Unforgiven, that is called putting up a straw man. I never said that drinking one’s own urine is beneficial, go back and read my posts again. Show me the posts where I said that drinking one’s own urine is beneficial.
Yes you did.
here:
No doubt some people would do it, but then again some people drink their own urine.
Indeed they do, unforgiven. I understand it has some medicinal benefits (something to do with heart disease, I think).
here:
Not really, unforgiven, it really does have some beneficial effects. I think urine extract is used in heart medicine.
This whole thing was discussed on television more than 20 years ago, when Mr. Desai was the Prime Minister of India (he succeeded Mrs. Gandhi).
He used to drink is own urine. CNN did a special on this subject, where they said that urine is beneficial to heart.
here:
How is drinking urine and some urine extract, if that's the case even the same thing?
Why not, unforgiven?
This is the similar situation. I don’t know how expensive urine extract is, how easy it is to obtain. Urine is to be had with no trouble. So yes, it can be the same thing, depending upon the situation.
here:
So I stand by my opinion that urine has beneficial properties (at least that was the thought 20 years ago)
You said, and the meaning of what you said was that drinking urine was beneficial and that my claim that it was not was easily refuted. At which point you changed to saying some nonspecific urine extraction was suggested to be of benefit to heart patients. Not drinking their own piss as you started out with.
What I said was that Mr. Desai, former PM of India used to drink his own urine, that CNN did a special on this where they described the benefits derived from urine extract, and that Mr. Desai was not putting himself at any risk by drinking his own urine. I stand by all that.
I am pretty confident that any reasonable person could read through this thread, take what you said in context to mean that drinking urine was healthy. Those posts of yours are there and no matter how much to care to twist what you said, it's meaning remains clear.
You on the other hand, clearly implies that using urine extract for medicine is bunk.
It's off the top of my head, but it should be easy enough to Google for it. CNN did a special on the subject, I definitely remember that. - SJP
Feel free to bring your supporting links then. I will be happy to tear them apart and easily refute this ridiculous claim. – unforgiven
In your attempt to change the context of what was posted shows your trolling behavior. As pointed out by a number of others already.
Your comment was in response to my comment see your post #22. The clear implication on your part is that what I said (about CNN doing a special on the beneficial effects of urine extract) was rubbish.
As I said and remain to assert, your claim of drinking piss is healthy and beneficial is, using your own words, rubbish.
To which I provided voluminous references and challenged you to tear them apart, as you promised.
You provided 4 links, to pay for use sites, that present research data and opinion on clinical testing of a urine extract (not piss drinking) used in an injected cocktail for heart research conducted on animals.
Did you even bother to read any of it? There is nothing to tear apart there, as this was not what you claimed and I said I would refute.
You failed to do that and shifted the argument, claiming that there are no beneficial effects of drinking one’s own urine.
I've covered this already but again, you made the claim, I kicked the crap out of it. In doing so, I've also you shown you to be exactly what you've been called by others here.
I never said there were (though I don’t know that one way or the other). So anyway, I assume you agree that urine extract can be used in medicine. Let us leave it at that.
No we will leave it at you made a ridiculous claim about drinking urine and got called on it. You made the usual comedy of errors attempting to bluff your way through and had to make up a little bit of a lie to make it sound right. Again SJP you're busted here.
It's not that it's difficult to do, just time consuming responding to all the hot air coming out of you. Though here I am, some what let down in that you didn't even bother to bring the "A" game. Granted neither did I but your not my first dance I am afraid.
So here is where you can leave it, use the ignore feature or read the sarcasm I direct your way for the other ridiculous things you say here to others. Don't expect much argument from me though. You're thick and obviously not here to do more than troll and disrupt things. Eventually some Mod or admin will figure your **** out and give you the punt. I don't expect I'll notice it.
