Karissa’s mother going straight to trial

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC

Penny Boudreau pleads for her daughter Karissa to come home during a news conference at the Bridgewater Police Department in January. Ms. Boudreau was later charged with murder when the 12-year-old’s body was found dumped on a riverbank 12 days after she was reported missing.

Karissa’s mother going straight to trial - Nova Scotia News - TheChronicleHerald.ca

BRIDGEWATER — Penny Boudreau has waived her right to a preliminary inquiry, which means she accepts the prosecution has at minimum a basic case against her.

"We’ve got a case at least to proceed, yes," Crown attorney Paul Scovil said outside a Bridgewater provincial courtroom Wednesday morning. "We’re entering the trial phase, the very beginning of it."

Ms. Boudreau was charged in June with the premeditated killing of her daughter, Karissa. The 12-year-old girl’s frozen remains were found on the riverbank just outside Bridgewater on Feb. 9, 12 days after her mother reported her missing.

Ms. Boudreau did not appear in court Wednesday. Her lawyer, Pat Atherton, was there on her behalf and declined to give an interview, as did about a dozen family members who were there.

A preliminary inquiry determines if there are enough basic facts to take a case to trial.

"Generally, a preliminary might be waived because they are satisfied that the test that we have to put to the court in the preliminary hearing would be satisfied at that level and it would be put over to the Supreme Court for trial," Mr. Scovil said. "It’s a very low test."

Waiving the hearing does not mean Ms. Boudreau may plead guilty to killing her daughter, Mr. Scovil said.

"It doesn’t mean they’re going to plea, it doesn’t mean they’re not going to plea, it doesn’t mean anything other than they obviously are satisfied we can meet the test and that there aren’t any witnesses that they wish to question for their purposes."

Ms. Boudreau elected to be tried in Supreme Court by a judge and jury but has not yet entered a plea. Mr. Scovil said that might not happen for some time because an accused does not usually enter a plea until she is before a jury.

If the accused changes her plea, she would re-elect to appear before a judge alone, plead guilty and be sentenced.

The case goes before a Supreme Court judge Dec. 4. At that point, a trial date may be set or further court dates set aside for preliminary motions.

Frig this is taking forever..... but for those following this case, here's an update at least.
 

scratch

Senate Member
May 20, 2008
5,658
22
38
Ten Penny,

Sounds good..... as soon as we find out for sure she's actually guilty.... which I pretty well believe... but due process should be applied first.

Then when she's found guilty, tie her up and dunk her.

I like this,

Guilty until found Innocent.


Pretty `Rooish to me.

Yet she must have due process.

Got the rope ready.......

scratch
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
Ten Penny,

Sounds good..... as soon as we find out for sure she's actually guilty.... which I pretty well believe... but due process should be applied first.

Then when she's found guilty, tie her up and dunk her.

I like this,

Guilty until found Innocent.

Pretty `Rooish to me.

Yet she must have due process.

Got the rope ready.......

scratch

Well there have been no other suspects at this time, very shortly after they found the body, the mother was admitted to a hospital for unknown reasons..... then she was arrested and charged with the murder of her daughter..... she was living with her father for some time and just recently moved back with her mother..... her mother said they got into a fight and she ran off.... she made one sob story to the media..... then the body was found and yet, most parents then go back to the media and voice they want to find the killers and bring them to justice...... instead, she just kept all hush hush until the hospital incident and her arrest...... witnesses such as her ex-husband and her current boyfriend are going to be testifying against her....... not to mention I know what it's like in the small town communities around here like Bridgewater, Kentville, New Minas, etc.... there are a good chunk of screwed up people around those parts and I'm not above guessing that she's one of them.

...... gee I dunno.... the chances of her being innocent or not guilty of the crime are pretty slim.

If she's found not guilty/innocent, then that's that I guess and we'll have to continue to figure out who had the motive and means to kill her daughter.

But I doubt that's the case.

I have very little doubt that she didn't do it..... I've predicted that she was behind it long before the police even brought her up as a suspect.

There is a small chance she didn't do it, which is why I said I would wait for due process, as there maybe something I don't know about the situation that may change things..... but I doubt it..... so yes.... get the rope and cinder blocks ready.
 

scratch

Senate Member
May 20, 2008
5,658
22
38
Well there have been no other suspects at this time, very shortly after they found the body, the mother was admitted to a hospital for unknown reasons..... then she was arrested and charged with the murder of her daughter..... she was living with her father for some time and just recently moved back with her mother..... her mother said they got into a fight and she ran off.... she made one sob story to the media..... then the body was found and yet, most parents then go back to the media and voice they want to find the killers and bring them to justice...... instead, she just kept all hush hush until the hospital incident and her arrest...... witnesses such as her ex-husband and her current boyfriend are going to be testifying against her....... not to mention I know what it's like in the small town communities around here like Bridgewater, Kentville, New Minas, etc.... there are a good chunk of screwed up people around those parts and I'm not above guessing that she's one of them.

...... gee I dunno.... the chances of her being innocent or not guilty of the crime are pretty slim.

If she's found not guilty/innocent, then that's that I guess and we'll have to continue to figure out who had the motive and means to kill her daughter.

But I doubt that's the case.

I have very little doubt that she didn't do it..... I've predicted that she was behind it long before the police even brought her up as a suspect.

There is a small chance she didn't do it, which is why I said I would wait for due process, as there maybe something I don't know about the situation that may change things..... but I doubt it..... so yes.... get the rope and cinder blocks ready.


Prax,

As my Mom used to say `...and this to shall pass`.

regards,
scratch
 

Scott Free

House Member
May 9, 2007
3,893
46
48
BC
There is little more telling about humanities dark nature than infanticide.

I hope she gets a fair trial. In this day and age it is easy to think old fashioned witch hunts are looming just around the corner.

Popular opinion is no substitute for a proper trial. It is pretty easy to make a case that both personal and public opinion is too significant in trials these days.
 

Praxius

Mass'Debater
Dec 18, 2007
10,677
161
63
Halifax, NS & Melbourne, VIC
There is little more telling about humanities dark nature than infanticide.

I hope she gets a fair trial. In this day and age it is easy to think old fashioned witch hunts are looming just around the corner.

Popular opinion is no substitute for a proper trial. It is pretty easy to make a case that both personal and public opinion is too significant in trials these days.

Oh I dunno about that.... there's been plenty of criminals either getting away with a crime due to some technical legal loophole or by some "Tainted" evidence of some kinda..... either that or they get out much earlier then they should, long before they get proper help/rehabilitation, etc.

I've been seeing a lot of legal cases crossing the media where a certain verdict was made and 90% of the community/population are furious about it..... but public opinion doesn't matter and they get to walk.

Perfect Example? OJ's murders.... nobody else had motive, opportunity.... oh, and found guilty of the crime later after evidence not allowed in the first case were allowed in the second.

Good ol technical legal loopholes.