Did Jesus Struggle Like you Do?

Nikki

Free Thinker
Jul 6, 2006
326
2
18
calgary,ab
www.avonbynikki.com
So, it goes full circle and ends up to the question I had before...where did Falwell's spiritual self go? Heaven...or hell?

Obviously he went to hell. If there is a god (which there isn't but thats not the point here) then he went to hell for judging others. Didn't god say "let thee be judged." I would imagen that god is pretty pissed off that this Jerry guy has taken it upon himself to judge gods children. Whome I might add God made. And if god is the maker of all (like many claim) then god made all of us the way we are. God therefore new that I would be an atheist, that Joe Blow would be gay ect. How can he actually fault someone for that. Therefore God also new that Jerry would be a prick who judged all because God made him this way. So if God is the creator of all and he does exsist and there is infact a hell... your god is kinda an asshat.

And another thing Jerry was all about the bible, like many others, and I want to know since when is it ok to pick and choose what to follow from the bible??? The bible says that being gay is wrong. So Many discriminate against gays and say they are sinning. but the bible also says you should stone your children if they disobey you..... Does anyone actually do this anymore? People simply use the bible as an exscuse to be asshats. They simply need it to justify their actions. In short, the whole thing is stupid and makes no sense at all. :angryfire:
 

MikeyDB

House Member
Jun 9, 2006
4,612
63
48
At this point in the discussion I think it might be interesting to turn the OP's question around: do you struggle like Jesus did? I think most of us who are trying to make sense of our lives would probably answer yes, to some degree, though fortunately very few of us know that our lives are going to be sacrificed for some supposedly greater good and I hope very few of us would have the hubris to equate our personal struggles with what reportedly happened to Jesus.

Even as an atheist, this is one of the great mysteries to me. I've never been any good at making leaps of either faith or logic, I have to see the whole argument laid out in rational steps and justified at every point before it makes sense to me, and this one eludes me entirely. How can one person take on all the 'sins of the world,' whatever that means, for all time, for everybody? Why didn't the whole world get that message at the same time? I've been told at various times by various people that god has not seen fit to remove the scales from my eyes, that I'm arrogant and ignorant, that I'm a scoffer and a mocker and worse, that I'm damned for all time because I insist on reasoned explanations and justifications, that doubt and reason and logic are bad and useless things, that I am personally a bad man, and I've had scripture cited at me to justify all those claims. I reject it all. It fundamentally doesn't make sense to me.

It's not intended to make sense to you Dex, it's intended to inform you of your inadequacy. Religions that claim a system of rules and formula for human interaction must begin with discrediting anyones ability to arive at a system of rules or formula out of their own mind. That's why the notion of sinfulness gives such depth and breadth to those who'd impose their own systems and formulas on everyone else.

We (human beings) find something that "works", but if some element of that "work" or some facet of the process involved raises questions for which no apparent immediate answer arises, we're encouraged to seek the "answers" from our holy works rituals and ceremonies. When that thing that once "worked" doesn't work, its never the observation that the solution was temporal in nature because the problem was temporal in nature, but more likely to be that it wasn't Allah's will or Gods will or failed or became useless because it had not flowed from that manual of formula and systemics that permits the incredible and the invisible to command human thought.

It's a game Dex...always has been and always will be...
 

look3467

Council Member
Dec 13, 2006
1,952
15
38
Northern California
It's not intended to make sense to you Dex, it's intended to inform you of your inadequacy. Religions that claim a system of rules and formula for human interaction must begin with discrediting anyones ability to arive at a system of rules or formula out of their own mind. That's why the notion of sinfulness gives such depth and breadth to those who'd impose their own systems and formulas on everyone else.

We (human beings) find something that "works", but if some element of that "work" or some facet of the process involved raises questions for which no apparent immediate answer arises, we're encouraged to seek the "answers" from our holy works rituals and ceremonies. When that thing that once "worked" doesn't work, its never the observation that the solution was temporal in nature because the problem was temporal in nature, but more likely to be that it wasn't Allah's will or Gods will or failed or became useless because it had not flowed from that manual of formula and systemics that permits the incredible and the invisible to command human thought.

It's a game Dex...always has been and always will be...MikeyDB

Religion is always evolving. It is as like a child born 2,000 years ago and growing up amidst contradictions, restrictions and persecutions.

So I can understand what you said which fits the pattern.

But, the reality of it is, is that God is tempering it, guiding it, honing it and working to get this child grown up to maturity.
Many of us, are matured and many are still childish in our thinking.

But collectively, the child is growing and will some day become fully mature.

Peace>>>AJ:love9:
 

AndyF

Electoral Member
Jan 5, 2007
384
7
18
Ont
look3467:

I mean, if God wanted all good, then He would have never placed the tree of knowledge in the earth.
Your implying that He was tricking the people. 8O The tree was placed to taunt Adam and Eve, so that He can "teach" evil to them?. I think your moving on to breaking some pretty basic precepts of even Protestant religions. ;-)

Perhaps he placed it there because it simply was His and he wanted His earthly property respected and cared for and no one was to disrespect His wishes. He claimed earthly property elsewhere also. Remember the burning bush that Moses just happened to come upon?. God said that the ground it was on was holy ground. Was the ground holy just because he wanted to taunt people once again; just to see if Moses would walk on it with his sandles?

Apart from evil, can you tell me how to measure good?
Your claiming it is an absolute that we need evil to compare good. Isn't heaven doing fine without evil? Do the angels need to review the day's evil accomplishments to analyze the day's cumulative good. Here is a place before your very eyes where evil does not exist and good get's created and celebrated continuously.

What we are asked to do is obey God as servants, and to observe that all acts are in conformance to the law. The good comes from those acts. If we are to watch anything, it is to be obedient. We can measure our good against other good in order to see if we can accomplish more, or in a better way, just as we would to see if a gift is well wrapped or more presentable. We can compare good with good, evil has no place in this exclusive club.

......as we learn who we are.
Not necessary. We were already told.....Servants.

Rom 8:20 For the creature was made subject to vanity, not willingly, but by reason of him who hath subjected the same in hope,
I think you need the New American Bible with footnotes that actually explain the passages rather than leaving the reader to his interpretations. My passage doesn't read the same either.

Here Paul merely "considers the created world to be linked to human destiny through it's solidarity with man", etc. Nowhere does it say man cannot control his own acts,avoid evil, or make a difference on earth.

AndyF
 

look3467

Council Member
Dec 13, 2006
1,952
15
38
Northern California
Your implying that He was tricking the people. 8OThe tree was placed to taunt Adam and Eve, so that He can "teach" evil to them?. I think your moving on to breaking some pretty basic precepts of even Protestant religions. ;-)>>> AndyF
The story of Adam and Eve is at best the easiest way to introduce to mankind its creator and the reason for evil in the world.
In other wards, God created a situation by which mankind had to seek Him out.

There was no deceiving and there is no lie. The story shows how mankind acquires knowledge, and what that knowledge reveals.
That knowledge reveals a standard by which good and evil can be measured.

One finds out(Assuming one acquires a belief in God) that we fall short of Gods kingdom as depicted in the expulsion from the garden, and therefore, creating a need to seek redemption.
God provides that redemption for us, for He created the situation we find ourselves in.

Perhaps he placed it there because it simply was His and he wanted His earthly property respected and cared for and no one was to disrespect His wishes. He claimed earthly property elsewhere also. Remember the burning bush that Moses just happened to come upon?. God said that the ground it was on was holy ground. Was the ground holy just because he wanted to taunt people once again; just to see if Moses would walk on it with his sandles? >>> AndyF

The ground was Holy simply because the presence of God was there, and taking off the sandals represents shaking off earthly attachments that represent bondage to the soul.

When we comes to God, we come to Him in heart and in spirit only. No earthly attachments to hinder us from truly worshiping Him.

Your claiming it is an absolute that we need evil to compare good. Isn't heaven doing fine without evil? Do the angels need to review the day's evil accomplishments to analyze the day's cumulative good. Here is a place before your very eyes where evil does not exist and good get's created and celebrated continuously. >>> AndyF

Yes, it is an absolute. There can be no good apart from evil, hence the tree of knowledge of Good and Evil.
Evil simply means everything that is not of God. One doesn’t have to do something bad to some one to constitute evil. Just simply gorging oneself with lustful things is evil in itself.
The world is a lustful place for the body belongs to it.

What we are asked to do is obey God as servants, and to observe that all acts are in conformance to the law. The good comes from those acts. If we are to watch anything, it is to be obedient. We can measure our good against other good in order to see if we can accomplish more, or in a better way, just as we would to see if a gift is well wrapped or more presentable. We can compare good with good, evil has no place in this exclusive club. >>> AndyF

If what you said is true, then God would have not given us any knowledge by which to make any choices.
The object of the whole matter is to teach us obedience by experiencing the two opposites and where good is born out of.

Not necessary. We were already told.....Servants.>>> AndyF

Servants as long as there is a law, but when grace came in, the law ceased to perform, thereby, we become friends of the groom who performed the letter of the law in our stead.

I think you need the New American Bible with footnotes that actually explain the passages rather than leaving the reader to his interpretations. My passage doesn't read the same either.>>> AndyF

The ability to understand the whole picture is not on footnotes alone, but by the thought that prevails through out the whole bible.

The interpretation must be inline with the theme of the whole bible so that we don’t take a few verses and make of it any application we want.

That is the main argument against individual interpretation, which will always go against the established norm.

That is why you see Sanctus against what I say, because his is an established norm for the Catholic Church.

I see passed all that, and to the core of what the Theme of the bible is, and then apply my views which encompass the acceptance of all human souls as bought and paid for by God in Jesus.
Therefore we are no longer servants to the law, but friends of God in Jesus.


Here Paul merely "considers the created world to be linked to human destiny through it's solidarity with man", etc. Nowhere does it say man cannot control his own acts,avoid evil, or make a difference on earth.>>> AndyF

The created world was created for mankind to experience knowledge of good and evil, so that mankind could be like as gods, and rule by choice.

The preferred choice is good over the evil, but not before first experiencing the evil.

Let me add that evil is present in this world as bait for the flesh, but Godliness is not of this world, so nothing less then perfect good can be accepted.

And the only possible way that we can get away from evil presence is to either die, or give God our hearts so that He may reckon us as perfect good, and acceptable to God.

Peace>>>AJ:love9:
 

eh1eh

Blah Blah Blah
Aug 31, 2006
10,749
103
48
Under a Lone Palm
You know, there was no reason for Jesus to suffer. His dad owns the universe. Why din't he just fix things. I would if my dad was omnipotent. I hope I haven't cast anymore doubt on the story in the bible. It is already kind of sketchy. Did Jesus suffer like me? That is to assume I am suffering. Why do religions think people need their help to releive their suffering? What are they suffering from, is there something printed in the bible that says they should suffer?

Can someone answer these questions without bible quotes? (look3467):-|
 

look3467

Council Member
Dec 13, 2006
1,952
15
38
Northern California
the Holy Koran identifies Jesus as a Prophet not a God. There is only one God. How can a man be God?

The linage of both of Abraham's sons consider Jesus as a mere prophet.
Issac considered the "free born" the Jews and Ishmael the "Bondage born" the Muslims, both consider Jesus a prophet.
The Gentiles believers on the other hand, believe in Jesus as the son of God.

There is truly only one God, and Jesus is God in this respect. Yah is the name of the Father God, and Shua means salvation.
God the Father alone could save His own creation, so the name "Yahshua" means the Fathers salvation.

God with a new name that is eternal in the heavens by which all mankind should be saved.

Jesus is the key figure in the re-creation of the spiritual world, thereby making Him the Alpha and the Omega, meaning He was, is and forever shall be.

If you are a Muslim believer, Jesus has made provisions for your salvation whether you believe He is God or not.
But it does make a difference if you came to that realization while you still have life in the flesh to experience His wonderful glory.

This life grants us the opportunity to experience the god like qualities without the penality of eternal damnation.
I'm not sure whether you can understand what I said, because it requires understanding on Jesus accomplished mission.

Peace>>>AJ:love9:
 

sanctus

The Padre
Oct 27, 2006
4,558
48
48
Ontario
www.poetrypoem.com
You know, there was no reason for Jesus to suffer. His dad owns the universe. Why din't he just fix things. I would if my dad was omnipotent. I hope I haven't cast anymore doubt on the story in the bible. It is already kind of sketchy. Did Jesus suffer like me? That is to assume I am suffering. Why do religions think people need their help to releive their suffering? What are they suffering from, is there something printed in the bible that says they should suffer?

Can someone answer these questions without bible quotes? (look3467):-|

We are all suffering, in a spiritual sense, because of a separation from God. In a literal sense, we suffer by being upon this earth. not in the sense of deprivation so much, but through our efforts to survive in a world of chaos and misery.

Suffering happens at many levels, and often the biggest thing we suffer from is being alone surrounded by people.
 

look3467

Council Member
Dec 13, 2006
1,952
15
38
Northern California
You know, there was no reason for Jesus to suffer. His dad owns the universe. Why din't he just fix things. I would if my dad was omnipotent. I hope I haven't cast anymore doubt on the story in the bible. It is already kind of sketchy. Did Jesus suffer like me? That is to assume I am suffering. Why do religions think people need their help to releive their suffering? What are they suffering from, is there something printed in the bible that says they should suffer?

Can someone answer these questions without bible quotes? (look3467):-|

eh1eh,

How then could salvation come to mankind, if mankind was under the penalty of eternal death?
How could mankind save self when self had nothing to do with its original creation?

Peace>>>AJ:love9:
 

snfu73

disturber of the peace
eh1eh,

How then could salvation come to mankind, if mankind was under the penalty of eternal death?
How could mankind save self when self had nothing to do with its original creation?

Peace>>>AJ:love9:
Why do we need to be saved? Why is the emphasis on being saved? And from what? If someone is happy with their life and how it has unfolded, do they really need to be saved? And, is eternal existence...well...all it's cracked up to be??
 

look3467

Council Member
Dec 13, 2006
1,952
15
38
Northern California
There is nothing "holy" about that book. Further, who cares what it has to say about Jesus? It is a false teaching, a demonic plague upon the earth.

That's the response coming from a loving father? (Priest?)

Any religious belief that does not the following is, a plague upon the earth: 1Jo 3:10 In this the children of God are manifest, and the children of the devil: whosoever doeth not righteousness is not of God, neither he that loveth not his brother.

Now that shows no favorites.

Peace>>>AJ:love9: