The Real Story on Seniors' Beds
NDP claims
(from NDP News release , 15 April 2005)
The facts
"By 2007, under Gordon Campbell's health care plan the province will see a net reduction of 565 long-term care beds."
WRONG.
FACT: Since 2001 we have built more than 4,000 new, replacement or upgraded residential care and assisted living units for seniors.
FACT: By the end of 2006, there will be a net increase of more than 2,700 beds for seniors.
FACT: By 2008, we will have achieved our goal of adding 5,000 new beds for seniors across the spectrum of assisted living, residential care and independent housing.
James said that a number of the health authorities are planning for significant, continual reductions to long-term care beds, not the increase as promised by Campbell.
MISLEADING. We have always said we will build an additional 5,000 intermediate AND long-term care beds (New Era, 2001). The NDP is cherry-picking data from only one category.
FACT: Under the NDP, wait times for a residential care bed was as much as 1 year. Today average wait times for residential care are a fraction of that: ranging from 30 to 90 days. Our approach is working.
"Our province needs a dramatic and immediate increase in the number of long-term care beds that provide complex care around the clock. This is the only way we can relieve the stress on our hospital's acute care wards and emergency room backlogs."
MISLEADING. To relieve pressure on our hospitals, we need to invest in new hospitals (NDP never did; we are – eg., new Abbotsford Hospital), technology, preventative health care, and skilled health professionals (who the NDP drove out of the province).
The NDP platform says NOTHING about building new hospitals, investing in technology, supporting preventative health care, or training and recruiting skilled health professionals.
FACT: Under the NDP, wait times for a residential care bed was as much as 1 year. Today average wait times for residential care are a fraction of that: ranging from 30 to 90 days. Our approach is working.
"To date the BC Liberals have not made a single announcement to build long-term care beds. Instead they are building assisted-living units, offering rent supplements and home support."
WRONG. Examples of residential care bed projects:
· 50 new complex care beds and 30 units for seniors with dementia at Gibsons (27 Sept 2004)
· 155 new residential care beds at South Surrey Seniors Village (1 April 2005)
· 30 new residential care beds at Hilton Villa in Surrey (14 April 2005)
· 94 new residential care beds at Laurel Place in Surrey (14 April 2005)
· 60 residential care and 40 dementia beds at Village by the Station in Penticton.
· 46 specialized psycho-geriatric beds at Sandringham care centre in Victoria. (8 Mar 2005)
· Redeveloping Simpson Private Hospital (Langley) including 40 additional beds (announced April 6, 2005)
· And more….
"But assisted living units do nothing to help seniors waiting in hospital beds because they require long-term complex care."
WRONG. Having more options like assisted-living units helps free up residential care beds for those seniors who need them.
Proof that this approach is working is in the reduction in wait times for residential care beds. Under the NDP, wait times were as much as 1 year – today, average wait time is 30-90 days.
We believe that seniors want a range of options from assisted-living to home care to residential care. Seniors want a system that fits their needs. The NDP wants a one-size-fits-all program where seniors have no options but institutionalized residential care beds.
"I have committed to opening 1,000 long-term care beds within the first year."
DOESN'T ADD UP. The NDP platform has no plausible explanation for how they will do this other than the fact that we already have 1,700 units being built in 46 projects right now.
The NDP is committed to opening an additional 5000 long-term care beds by 2009.
EMPTY PROMISE. The NDP Platform offers NO explanation for funding these beds. Their platform is a ONE-YEAR plan with no financial details beyond that first year.
NDP Record: Between 1993 and 1999, the NDP actually reduced the number of care beds by 18% (source: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives).
NDP Record: A 2002 inventory of residential care found that HALF of the existing residential care beds were either unsalvageable and required outright replacement or needed upgrading in order to be used for complex care.
Many beds failed to meet modern building and fire codes; resident rooms were overcrowded; hallways and washrooms were too narrow to accommodate wheelchairs. Since 2001, we have been renovating, replacing or upgrading thousands of these units.