the Conservatives to Labour of 2.5 points from the 2019 general election. Hartlepool's by-election saw a 16% swing the other way.
Labour have made at least some progress in this election, albeit far less than what one might expect from an opposition in the middle of a government's term.
The Liberal Democrat projected share is two points lower than the party's performance in the last local elections in 2019 and only slightly better than that registered in 2016 and 2018.
The party still seems to be doing little more than treading water, even if it is still stronger in local elections than it is for Westminster.