Canadian Idol Fans Watching American Idol

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
How will they maintain their own style and yet deal with weird themes.

Like ross said, I think both David and Kris managed to do that. Cook and Mariah Carey week? Totally worked. Kris and Disco night? Great performance. Crystal and Lilly with Glam night? I'm not worried. But I'm very curious!!

ETA: Also, I want to keep Katelyn. I like her voice and I think she could do great... or maybe not. Still, I want to believe in her potential, so I hope she stays. I think she deserves it more than Lacey, Paige and Katie.
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
Like ross said, I think both David and Kris managed to do that. Cook and Mariah Carey week? Totally worked. Kris and Disco night? Great performance. Crystal and Lilly with Glam night? I'm not worried. But I'm very curious!!

Good point. That's when it gets really interesting. :)
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
Oops, I said Lilly played the ukelele when she played the mandolin. Well, you know what I meant.

I agree with Crystal, Siobhan and Didi being the top 3. I think the 4th will be Lilly.

These four were defintiely the best tonight. My order is different, I actually liked Didi the best tonight. Well, Crystal is amazing, though. Does anybody know what her background is? Has she recorded anything? What's her professional experience?
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
Does anybody know what her background is? Has she recorded anything? What's her professional experience?

Crystal? I vaguely recall a website or something with some guy??? Vague, vague recollection...?
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
Does anybody know what her background is? Has she recorded anything? What's her professional experience?

I know she recorded one or two (independant) albums. I posted a link to some of her original songs during the weekend. I got MP3s for some of them, but I haven't listened to them that much yet.

I think she must have been playing shows in her area, but I didn't see anything that made me believe she had more professional experience than say David Cook before Idol. Lots of experience, but not in the big leagues, I would say.
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
By the way, I STILL DON'T LIKE THE GENDER SPLIT. It's much more interesting to watch a mixed group competing. Also, I guess I just don't like the idea that there will be a Top 12 with 6 of each. It's arbitrary. But I guess, everything on this show is arbitrary.

I don't like it either. I want the most talented regardless of gender.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
DialIdol.com - Measuring the busy signal.

^DialIdol "overall score" graph^

I don't get the Lacey Brown love.

I just questioned one of the nincompoops (nincompoops, I say!) on that little ol' Idol blog, who used the expression "hiding behind their intruments." Why I bother to do things like this, je ne sais pas. Just plain stupid, I guess.

Why would anyone have a problem with a pop or rock singer playing an instrument?
Seriously, can one of you patient souls please try to explain it to me? Have they (artists) not been playing instruments forever? It goes beyond the Kris-Adam rivalry. (Or does it? I don't know, maybe not.) Well, moving on . . .

Thanks for the thoughts about Crystal. I just find her ridiculously polished. She seems to be not only a God-given talent but also very sure of who she is as an artist, and ready to make a record tomorrow. I just don't see too many of those competing on AI, usually. (ETA: This sounds like I resent her for it, somehow -- I don't know why. I don't think I do.)
 
Last edited:

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
I don't get the commericals - so I feel ripped off

Aw, I do get them here on the Vermont Fox station. Love them!

I have no clue about the singers hiding behind their instrument thing. Idol actually started making sense for me personally when they added instruments. That's when I started to be a huge fan of CI. That's when I started to watch AI. So, I have absolutely no clue why it should be a problem.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
The "leaves" Kris/Ford ad on YouTube seems somewhat different from the actual ad. I think maybe it's an alternate take. I don't know what it is. Anyhow, it's too bad you don't get to see the ads!

If Alright With Me becomes the next single, all the 20,000 or so sales, so far, won't count towards it, right? As they're from the "album version."

I think iTunes has really messed with album sales. Why buy an album when you can buy individual songs off the album? Before ITunes you just had to buy the album if you wanted to hear a song that wasn't a single.
 
Last edited:

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
Oh, Lacey. I don't get it either. Looking at that graph it looks like Lily is in trouble. Please America don't keep Lacey over Lilly.

Seriously, can one of you patient souls please try to explain it to me? Have they (artists) not been playing instruments forever? It goes beyond the Kris-Adam rivalry. (Or does it? I don't know, maybe not.) Well, moving on

It's probably an Idol thing. In the real world.. instruments are good. (musician) On Idol they are evil and it means you are "cheating".
 

SleepinIn

House Member
Dec 24, 2008
3,799
0
36
Oh man.. I am missing the real Kris commerical #Sleepininisrippedoff (I think Jim's tagging disease is catching)

If Alright With Me becomes the next single, all the 20,000 or so sales, so far, won't count towards it, right? As they're from the "album version."

I think they still count, don't they? When they count the singles sold for LLWD they count them from both versions Deluxe and regular album. I think when the singles don't count is when the person then buys the Album (Complete the album thing) and then they take them away from the total of singles.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
I have no clue about the singers hiding behind their instrument thing. Idol actually started making sense for me personally when they added instruments. That's when I started to be a huge fan of CI. That's when I started to watch AI. So, I have absolutely no clue why it should be a problem.

I actually used to feel that CI should hold auditions like AI -- no instruments. The reason being that I felt people with instruments had an unfair advantage -- the judges could hear them accompanied by an instrument, while the ones that didn't play instruments had to sing a capella. But my feeling changed about that -- not sure why, but it just changed. I do think, though, that they should give singers who can't play an instrument an opportunity to bring someone to acconpany them. But logistically that's probably not a good idea.

Anyhow I think people who say instruments are a crutch, or that people are hiding behind them, are somehow not really into music.
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
If Alright With Me becomes the next single, all the 20,000 or so sales, so far, won't count towards it, right? As they're from the "album version."

No, all sales of the song will count. Also, for a second single, they don't necessarily release something else on iTunes. People can buy the album version if they want only the song. LLWD was released before the album, so they needed to release a single. For example, Light On was sold as a single, but Come Back to Me was not sold seperately from the album version. They can do something like this, though, for example, if they release remixes of the song, or B-sides. But, still, all the sales of the song count towards the sales of the single. Like, right now, whether people buy LLWD from the single or from the album doesn't matter. If they buy the song, it both counts for the sales.

Why buy an album when you can buy individula songs off the album?

I love that about iTunes actually. I admittedly buy more albums than singles in general, and I buy more albums than most people as well, but sometimes, you just want to buy Poker Face, not the whole Lady Gaga album. Which is what I did. So, I think, in my case, it's good for the artist, because there's no way I would've bought Lady Gaga's whole album. But, yeah, I'm probably not representative of the average music consumer at all.
 

missaddicted

House Member
Jan 16, 2009
3,177
0
36
I think they still count, don't they? When they count the singles sold for LLWD they count them from both versions Deluxe and regular album. I think when the singles don't count is when the person then buys the Album (Complete the album thing) and then they take them away from the total of singles.

Yes, I'm pretty sure that's totally accurate.
 

ross 1

Senate Member
Dec 21, 2008
5,858
2
38
It's probably an Idol thing. In the real world.. instruments are good. (musician) On Idol they are evil and it means you are "cheating".

I get it. Yeah, I think you're right.

Oh man.. I am missing the real Kris commerical.

I may be loco about that. It just sounds like the same words but a different tone of voice.