It kind of bugs me when I have to agree with Harper but he is not a stupid man and he just might be on to something. The Indian Act is seriously flawed but we have been creaking along with it for a long time and lately some things have been getting done. Now if Harper would have announced that he was scrapping the act and writing a new one we know that nothing would get done for at least the next 5 years while every lawyer in town would be looking for a way to profit from a rewrite. We also know that a one size fits all plan is not going to work either. So if both sides are committed to work together there is at least a 50% chance that he can make things work.
There's a 50% chance that 50% of Indian bands will get some success from Harper's plan, which will likely not be much different from what they are already doing. If Harper's new plan means both sides will have to get bolder and demand results, that will be good. Because for one thing, the TB health clock is ticking and continued abject failure here is not a viable option as the media will beat on Harper and aboriginal leaders relentlessly if stagnation continues.