I think that thinking a certain drummer is the best because you like him, doesn't make him the best drummer alive. Niel Peart is simply amazing. His talent and skills are through the rough. You could ask any real rocker, and they'd tell you that niel peart is the best.
Ringo star, well i wouldn't even compare. Now if you mentioned the drummer for emerson lake and palmer, well then its debatable. I do remember when he performed in montreal and played in a glass dome and was strapped to his seat and played his drums while being turned and spun around upside and all. Then again, those are just stunts, which any rock band could do, altho it takes practice being able to play upside

.
Well as a rocker, and becuase i love the band, and from the ratings and news about him, Niel Peart is #1 drummer alive!!
*i recommend some of you go see the Rush in Rio dvd, and view his drum solo, just as mentioned above, after seeing that you all wouldn't even think twice about answering this question ;-)