"The west wants out": Separatist sentiments growing in Alberta

Serryah

Hall of Fame Member
Dec 3, 2008
10,845
2,729
113
New Brunswick
And there it is. We aren't looking for a hand out or charity. We're looking for the ability to be successful or or remain successful without the rest of Canada who are suppose to be our countrymen (that whole 'united we stand....' when it suits the narrative) trying to impose restrictions on our lives and livelihoods. If anything, we could use the support of OUR Nation to remain successful.

We'll pay to play to be Canadians, but expect the ability to pay to play to not be removed from us if we're expected to pay, but then to have others mock us for just wanting to be able to be successful? You may not be, but you are not most of the narrative inside Canada not from the Prairies. I KNOW People who are out of work due to this Woke Posturing regarding the pipelines. I KNOW People who are worried and waiting to see what this Federal Gov't (Now a minority with support to come from the three other parties that campaigned against the Prairies) will do to remain in power at our expense. With 150,000 people out of work just from the Oil Industry in SK & AB, it's hard for most people out here not to personally KNOW Someone who isn't affected. We Need to get this Product to Markets outside the USA who will only pay pennies on the dollar 'cuz they know we're screwed (by our own countrymen) in being able to get this product anywhere but to the one country we're physically connected to in any significantly modern quantity. That's sure a Canadian thing to be proud of...."We don't use your dirty Western Oil or Alberta Beef and we'd better find a different source of Uranium to power 60% of Ontario if it's coming from Saskatchewan 'cuz we're the REAL Canadians!!" We are listening.



You make good points.


The people I know of who have gone out to the prairies then come back actually have said they liked it there but it just didn't feel like home.


The one thing I like about minority governments is that everyone is forced to work together. But you do make a valid point that the left side of things right now may pass things in coalition despite what the cons might want. I would hope that the liberals would work to try and make things more equal and appealing enough to get con votes/support and we'll just have to wait and see.


I'm all for Alberta Beef - but then I also support local - and most people I know support it. Just sayin'.


We buy Ontario's Cars and Drink our Milk (which isn't coming from the prairies) and smoke that BC Bud, and last night my Girlfriend & I steamed up lobster claws from Costco that they say are Canadian sourced (& also probably not from the Prairies). We pay our taxes and go about our lives and we watch and we listen. We aren't the hillbillies and hicks and dumb rednecks we're parodied as. On this very forum are members PROUD of the fact that they don't support all of Canada because they are REAL Canadians (selectively, I guess).


There's stereotypes everywhere really. I've tried not to think of people out west as rednecks or hillbillies though I admit it's hard. I'm not a fish person or a wife of a fisherman and despite things I am proud of Canada as a whole; not having Quebec, or the Prairies, as part of Canada would, to me, mean there is no Canada. To put it another way, for all the BS going on now if something happened to Alberta, Saskatchewan or Manitoba (which I've been to Winnipeg and liked it for the limited time I stayed), my first thought would be "how can I help". I know I'm an odd duck out of a lot of people I know though...



We have had a shit run of luck as of late with the Coldest winter in 84 years last year followed by a very dry Spring and a cold wet Summer & a cold wet Fall...and an early winter that hasn't done our agriculture any favours...and we're told (in Saskatchewan) that our plans on the Climate issue aren't up to Mr. Trudeau's standards so he'll impose his own vision upon us. Seriously....really? Justin, Get Bent!! There's the whole Global Warning/Changing/Cooling/Extreme'ing of Settled Science thing rearing it's head but that's a different topic for a different Thread where we can see Mr Trudeau posturing for the IPCC and various other celebrities as a Woke Political Religious Move
ment willing to sacrifice specific regions of OUR Nation to the AGW Gods (but not others...) when our only other physically connected trade partner that is tenfold our population isn't drinking the cool-aide? That is economic suicide for specific regions of OUR Nation (but again, not others...).



The issue of Climate change is, as you said, for another thread. All I can say on it is that the back and forth pizzes me off, I do not understand why caring about the planet is such an evil thing but I also think being connected and giving slack to other nations who do worse environmentally than us is not just counter productive, but hypocritical and if we're gonna put on our own people consequences of climate, then we should do so to the imports from other countries as well.


But to be fair, there was time given for all provinces to come up with their own 'carbon tax' idea and those that didn't had one imposed. NS came up with their own idea and they're fine. NB stalled and had one put in for us.


Now gas is cheaper in NS than here, even though it used to be the other way around. If it was imposed on Sask like on NB, that's on your Provincial government, not on Trudeau really for being too whatever about the issue (lazy, ignorant, thought it'd go away, whatever). Least that's how I think of it. Now we're paying the price because our Provincal government sucks.


India had a drought so that they aren't ordering as much Prairie Potash for fertilizer this round? Well, things happen in cycles and it'll come given the chance. We still do multi-billion dollar trade with India and from the Prairies it's Lentils & Peas & other Pulse Crops...& Trudeau isn't going to interfere in that, right? Four years ago the question would have been, "How could he possibly undermine Canada on that front?"



Not sure but I think I'm missing the point here. Or missing references.


Freeland Tweeting her Twitter pissing off Saudi Arabia...so the Saudi's will stop buying Canadian wheat & barley? OK


Honestly... good. I despise Saudi right now for a lot of reasons and if they stop buying our stuff, we should be looking elsewhere to sell.


....Hauwei Exec arrested in Vancouver....so the Chinese will stop buying Canadian Canola? Ok


That was a cluserfuk that I put not just on our government, but the US as well. Personally? I say terf the lady out of Canada, let the US do their own dirty work at this point since we did our job and they decided to screw the pooch to make US out to be the bad guys, and IMO we should avoid China all together or as much as possible.


...there seems to be a pattern here. As Canadians, we sure didn't elect Donald Trump to be the President of the ONE Country we're physically connected to, but we can quickly get off our duff's and react to the new reality instead of hamstringing ourselves like we've done. Getting pipelines built to the coasts was the immediate thing that should have been going full steam in Canada since November 10th, 2016.


And screw what the local people - not just in Canada but the US - thought about it? Screw where these lines would go? That's part of what people had issues with. I know you're not going to win over everyone who was/is against pipelines; hell it took time for me to be won over to the fact but railroading things through even before Trump was in office would never have worked, and it definitely won't work now with his stripping out the EPA so that regulations are less than they should be. And while the US might have the right to pollute their lands if something happens with a spill, for me at least I still care that it'll affect people for who knows how long.


When other Nations wish to punish Canada over diplomacy or in trade, they seem to see clearly how best to kick Canada right in the balls, & how to harm OUR Nation in a manner that is most destructive to OUR Nation.
I read Newspaper articles and Op-Eds from those in Central Canada telling the rest of Canada that this Western alienation is a Joke and it'll blow over 'cuz it always has and it always will...and it's a minority of a minority, etc...yet how can other Nations see this and use it when the rest of Canada can't see this and claim it's not real....is it a 'forest for the trees' thing or just utter arrogance?



Which is why I DON'T take it as just another bunch of bologna, but serious. And while I'm trying to learn the concerns and all and trying to understand it, from some people it sounds like all it is, is whining and bitching because "their guy" didn't get in, thus they lost, thus they're pizzed off and that just pizzes me off in return. I mean, there are people who can't even admit that the cause of the loss was due to the social policy of the Con party and how it just will not work with the rest of Canada and because of that, the con party is in trouble.


I don't expect everyone to work together - too many regional differences - and I certainly don't expect we all sing kumbaya or anything, but I'd feel the same way if Quebec was throwing another tantrum over them not being super special (which is another thread too)


Does the West want out or does it really just want in? The reality is....it's not the West's choice either way but the choice of the rest OUR Nation.

This last Federal Election was telling. Look at it! The Prairies aren't just AB & SK. The Prairies voted for the one Party that wasn't Demonizing it and claiming to want to gut it and replace the economy with Unicorn & Fairy Dust sales that currently don't exist....& this coming from the same political slant that can't even successfully sell weed? Really? Oh Lord, that's a jagged pill to try and swallow.



And as I mentioned, socially it just isn't going to mesh with the rest of Canada. I think the question needs to be ask, WHY didn't the PC's win more outside of the prairies. They won some places, sure, but why didn't they win MORE? They should have; FFS Trudeau screwed the dog enough that he deserved to lose.


I didn't vote blue - why? Because while I might have agreed with economic stuff, socially I just could not stand with Sheer. I've a friend in Calgary who didn't vote for Sheer? Why? Because she's a Minority of different types and the PC's did not do anything to help her feel that she or others like her would be welcomed.


Same with a friend from Edmonton.


The PC's don't have to sell their souls or bend over backwards to be better in the social aspect of their platform, but they sure as hell need to make more of an effort at least.


The reaction to the above from the Left Coast, or Central Canada, or the 905, or even from some in the East? "Well, if you wanted a voice in OUR Canada, you should'a voted for one of the Parties promising to put your nutz in a vice for your own good, don't you know?" Again, is this a 'forest for the trees' thing inside Canada or just complete and utter arrogance?


I can see some saying that. But personally, I'd put it as "You should'a had someone leading "your" party who actually wanted to include all of Canada and just not the West". That's how it felt to me personally, Sheer didn't give a damn about the rest of Canada, just the West. Which, mind you, is no better than the other way as you said. Which is why I couldn't vote Liberal, either.


Is it willful blindness that our trade partners and competitors aren't afflicted with? It's not a matter of the Prairies taking their ball and going home, but a matter of the rest of Canada deciding if it'll include or exclude the above blue swath in what I hope will remain OUR Canada. I'd like to say, "Govern Yourselves Accordingly" but we just elected Justin Trudeau again somehow...


But the problem is a lot of people see it as taking your ball and going home, because that's how it sounds. Truth or not, that's how it comes across. "Oh you didn't like and elect our guy, fine, screw you guys, we're going home and if you want us to play well you'd best do what we want and what we say or we won't ever play again." And it's that impression I hate.


But I also hate that to a lot of Westerners, the East means Ottawa and Quebec only, or that all the East, including (or maybe especially) the Maritimes and Newfoundland and Labrador are just people wanting handouts who don't want to work. It drives me absolutely bonkers that there's that kind of belief out there.



The Federal Election is now a couple of weeks in the past and what has happened? What has the Natural Governing Party of Canada done about anything so far? The World and Canada's place in it haven't sat idle for weeks waiting for Justin to get his poop in a group when he's had the last four years to accomplish that feat.


Not done enough, I agree. I don't expect the feds to do much honestly and I hate that, too.


Maybe I'm an idiot and naïve or whatever but the whole thought of this country tearing itself apart infuriates me and makes me want to take a baseball bat to everyone and play whack-a-fukin-mole for the stupidity going on, yell at them all to grow the fuk up and get serious about things.
 

Tecumsehsbones

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 18, 2013
60,150
9,431
113
Washington DC
It is kinda funny. "Ontario, Quebec, and BC supported us when we were nothing but a couple of trading posts in the middle of the prairie, but now that we've found something worth selling, we want OUT!"

"Canadian" and "traitor" are two words that have never gone naturally together in my mind. Guess it's time for the old dog to learn a new trick.
 

pgs

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 29, 2008
28,501
8,104
113
B.C.
It is kinda funny. "Ontario, Quebec, and BC supported us when we were nothing but a couple of trading posts in the middle of the prairie, but now that we've found something worth selling, we want OUT!"

"Canadian" and "traitor" are two words that have never gone naturally together in my mind. Guess it's time for the old dog to learn a new trick.
Yes they just discovered cattle and oil in Alberta last year .
 

taxslave

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 25, 2008
36,362
4,340
113
Vancouver Island
As soon as the threat of the west leaving gets as loud as Quebec the Feds will take us seriously and take steps to avoid loosing their ATM.
 

captain morgan

Hall of Fame Member
Mar 28, 2009
28,429
148
63
A Mouse Once Bit My Sister
Trust me, I do.


But since you don't seem to care, I guess there's nothing further to discuss.


The West has supported the East in hundreds of billions in cash low these many years.


Your assertion that no one cares falls pretty flat considering that the ROC has decided to throw the West under the bus.


And there it is. We aren't looking for a hand out or charity. We're looking for the ability to be successful or or remain successful without the rest of Canada who are suppose to be our countrymen (that whole 'united we stand....' when it suits the narrative) trying to impose restrictions on our lives and livelihoods. If anything, we could use the support of OUR Nation to remain successful.

We'll pay to play to be Canadians, but expect the ability to pay to play to not be removed from us if we're expected to pay, but then to have others mock us for just wanting to be able to be successful? You may not be, but you are not most of the narrative inside Canada not from the Prairies. I KNOW People who are out of work due to this Woke Posturing regarding the pipelines. I KNOW People who are worried and waiting to see what this Federal Gov't (Now a minority with support to come from the three other parties that campaigned against the Prairies) will do to remain in power at our expense. With 150,000 people out of work just from the Oil Industry in SK & AB, it's hard for most people out here not to personally KNOW Someone who isn't affected. We Need to get this Product to Markets outside the USA who will only pay pennies on the dollar 'cuz they know we're screwed (by our own countrymen) in being able to get this product anywhere but to the one country we're physically connected to in any significantly modern quantity. That's sure a Canadian thing to be proud of...."We don't use your dirty Western Oil or Alberta Beef and we'd better find a different source of Uranium to power 60% of Ontario if it's coming from Saskatchewan 'cuz we're the REAL Canadians!!" We are listening.

We buy Ontario's Cars and Drink our Milk (which isn't coming from the prairies) and smoke that BC Bud, and last night my Girlfriend & I steamed up lobster claws from Costco that they say are Canadian sourced (& also probably not from the Prairies). We pay our taxes and go about our lives and we watch and we listen. We aren't the hillbillies and hicks and dumb rednecks we're parodied as. On this very forum are members PROUD of the fact that they don't support all of Canada because they are REAL Canadians (selectively, I guess).

We have had a shit run of luck as of late with the Coldest winter in 84 years last year followed by a very dry Spring and a cold wet Summer & a cold wet Fall...and an early winter that hasn't done our agriculture any favours...and we're told (in Saskatchewan) that our plans on the Climate issue aren't up to Mr. Trudeau's standards so he'll impose his own vision upon us. Seriously....really? Justin, Get Bent!! There's the whole Global Warning/Changing/Cooling/Extreme'ing of Settled Science thing rearing it's head but that's a different topic for a different Thread where we can see Mr Trudeau posturing for the IPCC and various other celebrities as a Woke Political Religious Movement willing to sacrifice specific regions of OUR Nation to the AGW Gods (but not others...) when our only other physically connected trade partner that is tenfold our population isn't drinking the cool-aide? That is economic suicide for specific regions of OUR Nation (but again, not others...).

India had a drought so that they aren't ordering as much Prairie Potash for fertilizer this round? Well, things happen in cycles and it'll come given the chance. We still do multi-billion dollar trade with India and from the Prairies it's Lentils & Peas & other Pulse Crops...& Trudeau isn't going to interfere in that, right? Four years ago the question would have been, "How could he possibly undermine Canada on that front?" Freeland Tweeting her Twitter pissing off Saudi Arabia...so the Saudi's will stop buying Canadian wheat & barley? OK....Hauwei Exec arrested in Vancouver....so the Chinese will stop buying Canadian Canola? Ok...there seems to be a pattern here. As Canadians, we sure didn't elect Donald Trump to be the President of the ONE Country we're physically connected to, but we can quickly get off our duff's and react to the new reality instead of hamstringing ourselves like we've done. Getting pipelines built to the coasts was the immediate thing that should have been going full steam in Canada since November 10th, 2016.

When other Nations wish to punish Canada over diplomacy or in trade, they seem to see clearly how best to kick Canada right in the balls, & how to harm OUR Nation in a manner that is most destructive to OUR Nation. I read Newspaper articles and Op-Eds from those in Central Canada telling the rest of Canada that this Western alienation is a Joke and it'll blow over 'cuz it always has and it always will...and it's a minority of a minority, etc...yet how can other Nations see this and use it when the rest of Canada can't see this and claim it's not real....is it a 'forest for the trees' thing or just utter arrogance?

Does the West want out or does it really just want in? The reality is....it's not the West's choice either way but the choice of the rest OUR Nation.

This last Federal Election was telling. Look at it! The Prairies aren't just AB & SK. The Prairies voted for the one Party that wasn't Demonizing it and claiming to want to gut it and replace the economy with Unicorn & Fairy Dust sales that currently don't exist....& this coming from the same political slant that can't even successfully sell weed? Really? Oh Lord, that's a jagged pill to try and swallow.

The reaction to the above from the Left Coast, or Central Canada, or the 905, or even from some in the East? "Well, if you wanted a voice in OUR Canada, you should'a voted for one of the Parties promising to put your nutz in a vice for your own good, don't you know?" Again, is this a 'forest for the trees' thing inside Canada or just complete and utter arrogance? Is it willful blindness that our trade partners and competitors aren't afflicted with? It's not a matter of the Prairies taking their ball and going home, but a matter of the rest of Canada deciding if it'll include or exclude the above blue swath in what I hope will remain OUR Canada. I'd like to say, "Govern Yourselves Accordingly" but we just elected Justin Trudeau again somehow...

The Federal Election is now a couple of weeks in the past and what has happened? What has the Natural Governing Party of Canada done about anything so far? The World and Canada's place in it haven't sat idle for weeks waiting for Justin to get his poop in a group when he's had the last four years to accomplish that feat.


Post of the year Ron
+10 million
 

Twin_Moose

Hall of Fame Member
Apr 17, 2017
22,041
6,160
113
Twin Moose Creek
And there it is. We aren't looking for a hand out or charity. We're looking for the ability to be successful or or remain successful without the rest of Canada who are suppose to be our countrymen (that whole 'united we stand....' when it suits the narrative) trying to impose restrictions on our lives and livelihoods. If anything, we could use the support of OUR Nation to remain successful.

We'll pay to play to be Canadians, but expect the ability to pay to play to not be removed from us if we're expected to pay, but then to have others mock us for just wanting to be able to be successful? You may not be, but you are not most of the narrative inside Canada not from the Prairies. I KNOW People who are out of work due to this Woke Posturing regarding the pipelines. I KNOW People who are worried and waiting to see what this Federal Gov't (Now a minority with support to come from the three other parties that campaigned against the Prairies) will do to remain in power at our expense. With 150,000 people out of work just from the Oil Industry in SK & AB, it's hard for most people out here not to personally KNOW Someone who isn't affected. We Need to get this Product to Markets outside the USA who will only pay pennies on the dollar 'cuz they know we're screwed (by our own countrymen) in being able to get this product anywhere but to the one country we're physically connected to in any significantly modern quantity. That's sure a Canadian thing to be proud of...."We don't use your dirty Western Oil or Alberta Beef and we'd better find a different source of Uranium to power 60% of Ontario if it's coming from Saskatchewan 'cuz we're the REAL Canadians!!" We are listening.

We buy Ontario's Cars and Drink our Milk (which isn't coming from the prairies) and smoke that BC Bud, and last night my Girlfriend & I steamed up lobster claws from Costco that they say are Canadian sourced (& also probably not from the Prairies). We pay our taxes and go about our lives and we watch and we listen. We aren't the hillbillies and hicks and dumb rednecks we're parodied as. On this very forum are members PROUD of the fact that they don't support all of Canada because they are REAL Canadians (selectively, I guess).

We have had a shit run of luck as of late with the Coldest winter in 84 years last year followed by a very dry Spring and a cold wet Summer & a cold wet Fall...and an early winter that hasn't done our agriculture any favours...and we're told (in Saskatchewan) that our plans on the Climate issue aren't up to Mr. Trudeau's standards so he'll impose his own vision upon us. Seriously....really? Justin, Get Bent!! There's the whole Global Warning/Changing/Cooling/Extreme'ing of Settled Science thing rearing it's head but that's a different topic for a different Thread where we can see Mr Trudeau posturing for the IPCC and various other celebrities as a Woke Political Religious Movement willing to sacrifice specific regions of OUR Nation to the AGW Gods (but not others...) when our only other physically connected trade partner that is tenfold our population isn't drinking the cool-aide? That is economic suicide for specific regions of OUR Nation (but again, not others...).
India had a drought so that they aren't ordering as much Prairie Potash for fertilizer this round? Well, things happen in cycles and it'll come given the chance. We still do multi-billion dollar trade with India and from the Prairies it's Lentils & Peas & other Pulse Crops...& Trudeau isn't going to interfere in that, right? Four years ago the question would have been, "How could he possibly undermine Canada on that front?" Freeland Tweeting her Twitter pissing off Saudi Arabia...so the Saudi's will stop buying Canadian wheat & barley? OK....Hauwei Exec arrested in Vancouver....so the Chinese will stop buying Canadian Canola? Ok...there seems to be a pattern here. As Canadians, we sure didn't elect Donald Trump to be the President of the ONE Country we're physically connected to, but we can quickly get off our duff's and react to the new reality instead of hamstringing ourselves like we've done. Getting pipelines built to the coasts was the immediate thing that should have been going full steam in Canada since November 10th, 2016.

When other Nations wish to punish Canada over diplomacy or in trade, they seem to see clearly how best to kick Canada right in the balls, & how to harm OUR Nation in a manner that is most destructive to OUR Nation. I read Newspaper articles and Op-Eds from those in Central Canada telling the rest of Canada that this Western alienation is a Joke and it'll blow over 'cuz it always has and it always will...and it's a minority of a minority, etc...yet how can other Nations see this and use it when the rest of Canada can't see this and claim it's not real....is it a 'forest for the trees' thing or just utter arrogance?

Does the West want out or does it really just want in? The reality is....it's not the West's choice either way but the choice of the rest OUR Nation.

This last Federal Election was telling. Look at it! The Prairies aren't just AB & SK. The Prairies voted for the one Party that wasn't Demonizing it and claiming to want to gut it and replace the economy with Unicorn & Fairy Dust sales that currently don't exist....& this coming from the same political slant that can't even successfully sell weed? Really? Oh Lord, that's a jagged pill to try and swallow.

The reaction to the above from the Left Coast, or Central Canada, or the 905, or even from some in the East? "Well, if you wanted a voice in OUR Canada, you should'a voted for one of the Parties promising to put your nutz in a vice for your own good, don't you know?" Again, is this a 'forest for the trees' thing inside Canada or just complete and utter arrogance? Is it willful blindness that our trade partners and competitors aren't afflicted with? It's not a matter of the Prairies taking their ball and going home, but a matter of the rest of Canada deciding if it'll include or exclude the above blue swath in what I hope will remain OUR Canada. I'd like to say, "Govern Yourselves Accordingly" but we just elected Justin Trudeau again somehow...

The Federal Election is now a couple of weeks in the past and what has happened? What has the Natural Governing Party of Canada done about anything so far? The World and Canada's place in it haven't sat idle for weeks waiting for Justin to get his poop in a group when he's had the last four years to accomplish that feat.

Deserves a bump
 

Twin_Moose

Hall of Fame Member
Apr 17, 2017
22,041
6,160
113
Twin Moose Creek
So much for farmer exemption

Farmer slams carbon tax’s grain drying cost

Farmers across the Prairies could be drying a record amount of grain this year and some of them will be paying extra for that unwelcome expense.
Glenn Helgason estimates he will be doling out at least $3,700 in carbon tax for drying down tough grain on his farm near Foam Lake, Sask.
“I’m having a tough enough fall as it is with harvest and then, because the federal government wants to save the world, they’re throwing an 18.6 percent increase at me,” he said.

“It’s going to Ottawa for Ottawa to send cheques out to the general public to buy their votes with my money.”...…………………...MORE
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
I thought you wanted the snowflakes to lose their gravy train
 

pgs

Hall of Fame Member
Nov 29, 2008
28,501
8,104
113
B.C.
I thought you wanted the snowflakes to lose their gravy train
Instead of thinking you know what everybody else wants , why don’t you tell us what you want and why ? It might be more enlightening than putting words in people’s mouths , as you like to do .
 

Hoid

Hall of Fame Member
Oct 15, 2017
20,408
4
36
You are warning the lefties against losing transfer payments because you really want the lefties to lose their transfer payments.