Budget 2018: Ontario Can't Afford Doug Ford's Cuts

Vbeacher

Electoral Member
Sep 9, 2013
651
36
28
Ottawa
This coming election is Ford's to lose. All he needs to do is promise specific well-thought out but major spending cuts and not promise any tax cuts. He could express a desire to reduce taxes and a plan to reduce taxes to the extent that it does not result in a budget deficit but don't promise it and that should win him a ton of votes.

Given half the population pays little or no taxes he will have to offer them free stuff if he hopes to get their votes. They only vote for political parties that give them ever more free stuff.
 

Curious Cdn

Hall of Fame Member
Feb 22, 2015
37,070
8
36
The ones that pay little or no tax will probably get a great, big tax cut right off the bat like the one that Trump just gave the filthy rich in his juridtiction. They,'re only 10% of the population, though.
 

White_Unifier

Senate Member
Feb 21, 2017
7,300
2
36
Given half the population pays little or no taxes he will have to offer them free stuff if he hopes to get their votes. They only vote for political parties that give them ever more free stuff.

If that's true, then maybe it's time to explore a different political system. The traditional democratic systems might have run their course.
 

Twin_Moose

Hall of Fame Member
Apr 17, 2017
22,041
6,160
113
Twin Moose Creek
In scathing pre-election report, Ontario auditor general says deficit is $11.7B, not $6.7B

Ontario’s fiscal watchdog is again questioning the government’s accounting, warning the province’s deficit projections are far greater than outlined in last month’s budget.
Auditor general Bonnie Lysyk, who has an ongoing accounting dispute with Premier Kathleen Wynne’s Liberals, said Wednesday that this year’s shortfall is $11.7 billion, not $6.7 billion, as Finance Minister Charles Sousa forecast March 28.
“When expenses are understated, the perception is created that government has more money available than it actually does,” Lysyk wrote in a scathing 27-page pre-election report to the Legislature.
“Government decision-makers might, therefore, allocate money to initiatives and programs that is actually needed to pay for expenses the government has failed to record properly,” she continued.
Lysyk calculated that the deficit forecast for next year is $12.2 billion, not the $6.6 billion Sousa predicted, and for 2020-21 it’s $12.5 billion, not $6.5 billion.
“More money will need to be borrowed to pay for the unrecorded expenses even when the government reports an annual surplus or a balanced budget.”
Her report is a political gift to Progressive Conservative Leader Doug Ford and NDP Leader Andrea Horwath as Ontarians head to the polls in six weeks.
The accounting disagreement stems from whether around $11 billion in the government co-sponsored Ontario Public Service Employees’ Union Pension Plan and the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan can be counted toward the bottom line.
While Lysyk and her predecessors had booked the pension holdings as an asset starting in 2002, she changed her mind two years ago.
“I had my staff review that asset much more than in past years,” she told the Star at the time. She concluded that they should not be considered assets, because the government doesn’t have ready access to the funds.
It is unclear whether the Progressive Conservatives or the New Democrats would adopt Lysyk’s accounting practice and not count the pension funds if either party topples the Liberals in the June 7 election.
Wynne conceded Wednesday there is an “ongoing discussion” with the auditor general over the accounting “disagreement.”
“I know one of the discussions is over the Fair Hydro Plan. We made a decision that we needed to reduce electricity bills by 25 per cent. We have done that,” said the premier.
“We’ve kept that debt within the electricity system. That is the responsible step that we have taken,” she said.
Lysyk has had a fractious relationship with the governing Liberals in recent years.
Advertisement

Aside from being at odds with the government over its Fair Hydro Plan scheme to borrow money to reduce electricity rates by 25 per cent, she has railed against the Liberals diminishing her authority when it comes to overseeing government advertising.

I'm with the AG that pensions should not be looked at as an asset

A question to you MF since you are in finance, in default can creditors secure the pension plan for payment?
 

Danbones

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 23, 2015
24,505
2,198
113
LOL, the day the government illinois's those pensions will be very interesting.
;)
If the government ever gets their hands on that money, even as collateral, kiss it goodbye.
(LIKE MFs good buddy CLINTON did with the us pension funds)

Meanwhile we have a national central bank that could have us doing as well as the state bank is doing in the dakotas...but noe, we can't have financial success, the crooked bankers and politicians can't steal everything that way.
 

IdRatherBeSkiing

Satelitte Radio Addict
May 28, 2007
15,266
2,893
113
Toronto, ON
Speaking of not being able to budget, appearently Wynn has been lying about the size of her deficit by only several billion dollars.

Ontario Liberals understating deficit by billions: auditor | CBC News

The Kathleen Wynne government is low-balling its budget deficits by billions of dollars, according to a report released Wednesday by the province's auditor general, just six weeks ahead of the provincial election.
The Liberal government's projected deficit of $6.7 billion for 2018-19 should actually be $11.7 billion, says Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk in her pre-election report on government finances.
 

Mowich

Hall of Fame Member
Dec 25, 2005
16,649
998
113
76
Eagle Creek
Speaking of not being able to budget, appearently Wynn has been lying about the size of her deficit by only several billion dollars.

Ontario Liberals understating deficit by billions: auditor | CBC News

The Kathleen Wynne government is low-balling its budget deficits by billions of dollars, according to a report released Wednesday by the province's auditor general, just six weeks ahead of the provincial election.
The Liberal government's projected deficit of $6.7 billion for 2018-19 should actually be $11.7 billion, says Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk in her pre-election report on government finances.

Lysyk said the government failed to account properly for the financial impact of its Fair Hydro Plan on provincial coffers and improperly treated the revenues and expenses related to two provincial pension plans.

For the same reasons, the auditor says the Liberals are underestimating the deficits in future years:

  • $6.6 billion deficit in 2019-20 should be $12.2 billion.
  • $6.5 billion deficit in 2020-21 should be $12.5 billion.
Ontario Liberals understating deficit by billions: auditor | CBC News
 

Danbones

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 23, 2015
24,505
2,198
113
Ok, so an ability to do basic math ( or at least the ability to punch some calculator buttons, or have an aid do it...) would be considered an essential skill for this job I take it?
;)'
why has no one noticed that before?
 

10larry

Electoral Member
Apr 6, 2010
722
0
16
Niagara Falls
Creative accounting has long been a lib mainstay starting with justyns late father, not to worry after justyn hits the auto balance key he'll e-mail his buddy wynne the formula and delete those $bils from her balance sheet. Hopefully for once trudough has a clue if not our gkids will never be able to keep up the interest payments let alone pay off the lib legacy.
 

JLM

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 27, 2008
75,301
548
113
Vernon, B.C.
Ford to eclipse Wynne's deficits with absolutely no revenue and Ontario will be paying for generations for his mistakes.


Driving Ontario over the cliff: Doug Ford’s fiscal plan

U.S. President Donald Trump has taught us all about so-called political discourse based on “huge” exaggerations and falsehoods.

As I write this, Trump is pushing the stock market into a vertical nose divehttps://www.thestar.com/opinion/con...io-over-the-cliff-doug-fords-fiscal-plan.html

I think it's called a CORRECTION, Flossie, after 14 months of unprecedented climb! Next week it will be going the other way again, much to Walter's delight! :lol:
 

OpposingDigit

Electoral Member
Aug 27, 2017
903
0
16
Dalton McGuinty created this type of reporting by the auditor because when McGuinty and the Liberals first took office after Harris and The Clowns, there was a hidden deficit of 10 billion dollars.

And, I keep sayin' ..... quit worrying about deficits. The Ruling Class will just print more money. They only battle about which bunch of crony capitalists will receive the freshly created money.

Deficit talk is all propaganda. Totally propaganda. There is no value at all to money which is created by fractional reserve currencies. It is all in our heads. Put there and nourished by the Capitalists.

The U.S. Capitalists are running scared .... they are totally worried about the class war on the horizon as what happened during Hitler's reign. Just today, there was a law passed in the South Carolina senate that any criticism of Israel "Whether Factual Or Not" is anti-semetic. I am sure that all across North America laws like this will be tweaked so as any criticism of any bank owned/operated or managed by somebody of Jewish origin will be deemed as being anti-semetic and therefore impermissible.
https://israelpalestinenews.org/lan...f-israel-sneaks-through-south-carolina-senate
 
Last edited:

Danbones

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 23, 2015
24,505
2,198
113
They say Voltaire himself said that you can tell who would enslave you and be your master, because they would put themselves above your right to criticize them.


Lazy people always have excuses

You certainly do.

Here is the government that people like MF and Cannuck want to see in Canada...I guess they have all the available loot here lined right up.

The Pentagon and HUD can’t account for $21 trillion over just the past 17 years – enough money to pay back the current U.S. national debt.
https://americandigitalnews.com/2017/12/24/follow-money-21-trillion-missing/#.WuG36m4vw4h

Yup, that amount of stolen dough will buy a lot of fake news. Just ask CNN and the WAPO.
 
Last edited:

Cannuck

Time Out
Feb 2, 2006
30,245
99
48
Alberta
Here is the government that people like MF and Cannuck want to see in Canada...I guess they have all the available loot here lined right up.

The Pentagon and HUD can’t account for $21 trillion over just the past 17 years – enough money to pay back the current U.S. national debt.
https://americandigitalnews.com/2017/12/24/follow-money-21-trillion-missing/#.WuG36m4vw4h

Yup, that amount of stolen dough will buy a lot of fake news. Just ask CNN and the WAPO.

I want governments to reduce their size and balance their budgets. You and Flossy don't.
 

Jinentonix

Hall of Fame Member
Sep 6, 2015
11,619
6,262
113
Olympus Mons
Ford doesn’t have a plan.

He's already done worse and Wynne has actually done quite well for the province.
:lol: in 15 years the Liberals managed to triple the provincial debt with next to nothing to show for it. In the last 5-10 years housing prices at least doubled in Ontario.
We know the Wynned Bag's plan, lie through her f*cking teeth. Even the budget is 100% Grade A bullshit. The Auditor General released her report stating the Liberals have understated projected deficits by as much as 75%.

Ontario’s Auditor-General says the Liberals have understated the province’s projected deficits by billions of dollars, casting doubt on the government’s fiscal forecast weeks ahead of a spring election.

It’s the latest development in a long-running dispute between Bonnie Lysyk and Canada’s second-largest government. Finance Minister Charles Sousa repeated his assertion on Wednesday that the Liberals had delivered a small surplus for the fiscal year ended March 31 – the first balanced budget in Ontario since the financial crisis of 2008-09. However, during the release of last month’s budget, he projected deficits of more than $6-billion over each of the next three years and further shortfalls for the following three.

Ms. Lysyk presented a much different picture on Wednesday when she released her review of last month’s pre-election report, a financial document that the government is obliged to present to Ontarians before an election. She concluded that the report substantially understated expenses and deficits and “is not a reasonable presentation of Ontario’s finances.”

Using proper accounting, she said, this fiscal year’s deficit should have been forecast at $11.7-billion, or 75 per cent higher than the government’s estimate of $6.7-billion. By 2020, Ms. Lysyk’s estimate of the deficit is nearly double that supplied by the government.

Ms. Lysyk warned that understated deficits could lead officials to authorize new spending “when the money is actually needed to pay for expenses they’ve already incurred.”

The discrepancies arise from two distinct issues. The first is the Fair Hydro Plan, introduced last year to lower electricity rates for Ontario consumers. Ms. Lysyk said the government will now have to borrow to pay power generators for providing electricity. But neither those expenses nor the resulting interest costs, she said, were included in the pre-election report’s estimates, resulting in distortions that add up to more than $2-billion each year over the next three years. Ms. Lysyk said last year that the government deliberately structured the rate-reduction plan to avoid showing a deficit and rising debt on its books.

The second issue involves how the government calculates pension expenses. The Auditor-General says the government is erroneously recording revenue from the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan, and “insufficient” expenses from the Ontario Public Service Employees’ Union Pension Plan.

Eleanor McMahon, president of the Treasury Board, Mr. Sousa and Ms. Lysyk met on Tuesday to discuss their differences; all three characterized the discussions as respectful, but no resolution was reached. “Our opinion hasn’t changed,” Ms. McMahon said.

Mr. Sousa defended the government’s financial presentation. “Ontario has been noted for having the most transparent numbers by the Conference Board of Canada,” he told reporters. “Nothing is hidden.”

The Conference Board said it doesn’t rank provincial governments on transparency or quality of financial reporting. “I’ve talked to all different people, and nobody seems to know where this is coming from,” spokeswoman Yvonne Squires said. “We don’t have research in this area.”

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/can...ral-says-province-substantially-understating/

:lol: :lol: The Libtards are just making shit up as they go along.
 

10larry

Electoral Member
Apr 6, 2010
722
0
16
Niagara Falls
Dalton McGuinty created this type of reporting by the auditor because when McGuinty and the Liberals first took office after Harris and The Clowns, there was a hidden deficit of 10 billion dollars.

And, I keep sayin' ..... quit worrying about deficits. The Ruling Class will just print more money. They only battle about which bunch of crony capitalists will receive the freshly created money.

Deficit talk is all propaganda. Totally propaganda. There is no value at all to money which is created by fractional reserve currencies. It is all in our heads. Put there and nourished by the Capitalists.

The U.S. Capitalists are running scared .... they are totally worried about the class war on the horizon as what happened during Hitler's reign. Just today, there was a law passed in the South Carolina senate that any criticism of Israel "Whether Factual Or Not" is anti-semetic. I am sure that all across North America laws like this will be tweaked so as any criticism of any bank owned/operated or managed by somebody of Jewish origin will be deemed as being anti-semetic and therefore impermissible.
https://israelpalestinenews.org/lan...f-israel-sneaks-through-south-carolina-senate

No revelation that fiat currency is pretty much on par with monopoly money however peons pay a heavy price in financing this political shell game that banksters luv. Liberals like justyn and wynne see no prob flushing a few $bil per month into banksters pockets but joe n' jane envision that enormous amount of cash being of service to canucks. After all they trusted libs to use their money wisely instad of lieing through their teeth about how they not only squandered that trust but try to cover it up with creative accounting.
Thank gawd bonnie respects the public trust placed in her.
 

OpposingDigit

Electoral Member
Aug 27, 2017
903
0
16
I recall the doom and gloom chants from Ronnie Ray-Gun about Federal Budget deficits and at that time it was about Zero.

Then, I remember all the doom and gloom about deficits from Bill Clinton and through the decades since where every president nearly wept with apprehension concerning the deficit increases rising from about a trillion dollars under George W. Bush to 21 trillion with Donald Trump, and with a projected deficit of 28 trillion dollars by 2027.

And, then add to that, another 21 Trillion Dollars Missing In The Federal Budget Going Back To 1998.
https://usawatchdog.com/21-trillion...t-a-criminal-enterprise-catherine-austin-fits

Quit worrying about deficits ..... it is all a scam.

Deficit Talk is all about convincing the voters to vote against their best interests.
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
The deficits and the debts belong to the 99%. The 1% designed it that way.
 

OpposingDigit

Electoral Member
Aug 27, 2017
903
0
16
I keep saying ..... it is all a myth. A total scam. A belief system like a religion. It is a fantasy.

Nobody intends to honour any debt. Any argument and you will get nuked.

It may be easier to understand with the use of pictures ....

How Much Is A Trillion Dollars?
What does one TRILLION dollars look like?

U.S. Debt Visualized - Stacked In 100 Dollar Bills
US Debt Visualized: Stacked in $100 dollar bills at 20+ Trillion USD for 2017

US debt visualized: Stacked in 100 dollar bills @ 15 Trillion Dollars (2011)





 
Last edited:

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
well, they're real and they need attention.

It will be the kids who get stuck with it.