First muslim elected to congress

tracy

House Member
Nov 10, 2005
3,500
48
48
California
When people post things about Islam and I get offended and maybe even defensive it's because this man is the kind of muslim my friends are. They aren't the people looking to destroy America or kill infidels. They are people who live their lives like the rest of us. I see this as an affirmation that Americans are capable of telling the difference and that modern muslims are perfectly capable of living in a democracy.

http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/11/08/muslim.elect/index.html
Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

POSTED: 10:30 a.m. EST, November 8, 2006


var clickExpire = "-1";Adjust font size:



MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota (CNN) -- In a political first, a Muslim has been elected to serve in the U.S. Congress.
Keith Ellison, a Minnesota state legislator and lawyer, reached the political milestone by defeating two other candidates in Minnesota's 5th Congressional District, which covers the Minneapolis area.
His victory was part of the Democratic wave that seized control of the House of Representatives from the Republicans. (Watch how Democrats' victory will change Capitol Hill -- 2:25)
Ellison won 56 percent of the vote, defeating Republican Alan Fine and the Independence Party's Tammy Lee, both of whom garnered 21 percent of the vote. A Green Party candidate received 2 percent.
With 99 percent of the precincts reporting, Ellison received 135,519 votes, Fine 51,896, and Lee, 51,250.
Ellison is also the first African-American from Minnesota to be elected to the U.S. House. He ran on the Democratic-Farmer-Labor ticket in a district that is heavily liberal.
Members of that party, a uniquely Minnesotan movement, describe the DFL as the state chapter of the Democratic Party.
Ellison's winning platform

Ellison's views reflect Democratic ideals and discontent.
He is opposed to the war in Iraq and on his Web site, he has called "for an immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq."
"I opposed the war before it began. I was against this war once it started and I am the only candidate calling for an immediate withdrawal of troops."
His religious message is one of inclusiveness.
Regarding his Muslim faith, he said, "people draw strength and moral courage from a variety of religious traditions."
"Mine have come from both Catholicism and Islam. I was raised Catholic and later became a Muslim while attending Wayne State University. I am inspired by the Quran's message of an encompassing divine love, and a deep faith guides my life every day."
Ellison's position on the Israeli-Palestinian issue is supportive of the two-state solution and the road map to peace process. He has been critical of the Hamas movement.
"Peace is necessary for both Israeli and Palestinian people, and I wholeheartedly support peace movements in Israel and throughout the region," he said in a statement on his Web site.
He was endorsed by the Twin Cities newspaper, the American Jewish World, which said, "In Ellison, we have a moderate Muslim who extends his hand in friendship to the Jewish community and supports the security of the State of Israel."
Ellison is pro-choice and pro-labor, and supports "universal single payer health care" -- long popular stances among liberals.
The seat Ellison won had been held by Rep. Martin Olav Sabo, the longtime Democratic incumbent, whose retirement sparked a wide-open race. Sabo won 70 percent of the vote for the House seat in 2004.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gc

gopher

Hall of Fame Member
Jun 26, 2005
21,513
66
48
Minnesota: Gopher State
... thankfully most American Christians aren't like Bush.

Keith Ellison's election to the Congress helps to diversify the government and will make for an excellent addition to Capitol Hill. Note how so many of the extremist right wing Televangelist elements have lost their Congressional jobs. That change is long overdue. None of those destructive hatemongers will be missed.
 

gc

Electoral Member
May 9, 2006
931
20
18
When people post things about Islam and I get offended and maybe even defensive it's because this man is the kind of muslim my friends are. They aren't the people looking to destroy America or kill infidels. They are people who live their lives like the rest of us. I see this as an affirmation that Americans are capable of telling the difference and that modern muslims are perfectly capable of living in a democracy.

I don't know much about this Keith Ellison guy, but this first paragraph of yours is very well said!
 

Curiosity

Senate Member
Jul 30, 2005
7,326
138
63
California
Tracy

You can perhaps understand how I feel when I read all the choice words describing the people I work with and play with and have as friends - close people I love dearly - when they are called indescribable names by people who know nothing about them. Citizens of the U.S.A. either born here or immigrated from other lands but nevertheless U.S. people. Even you without realizing it (or perhaps realizing it and only repeating what you hear) make critical remarks about some you have chosen to live with here in the U.S.

It applies to all groups - why you are making any muslim to be unique in the world of insult seems rather odd to me.

Try the Asian people - especially in the early days of North America when they were no better than slave animals - same as the imported Africans where were sold into slavery. Try the Latinos who cram into trucks and busses, urniating on each other to be dumped out at an desolate place in the dark - after paying all their savings of thousands of dollars, carrying empty bottles where water was the only nourishment, to be picked up and herded back south again.

Would you ever choose to be a Jew or Israeli??? Native American???

If you want to belong to the U.S. and be called "American" eventually it would seem the majority of people who are not born within the borders - have some kind of trials to be encountered. Muslims or middle eastern people who worship Islam are not an isolated group in suffering. Yet the latter group seem to be the only ones rebelling these days with bombs and killing innocents in their chosen countries these days (see Spain, Britain, Bali, etc.) while "not declaring war".

Try plain Americans for a change - see what they abide every day....while they are supporting many minorities of those in poverty all over the world. While the world calls them evil.

No ethnic group is without fault - and all of us experience insults by others for our ethnicity.
 
Last edited:

tracy

House Member
Nov 10, 2005
3,500
48
48
California
Tracy

You can perhaps understand how I feel when I read all the choice words describing the people I work with and play with and have as friends - close people I love dearly - when they are called indescribable names by people who know nothing about them. White citizens of the U.S.A. Even you without realizing it (or perhaps realizing it and only repeating what you hear) make critical remarks about some you have chosen to live with here in the U.S.

It applies to all groups - why you are making any muslim to be unique in the world of insult seems rather odd to me.


.....
No ethnic group is without fault - and all of us experience insults by others for our ethnicity.

I do understand it and didn't think I participated in American bashing. I live down here and like it. Edited to add: this part struck me as really funny because I actually had a member pm me accusing me of being a crazy American lover after posting in your "thank you cousins" thread.

I don't think muslims are unique in suffering discrimination, though I think they are certainly one of the favorite topics on this board and definitely the most hated today.

All of us experiencing insults doesn't make any of it right, that's all I'm saying. I don't understand why we are so incapable of seeing the common things we share and instead have to always focus on the different, the other, the bad.
 
Last edited:

sanctus

The Padre
Oct 27, 2006
4,558
48
48
Ontario
www.poetrypoem.com
No ethnic group is without fault - and all of us experience insults by others for our ethnicity.

As a Canadian, it befuddles my brain trying to figure out why it matters what religion the man is. I cannot ever recall a time in Canadian federal elections where the religion of a propsective MP was any kind of an issue, or even taken notice of.Wouldn't it be more important the quality of his ability to serve his riding than where he chooses to worship?
 

Curiosity

Senate Member
Jul 30, 2005
7,326
138
63
California
Sanctus

Ask Joe Lieberman how he feels in his long number of years serving in government - he is still the "Jew" - as if he wears his yarmulke in the Senate or something.

On the other side we have "adopted ethnics".... Obama and Ford - who are not fully Black but are claimed to be of African descent.... I forget the Hawaiian representative's name but he is always categorized as such - even though Hawaii is a state...and he is a mixture of Asian racial types.

The world is nuts when it comes to politics and religion and ethnicity. It would be better had we been all one race - but perhaps that is why we are not - to learn to live with diversity until we realize there is really none at all.
 

Sassylassie

House Member
Jan 31, 2006
2,976
7
38
We all bleed red, and all man kind suffers. It doesn't matter what Religion you worship, we are all gods creatures.
 

ottawabill

Electoral Member
May 27, 2005
909
8
18
Eastern Ontario
As a Canadian, it befuddles my brain trying to figure out why it matters what religion the man is. I cannot ever recall a time in Canadian federal elections where the religion of a propsective MP was any kind of an issue, or even taken notice of.Wouldn't it be more important the quality of his ability to serve his riding than where he chooses to worship?

Stockwell day? Steven Harper, Preston Manning? There religion was all called into question during Federal votes.

We all bleed red, and all man kind suffers. It doesn't matter what Religion you worship, we are all gods creatures.

Agreed....It's not what you worship, it has noting to do with nothing!! It is the dangerous people who use and twist the faith for power, greed and gain. The problem is that they are squeeky wheels, we pay attention to them and start to label. Osama speaks no more for the general Muslim than Benny Hinn speaks for the general Christian....but a secular public believe they do
 

sanctus

The Padre
Oct 27, 2006
4,558
48
48
Ontario
www.poetrypoem.com
Stockwell day? Steven Harper, Preston Manning? There religion was all called into question during Federal votes.

My apologies. I do not remember that being an issue at all. Well, at least the religion of the canidate isn't of terribly great importance to me. I liked Preston, by the way. Hated his politics, but for some reason liked him. What is he up to these days?
 

ottawabill

Electoral Member
May 27, 2005
909
8
18
Eastern Ontario
Preston is part of a think tank. I do know him not very close but his former advisor is a member of our Church, therefore he shows up maybe once a quarter there. He is a very real person, if you agree with him or not he is honest dirrect and forward. It's unfortunate in this day and age having policy is not enough..you have to look good too..duh!!

He and other's Christian ways were brought into question, with thoughts of them bringing Christ to the house and laws, and pushing a very right wing religious course. I don't believe any of them feel that way, but again when a secular person only sees Jerry Faldwell and John Haggie on T.V. they think "thats what those damn religiuos zealots are up too...It really is sad!!
 

sanctus

The Padre
Oct 27, 2006
4,558
48
48
Ontario
www.poetrypoem.com
Preston is part of a think tank. I do know him not very close but his former advisor is a member of our Church, therefore he shows up maybe once a quarter there. He is a very real person, if you agree with him or not he is honest dirrect and forward. It's unfortunate in this day and age having policy is not enough..you have to look good too..duh!!
!!
That is why I liked him, I think. He was honest, direct and obviously devoted to his vision of the country. I respected hima great deal for that during the Reform Party days.
 

sanctus

The Padre
Oct 27, 2006
4,558
48
48
Ontario
www.poetrypoem.com
He and other's Christian ways were brought into question, with thoughts of them bringing Christ to the house and laws, and pushing a very right wing religious course. I don't believe any of them feel that way, but again when a secular person only sees Jerry Faldwell and John Haggie on T.V. they think "thats what those damn religiuos zealots are up too...It really is sad!!

Oh. That's right! I forgot all about that.